!"#$%&'(')*+$(*%,(!-%./$''(!"0,'(-%(12$(",3''$3 *456789:;<(=4>?56(@AB5C6B8 '748CB<()67BD?EF(G7AH(IJF(%7H(KLJ(9'M8?DNO'4PPB8LM8?D5BPM:OQ5Q(JRRS;F(MMH(TTOUK )4VA?:6B>(VW<(Classical Association of Canada '5XVAB(Y0/<(http://www.jstor.org/stable/25651698 . *CCB::B><(JJLRZLJRK[(RR<RI Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. . Classical Association of Canada is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Phoenix. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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`L( TaJ`Z]V`ZY^( K789( @( E8@7>=@E<( ;<@67CM( 8B(@C( 5HH<>( E8B>G(O<6>BB?J( "C( )<C<;BH<&E( @EEB=7@87BC( K789( 89<( 9B5E<L( E<<( 7C(H@>87=5;@>( T[YVTbaJ( -8( 7E(CB8( C<=<EE@>G( FB>(?G( @>M5?<C8( 8B(?@R<( @CG(H>BCB5C=<?<C8E( BC( 89<(=BCC<=87BCE( O<8K<<C( 2B?<>7=( @C6( #G=<C@<@C( @>=978<=85><L( O58( E<<(/@8<7C<>&E( O7O;7BM>@H9G( @8( S`SL( CJ( _[J( T,<( 4BCM( TaaSI( `[J( '9<( CB8<E( 89@8(B89<>(2B?<>7=( KB?<C( K<@>( D<7;E( BC;G(K9<C( 89<G( ;<@D<( 89<( 9B5E<L( K97;<( )<C<;BH<( 7E(EB?<87?<E( D<7;<6(K7897C( 9<>(9B?<J( ]]( )2"$%-cL( d"/J( bT( \TaaZ^( SJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ]Z( )2"$%-c( 89>B5M9B58( 89<("6GEE<GJ(*8( 89<(BH<C7CM( BF( 89<(HB<?( "6GEE<5E( ;@CM57E9<E( BC( 89<(7E;@C6(BF("MGM7@L( 8>@CEF7P<6(OG(89<(EH<;;O7C67CM(KB>6E( BF(+@;GHEB( \SJ[bV[Z^L( K9B( @;EB( =B?H<;E( 97?( 8B(9@D<( E<P(K789( 9<>W@( D<>G(BOD7B5E( =BCF;@87BC(BF( 89<( 8K7C(6@CM<>E( BF(KB?<C&E( ;@CM5@M<( @C6( E<P5@;78GJ( '7?7;@>;G(+7>=<&E( ?<;B67B5E( EBCM( @88>@=8E(89<( =B?H@C7BCE( BF("6GEE<5E( \SaJTTaVTTZ^N( 97E( EBC( 7E(F@E=7C@8<6( CB( 6@CM<>( 8B( OG( 89<(6>5MV<C9@C=<6( E8B>G(BF(2<;<C( \_JTTaVTT[^J( '9<( H><E<C8E( 1<;<?@=95E( 7C('H@>8@L( O58(#<C<;@5E( ><=B5C8E(9BK( E9<( 7?78@8<6(89<(DB7=<E( BF( ?@C( ;B=R<6( 7CE76<(89<(KBB6<C( 9B>E<( \_JTZaVTZ_^L( D<>G(C<@>;G( 89<(K7D<E( BF(<D<>G( 89<(>5E<J`( #BE8( F@?B5E;GL( 89<( EBCM(BF(89<('7><CE( \STJ`YV_b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eC6<>KB>;6L( 9<(R<<HE( 97E( 76<C878G(=BC=<@;<6( F>B?(97E(K7F<( 5C87;( 89<(><D<CM<( 7E(=B?H;<8<Jb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f#<C8B>L( @C6( 89<(E578B>E(9@D<( O<<C( ;7E8<C7CM( F>B?( O788<>( K9B( E7CME(QBF(89<(.><<RE&( 9B?<=B?7CM( 1>BGQ( \SJ`T[V``a^J( 19<( EBCML( `( 7CE7C5( 2<@89( \Taa[I( ]TV]`^( E5MM<E8E( 89@8(2<;<C&E( O<9@D7B5>( @8('H@>8@( =B>>BOB>@8<E(#<C<;@5E&( @87BC( 89@8(97E(K7F<( Q6B<E( CB8(RCBK(K9<C( 8B( E958(5HQI( E9<(O;5>8E( B58(1<;<?@=95E&( C@?<( \_JS`]^L( @C6( K@C8E( 8B(HBE8HBC<( =BCD<>E@87BC( 5C87;(?B>C7CM( \_JTS_^L( E9<( 6>5ME( 89<(K7C<( @C6( @;89B5M9(#<C<;@5E( E8@>8E(89<(?589B7J( SYY`I( `_J( :B>( F5>89<>(67E=5EE7BC( BF( 89<(6@CM<>( BF(KB?<C&E( EH<<=9( 7C( <@>;G(.><<R( _+FJ(!B9;( HB<8>GL( E<<(g<>M><C( SYZ`I( bYVY[J( [( 1<;<?@=95E( =BCF;@8<E( EH<<=9( @C6( E<P5@;78G(OG(@==5E7CM( 89<(?@76E( BF(D<>O@;;G( @O5E7CM( 97E(?B89<>( @C6( E;<<H7CM(K789( 89<(E578B>E( \TTJ_b`V_b_^J( <"6J( SSJ_T]V_`_L( __SV_[bJ( ]#@>87C( SYZYI( SV_TJ( '<<#5>C@M9@C( SYZ]I( ST_VST[N( 6<( 4BCM(TaaSI( TZZVTZYJ( Z+FJ(2<@89( Taa[I( ]YVSSZL( CB87CM( @( =B>><EHBC6<C=<( O<8K<<C( 1<;<?@=95E&( =B?7CM( BF( @M<( @C6(97E( 7C(@( =9@H8<>( <C878;<6( Q+BC8>B;;7CM( /@CM5@M<I( 1<;<?@=95E( /<@>CE( 8B( @O7;78G( 8B( EH<@R(K789( @589B>78G( 'H<@RJQ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ]Y( ')*+$( *%,(!-%./$''( !"0,'( !"#$%&'( K97=9( ><@=9<E(9<>(5HH<>( =9@?O<>L(67EH;<@E<E( )<C<;BH<L( K9B( 6<E=<C6E( 8B(89<(<6M<( BF(89<(?<M@>BCL(@==B?H@C7<6( OG(8KB(?@76EL(K789( 9<>(D<7;( E8><8=9<6(7C(F>BC8(BF(9<>( F@=<L(@C6( @ERE( 89<(O@>6( 8B( E7CM(@(67FF<><C8(EBCMJ(1<;<?@=95E( ><EHBC6E( 7C(@CM<>L( 6<F<C67CM( 89<(O@>6&E( =9B7=<L( @C6(9<(B>6<>E(97E(?B89<>( \SJ`[bV`[Y^I( Ocd( <;U( B7RBD( 7B5@@( P6( @&( @5PFA7N( <HG@( hB5@i<L( REcEDE( ;@PBD( P( Fj*L@h6P>jD( PE( h@8( 6F7\j^7]7biB7@7( <HGBD( '17B7P<=>.@7J( 55"B=L( [&( 6DZH<@@7( j7<*f>j@E7( C@B7L( 56i7@P@( Z&( E5VB7V( PB5( G@H( hH6PBU( <@P&( <D7( B7R=BJ( g58( MB( 7C8B( 89<( 9B5E<L( @C6( 8@R<( GB5>(KB>R( K789( GB5L( @C6(O76(GB5>(9@C6?@76E( 89<(;BB?(@C6(89<(67E8@FFL( 8B(6B( 89<7>(KB>RJ( g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`[aV`[`^L( K789( ?589BE( ><H;@=7CM( HB;<?BEJY( g58( h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h@8X( =BC8<C6EL( 89<(H@EE@M<( 7E(Q@(6<?BCE8>@87BC( BF( ?B?<C8I( @E(@C(@65;8(?@;<( 9<(K7;;( 1<;<?@=95E&( ?@85>78GLQSa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aI( STaJ( !<E8( OG(<?H9@E7X7CM( 89@8(89<(H@EE@M<( 7E( Sah@8X( \*>895>^( SYZSI( `bJ(+;@>R( \TaaSI( ``Y^( ><EHBC6E( 8B( @(FB>?5;@(5E<6( 7C(89<( @E( K@E( 7C(89<(-;7@6( Q8B(7C67=@8<( @( "6GEE<G( 78( EB=7@;;G( E@C=87BC<6( M<C6<>( 67E87C=87BCJQ( 2<( CB8<E( 89<( E7?7;@>78G(8B(*;=7CB5E&( @88<?H8( 8B(H58(*><8<( 7C(9<>(H;@=<( \SSJ`[aV`[`^J( SYY`I( T`bN( 2<@89( Taa[I( ]SV]TJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions '<<( @;EB(#@>87C( Za( )2"$%-c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`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bbJ( ST( +;@>R( \TaaSI( ``Y^( <P@?7C<E( 89<(67E8>7O587BC( BF(?589B7( EH<<=9<E( 7C(89<("6GEE<G( @C6( =BC=;56<E( 89@8( 89<(HB<?( 7C8<M>@8<E( 89<(6B?<E87=( EH9<><( 7C(K97=9( KB?<CL( @C6( <EH<=7@;;G( )<C<;BH<L( 6B( EH<@R( ?589B7J( S`( -8( 7E(@( 8>57E?( 89@8( 7C(.><<R( 89B5M98( 89<(9B5E<( 7E( ><M5;@>;G(HBE78<6( @E( 6B?<E87=( F<?@;<( EH@=<L( ?@E=5;7C<( @C6( H5O;7=J( 3<8( <D<C(H>7D@8<(9B?<E( K<><( 67D76<6( 7C8B(M<C6<><6( EH@=<EL( K97;<( 89<(B586BB>E( 7E( K789( KB?<C&E( U5@>8<>E( @C6(?B><( H5O;7=( ?@;<( @><@EI( E<<(*C8BC@==7B( Taaa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`L( CB87CM( @( EG?OB;7=( 67E87C=87BC( O<8K<<C( 89<(@=87D787<E( BF( EH7CC7CM( @C6(K<@D7CM( 7C(OB89( <H7=EI(K<@D7CM( 7E(@C( Q<E=@H<( F>B?(@( E8@8<(BF(6B?<E87=( 67EB>6<>Q( FB>()<C<;BH<L( 2<;<CL( @C6(*C6>B?@=9<L( O58( 89><<(HBK<>F5;(KB?<C( \2<;<CL( Q6B?<E87=( E8@O7;78GQ( 7C(89<("6GEE<G( =<@E<(K<@D7CM( @C6( @><(6<H7=8<6( )<C<;BH<L( @C6(*><8<^( K9B( @=97<D<( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions !"#$%&'( ')*+$( *%,(!-%./$''( !"0,'( ZS( @( .><<R( ;78<>@85><N( !BB;KB>R7CML( @C6( <EH<=7@;;G(K<@D7CML( 7E( HB;GD@;<C8( EG?OB;(7C( 78(7C=;56<E( 7?H;7=@87BCE(BF(C@>>@87D78G(@C6( E8B>GV8<;;7CML(FB>(7CE8@C=<L(@C( 76<@(89@8( @E( 7C( 7E(7?H;7=78(7C( 2<;<C&E( KBD<C( 8@H<E8>G(\--J(`JST[^LS[( B>( =5CC7CM( @C6( 8>7=R<>GL( K<;;V<E8@O;7E9<6( =BCCB8@87BC( BF(=9@E878G( 89<(=@E<( BF()<C<;BH<&E( >5E<J(g58( 78(7E(89<( 89@8(89<(FB;;BK7CM(67E=5EE7BC(K7;;( <PH;B><JSb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`S`V`Sb^I( @D@hP=PNL( &"'5@@FABUL( Z>AD( B7PB57DB7B( <HPE=>.<( CHBU( [=BH@b&L( 7d( @7'B7>A( H@@7;<8@( P>k(Z<( 1=@H&( Fj*J@h@P@( @PHBi@i7i7<L( PEHC<P<( [&( @57>jd( FAH<D@7( <D( H<G6H=HL( >k(<7H7@( ]7E7hW7Z( l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aa^J( S[)@C8<;7@( \SYY`I( _Y[^( =B?H@><E( 2<;<C( 7C(897E(H@EE@M<( 8B(@C( <H7=(HB<8(K9B( H><E<>D<E( 9<>B7=( 6<<6E( 89>B5M9( EBCMJ(+FJ( 0B7E?@C( TaabI( Sa(BC(2<;<C( @E( Q@C( 7C8<>H><8<>(BF(97E8B>G( @C6(?@R<>( BF(?<@C7CMJQ( Sb( @( +;@G8BC( \Taa_I( [V]^( E5>D<GE( >7=9(OB6G( BF(KB>R( 67E=5EE7CM( 89<( ><;@87BCE97HE( O<8K<<C( K<@D7CM( @C6( E8B>G8<;;7CM( 7C( 89<( <H7=EJ( :<;EBCV05O7C( \SYY_I( SZVSY^( H>BD76<E( BC<( BF( 89<(?BE8( 6<8@7;<6( @C6( EBH97E87=@8<6( @C@;GE<E( BF()<C<;BH<&E( @=8(BF(K<@D7CM( @C6( 5CK<@D7CM( 7C(><;@87BC( 8B(89<( 7C6<8<>?7C@=G( BF( 9<>( =9@>@=8<>( @C6( 7C(8<>?E(BF( 78E(>B;<( 7C(89<( H;B8J( +;@G8BC( \Taa_^( <PH@C6E( 5HBC( 897E(K97;<( =>787U57CM( @C( @C6>B=<C8>7=( C@>>@87D<J( @C@;GE<E( BF()<C<;BH<( K97=9( E785@8<(9<>(K7897C( S]( #<;@C89B( @E( Q@=87CM( B58(K9@8( :<;EBCV05O7C( \SYY_I( `a^( E<<E( )<C<;BH<( =B5;6( O<( 6B7CM( O58( 7E(CB8LQ( @C6( 89<><OG( F5C=87BC7CM( @E( @( E=@H<MB@8( F7M5><J( '<<( @;EB( :5;R<>EBC&E( =B??<C8E( \TaaTI( `_`V`_[^( BC( #<;@C89BL( K9B( OG( E;<<H7CM(K789( $5>G?@=95EL( )<C<;BH<&E( F@DB>78<( E578B>L(?@G( O<( ><@6( @E()<C<;BH<&E( @;8<>(<MBJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ZT( )2"$%-c( ?<C&E( @><@( ;BCM(@F8<>(78(7E(><EH<=8@O;<(@C6(K9B( 8@;R(O@=R( 7C67E=><<8;G(><?@7C(7C(89<( @F8<>(O<7CM( 8B;6(8B(MB( 7CE76<J( -8( 7E( 89<( B;6( C5>E<( $5>G=;<7@( K9B( 8@5M98( 89<(?@76E( 89<7>(KBB;VKB>R7CM( #<;@C89B( @C6(9<>(F>7<C6EI( \EH<=7F7=@;;G(=@>67CML(TTJ_TT^J( '9<( 7E(89<(@C8789<E7E(BF( 9<>(=<;7O@=G( 7E(<?H9@E7X<6( \SJ_``^L( @C6(9<>(=@H@=78G(FB>(R<<H7CM( E7;<C8(=B>>BOB>@8<E( 897E(HB>8>@78(BF(><E8>@7C8J($5>G=;<7@( H;@GE( @C( 7?HB>8@C8(>B;<(7C(gBBRE( SYVTTN( 9<>( E7;<C=<( 7E(E8><EE<6(@8(R<G(?B?<C8E( 7C(89<(<D<C8E(O<FB><(@C6( @F8<>(89<(=BC8<E8(BF( 89<( OBKJ( "C<( BF( 9<>( B==5H@87BCE( 7E( 8B( E<>D<( @E( @( 6BB>R<<H<>J( -C6<<6L( 9<>( C@?<( ?7M98( O<( =BMC@8<(K789( h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a@8@Pj@=5BL( abH>jD( Z&( <C<H5@@<( HFA( H&( 7j@<D( ECk( '<( R*8j7Z&( <P6DB@@<D( ;56D=7J( hBH=BDC( 6HG5H<CL( '9<(;<F8( 89<(=9@?O<>L(@C6(F@E8<C<6(89<(6BB>(K789(@( ;@8=9( BF( E7;D<>L( @C6( =;@EH<6( 89<( 6BB>VOB;8( K789( @( E8>@HJ( 19<( C<P8( 87?<(K<( <C=B5C8<>( $5>G=;<7@( E9<( 7E( @M@7C( E5H<>D7E7CM( @( 6BB>L( @C6( 9<><(KB>6E( @C6( 6BB>E( @><( @EEB=7@8<6( FB>(89<(F7>E8(87?<J(1<;<?@=95E( 7E(?@R7CM( H><H@>@87BCE( FB>(97E(F7>E8(AB5>C<G(@O>B@6L( @CB89<>( E7MC(BF(97E( 7C=><@E7CM(?@85>78G( \TJ`_YV`ba^J( *E( 9<(M@89<>E(H>BD7E7BCE(FB>(89<(E<@(AB5>C<G(9<(<C=B5C8<>E($5>G=;<7@L( K9B( K@8=9<E( 89<( E8B58(6B5O;<( 6BB>E( BF( 89<( E8B><>BB?( @C6( F>B?(K9B?( 9<( 7E( EB(9<(?5E8( ><=B5C8(97E( H;@C( 8B( E<<R(C<KE( BO;7M<6( 8B(><U57E787BC( E5HH;7<EJ(1B( 6B( BF("6GEE<5EL( O58( 897E(?5E8( O<( @( =;@C6<E87C<( 6<H@>85><(5C6<8<=8<6( OG( 89<(E578B>EJ( *C6( EB(1<;<?@=95E( 8<C6<>E(@C( B@89( F>B?(89<(B;6(KB?@C( CB8( 8B( EH<@R( @OB58( 97E( DBG@M<( 5C87;( @F8<>(97E( 6<H@>85><( \TJ`]TV`]Z^JSZ( $5>G=;<7@( 7E(=9@>M<6(K789( 8B(6B6M<( 89<( E578B>E&( M5@>67CM( 7?HB>8@C8(RCBK;<6M<( K97=9( @;;BKE(1<;<?@=95E( @?O5E9J(*==B>67CM( 8B(@(HBH5;@>( <8G?B;BMGL(9B>RBE(\QB@89Q^( 7E(6<>7D<6(F>B?(9<>RBE( -C( 897E(=@E<( 89<(B@89( BF($5>G=;<7@( 6B<E( F5C=87BC(@E( @(O@>>7<>(8B( \QOB5C6@>GQ^JSY( @E( '9<( ><EHBCE7O;G( M5@>6E( 89<(H><=7B5E( RCBK;<6M<( BF(1<;<?@=95E&( H;@C( EH<<=9J( @E( E9<( E8B><>BB?J(gB5C6( OG( 89<(B@89L( $5>G=;<7@( R<<HE( 89<(6BB>E( BF(89<( M5@>6E( 897E(RCBK;<6M<( 8B(9<>E<;F(@C6(6B<E( CB8(5C;B=R( 89<(8>589(5C87;(@F8<>()<C<;BH<( 9@E( #<6BC( 89<(9<>@;6J( ;<@>C<6( 78(89>B5M9( BF( E7;<C=<( EKB>C( @8( 89<(6BB>E( BF( 89<( E8B><>BB?( 9<;HE( 8B( B@89( $5>G=;<7@&E( <E8@O;7E9(@(=BCC<=87BC(O<8K<<C( EH@=<( @C6( EH<<=9L(6BB>E( @C6( E7;<C=<L(K97=9( ><=5>E( SZ( '<<(*><C6( SY``I( STTVST`( FB>(89<(B@89( @E(@( 8GH<VE=<C<J( SY( '<<( :>7ER( SY[_I( _SZV_SYJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions !"#$%&'( ')*+$( *%,(!-%./$''( !"0,'( Z`( 89>B5M9B58(89<("6GEE<GJ('7MC7F7=@C8;GL(9<>(B@89(BF(E7;<C=<(B==5>E( 7C(89<(EG?OB;7=@;;G( >7=9(HBE787BC( BF(89<(6BB>( 8B(89<(E8B><>BB?L( K97=9( <?H9@E7X<E( 89<(=BC=<H85@;( ;7CR( O<8K<<C( ;B=R<6( 6BB>E( @C6( ><E8>@7C<6( EH<<=9J( 197E( ;7CR( 7E( =BMC@8<(K789( 89<( =B??BC( FB>?5;@I(Q!9@8( @(KB>6( 9@E( <E=@H<6( 89<(OB5C6@>G( BF(GB5>(8<<89Q(\EHh"=N( K97=9( bZad1+"dL( <JMJL(SYJ_YT^J( 19<( 8<<89(@><(<CD7E7BC<6( @E(@(R7C6(BF(6BB>( 89>B5M9( KB>6E( =@C(H@EEJ(d@>7B5E( E=9B;@>E(9@D<( @EEB=7@8<6( 89<(<Hh"8N(bZbDP=BD(K789( @CB89<>( =B??BC( 2B?<>7=( FB>?5;@L( ']7<@( 17P<HB<DP@L( QK7CM<6( KB>6EQ( \<JMJL( ZJ_[Y^L( ?BE8( ;7R<;G(@(?<8@H9B>( <CD7E7BC7CM(KB>6E( @E(O7>6EJTa(*( FBB;7E9( B>( 7C67E=><<8(H<>EBC( =@CCB8( ><E8>@7C( KB>6E( F>B?(F;G7CM(89>B5M9( 897E(9<>RBE(B>(OB5C6@>GJ( $5>G=;<7@L( BF(6BB>E( @C6( B@89EL( 9BK<D<>L( 7E(@O;<( 8B(><E8>@7C(9<>(KB>6EJ( +BCC<=8<6( R<<H<>( K789( 9<>( ;7CM57E87=(><E8>@7C8L(-(KB5;6( @>M5<L( 7E(9<>(@HH@><C8( ;@=R(BF(E<P5@;(@=87D78GJ( /@<>8<E( ><F>@7C<6(F>B?(E;<<H7CM(K789( 9<>( \SJ_``^L( @C6($5>G=;<7@&E( @6D@C=<6( @M<( H><=;56<E( @CG(CB87BC( BF(9<>( E<P5@;78GL(<FF<=87D<;G(E<H@>@87CM(9<>( F>B?()<C<;BH<( @C6( 89<(?@76EL( K9BE<( E<P5@;78G(7E(@;K@GE(H>BO;<?@87=J(2<>( @HH@><C8;G(H<>?@C<C8( =<;7O@=G(9<;HE( 8B(E<=5><(9<>( ;BG@;8G(8B(9<>(9B5E<9B;6L( @C6( EB(BF(@;;(89<(KB?<C( 7C( 89<(9B5E<L( )<C<;BH<( 7C=;56<6L( E9<(@;BC<( =@C(O<( <C8>5E8<6(K789( 89<(E<=><8E(BF( 78E( 97E(F@89<>( ?@E8<>EL( OB89(1<;<?@=95E( @C6L( ;@8<>(7C(89<(E8B>GL( "6GEE<5EJ( -8(7E(@;?BE8( @E( 7F(897E(@E<P5@;( =9@>@=8<>(E8@87BC<6(@8(89<(6BB>( 7E(@;EB( 7C(@( ;7?7C@;( HBE787BC(K789( *E( E<D<>@;(E=9B;@>E(BOE<>D<L( E9<(7E(@EEB=7@8<6(K789( ><M@>6(8B(9<>(M<C6<>( 76<C878GJ( 89<(?@;<E( BF(89<(F@?7;GL(@C6( 7E(8B(O<( FB5C6(K7897C( 89<(?@;<( EB=7@;( EH@=<E(?B><( BF8<C( 89@C( 7C( 89<(KB?<C&E( EH@=<EJTS( "C<( <P=<H87BC( 8B( 897E(H@88<>C( B==5>E( 7C()<C<;BH<&E( 6BKCE8@7>E( E@;BCL(K97=9( 89<(O<MM@>("6GEE<5E( 9@E(?@C@M<6( 8B( 7CF7;8>@8<J("6GEE<5E( M@7CE( @( FBB89B;6( 7C( 89<(?<M@>BCL(KB>R7CM( 97E(K@G( F>B?(97E(HBE787BC( BC( 89<(89><E9B;6(8B(89<(7C87?@8<( EH@=<( @8()<C<;BH<&E( 9<@>89J( -8( 7E(9<><( 89@8(9<( <C=B5C8<>E(97E( B;6( C5>E<L( 89<(BC;G( ?<?O<>( BF(97E(9B5E<9B;6L(K789( 89<(<P=<H87BC(BF(97E(6BML( 8B( ><=BMC7X<(97?(K789B58( @CG(H>B?H87CMJ( *F8<>( )<C<;BH<( BFF<>E(89<(FBB8O@89L("6GEE<5E( EH<=7F7=@;;G(@ERE( FB>(@C( B;6<>(KB?@C( 8B(H<>FB>?(897E(F5C=87BCJ( !<( =@C( BC;G( EH<=5;@8<( @OB58(97E( ?B87D<( FB>(7CD787CM(=;BE<( H9GE7=@;( =BC8@=8(K789( @(KB?@C( K9B( RCBKE(97E( OB6G( EB( $D<C( O<FB><( 89<(FBB8( @><( O@89L( $5>G=;<7@&E( E5EH7=7BCE( @;<>8<6N( E9<( 7C87?@8<;GJTT( ><?@>RE(BC( 89<(O<MM@>&E( E7?7;@>78G(8B("6GEE<5EL( @C6( FB>(@(?B?<C8( 9<>( 89B5M98E( Ta( 197E( 7E(BC<( BF(89<(?BE8( F@?B5E( @C6( <C7M?@87=(2B?<>7=( FB>?5;@<N( 78E( 7C8<>H><8@87BC( >@CM<E( F>B?( #@>87C&E( \SYZYI( `aV`[^( @C@;GE7E( )@>>G&E( \SY]SI( _S_V_SZ^( =BC8<C87BC( 89@8(89<(H9>@E<( 7E( ?<@C7CM;<EE( 8B( BF( 89<(H9>@E<( @E( @(67><=87D<( EH<<=9( @=8J( TS19@;?@CC( SYYZI( `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`]TV`]_^( 6<( 4BCM( \SYZ[I( _][^( BOE<>D<EL( 9@D<( @;><@6G( 7CE5;8<6(97?J( h@>G6@E( \SYYZI( [[^(?@7C8@7CE( 89@8("6GEE<5E( 7CE87M@8<E($5>G=;<7@&E( ><=BMC787BC( O<=@5E<( 9<(K@C8E( 8B(8<E8(9<>( ;BG@;8GL(O58( B89<>( 89@C(9@D7CM( $5>G=;<7@( ><?@>R(BC( 89<(?@76E&( >56<C<EE( 89<(8<P8(6B<E( CB8( ><D<@;(97E(?B87D<EJ( "89<>K7E<( h@>G6@E( ?@R<E( MBB6( BOE<>D@87BCE( BC( 89<( 7C8<;;7M<C=<( @C6( =BC8>B;(6<?BCE8>@8<6( OG($5>G=;<7@( 7C(897E(E=<C<J( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Z_( )2"$%-c( O<=B?<( 8>@CEH@><C8L(@E( 89<(H>B=<EE( BF(9<>( ><=BMC787BC( 7E(H><E<C8<6( @E( @( ;<CM89G( BC( 89<(=7>=5?E8@C=<E(BF( 197E( 7E(@(E5EH<CE<F5;( ?B?<C8L( "6GEE<5E&( E=@>JT`( 67M><EE7BC( <P8<C6<6( OG( 89<(67M><EE7BCL( 89<(D7D76( 6<E=>7H87BC( BF( 89<(FBB8O@89( 87HH7CM(BD<>L( @C6($5>G=;<7@&E( @E8BC7E9<6( ><@=87BCJ(0<@;7X7CM( 89<(8>589L(89<(B;6( C5>E<( @88<?H8E( 8B(=@8=9()<C<;BH<&E( @88<C87BCL(K97=9( 9@E( O<<C( ?B?<C8@>7;G( 67D<>8<6( 89@CRE( 8B( *89<C@J( "6GEE<5E( 9@E( 8B(@=8( F@E8N(9<( M>@OE($5>G=;<7@( OG( 89<( 89>B@8L(H5;;E( 9<>( =;BE<( 8B(97?L( @C6( 5>M<E(9<>( 8B(R<<H( E7;<C8(5C6<>( 89><@8(BF(6<@89J( '9<( ><EHBC6E( \SYJ_Y`V_Y_^I( H<D( B7BD( <HBD( H<DB=L( EH>=<'BD( B5[&( Z85WRPbDL( Z&( @PN( BP<( P7U(@P<HE>m( c7nBU( Fj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`a^I( 1<;<?@=95E( F7C@;;G(><85>CE( HB<?L( A5E8(@F8<>( [&( <7@=B( ;<D( h@7( 7?<H)>j( c@7DBD( B5[bDJ( PBD( ZE( CBcO( ]8H=BP>j(<1Z<( PHBFGBU( $DAH5hiE7@( @?BU( =@?<( 7CE76<( @C6( 9<(K<C8( BD<>( 89<( E8BC<( 89><E9B;6J( 2<( *C6( 89<( C5>E<( $5>G=;<7@( K@E( 89<(D<>G( F7>E8(8B( E<<( 97?J( 6?B@8( \QF<?@;<(6B?<E87=( E;@D<EQ^(@>B5C6( $5>G=;<7@( AB7CE( 7C(89<(<?B87BC@;( 89>BCM(BF( 89<(GB5CM(?@CL( O58( 78(7E()<C<;BH<L( =B?7CM(B58(BF(9<>(=9@?O<>L(K9B( @66><EE<E(9<>( EBC(K789(K7CM<6( KB>6E( \S]J_aV__^J( 197E( 7E(89<(F7>E8(87?<(89@8(E9<(9@E( E<<C(97?( K789B58( 9<>(RCBK;<6M<J( '9<( =976<E(97?( M<C8;G(@C6( 7CU57><E(@OB58( E7C=<(9<( ;<F8( T`( ,<( 4BCM( SYZ[I( [S]V[SZJ( T_( K9<C( 78(7E(87?<(8B(6<@;(K789( ";EBC( \SYYTI( TT`^( CB8<E( 89@8("6GEE<5E( 6B<E( 8@R<(9<>(5H( BC(9<>(BFF<>( 89<(?@76EJ( 197E( 7E(=BCE7E8<C8(K789( 9BK( 9<(6<@;E(K789( 97E( E<>D@C8EL(K9B( BF8<C(9@D<(D@;5@O;<( E5MM<E87BCEJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions !"#$%&'( ')*+$( *%,( !-%./$''( !"0,'( Z[( 97E( AB5>C<GL(@(C@85>@;( <CB5M9( ><@=87BC( 8B(9<>( EBC&E(67E@HH<@>@C=<J( -(OB>>BK(97E( ><EHBCE<(F>B?(/B?O@>6B&E( 8>@CE;@87BC(\S]J_bV[a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noN( K789( @( ;7C<(89@8( K7;;( ><=5>(89><<( P>k( @H&( W\j^\BD>jBpMDL( Z&(@]87ZH"\N( W]8*LWPB( H5"B=NL(K97=9( -(8>@CE;@8<(@E( Q*C6( EB(9<( EHBR<L(@C6( EH<<=9(K@E( KB>6E( =@C(O<(K7CM<6L( 89<C(89<(BHHBE78<(KB5;6( H><E5?@O;G(O<( K7CM;<EE( FB>(9<>JQ(-F( ?589BEL( @H8<>BE( K7CM;<EE(KB>6EJ(*E( '8@CFB>6(H58E( 78L(Q=BCD<>E@87BC( q7Em(><M@>6<6(@E( @(O7>6(89@8(F;7<E(O@=R( @C6(FB>89(O<8K<<C( EH<@R<>EN(9<><( 89<(O7>6(F@7;E(8B(F;G(O@=RJQTb( 8B(897E( -( @==<H8L(KB>6E( @><(K7CM;<EE( 7F(EH<<=9( K97=9( 7C8<>H><8@87BCL( *==B>67CM( 7E(5C@==B?H;7E9<6( B>( E5HH><EE<6J( 05EEB( @C6(2@7CEKB>89L( 9BK<D<>L( @>M5<( 89@8( @H8<>BE(?589BE( 7E(@( EGCBCG?(FB>(<H<@(H8<>B<C8@L(K7CM<6( KB>6EL( @C6( ><F<>E(8B(89<( ?@;<( EH<@R<>(BF(89<(H><=<67CM( ;7C<EL(K9BE<( KB>6E( @><( EK7F8JT]( *==B>67CM( 8B(897E( ;7C<(BF(89B5M98(89<(FB>?5;@(9@E( O<=B?<L( 7C(89<(KB>6E( BF(2@7CEKB>89L( Q8>78<(@C6( ?<@C7CM;<EEJQTZ( $@=9( E76<(BF(89<(@>M5?<C8(BFF<>E(=B?H<87CM(H97;B;BM7=@;( <D76<C=<( 8B(E5HHB>8(89<7>(BHHBE7CM( 8>@CE;@87BCEJTY( g58( E5><;G(89<(H><F<>><6(8>@CE;@87BC(7E(89<( T[( 05EEB( 7C(05EEBL( :<>C@C6<XV.@;7@CBL( @C6(2<5O<=R( SYYTI( TTJ( Tb( '8@CFB>6( SYb[I( TZTVTZ`J( T]( 05EEB( 7C(05EEBL( :<>C@C6<XV.@;7@CBL( @C6(2<5O<=R( SYYTI( TTVT_( @C6(2@7CEKB>89( SYbaI( Tb`VTbZJ( *8( 7EE5<(7E( K9<89<>( 89<(@;H9@( BF(@]>PWHB=L( 7E(7C8<CE7D<( \QEK7F8Q^(B>(H>7D@87D<( \QK7CM;<EEQ^L( @C6( =BCE<U5<C8;G( K9<89<>( 6CP<HBU( JJJ( 55aB=N( BF( 89<( E<=BC6( 9<?7E87=9( ><F<>E(8B(89<(?@;<( EH<@R<>( BF( 89<(F7>E8(9<?7E87=9L( B>( 89<(F<?@;<( ><=<7D<>(BF(97E(KB>6EJ( TZ( 2@7CEKB>89( \SYbaI( Tb`VTbZ^L( 7C(89<(?BE8( <P8><?<( D<>E7BC( BF( 89<(@;H9@( 7C8<CE7D<( 89<B>GL(HBE78E( @C( 8B(897E( K789( ]7PWH"WDP@( FB>?<6(OG(@(F@;E<(67D7E7BC( \<C<( @18P<HB<D7@^J( B>7M7C@;( rs]81<HBW7o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`bI( SV`^L( K9B( @>M5<E( 89@8(W]8W@( ]=PWHBWDP@( =BCCB8<E( QF<@89<><6Q( ;7R<( JJJ( 55.BU(?5E8( 89<><FB><(?<@C( 89@8(89<(KB>6( F;7<E( @>>BKE(K97=9( F;G(E8>@7M98( 8B(89<7>(8@>M<8N(@]8PWHB=N( K76<( BF(89<(?@>RL( ;7R<(@C(5CF<@89<><6( @>>BK( \=FJ(4@=RE( SYTTI( ]aV]S^J( 197E( >@89<>(F;@==76( 7C8<>H><8@87BC( 6B<E( CB8( E<<?( E578@O;<( FB>(89<(><EHBCE<E( BF($5>G=;<7@L( K9B( EB?<( =<>8@7C;G(9@E( =B?H><9<CE7BC( BF(K9@8( 7E(MB7CM( BCJ( -C( M<C<>@;( -( @M><<(K789( /@8@=X( \SYbZ^( 89@8(89<(KB?@C( 7C(U5<E87BC( E5HH><EE<E( @( ><EHBCE<( 8B( 89<(?@C( K9B( 7EE5<6( 89<( =B??@C6J( -8(KB5;6( K<( RC<K( 9BK( @C( @C=7<C8( @567<C=<( 9<;H( 7F( ?7M98( 5C6<>E8@C6( 89<( FB>?5;@L( O58(@CP<HB=N( @C6( 78E(D@>7@C8E( @HH<@>( 8B(?<@C( <789<>( QEK7F8Q(B>( 8B( QK7CM;<EEQ( 67FF<><C8( @C=7<C8( @589B>EJ( #BC87M;7B( \TaaaI( T]`^( ?@R<E( 89<(?BE8( E<CE7O;<( ><?@>RE( BC( 89<(D@>G7CM( E<?@C87=( D@;5<E( BF( 89<( 8<>?( 7C( *<E=9G;5E( @C6(2<E7B6J( *E( E9<(CB8<EL( 89<( Q7C8<>H><8@87BC( BF(@H8<>BE( @E( &E7;<C8&(9@E( 89<(@6D@C8@M<( BF( ><F<>>7CM(8B(89<(<U5@;;G(2B?<>7=( <PH><EE7BC( <H<@H8<>B<C8@L(K7CM<6( KB>6&JQ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Zb( )2"$%-c( BC<( 89@8(5C6<>E8@C6E( 89<(FB>?5;@7=( EGE8<?(8B(9@D<(?<@C7CM( >@89<>(89@C(@( ;@=R(BF( ?<@C7CML( @C6( 8B(O<(H@>8(BF(@( ;@>M<>( ?<8@H9B>7=@;( =;5E8<>I(7C(B89<>(KB>6E( 89<(?589BE( 8B( O58( ><?@7CE( ?<@C7CM( BF(89<( O<;BCME( )<C<;BH<L( 5CEHBR<CJ( )<>9@HE( 89<(;78<>@;( 8<>?(7E(7>><;<D@C8L(E7C=<(K9<C<D<>( 78(B==5>E( 7C(89<(HB<?( @(KB?@C( E7;<C8;G(BO<GE( @( ?5=9( 89@8(E9<(=B5;6(9@D<( ?@CJ`a( 'B(K9G( 7E()<C<;BH<( E7;<C8(9<><W(19<><( 7E(=<>8@7C;G( E@76L(U5<E87BCE( 8B(O<( @ER<6L( 7C67MC@87BC( 8B(O<( ><M7E8<><6L(O58(89<(=BCD<>E@87BC( 7E(@8( @C(<C6L(@C6(6B<E(CB8(F;GO@=R(@C6(FB>89( O<8K<<C( EH<@R<>EJ(/@8@=X( =BC8<C6E(89@8(E9<( 7E(8BB( <?B87BC@;;G(67E8>@5M98(8B(EH<@RJ`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`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`T(2<( @CEK<>E( 89@8(89<(O<MM@>( K7;;L( E7C=<(9<( E9B5;6(6B( EB?<897CM( 8B(<@>C(97E(R<<HJ( $5>G=;<7@( 6B<E( CB8( ><EHBC6( D<>O@;;GL(@C6( 89<(C@>>@8B>(=B??<C8E( \SYJTYV`a^I( pUJU( 6H&( W\j^\BD>j=tWdL( PFA([&( 6]71WHB=N( W]8*LW1"(H5.BUJ( RcPkko`ud(6E( .5H@=N( HWG6H=BD( We( D@7F7P@BDP=BDJ( 895E( 9<( EHBR<L( @C6(KB>6E( K<><( K7CM;<EE( FB>(9<>L( O58( E9<( ;B=R<6( 89<(6BB>( BF( 89<(K<;;VO57;8( ?<M@>BCJ( *C6( /@8@=X( @>M5<E( 89@8($5>G=;<7@( 7EL( ;7R<()<C<;BH<L( 8BB( E8@>8;<6(OG(1<;<?@=95E&( =5>8(><H;G(8B( E@G(@CG897CMJ``(g58( $5>G=;<7@( 9@E( @;><@6G(O<<C( B>6<><6( @OB58( OG( 1<;<?@=95EL( @C6( @;89B5M9( E9<( 7E(5C@K@><( BF(89<(O<MM@>&E( 76<C878G(@8(897E(HB7C8L( `a( *E( 89<( @CBCG?B5E( ><F<><<(HB7C8<6( B58L( 897E( 7E(@( =@E<( BF(K9@8( :B;<G( \SYYYI( T[_VT[[^( Q8>@6787BC@;( ><F<><C87@;78GJQ( =@;;E( `S/@8@=X( SYbZI( T]V`aJ( `T( +FJ(#BC87M;7B( TaaaI( T]`I( Q19<( DB7=<( BF(1<;<?@=95E&( EH<<=9( ><@=9<E( 78E(@66><EE<<E( @;;( 89<(?B><( @( 89<(6<<H( 5H9<@D@;( H>BDBR<6( OG( @567O;G( O<=@5E<( 78(><EBC@8<E( @M@7CE8( 89<7>(E7;<C=<N( E7;<C=<( 89@8( E7MC@;E( 1<;<?@=95E&( @589B>78GL(K97=9( 6<?@C6E( @C( 7??<67@8<( @=87BC(K789B58( KB>6EJQ( '<<( @;EB( T]`L( CJ( ]YJ( `T'=B6<;( \SYYZI( bV]^( BOE<>D<E( 89@8( 89<( 7C=76<C8( H><H@><E( 89<( @567<C=<( FB>( 89<( 7?HB>8@C=<( BF( ?B><( CB8<E( 89@8(E9<( 7E( 6@CM<>B5E( 9<><( 89@C( 89<(E578B>EJ( $5>G=;<7@( ;@8<>(7C(89<(OBBRL( @C6( `TV``J( ``/@8@=X;YbZI( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 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`_(7??<67@8<;G(F5;F7;;E( KB?<C( K7897C( BF(6BB>R<<H<>J(1<;<?@=95E( 9@E( 7CE8>5=8<6($5>G=;<7@( 8B(6<8@7C( 89<( 89<(H@;@=<( \SYJSb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`[( F5C=87BC(@E(@(6BB>R<<H<>J( 19<( C<P8(6@G( 89<(=BC8<E8(BF(89<(OBK( O<M7CEJ( %BC<( BF( 89<(E578B>E(7E(E5==<EEF5;(7C(E8>7CM7CM(89<(OBKN( 89<(B;6( O<MM@>(K@C8E( 8B(M7D<( 78(@( 8>G( O58()<C<;BH<( 6<?5>EJ(1<;<?@=95E( E<C6E(9<>( @K@G(G<8(@M@7C( \"6J(TSJ`[aV`[`^I( E7=L(B7RBD( 7B5=@( P6( @&( @5PFA=L( <HG@( hB5@i<L( 7BPBD( P&( >j*L@h6P>jD( P<( h@7( 6^77\j^7]=biB7@7( h<*L<5<( <HGBD( Z]7B7P<@Y@7J( PBiBD( [&( 6D'H<@@7( AC<i5@<7( @Rc( ]76@7L( 56i7@P@( Z&( <5VB7V( PB5( G@H( hH6PBU( E@P&( ED7( B7RM^J( g58( MB( 7C8B( 89<( 9B5E<L( @C6( 8@R<( GB5>( KB>R( K789( GB5L( 89<(;BB?(@C6(89<(67E8@FFL( @C6(O76(GB5>(9@C6?@76E( 8B(6B( 89<7>(KB>RJ( g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`ZSV`Z[^I( "6GEE<5E( 7E(H><E<C8L(H58E( 78(897E( 1C*7A/7@lBM( hc>j7Fj@@7( h<c<P=6( @<( ]7WH5j^H=BD( $5H57=c<7@L( AAL<G6HB7B( "5H@=N( 875R7D==RN(6H@H57@M( `_( :B>( <P@?H;<L( "6J( SYJ`[]J( $5>G=;<7@&E( D@>7B5E( <H789<8E( =BCCB8<( 9<>(K7E6B?L( H>56<C=<L( @C6( CBO7;78GJ(*==B>67CM( 8B(h@>G6@E( \SYYZI( []^( 89<(B;6( C5>E<(9@E( @(M><@8<>(D@>7<8G(BF(<H789<8E( 89@C()<C<;BH<L( @C6( E9@><E( EB?<( <H789<8E(K789( "6GEE<5EJ( '<<( h@>G6@E( SYYZI( baVbS( FB>(@( =B?H7;@87BC( BF(9<>( <H789<8EJ( `[( .>7FF789( SYY[I( TJ(.>7FF789( H>BD76<E( @(H<>E5@E7D<( =B?H;<P( BF(><F<><C=<E(F>B?(@>=9@7=( @C6( =;@EE7=@;( HB<8>G( 8B( E5HHB>8( 89<(CB87BC( 89@8( 89<( 8BCM5<( 7E(=BC=<7D<6( @E( @( 6BB>J( +5>7B5E;G( 2@7CEKB>89( \SYbaI( TbZ^( =BC=;56<E( 97E( @>M5?<C8( 89@8( 89<(@H8<>BE(?589BE( FB>?5;@( 9@E( O<=B?<( Q8>78<(@C6(?<@C7CM;<EEQ( OG( CB87CM( Q@( ;7CR(89>B5M9(1<;<?@=95E( @C6( ;B=R7CM( @C6( 5C;B=R7CM( BF(6BB>EJQ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ZZ( )2"$%-c( FmD( Z<( P7=N( Fj(@PBD@PFAU( 6D'H=OD( F^<( h1e]>B5( <DZBD( @h"5@C( ED( <Hh<B7L( H>j( P7( .BH@8i<( 6tc( @5PBB( B8h1mD(<H<D@7( >=@H6( EHG=BJ( >7H<P<HB7@7D( ]>HBHi\bBhZ7D( )>56<C8( $5>G=;<7@L( 1<;<?@=95E( O76E( GB5( 8B(;B=R(89<(6BB>E(BF(89<( E958( ?<M@>BC(87M98;G( @C6(7F(@CG(BF(GB5(9<@>(=>7<E(B>(O@CM7CM( K7897C( F>B?(?<C( 7C(B5>( 8>@HEL( 6BC&8( BH<C( 89<(6BB>( @8( @;;( =@5M98( @C6( 6BC&8( ;BBR( 7CL(O58( E8@G( 89<><( @8(GB5>( KB>RJ( E7;<C8;G( +B?H@><( 897E(E785@87BC(K789( 89<(F7>E8( <H7EB6<( BF(*<E=9G;5E&( '<D<C(*M@7CE8( 19<O<EL( K9<><( $8<B=;<E( ><H<@8<6;G( 8>7<E(8B( E7;<C=<( @C6( E<C6( @K@G( 89<(=9B>5E(BF(KB?<C( \'<H8J(SZaVTaS^L( K9BE<( BOE8><H<>B5E(H><E<C=<( 7E(CB8(K<;=B?<( 7C(89<(H5O;7=( EH@=<( BF(19<O<E( =5>><C8;G( KB?<C( =@CCB8( 5C6<>(7CD@E7BCJ( '7C=<( 89<G(@><(89<(=9B>5EL(89<( BC=<( ?5E8J( O58(9<><( *C6( =BC8>B;E( 89<(6BB>( BF( 89<( ;<@D<L( 89<G( @M@7C($5>G=;<7@( 7CC<>(=9@?O<>(K7897C(K97=9( KB?<CL( 7C=;567CM(?BE8( CB8@O;G( 89<(67E;BG@;(?@76EL( @><(<PH<=8<6( 8B( KB>R( 89<7>( KBB;J( $5>G=;<7@( E@GE(CB897CML( @C6( 7??<67@8<;G(@88<C6E( 8B(89<(8@ERE(\TSJ`ZbV`Z]^I( =&FT=L( 6H&( Z\jt=bD>jB<DL( PFA([&( 6>=P<HBU( W]8i<PB( H."B=LL( R*f8j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`YZV`YY^I( +%noN( 6HS( Ei=BD>A@<DL( PFA(Z&( @18P<HB=L( Z]7tJEPB( HB.BUL( EB( D@7<P@BDP=BDJ( B'7+AZD( '<( .BH@U( H<G6H=BD( 895E( 9<( EHBR<L( @C6(KB>6E( K<><( K7CM;<EE( FB>(9<>L( @C6( E9<( BH<C<6( 89<(6BB>( BF( 89<(K<;;VO57;8( ?<M@>BCJ( *C6( !9@8( 9@E(O<<C(OB5C6L(K7;;( CBK( $5>G=;<7@( BH<CE( 89<(6BB>( @C6(<C8<>E(89<(?<M@>BCJ( O<=B?<( 5COB5C6L( 78( KB5;6( E<<?I( 89<(D<>O(hi>H@EDL( Q=;BE<6LQ( 9@E( E7MC7F7=@C8;G( O<<C( ><H;@=<6(OG( \'7=i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his content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions !"#$%&'( ')*+$( *%,(!-%./$''( !"0,'( ZY( @><( E7;<C=<6(FB>(89<(F7C@;(87?<L(CB8(K7897C( E9B=R7CM(<H7EB6<E( BF(89<(HB<?J( 19<G( K97=9( 9@D<( 89<(9B5E<( 78E<;FL( 89<G( O<8>@G<6L(O58( 7C(@( E<H@>@8<(B58O57;67CMJ`b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g58( E9<(><7CE( K789("6GEE<5EL( K9B( 9@E( ;<@>C<6( 9<>E<;F(7CL(@C6(<P97O78E(@( ><E8>@7C8(89@8(E9<(E9@><E( 89<(D@;5<( BF(E7;<C=<( @F8<>(89>BK7CM(97E( C@?<( B58( 8B( 89<(+G=;BHEJ( *C6( O<=@5E<( KB?<C( 7C(89<(9B5E<9B;6( O<=B?<E( @( BF(9<>( E<;FV=BC8>B;($5>G=;<7@( @;BC<( BF(@;;(89<( 2<>( F7C@;(8@ER( ?<?O<>( BF(9<>(?@E8<>&E( 8<@?L(9<;H7CM( 8B(7?H;<?<C8(89<(><D<CM<J`]( 7E( 7E(8B(@K@R<C()<C<;BH<( F>B?(9<>(E;5?O<>(8B(><HB>8(89@8( 9B?<( @C6( 89<( "6GEE<5E( E578B>E(67EH@8=9<6J`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eC7D<>E78G( "C8@>7B( %T/(`+[( AF;<8=9<>vK;5J=@( `b:5;R<>EBC( \TaaTI( T_`^( =B??<C8E( BC( 89<(@EEB=7@87BC( O<8K<<C( ?B589E( @C6( F<?@;<( M<C78@;EL( @C6( CB8<E( 89<(@HH>BH>7@8<C<EE( BF(1<;<?@=95E&( 6<=7E7BC( 8B( E8>@CM;<( 89<(8><@=9<>B5E(KB?<CL( QO<=@5E<( <@=9( BF( 89<(?@76E&( &?B589&( O>7CME( 8>B5O;<(5HBC( 89<(9B5E<9B;6JQ( `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`SV[TJ( `Z( '<<(:<;EBCV05O7C&E( \SYY_I( STTVST`^( BOE<>D@87BCE( BC( )<C<;BH<&E( ER<H87=@;( ><EHBCE<( 8B($5>G=;<7@&E( C<KE( @C6(9<>( M>@65@;( @==<H8@C=<( BF(89<(8>5<(C@85><( BF( 89<(E578B>EJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Ya( )2"$%-c( g-g/-".0*)23( +J( TaaaJ( *C8BC@==7BL( Q*>=978<=85><( @C6( g<9@D7B>I( +!( Y`I([S]V[``J( g57;67CM( .<C6<>( 7C8B(.><<R( 2B5E<ELQ( '=<C<C( O<7(2B?<>J( g<>;7CJ( 8GH7E=9<C( 7C($@>;G( .><<R( SYZ`J( @C6( 89<(:<?@;<( 19B5M98LQ( Q/@CM5@M<( SY``J( ,7<( *><C6L( !J( g<>M><CL( *J( /J( 1J( SbI( bYVY[J( +;@>RL( #J( TaaSJ( &!@E( 1<;<?@=95E( 8B(27E( #B89<>W( 056<( *><895E@( +)( "6GEE<G( SJ`[bV[YLQ( YbI( ``[V`[_J( *( gJ( Taa_J( +;@G8BCL( )B<87=EI( )<C<;BH<@C( 0<K<@D7CM( 89<(:<?7C7C<( 7C(2B?<>E( "6GEE<GJ( /@C9@?L( #,J( 6<( 4BCML( -J4J( :J( SYZ[J( [S]V[SZJ( @C6( "6GEE<5E&( Q$5>GR;<7@( '=@>I( +n( CJEJ( `[I( "6GEE<G( SYJ`Y`V_bbLQ( BC( 89<( *( "6GEE<GJ( +@?O>76M<J( %@>>@8B;BM7=@;( +B??<C8@>G( ,B9<>8GL( /J( $J( SYY[J( '7><C( 'BCMEI( .<C6<>L( *567<C=<EL( @C6(%@>>@8B>E( *>OB>J( VTaaSJ( 7C( 89<("6GEE<GJ( *CC( :>B?( +9@>@=8<>( 8B()B<87=EJ( )>7C=<8BCJ( %J( SYY_J( :<;EBCV05O7CL( 0<M@>67CM( )<C<;BH<I( `aJ(!7<EO@6<CJ( :<C7RL( gJ( +J( SY]_J( '8567<E( 7C(89<("6GEE<GJ( 2<>?<E( $7CX<;E=9>7F8<C( #J( SYYYJ( 2B?<>E( 1>@6787BC@;( *>8J( eC7D<>E78G( )@>RL( )*J( :B;<GL( 4J( :>7ERL( 2J( SY[_J( .>7<=97E=9<( <8G?B;BM7E=9<E(!B>8<>O5=9J( 2<76<;O<>MJ( !B?@CLQ( +4(Y]I(``[V`[aJ( :5;R<>EBCL(/J( TaaTJ( Q$H7=( !@GE( BF(h7;;7CM(@( .>7FF789L( 0J( ,J( !B>6ELQ( *4)( SYY[J( 4J( gJ( 2@7CEKB>89L( Q*( 2B?<>7=( #<8@H9B>( +;5E8<>( ,<E=>7O7CM( 1<<89L( @C6( 1BCM5<L( SSbISV[J( Q6>=P<HB=L( H."BUI( *( +BC=<@;<6( SYbaJ( :@;E<( ,7D7E7BCWLQ( .;B88@( `ZI( Tb`VTbZJ( 2B?<>L( *<E=9G;5E( @C6( 4J(Taa[J( 19<( 1@;R7CM( .><<REI( 'H<<=9L(*C7?@;E( @C6( 89<("89<>( 7C( );@8BJ( +@?O>76M<J( SI( SYYaJ( *( +B??<C8@>G( BC(2B?<>E( "6GEE<G( @C6( 4J(gJ( 2@7CEKB>89J( 2<5O<=RL( *JL( 'J(!<E8L( -C8>B65=87BC( @C6( gBBRE( -Wd---J( "PFB>6J( Q( <Cc<PB( H."BULQ( +0( `bI( ]aV]SJ( P>k(Z&( @C7<HBU( =PnJU( 6H&( <i=BDC@<DL( 4@=REL(#J( /J( SYTTJ( 7C(.><<R( @C6(2<>( '5==<EEB>EI( :<?@;<( :7M5><E( BF( )J( SYYZJ( 2J( *589B>78G( h@>G6@EL( $5>GR;<7@( )B<87=EJ( /@C9@?L( #,J( 2<@89L( 2J( :B;<G(\<6J^L(0<F;<=87BCE( #J( gJ( SYZSJ(Q19<(,7D76<6(!B>;6( BF(-;7@6(d-LQ( 7C( h@8X( \*>895>^L( !B?<C( 7C( %<K( 3B>RJ( SYV__J( *C87U578GJ( BF( .;B88@( _bI( T]V_]J( SYbZJ( /@8@=XL( 4J( \j^6P7UI( 5CM<F75M<;8<( !B>8<WLQ( Q@C7<HBU( H."BUW6L]=PEHB=N( 2B?<>7=( $H7=J( *CC( *>OB>J( /@8<7C<>L( ,J( SYYZJ( 19<( '@>6BC7=( '?7;<I(%BCD<>O@;( g<9@D7B>( 7C( 'J( 8>J(TaaaJ( "6GEE<GJ( -C67@C@HB;7EJ( @C6( )<>FB>?@C=<( 2<>B<EI( 0J( SYZYJ( 19<( BF( 'H<<=9( /@CM5@M<( /B?O@>6BL( #@>87CL( VSYY`J( 7C(89<( -;7@6J( -89@=@J( /@E8(2<>B( 'BCMW(+B;OG(n5@>8<>;G(S`I(TTTVT_aJ( Q1<;<?@=95E(@C6(89<( )>7C=<8BCJ( BF(/BMBEJ( 'J( SYZ]J( ,7EM57E<( @C6( 0<=BMC787BC( 7C(89<("6GEE<GJ( )>7C=<8BCJ( #5>C@M9@CL( Z]I( TSYVTT]J( 7C(2B?<>&E( ";EBCL( 'J(,J( SYYTJ( Q'<>D@C8E&( '5MM<E87BCE( "6GEE<GQ( +F( ">6<>( 7C(2B?<>LQ( BF(,B?<E87=( -6<@E( @C6( #J( SYY`J( )@C8<;7@L( !<@D7CMI( Q'H7CC7CM( #BC87M;7BL( 'J( TaaaJ( '7;<C=<( 7C(89<(/@C6( *F)( SS_I(_Y`V[aSJ( SY]SJ( 19<( )@>>GL( #J( #@R7CM( *L( )@>>GJ( "PFB>6J( 0B7E?@CL( !<@D<>( 2J( #J( TaabJ( 8B()5O;7=( 2B?<>7=( BF( Q2<;<C( d<>E<I( 19<( +B;;<=8<6( )@H<>E( 7C( 89<( -;7@6I( =@5E@( O<;;7( @C6( d7=87?( BF#7;?@C( BF( !@>I( ST]I( SV`bJ( 'H<@R<>LQ( *4)( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions )@>>GJ( :>B?( $6J( '7;<C8( !"#$%&'( 05EEBL( #J( 4JL( :<>C@C6<XV.@;7@CBL( @C6(*J( 2<5O<=R( "6GEE<G(`I(gBBRE(cd--Vcc-dJ( "PFB>6J( '=B6<;L( 0J( SYYZJ( BF(*>?EL( +)( Y`I( SVS]J( Q19<( 0<?BD@;( 7C( 89<( 1<CE7BC( YS( ')*+$( *%,(!-%./$''( !"0,'( \<6EJ^J( SYYTJ( *( +B??<C8@>G( 89<( 0<=BMC787BC( BF( /@<>8<EL( BC( 2B?<>E( @C6( %@>>@87D<( "6GEE<GW( 7C( 89<( STI( ][V]YJ( '=B88L( 4J(*J( SYSZJ( Q$5>GCB?<( @C6( $5>G=;<7@( "6GEE<GW( +n( 2B?<>( TJ(%<K( 3B>RJ( '8@CFB>6L( !J( gJ( SYb[J( 19<( "6GEE<G( BF( 19@;?@CCL( !J( .J( SYYZJ( Q:<?@;<( ';@D<E( 7C( 89<("6GEE<GW( 7C('J(0J( 4BE9<;( @C6( 'J(#5>C@M9@C( /BC6BC( @C6( \<6EJ^L( !B?<C( @C6( ';@D<E( 7C(.><=BV0B?@C( +5;85><I( ,7FF<><C87@;( $U5@87BCEJ( %<K( 3B>RJ( TTV`_J( 19B?EBCL( 4J(*J( hJ( SY`bJ( Q!7CM<6( !B>6ELQ( +n( `aI( SV`J( !B9;L( dJ( 4J(SYY`J( Q'8@C67CM(OG(89<('8@89?BEI(19<( +><@87BC(BF('<P5@;(-6<B;BMG(7C(89<( "6GEE<GW( *><895E@( TbI( SYV[aJ( This content downloaded from 192.54.242.155 on Wed, 22 May 2013 00:06:13 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions