Academia.eduAcademia.edu
Bd"8ef$B_&N$+$%*,)&QC$gh;i*$8$`*jZ$%&^* b 1K $h;i*$`k DI[$B_&N$U_^5 Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 \_%0$%X„%%A0CM}%•R\„„%:0#@%•a8!%/:0>(%•+84%/:84 !"# %&'()*$+,"$-.,/ 01()2$.3$41'5$6 .7$!5,5$+8,9$:5.$1;<,=$%>?,@* A BC D5$EF,G$¡H+ 41IJ EK1*$¡LBI? DMN$,O1;&N$¡P+.!Q)*$R $BM5$¡S+.,MT$U;V9 m_ch1980@yahoo.com%A0B?BC$%8%+,-.%5S!8%¡&DTL!%4!HU%/0123!4%<V"3!%8%EFGH%I?CD%/5W23!4%¡ !"#$%`a,bFD /5YFG,3 „„…\…^%`9"G‹* „Œ…RX…X†%`En0G:4 4D;WJ %c53,ÜÜ( &D dBKYD !,= eG"f H! 0#3U H! &Z"@ gJ 5YKÜÜF= &30KÜÜL:0>?@ <0= E3,M. dD!,.H! 0=%h:0i g->j H! 0= kÜÜF?30;:!8"'?D%`XD" 8 %);*# %c53,( &D "?D 8 l"D !)?D mG!)n! o.0@ gp?K3 :4 53H0L &D TK6D%)?3 !: 0;5YY7 A40?. 8 !5YD:07 gW-@%%¡ !:0>?@ 0#Y$ g3 &30KL:0>?@ <0= E3,M. %gq[0rD%sG!%H!%t5=%cEL! gKn"; :!"i m=8u* 8 gj,$ 4:,D 0= E3,M. a"KY7 :,vYD g@ "?Z! <0= a0L :4 /"B3 A!:w ,303 8 ,303 <:80Yn H! /40MKL! cEL! 0KL:0>?@ dZ!4 <!,= &@"'?D :0@ m=0J :4 A!:w sG! <80S x3: y[0i :4 /"B3 A!:w ,303 "z! &L:"@ <0= 0KL:0>?@ H! &'G &3,M. <0= <:0>?@ mP@ :4 {0$! gL /"B3 ,303 A!:w <80S x3: A!5?[,$ &@"W?D 5| E?}0Z &L:"@ <!"@ YBZ.1[ \8. !,Y. g@ ~-KPD E7"( 84 a,OCD /"B3 ,303 A!:w <80S x3: •,3 84 0@ !:0>?@ <"KF@ {0$! 84 8 €0PK3! !"#$ &'()* +,-. /0123!4 < gq@0$ d@0$"* •>* H! <"?; g3,>3 <!"@%c535ÜÜ( <)?DU x3:%‚5=0ÜÜ(‚%{0$! !,Y. g@ /"B3 ,303 A!:w 85@ &[,>qD x3: 0@ +,ÜÜL {0$! 8%‚84 8 ƒG 4:!,D‚ :0;U H8"KÜÜFJ4 8"@0ÜÜL I?CD <8: gB?i4 :4 "K?[ X„…\%&@4 0@ gB?i4 X A5D :4 0= g3,>3 8 5ÜÜ( /40MKÜÜL!%¡Quick Take \†+03 g@ !,= :!4"@ g3,>3 gFG0BD k= 0@ ANOVA ,DHU H! /40MKL! 0@ 5=0( {0$! ƒG 8 4:,D {0$! 84 :4 (CFU/m!yFS"@) !,= :4 4,j,D <0= &Y-7 c5G4"; <:8U ‡>j %c535( ! 5=0( {0$! ƒG 8 4:,D {0$! 84 :4 (CFU/m yFS"@) /5( /5=02D &Y-7 9:0>( s?130?D s?@ <:!4 &YqD ˆ06$:! /5DU d>. g@ &L:"@ :4 Y," %(C,K &@"W?D &;4,[U :0@ m=07 :4 /"B3 ,303 A!:w <80S /5( /40MKL! <0= x3: A!"z! &L:"@ g7 EL! &YqD U g@ sG! 8 523 /5=02D &-J A:,} g@ :0@ m=0J :4 0= x3: sG! "?z0$ 4!4 0ÜÜ23 g@ :40i%‰<"?; g3,>3 •>* H! /40MKÜÜL! 0@Š%,?KJ! /,?ÜÜ( g@ /"B3 ,303 x3: 0@ /5ÜÜ( <)?DU x3: {0$! <!,= cEL! /4,63 0= {0$! <!,= &@"'?D a8! /0D :4 &@"'?D &ÜÜ;4,[U :0@ m=07 :4 /"ÜÜB3 ,303 x3: E?}0Z%¡/"ÜÜB3 ,303 x3: &ÜÜ2P@ "z! "@ 0DH EÜÜ(‹; "?z0$ &ÜÜL:"@ :4%`+1;] %ÜÜ^;(5 %c5(0@ &D 0G0>3 B5,(Z.,_;[ +," `5!aN$¡ !" # %&'()* +," -.,/$¡:5.$¡41'5 !5,5$Y+D;&G b,]c 8 !"#$ &'()* +,-. /0123!4%¡5678 9:!,; <0=%<:0>?@ A0B?BC$ )7"D 8 EFGH I?CD A0B?BC$ )J"D :0G40KL!%¡&3,M. <0= <:0>?@ NOPKD%QR A0B?BC$ 8 +,-. 5S!8%¡&DTL! 4!HU /0123!4 <V"3! 8 EFGH I?CD /5W23!4 :0G40KL!%QX !"#$ &'()* +,-. /0123!4 &Y?>Z +0D! 0KL:0>?@ <V,[,$0* 0>$:0*4%¡<V,[,$0* &OOP$ 4:,@%Q\ A0B?BC$ 8 +,-. 5S!8%¡&DTL! 4!HU /0123!4 <V"3! 8 EFGH I?CD /5W23!4%¡EFGH I?CD &L5Y#D 5(:! ]0Y(:07%Q^ !"#$ &W()* +,-. /0123!4 E(!5#@ /5W23!4 I?CD%E(!5#@%/8";:0?23!4%¡I?CD E(!5#@ <!"K74%Q_ Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 %c‰R™Š%5YJ%0MG!%/5YGU%&'()*%:4%<40GH%mB3%EL!%s'>D %*D'* %¡5(0@%&D%kJ%&=4%mYJ!8%E?}0Z%0@%<)-n%¡"K;:)@%40q@!%:4%/"B3 %5Y(0@%&D%&30KL:0>?@%<0=%E3,M.%dD0.%0=%kF?30;:!8"'?D %4,ÜÜ(%&D%dG56$%"KD,303%5S%:4%ƒ‘,J%40q@!%g@%gJ%&30DH%&ÜÜ[8 %<0= E3,M.%c53,ÜÜ( &D dBKYD%!,=%eG"f%H!%0#3U%H!%&ÜÜZ"@%gJ %mG!)n!%5ÜÜ}:4%ŽŽ%H!%m?@% U%&ÜÜ2J%€"ÜÜ'?D%EÜÜ?}0Z%•8! %:4 <"KÜÜF@ 4!"n! g7 4,ÜÜ( &D gKM; &K3,M. gÜÜ@ &30KÜÜL:0>?@ %A0S!"j%4,6#@%EÜÜ#j% U%H!% !,$%&ÜÜD%gJ%<5S%g@%¡5ÜÜ@0G%&D %53"@ &D "ÜÜL g@ 0KÜÜL:0>?@ :4 g7 &30DH A5D :4 0KÜÜL:0>?@ %0@%"K2?@%]0>$%šrÜÜL%E-.%g@%0?30z%4"J%/40MKÜÜL!%0=%E3,M.%8 %:4 EÜÜL! sW>D <:0>?@ A!"ÜÜ=0v$ 8 53,ÜÜ( &D TK6D U gÜÜ@ %sG!%s?Y›>=%¡4:!‹ÜÜ;%&D%I?CD"@%<"KÜÜ2?@%"?z0$% 8"?@%<0œn 5Y7 H8"@ :0>?@ 5ÜÜ( NZ"D H! 5q@ 0G 8 4,@ <"KÜÜF@ s?S %"z!%0=%kF?30;:!8"'?D%d•D%5?[,$%8%“MY$%¡kÜÜF?[,@0KD%"@%A!:w %dÜÜL8"•U !,Y. g@ g7 !,= •GV,[,?@ <0= /5YY7 /4,ÜÜ[U%c‰RQŒŠ %"?z0$% !,$%&D%/"B3%,303%A0ÜÜ?},OZ%g->j%H!%c‰RŒŠ%4:!‹;%&D %8 0= ]8"G8¡%0= h:0i¡%0= <"K70@ dD0ÜÜ( 53,ÜÜ( &D gKZ0YÜÜ( %"?ž%¡~-KPD%IG!"ÜÜ(%d>C$%E?-@0i%¡ 4,@%&>ÜÜL%"?ž%¡‡G"ÜÜL %a0ÜÜL%X††%485S H! &‘:0i <0= E3,M.%c‰„Š5YKÜÜF= 0= s[,* %"@!"@%:4%+80BD%%¡EFGH%I?CD%0@%<:0;H0ÜÜL%¡ 5@%<!"@%Ÿ"CD %g@ ˆ,@"D <0= 9:!);%R„Ž†%a0ÜÜL H! 8 /5ÜÜ( gKZ0YÜÜ( m?* %8%0=%]8"G8%¡0=%h:0i%¡0ÜÜ=%<"KJ0@%<8:%sKÜÜ(!4%"?z0$%¡A:!"S %:0ÜÜ2K3! g@ ˆ,@"D <!H <:0ÜÜ>?@ dD!,.%¡&‘:0i <0ÜÜ= <:0>?@ %<0=">?-*%H!%/40MKÜÜL!%/H8"D!%c‰R„Š4"@%+03%!:%<40ÜÜOKi!%gn"} %<0= E3,M. "@ /8T.%c4:!4 4,j8 <:0>?@ •,?ÜÜ( 8 &G0?n!"’j %sK(!4%g13%&K(!5#@%8%/H0$%<!"@%<5Y@%gKÜÜF@%4!,D%:4%/"B3%,303 %&‘:0i <0=%E3,M. H! <:0?F@ !H <:0>?@ <0= h:0i H! &ÜÜ(03 %!,=%g?MO$%8%gG,#$%kKF?L%¡a0›PGŠ%&130Z%+H!,[%¡&G!‹ž%4!,D %g7 53,( &D 40pG! E?n8"*0ÜÜL 8 y-f E}"n dD!,. E-. g@ %A•,OCD%¡/5YG,ÜÜ(%4!,D%8%0=%/5YYJ%Ÿ0*%:4%¡‰!H%EÜÜ@,f:%8 %&KDTÜÜL 8 /4!4 e?6r$ 0@)?D <0= En0@ 0@ !: 4,ÜÜZ 5ÜÜY3!,$&D %g@%m=8u*%sG!%:4%c‰RŽŠEÜÜL!%/5ÜÜ(% G!:%Ÿ0ÜÜ(,*%¡&j0ÜÜF3 %s70L )?3 &‘:0i dD!,. H! &Z"@%c53H!530?@ /"f0PD g@ !: :0>?@ %!,=%H!%g-BKYD%<0=%h:0i%a"KYJ%:4%%/"B3%A!:w%,303%"?z0$%&L:"@ %&qL 5@ <0=%En0@ :4 "1G4 <!/:0* 8 /4,@ 0ÜÜF3! 5@ &q?6f %<!,=%&@"W?D%E?M?7%<8:%"ÜÜ@%0#3U%&ÜÜ2P@%"z!% !)?D%s??q$%8 %g7 53:!4 )?DU E>[0ÜÜFD &KFG)>= E[0S 4:8U EÜÜL4 g@ :4 cEL!%/5(%gKZ!4"*% 0KL:0>?@%I?CD % 0@)?D :4 &@0#K[! d>q[! “W. g3,; ”?= 0#3U "@!"@ :4 •0ÜÜ>KS! %•0n4 g7 &rG!"ÜÜ( :4 0= h:0ÜÜi g3,; sG!%c5ÜÜGU&>3 4,j8%gÜÜ@ ,"$\8.$8$3 !* %<:0>?@ 40pG! g@ :40i%¡4,ÜÜ( dKPD 0G 8 48"@ s?@ H! 5@ &q?6f %,303%<0=%x3:%"?z0$%&ÜÜL:"@%45}:4%gq[0rD%sG!%g7%0p3U%H! %y-f E}"n &‘:0i dD!,. 0#3U g@ d?[4 s?>= g@ 8 5YÜÜ(0@ &D %EL!%&30KÜÜL:0>?@%I?CD%<!,=%&@"W?D%:0@% !)?D%m=07%8%/"B3 c‰ŽQRXŠ4,(&D gKM; %&@"W?D%:0@%sG!%mÜÜ=07%8%44";%&D%€,ÜÜFCD%<40?Y@%&S"f %8%&3,M.5|%%¡‰!,=%8%–,rÜÜLŠ%I?CD%E?M?7%4,6#@%8%a"KY7%0@ %44";%&30KÜÜL:0>?@%<0=%E3,M.%:0@%m=07%gÜÜ@%"pYD%53!,$%&D %<0=%E3,M.%H8"@%H!%<40ÜÜGH%485S%0$% !,$%&D% ,?ÜÜL!)?-G"KL! %&3!"G!%/"B3%,ÜÜ303%x3:%"?z0$%gÜÜq[0rD%sG!%:4%gÜÜJ%sG!%E-.%g@%8 %<0=%98:%8%&G0?>?(%4!,D%4"@:07%c4,>3%<"?;,-j%&30KL:0>?@ %€,ÜÜFCD%)?3%<4"@:07%–"f%sG!%¡4"?;%&D%:!"i%&ÜÜL:"@%4:,D %8%EF?3%<5G5j%"D!%"ÜÜ2@%&;53H%:4%&G!4H5Y;%E#j%&WG)?n c44";%&D %&;53H%"?Z!%A•,C$%<0KL!:%:4%c‰R\QR_Š%4:!4%gB@0L% "i%0=%/4 %<0=% 0KL:0>?@%H!%&'G%&3,M.%<0=%<:0>?@%mP@%:4%{0$!%gÜÜL %<0=%gK(:%g>=%:4%—6G"B$%8%gKn0G%gqL,$%<:80Yn%,303%k-.%¡ 0F3! %¢0C[%H!% 0F'G%IG!"ÜÜ(%0@% !"#$%&'()*%+,-.%/01ÜÜ23!4%gq@0$ %<:80Yn% !"12=8u*%c4,ÜÜ(%&D%En0G% U%H!%&G0=%g30ÜÜ23%&>-. %:!"W$%¡:0>?@%8%EP$%4!5q$%¡gG,#$%IG!"(%¡0D4 ¡:,3%¡{0$!%šrL %gJ%53!%/5(%0YÜÜ(U%A!:w%,303%0@%gr@!:%:4%<5G5j%˜!,Z%0@%,303 XŽ Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 %:4%8%0=%/"pY*%<:!4"@%g3,>3% 0DH%:4Š%c5(%/40MKL!%%£Œ†%a,30$! %x3:%84%0@%{0$!%84%g7%5ÜÜ(%€0PK3!%k=%:0YJ%¡{0$!% 4"7%)ÜÜ?>$ %gf,@"D%E?-*%/01KL4%€:4%&3,M.5|%H!%5q@%8%‰4,@%gKF@%{0$! %g@%4,@%/"B3%,303%A!:w%<80S%g7%~-KPD%E7"(%84%H!%A80MKD %H!%<"?;,-j%E#j%!:%EÜÜ?-*%:4%8%/4!4%:!"i%/01KÜÜL4%dZ!4%!: %/"B3%,303%A!:w% 85@%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%"1G4%{0$!%8%4:,D% !,Y. %“¤ÜÜL%/4!4%:!"i"K;:)@%&K?-*%dZ!4%t!"f!%IÜÜ?CD%0@%&;4,[U %•>*%IL,$%<:!4"@%g3,>3%c535(%<)?DU%x3:%5=0ÜÜ(% !,Y.%g@ %g3,>3%g@%•8"(% 0DH%A0>?vY$%H!%5q@%8%/4,>3%s(8:%!:%/01KL4 % 0G"j%8%5(%+0p3!% Quick Take%\†%•,3%H!%!,=%:!4"@%g3,>3 c5(%<:!4"@ %<8:%<:!4"@%g3,>3% 0DH%8%/"6?[0J%gB?i4%:4%"K?[%X„…\%<8:%•>* %‰ 0@U%IL!8!%0$%4!4"D%IL!8!%H!%Š%/0D%gL%a,f :4%<:!4"@%g3,>3% %4,j,D%h:0i%•,3%&G0L0Y(%8%N?P2$%<!"@%%c5(%k?vY$%gB?i4%X %¡a8!%%H8:%gÜÜL%0$%•8"ÜÜ(% 0DH%H!%g7%y?$"$%sG5@%c5ÜÜ(%+0p3! %:4%/"B3%,303%x3:%"?z0$%8%&3,M.%<0=%<:0ÜÜ>?@%mP@%<!,=%:4 % 0G0*%0$%+:0#‘%H8:%H!%¡‰"ÜÜO.%Œ8%š6}ŒŠ%gÜÜ3,>3%84%H8:%"ÜÜ= %I?CD%<0=%E?-*%0=%kF?30;:!8"'?D%sG!%m=0J%+5.%0G%8%m=0J %/0D% 0G0*%0$%a8!%gÜÜKM=% 0G0*%H!%¡g3,>3%•G%H8:%"ÜÜ=%¡a8!%gÜÜKM= %•>*%c5(%g?#$%0=%h:0i%5(:%E#j%¡:0;U%H8"KFJ4%8"@0L%E2J % 0G0*%H!%8%‰g6Y2pY*%8%g6Y2'G%<0=H8:Š%g3,>384%gKM=%"=%¡a8! %&ÜÜFMY$%%g?S03%H!%"KD%R…_%0$%R…X%485S%g-}0n%:4%:!4"@%g3,>3 %‰g6Y2'G%<0=H8:Š%g3,>3%•G%<!%gKM=%¡+,L%/0D% 0G0*%0$%a8!%/0D %H!%d6i%:0@%"=%s>|%:4%c5ÜÜ(%/4!4%:!"i%<"1G4%‡30D%"=%8%:0>?@ cEL!%/5DU%R%d'(%:4%<:!4"@%g3,>3%–"f%c5(%gKn"; %dW[!%H!%/01KÜÜL4%&[0@"ž%€:4%&3,M.5|%E#j%<:!4"@%g3,>3 %>?,@*$UK $.3$+. 31[$%5!_5$l1m$YSnWk oK,(5 %€0PK3!%E-.c%En";%A:,ÜÜ}%{0$!%gÜÜL%"=%:4%<:!4"@%g3,>3 %&3,M.%mP@%<!,ÜÜ=%:4%h:0i%4,ÜÜj8%<0G,;%¡"GH% ÜÜG0K3 %&@0GH:!%<!"@%5=0(%g3,>3%sK(!4%E#j%g@%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%{0$! %<!,=%:4%&@"W?D%dÜÜD!,.%"@%/"B3%,303%xÜÜ3:%"z!%8% 0KÜÜL:0>?@ %<:!4"@%g3,>3%H!%5ÜÜq@%h:0i%˜,OPD%<0=%EÜÜ?-*%€:4 c4,@ %c5(0@%&D%/5(%"7w%<0=%x3:%gFG0BD%8%% 0KL:0>?@ %8%5( &D %485FD U :84%<‹ž07%yÜÜF‘ :!,3 IL,$ 8%gKÜÜF@ %"?z0$%gÜÜFG0BD%<!"@% G0K3%&@0GH:!%EÜÜ#j%"KÜÜ2?@% 0Y?>f!%<!"@ %5( &D gK(!‹; H0@ !,= a406$ E#j "K>?K30ÜÜL •G /H!53! g@%0#Y$ %&;4,[U%:0@%mÜÜ=07%:4%/"B3%,303%x3:%0ÜÜ@%<)?DU%x3:%<:0ÜÜDU %¡¥G:0$%8% 0DH%8%{0$!%IG!"ÜÜ(%EÜÜ(!440G%8%<:!‹;%/:0>ÜÜ(%0@ %538:%gFG0BD%X%d'ÜÜ(%c5G4";%gÜÜFG0BD%E[0S%gÜÜL%:4%&‘:0i _%&[!%\%H!%“ÜÜ*%8%535ÜÜ(%&D%<:!5#13%/01ÜÜ2G0DHU%I?CD%:4 % 0DH%g@%E6ÜÜF3%CFU&Y-7%/5Y=4%d?WÜÜ2$%<0=5S!8%A!"??’$ %c5G4";%dBKYD%/01ÜÜ2G0DHU%g@%&G0L0Y(%8%9:0>ÜÜ(%E#j%H8: %{0$!%8%4:,D%<0=%{0$!%<!,=%H!%h:0i%/5ÜÜ(%g?#$%<0=%g3,>3%:4 %{0$!%84%:4%(CFU/m!Š%!,ÜÜ=%:4%4,j,D%<0=%&Y-7%sÜÜ>|%:4 %¡<:!4"@%g3,>3%/0D%gL%&f%:4%gKM=%"=%g6Y2WG%<0=H8:%5=0ÜÜ( %k=%0@%ANOVA% ,DHU%H!%/40MKÜÜL!%%0@%5=0ÜÜ(%{0$!%ƒG8%4:,D &Y-7%/5Y=4%d?W2$%<0=5S!8%A!"??’$%538:%gÜÜFG0BD%\%d'( c535(%gFG0BD \† %<0=%{0$!%<!,=%H!%h:0i%/5(%g?#$%<0=%g3,>3%:4% 0DH%g@%E6F3 %8%g6YÜÜ2WG%<0=H8:%s?130?D%5=0ÜÜ(%{0$!%8%4:,ÜÜD%<0=%{0ÜÜ$! %/0D%gL%&f%:4%gKM=%"=%:4%0=%g3,>3%s?130?D%5=0(%{0$!%8%4:,D %g6Y2WG%<0=H8:%s?130?D%8%<:!4"@%g3,>3%a8!%/0D:4%g6YÜÜ2pY* %%c5Y(0@%&D%<:!4"@%g3,>3 ^%d'ÜÜ(%s?Y›>=%8%<:!4"@%g3,>3%H!%/5ÜÜ30D%&ÜÜi0@%/0ÜÜD%84%:4 CFU/m3 •Ñ !"#$%&"ÏÇ'() %<!,=%H!%h:0i%/5ÜÜ(%g?#$%<0=%g3,>3%:4% 0DH%g@%E6ÜÜF3%CFU ! " # $ CFU/m3 •Ñ !"#$%&"ÏÇ'() $D",k$p,= $8$3.!*$+,"$p,= $$+ !"$# $-.,/$4Dk$%;I=$+,"$%5!_5$.3$b,*#$%[$`MV5$CFUB)&G$4D)"3$n;qd=$+,"D9 8$6 1;;r=$D58.$%VK,'*$Y$PnWk +. 31[$%5!_5$4,*$%Z$Bm$.3$%(a"$1"$%M)dqK$+,"#8. ! " # $ $D",k$p,= $8$3.!*$+,"$p,= $$+ !"$# $-.,/$4Dk$%;I=$+,"$%5!_5$.3$b,*#$%[$`MV5$CFUB)&G$4D)"3$n;qd=$+,"D9 8$6 1;;r=$D58.$%VK,'*$Y$L$nWk s+. 31[$%5!_5$# $4D5,*$B/,[$4,*$83$.3$%M)dqK$+,"#8.$U;t5,;*$8$+. 31[$%5!_5$08 $4,*$.3$%M)d^)f$8$%M)dqK$+,"#8.$U;t5,;*$u % * % *+ % %# %) % %) %&'( ! #$ ! " ! CFU/m3 •Ñ !"#$%&"ÏÇ'() Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 CFU%&Y-7%/5Y=4%d?W2$%<0=5S!8%A!"??’$%538:%gÜÜFG0BD $D",k$p,= $8$3.!*$+,"$p,= $$+ !"$# $-.,/$4Dk$%;I=$+,"$%5!_5$.3$b,*#$%[$`MV5$CFUB)&G$4D)"3$n;qd=$+,"D9 8$6 1;;r=$D58.$%VK,'*$Y$H$nWk s+. 31[$%5!_5$4,*$%Z$.3$%(a"$1".3$,"$%5!_5$U;t5,;*$u \R %c5(0@%&D%<:!4"@%g3,>3%/0D%gL%&f %<0=%“Yj%CFU&Y-7%/5Y=4%d?W2$%<0=5S!8%gFG0BD%_%d'( %" # $ ! " CFU/m3 •Ñ !"#$%&"ÏÇ'() Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 %:4%5=0(%8%4:,D%<0=%{0$!%:4%!,=%H!%g-BKYD%<0=%h:0i%~-KPD +. 31[$%5!_5$4,*$%Z$Bm$$D",k$p,= $8$3.!*$+,"$p,= .3$$ !"$# $%&'()*$+,"$-.,/$v&(w*$+,"$x)T$CFUB)&G$4D)"3$n;qd=$+,"D9 8$%VK,'*$Y$A$nWk %:4%/5ÜÜ(%g?#$%g3,>3%XR%¡gq[0rD%H!%mP@%sG!%<:0DU%)?[03U%<!"@ $y@Z$z",2$1[$41'5$!5,5$:5.$,[$+{;*|$:5.$1;<}=$BÜÜZ.1[ %x3:%0@%/5ÜÜ(%<)?DU%x3:%<0=%{0$!%H!%<:!4"@%gÜÜ3,>3%H8:%Ž† b,(Z.,_;[$+ !"$.3$BJ.,/$B]3!?| %/0D%/H0@%8%+84%/0D%/H0@%¡a8!%/0D%/H0@Š%&30DH%/H0@%gL%g@%/"B3%,303 %:0@%m=07%:4%/"B3%,ÜÜ303%x3:%0@%<)?DU%x3:%"?z0$%A06z!%<!"ÜÜ@ c5G4";%k?FB$%‰<:!4"@%g3,>3%+,L %4,j,D%&Y-7%/5Y=4%d?W2$%<0=5S!8%s?130?D%¡&‘:0i%&;4,[U %:4%/"B3%,303%x3:%"z!%"@% 0DH%E(‹;%"?z0$% 4:8U%EL4%g@%<!"@ %{0$!%gÜÜL%"=%:4%<:!4"@%g3,>3%<0=H8:%:4%(CFU/m! Š%!,=%:4 %c5G4";%<:0DU%gFG0BD%k=%0@%&30DH%/H0@%gL%"=%h:0i%5(:%538: %x3:%0@%<)?DU%x3:%8%‰X8R4:,DŠ%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%<)?DU%x3: % ,DHU%sG!%c5(%/40MKÜÜL!%%ANOVA ,DHU%H!%:,vYD%sG!%<!"@ ANOVA ,DHU%c5ÜÜ35G4";%gÜÜFG0BD%k=%0@%‰5=0ÜÜ(Š%&[,>qD %4!5q$%<0=%s?130?D%sÜÜ?@%<:0DU%:!4%&YqD%ˆ06$:!%g7%4!4% 0ÜÜ23 %"?z0$%H!%/5DU%EL4%g@% G0K3%c5G4";%/40MKL!%<:0DU%gFG0BD%E#j %{0$! :4 &30DH /H0@ gÜÜL :4 (CFU /m! )%!,=%:4%4,j,D%%&Y-7 %s?130?D%s?@%<:!4%&YqD%ˆ06$:!%gJ%EL!% U%";% 0?@%/"B3%,303%x3: %x3:%8%‰P¦†…†_\Š%R4:,D /"B3 ,303 x3: 0@ /5ÜÜ( <)?DU x3: %:4 (CFU /m! )%/5(%/5=02D%&Y-7%/5Y=4%d?WÜÜ2$%<0=5S!8 %/5=02D%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%gFG0BD%:4%‰P¦†…†R†Š%X4:,D%/"B3%,303 %<)?DU%x3:%{0$!%0ÜÜ@%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%/5ÜÜ(%<)?DU%x3:%{0ÜÜ$! %:4%h:0i%5ÜÜ(:%sG"K>7%‰a8!%/0DŠ%a8!%&30DH%/H0@%:4%c4,ÜÜ(%&D %g7%EÜÜL!%&YqD% !5@%sG!%8%4:!53%4,j8%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%/5ÜÜ( c4,(%&D%/5=02D%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%/5(%<)?DU%x3:%{0$! %,303%8%(P¦%†…XŽ† ) R4:,D%/"B3%,303%gG0*%0@%/5(%/40MKÜÜL!%x3: $y@Z$z",2$1[$41'5$!5,5$:5.$`;~,•$1[$b,*#$`k€]$1;<}= %<!,=%&‘:0i%&;4,[U%:0@%m=07%:4%(P¦%†…XŽ† ) R4:,D%/"B3 $b,(Z.,_;[$+ !"$.3$3!T!*$BJ.,/$+,"$x)T$B]3!?| %%cEL!%gK(!53%<"?z0$%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%gFG0BD%:4%0=%{0$! %H8:%Ž†%:4%/5(%g?#$%g3,>3%XR%¡•,|,D%sG!%<:0DU%&ÜÜL:"@%:4 $y@Z$z",2$1[$41'5$!5,5$:5.$`;~,•$1[$b,*#$`k€]$1;<}= %g@%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%/5(%<)?DU%x3:%<0=%{0$!%H!%<:!4"@%g3,>3 b,(Z.,_;[$+ !"$.3$BJ.,/$B]3!?| \X Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 %EL!%/5(%9:!);%"z,D%)?3%&CrÜÜL%EÜÜ2J%98:%0@%"?z0$%sG! c5G4";%k?FB$%g@02D%&30DH%/H0@%gL %0@%•0@%:4%/5(%"Jw%gq[0rD%H!%d}0S% G0K3%gFG0BD c‰P¦†…†R™Š %/"B3%,303%x3:%"z!%"@% 0DH%EÜÜ(‹;%"?z0$% 4:8U%EÜÜL4%g@%<!"@ %4!5q$%<0=%s?130?D%s?@%<:0DU%:!4%&YqD%ˆ06$:!%"ÜÜ|0S%gq[0rD %gFG0BD%k=%0@%&30DH%/H0@%gL%"=%h:0i%<0=%“Yj%5(:%538:%:4 %0@ /5ÜÜ( <)?DU x3: {0$! :4 (CFU/m!) !,=%:4%4,j,D%&Y-7 %c5(%/40MKL!%ANOVA% ,DHU%H!%:,vYD%sG!%<!"@%c5G4";%<:0DU %gJ%4,(%&>3%/5=02D%&[,>qD%x3:%0@%gFG0BD%:4%/"B3 ,303 x3: %&Y-7%4!5q$%<0=%s?130?D%s?@%g7%EÜÜL!%gK'3%sG!%";% 0?@% G0K3 passive%98:Š%<:!4"@%g3,>3%+0p3!%98:%g@%•0>KS!% U%E-. %x3:%{0$!%:4%&30DH%/H0@%gL%"=%:4 (CFU /m! )%!,=%:4%4,j,D %:!,G4%H!%&CrL%<0=%EÜÜ27%s?Y›>=%8%H0@8:%E?-*%A:,}%g@ %/5=02D%<:!4%&YqD%ˆ06$:!%R4:,D%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%/5(%<)?DU %,?KJ!%98:%0@%&-6i%gq[0rD%:4%dG"KL!%¨!,L%g-?ÜÜL8%g@%0=%{0$! %x3:%0@%/5ÜÜ(%<)?DU%x3:%{0ÜÜ$!%:4%&ÜÜ[8%c‰P§%†…%†_Š%5ÜÜ23 c‰X†ŠEL!%ˆ,@"D%‰"|0S%gq[0rD%:4 %¡‰P¦†…†R™Š%+,?-ÜÜL%&Y*%“Yj%4:,D%:4%IBn%X%4:,D%/"B3%,303 %98:%g@%eÜÜ?BC$%sG!%H!%/5ÜÜDU%EÜÜL4%g@% G0K3%gÜÜ@%gÜÜj,$%0ÜÜ@ %‰a8!%/0DŠ%a8!%&30DH%/H0@%:4%c5ÜÜ(%/5=0ÜÜ2D%<:!4%&YqD%ˆ06$:! %A:,}%<0=,pKÜÜFj%g@%gj,$%0@%gJ%%Active%%<:!4"ÜÜ@%g3,>3 %x3:%{0$!%:4%‰+,?-L%&Y*%“Yj%4:,D%:4Š%h:0i%5ÜÜ(:%sG"K>7 %gFG0BD%8%%EL!%gKn";%A:,}%:,ÜÜ2J%:4%:0@%s?[8!%<!"@%gKn"; %&[8%c4,(%&D%/5=0ÜÜ2D%&j:0Z%/"B3%,303%x3:%0@%/5ÜÜ(%<)?DU %¡,?ÜÜL0*%<:!4"@%g3,>3%98:%g@%gKn";%+0p3!%&-6i%gq[0rD%0ÜÜ@% U %:4%:,-?L%,303%x3:% 4"7%d>.%&2YG);%H!% 0Y?>f!%0@% !,$%&>3 %:4%passive%98:%H!%%<5q@%<0=%m=8u*%:4%4,(%&D%40#Y2?* %"$%/4"KÜÜF;%A0B?BC$%!"GH%c4,>3%A80œi%0=%h:0i%•!,3!%t‹S %&@"'?D%dD!,.%m=0J%:4%/"B3%,303%x3:%"z!%5?G0$%+5.%0G%5ÜÜ?G0$ %%cEL!%+H•%˜,OZ%sG!%:4 c44";%/40MKL!%!,=%H!%g-BKYD +1;]$%^;(5$8$•i[ B5 3.D/$8$1Wd= %<!,= &‘:0i &;4,[U &ÜÜL:"@%‚% !,Y. 0@ gJ%<!%gq[0rD%:4 %/0123!4%&2=8u*%+"KCD%E380qD%H!%g[0BD%sG!% 0;5YÜÜFG,3 %:,-?L ,303 <)?DU x3: "?z0$ 8 ki :0'D0J 0KL:0>?@ <0= mP@ %e?BC$%sG!%H!%&ÜÜ[0D%EG0>S%"ÜÜf0Z%g@% !"ÜÜ#$%&WÜÜ()*%+,-. %<0= h:0i <8: "@ %¡‰X†Š%5(%+0p3!%‚&;4,[U šrÜÜL m=0J "@ %A030WD!% 4,>3%k=!"n%8%‰Œ\_Œ…^™…†X…„Œ%`/:0>ÜÜ(%4!4:!"ÜÜiŠ %E?-* 98: 84 0@ /"B3 ,303 x3: gÜÜ3,>3 ƒG 0@ 8 !,= H! gÜÜ-BKYD %A0B?BC$%)J"D%H!%s?Y›>=%c5ÜÜYG0>3%&D%&3!4:5i%8%"WÜÜ2$%+H• %¨!,L g-?L8 g@ 0= {0$! :!,G4 H! &CrÜÜL <0= EÜÜ27 8 H0@8: %‰/:Š&Y?>Z%+0ÜÜD!% 0KÜÜL:0>?@%&3,M.%mP@%8%EÜÜFGH%IÜÜ?CD %:4%passive%98:%ƒÜÜG%gÜÜJ%5ÜÜ(%<:!4"@%gÜÜ3,>3%¡dG"KÜÜL! %g30>?>}%e?BC$%sG!%+0p3!% 0'D!% 4,>3%k=!"n%E#j%g@% !"ÜÜ#$ %/"B3%,303%x3:%gq[0rD%sG!%:4%c44";%&D%€,FCD%<:!4"@%g3,>3 c5G0>3%&D%<:!‹1L0¤L %‰P¦†…†††Š%EÜÜL!%/5G4";%9:!);%"z,D%H0@%4:%Plat%98:%:4 \\ Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 ‚[,)* from http://www. doctorfungus. Org /the fungi / index.htm 12. Laboratory –fungi, 2006, available from http:// faculty.valencia .cc.fl.us/ glindbeck/ BSC1011 C_ Labs/Fungi.pdf 13. Dvorak G. Disinfection101, Center for Food Security and Public Health2160 Veterinary Medicine, 2005. Available from http://www.cfsph.iastate.edu/BRM/ resources/Disinfectants/Disinfection101 14. EMS, Cleaning, Disinfection, and Sterilization of medical equipment, 2007, available from http:// www.ems.org.eg/esic_home/data/giued _part1/ Cleaning 15. Imandel K, Disinfectants and their Application in Environment Healthcare, Ayeneh Ketab Publications; 1996. 16. Cho K.H, Park J. E, Osaka T, Park S. G, The study of antimicrobial activity and preservative effects of nanosilver ingredient. Electrochimica Acta, 2005, 51: 956-960. 17. Science_Technology, Nanotechnology, 2007, available from http:// tebyan. Net /Science_ Technology/Nanotechnology//.html 18. Daneshnameh.roshd, nano silver, 2006, available from www.daneshnameh.roshd.ir/mavara. 19. Nanotech, Nano systems international, 2007, available from http://www.nanotech-now.com/ introduction.htm 20. Azizi far M. Examining Fungal infections in departments of Qom Kamkar hospital and Effect of Nano-Silver painting on decreasing the infection level [dissertation]. Tehran University of Medical Sciences; 1387. 1. Majid Pour A, Habib Zadeh Sh. Creation and recreation of diseases and health of medical professions. Published by University of Tehran; 2001. 2. Pittet D, Alleranzi b. Considerations for a WHO European strategy on health –care associated infection, surveillance and control, 2005. Available from http://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/ article/PIIS1473-3099 (05)70055-4/abstract. 3. Farr BM. Prevention and control of Nosocomial Infections, 2002,Available from www.wma.net/e/ publications/pdf/farr.pdf 4. Wikipedia, Nosocomial infection, 2009. Available from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosocomial_ infection. 5. Krishna prakash S. Nasocomial infections- an overview,john bell(1801)on :Hospital Infections; 2005. Available from delhimedicalcouncil.nic.in/ Nasocomial infections.pdf 6. Hospital hygience and infection control, available from http://www.who.int /water_ sanitation_health/ medicalwaste/148to158.pdf; 2008. 7. Pratta R.J, Pellowea CM, Wilsona JA, Lovedaya HP, Harpera PJ , Jonesa LJ, McDougallb C, Wilcox MH. National Evidence-Based Guidelines for Preventing Healthcare -Associated Infections in NHS Hospitals in England, Journal of Hospital Infection .2007; 65S, S1–S64. 8. Torbati P, Hekmat Yazdi S, The guide on recognizing hospital infections.Voice Publications Center; 2007. 9. Manhattan fungi, fungi, 2008, available from http:// www.Manhattan fungizygomyco.com 10. Types of fungi, 2008, available from http://www. infoplease .com/ce6 /sci /A0858309. 11. Doctor fungus, introduction to fungi, 2002, available \^ Iran. J. Health & Environ., 2009, Vol. 2, N0. 1 Downloaded from ijhe.tums.ac.ir at 8:13 IRST on Wednesday December 8th 2021 Studying the Effect of Nanosilver Painting on Control of Air-Transmitted Fungi Jabbari H.1, Mansouri N.2, Abdollahi A.3, *Chehrehei M.4, Naddafi K.5 Center for Envoromental Research, Teheran University of Medical Sciences, Iran 2 Islamic Azad University Sciences and Research, Tehran, Iran 3 Department of Pattologiy of Imam Khomeini Hospital, Tehran University of Medical Sceinces, Tehran, Iran 4 Islamic Azad University sceiences and Research, Tehran, Iran 1 5 Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran Received 9 April 2009; Accepted 25 May 2009 ABSTRACT Background and Objectives :Microorganisms including Fungi, are among air-transmitted infectious agents at hospitals and patient care settings, which in addition to patients, can afflict Health Care Workers (HCWs) and visitors, and may results in extravagant economic burden and impact on human health. Use of nanotechnology and especially nanosilver particles is one of the methods which are used in infection control. This article is the result of a research project investigating nanosilver painting effect on bioburden of indoor hospital air. Materials and Methods: The study was aimed to assess antifungal effects of nanosilver painting. Three rooms were selected at the infectious diseases ward of Imam Khomeini hospital complex. Two of the rooms were painted with two brands of nanosilver paints provided from two separate companies (as cases), and the third room with non-nanosilver paint brand(as control). Results: Air sampling was carried out using a portable air pump (Quick Take 30) at pre-planned schedule Each Sampling was done in two minutes with the rate of 28.3 Liter per minute. Samples were transferred on Sabourauds Dextrose Agar culture, to count the colonies of fungal based on Colony Forming Unite (CFU/m3). Results were analyzed by ANOVA method. Conclusion: Active sampling method was not able to show statistically significant reduction in the total fungal bioburden between the control and case rooms. In evaluating the time trend of the nanosilver paints effect, sampling measures revealed that nanosilver paints had statistically significant effect in fungal bioburden reduction in the first third( i.e. first month) of the study period. Keywords: Nanosilver, Painting, Air- transmitted micro-organisms, Nosocomical infections *Corresponding Author: m_ch1980@yahoo.com Tel: +98 21 84122776 Fax: +98 21 88325149