MEDICAL
GEOLOGY
IN BRAZIL
ENVIROMENTAL AND HEALTH
EFFECTS OF TOXIC
ON MATERIALS
GEOLOGICAL FACTORS
EDITORS
M EDICAL GEOLOGY IN BRAZIL
ENVIROM ENTAL AND HEALTH EFFECTS OF TOXIC
ON M ATERIALS GEOLOGICAL FACTORS
2005 WORKSHOP INTERNATIONAL ON M EDICAL GEOLOGY
RIO DE JANEIRO, BRASIL
EDITORS
Cassio Roberto da Silva
Geólogo, MSc, Chefe do
Departamento de Gestão Territorial do
Serviço Geológico do Brasil - CPRM/RJ
Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo
Geólogo, Professor Dr
do Instituto de Geociências da
Universidade Estadual de Campinas - UNICAMP - SP
Eduardo Mello De Capitani
Médico, Professor Dr. da Faculdade de Ciências Médicas da
Universidade Estadual de Campinas - UNICAMP - SP
Fernanda Gonçalves Cunha
Geóloga, Dra.do Departamento de Geologia do
Serviço Geológico do Brasil - CPRM/RJ
RIO DE JANEIRO, BRASIL
2010
Geological Survey of Brazil – CPRM
Rio de Janeiro
Coordenation – DEPAT/DIEDIG
Editoration/Diagramation/Design
English Text Translation
Roberto Kirchheim
English Text Revision by Bristish Native Speaker Roger Stanley Wilkinson
rswilkinson@hotmail.com
550.289
Medical Geologi in Brazil: enviromental and health effects
of toxic on materials geological factors
Cassio Roberto da Silva (Ed.)... [et al.]. – Rio de Janeiro:
CPRM - Serviço Geológico do Brasil
Medical Geology in Brazil, 2010.
220 p. ; 28 cm
Texts of 2005 on Medical Geology Workshop
International de Geologia Médica.
1. Medical Geology. 2. Geo Science. I. Workshop Internanacional de Geologia Médica, 2005, Rio de Janeiro. II. Silva,
Roberto da (Ed.). III. Título.
CDD 550.289
SUM M ARY
Presentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii
1. Medical Geology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Selinus, O.
2. Medical geology in Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Silva, C.R., Figueiredo, B.R., De Capitani, E.M.
3. Epidemiology and medical geology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
De Capitani, E.M.
4. Health surveillance related to chemicals in the ambit of the brazilian unified health system
Sistema Único de Saúde-SUS) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Netto, G.F.
5. Surface multi-element geochemisty for risk and enviromental impact assessments,
Paraná State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
Licht, O.A.B.
6. Geochemistry of brazilian soils: present situation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36
Pérez, D.V., Manzato, C.V., Alcântara S., Wasserman, M.A.V.
7. Biofortification as a combat tool for micronutrient deficiencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
Nutti, M., Carvalho, J.L.V., Watonabe, E.
8. Risk Evaluation a social and environmental management tool:
The case study of the Northern region of the State of Mato Grosso . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
Hacon, S., Farias, R., Campos, R.C., Wasserman, J.C.
9. Risks to health from organic substances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55
Mello, C.S.B. de; Miller, D.J.
– iii –
10. Human exposure to arsenic in Brazil. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64
Figueiredo, B.R., Borba, R.P., Angélica, R.S.
11. Arsenic in groundwater in Ouro Preto (MG) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71
Gonçalves, J.A.C., Pereira, M.A., Paiva, J.F., Lena, J.C. de
12. Arsenic in estuarial sediments of the Antonina bay, acess channel, Paraná State Brasil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78
Sá, F., Machado, E.C., Ângulo, J.R.
13. Human exposition to arsenic in the middle Ribeira Valley, São Paulo State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82
De Capitani, E.M., Sakuma, A.M., Figueiredo, B.R., Paoliello, M.M.B., Okada, I.A., Duran, M.C., Okura, R.I.
14. Lead and arsenic in the sediments of the Ribeira de Iguape River, SP/PR. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87
Lopes Jr., I., Figueiredo, B.R., Enzweiler, J., Vendemiatto, M.A.
15.Enviromental and humam health diagnosis: Lead contamination
in Adrianópolis, Paraná State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
Cunha, F.C., Figueiredo, B.R., Paoliello, M.M.B., De Capitani, E.M.
16. Study of aerosols isotopic Pb composition and sources
in Brasília (DF) Central Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101
Gioia, S.M.C.L., Pimentel, M.M., Kerr, A.
17.Dental Fluorosis and fluorine anomalies in groundwater of Sao Francisco Town,
Minas Gerais State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107
Velásquez, L.N.M., Fantinel, L.M., Ferreira, E.F., Castillo, L.S., Uhlein, A., Vargas, A.M.D., Aranha, P.R.A.
18. Fluorine geochemistry in fluvial waters and sediments of the Cerro Azul Region,
Paraná State: Definition of risk areas for human consumption . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115
Andreazzini, M.J., Figueiredo, B.R., Licht, O.A.B.
19. Hydrogeochemical study of fluorine in the groundwater of the Casseribú,
Macacú and São João Rivers basins, Rio de Janeiro State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123
Panagoulias, T.I., Silva Filho, E.V.
20. Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
Plawiak, A.B.R., Licht, O.A.B., Vasconcellos, E.M.G., Figueiredo, B.R.
21. Contamination by anthropogenic mercury in soil and stream
sediments in Lavras do Sul Municipality-RS, Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137
Grazia,C.A., Pestana, M.H.D.
22. Radioelements impact on the environment, agriculture and public
health in Lagoa Real, Bahia State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145
Oliveira, J.E.
23. Asbestos: what is important to consider . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154
Scarpelli, W.
24. The crenotherapy of Rio de Janeiro State Brazil mineral water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157
Martins, A.M., Mansur, K.L., Pimenta, T.S., Caetano, L.C.
– iv –
25. Assessment of groundwater contamination level in Parintins City,
Amazonas State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165
Marmos, J.L., Aguiar, C.J.B.
26. Geochemical characterization of the Eastern Amazonas, public water supply system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171
Macambira, E.M.B., Viglio, E.P.
27. Chemical elements in the public water supply in Ceará State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 181
Frizzo, S.J.
28. Contamination assessment of potable water in the UFRN (Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte)
campus regarding nitrates from septic tanks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 188
Petta, R.A., Araújo, L.P., Lima, R.F.S., Duarte, C.R.
29. Dissolved aluminum in the water of sand extraction pits – a study of the possible toxicity
implications – Seropédica Municipality – RJ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 196
Eduardo Duarte Marques, E.D., Silva Filho, E.V., Tubbs, D., Santelli, R.E., Sella, S.M.
30. The influence of the superfic surfau area of particles on trace-elements adsorption by bottom
sediments: a case study in the surroundings of Macaíba city Rio Grande do Norte State Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 200
Lima, R.F.S., Guedes, J.A., Brandão, P.R.G., Souza, L.C., Petta, R.A.
–v–
PRESENTATION
T
his book aims to share the concepts, methodologies and results of recent studies developed under the
multidisciplinary context of Medical Geology. It presents the work of Brazilian authors in the International Medical
Geology Workshop that was held in Rio de Janeiro in June 2005 at the Brazilian Geological Survey-CPRM head office. This initiative does not intend to encompass the whole universe of researchers working at the interface between
Health and Geology, but to present a scenario that significantly reflects the state of the art of this important issue
amidst existing health problems. The basic notions of this new field of science and its historical evolution in a global
context are presented by the paper written by Dr. Olle Selinus (IMGA).This introduction is followed by a description
of the actual Brazilian Medical Geology scenario, with emphasis on the importance of Epidemiology, as a basis to
assess public health issues. In this context, the National Health Vigilance Program related to chemical substances
is also exposed. The following articles present the research results of Medical Geology issues developed by a large
number of institutions, from geographical regions all over the country. According to these studies, geological data
has been correlated with the health data of a given population in order to search and define the casual nexus or
even to launch a new work hypothesis. Finally, we would like to thank all the authors for their valorous contribution.
Our thanks and appreciation are extended especially to the Rio de Janeiro State Research Foundation-FAPERJ, for
its financial support and to the Brazilian Geological Survey-CPRM, the Brazilian Geochemistry Society-SBGq, and to
the International Medical Geology Association-IMGA for their incentives and logistical support. We are confident our
contribution to foster and develop Medical Geology in Brazil will subsequently raise the quality of life of our population.
The Editors.
.
– vii –
M EDICAL GEOLOGY
Olle Selinus
Geological Survey of Sweden,Uppsala SE-751 28, Sweden
SUMMARY
Medical geology is defined as the science dealing
with the influence of ordinary environmental factors on
the geographical distribution of health in humans and
animals. Accordingly this is a complicated subject and
interdisciplinary contributions from essentially different
scientific fields are required when these problems are
to be solved. This paper discusses the background of
medical geology with examples from all over the world.
Emphasis is placed on the serious effects of acidification
of soil and water that pose a potential threat against the
health of humans and animals. All living organisms are
composed of major, minor and trace elements, given by
nature and supplied by geology.
Why is geology important for our health?
Our environment is the entire web of geological and
biological interactions that characterize the relationship
between life and the planet earth. Essential and toxic
elements in bedrock or soils may become a direct risk
for human and animal health; and may be the underlying
cause of both deficiency and toxicity. Some naturally occurring elements are necessary for our wellbeing while
others are detrimental to our health.
Before resources are committed to clean up or protect
the environment from man-made contamination, it would
seem prudent to determine how much of the “contamination” merely reflects the preexisting natural background
levels. Naturally occurring elements can have detrimental
effects on health when ingested in increasing quantities.
Metals have always existed and will forever exist, but we
cannot avoid the fact that the health of human beings
and animals are influenced by metals in the environment.
Geological processes along with human activities of all
kinds have redistributed metals from sites where they are
fairly harmless to places where they affect humans and
animals negatively.
Earth is the ultimate source of all elements. Metals
are ubiquitous in the lithosphere, where they are inhomogenously distributed and occur in different chemical forms.
Ore deposits represent natural concentrations that are
commercially exploitable. While such anomalous accumulations are the focus of economic geology, the background
concentrations of metals that occur in common rocks,
sediments, and soils are of greater significance to the
total metal loading in the environment. All known elements
are present at some level of concentration throughout the
natural environment in humans, animals, vegetables and
minerals, and their beneficial and harmful effects have
been present since evolution began.
Geology may appear far removed from human health.
However, rocks are the source of all the naturally occurring
chemical elements found on the earth. Many elements in
the right quantities are essential for plant, animal and human health. Most of these elements enter the human body
via food and water in the diet and through the air that we
breathe. Through the weathering processes, rocks break
down to form soils on which crops and animals that constitute the food supply are raised. Drinking water moves
through rocks and soils as part of the hydrological cycle.
Much of the dust and some of the gases present in the
atmosphere are the result of geological processes. Hence,
a direct link exists between geochemistry and health due
to ingestion and inhalation of chemical elements by eating
and drinking food and water and breathing air.
We need to understand the nature and magnitude of
these geological sources to develop approaches to assess
the risk posed by metals in the environment. It is very important to distinguish between natural and anthropogenic
contributions to metal loadings. Concentrations of metals
can range over orders of magnitude among different rocks.
For example, the concentrations of metals such as nickel
and chromium are much higher in basalts than in granites,
whereas the reverse is true for lead. Weathering of these
types of bedrocks results in the mobilization of elements
in the environment. In sediments, the heavy metals tend
to be concentrated in fractions with the finest grain size
and the highest content of organic matter. Black shales,
a fine grained rock, for example, tend to be enriched in
these elements.
In addition, knowledge of geological processes is
fundamental to understand the fate of those metals, which
are released as a result of human activity.
Volcanism and related igneous activities are the principal processes that bring elements to the surface from
deep inside the earth. For example, the volcano Pinatubo
ejected in just over two days in June 1991, about 10 billion
–1–
Medical Geology
tonnes of magma and 20 million tonnes of SO2 and the
resulting aerosols influenced the global climate for three
years. This event alone introduced 800,000 tonnes of zinc,
600,000 tonnes of copper and 1,000 tonnes of cadmium
to the surface environment. In addition to this, 30,000 tons
of nickel, 550,000 tonnes of chromium and 800 tonnes of
mercury were also added to the earth’s surface environment. Volcanic eruptions redistribute some of the harmful
elements, such as arsenic, beryllium, cadmium, mercury,
lead, radon and uranium, plus most of the remaining elements, many of which have still undetermined biological
effects. It is also important to realize that there are on an
average 60 subaerial volcanoes erupting on the earth’s
surface at any given time, releasing various elements
into the environment. Submarine volcanism is even more
significant than those at continental margins and it has
been conservatively estimated that there are at least 3,000
vent fields on the mid ocean ridges. One interesting fact
is that about 50% of SO2 is of natural origin, mainly from
volcanoes, and only 50% is from human sources.
The naturally occurring elements are not evenly distributed across the surface of the earth and problems can
arise when element abundances are too low (deficiency)
or too high (toxicity). The environment’s inability to provide
the correct chemical balance can lead to serious health
problems. The links between environment and health are
particularly important for subsistence populations that are
heavily dependent on the local environment for their food
supply. Approximately 25 of the naturally occurring elements are known to be essential to plant and animal life
in trace amounts, including Ca, Mg, Fe, Co, Cu, Zn, P, N,
S, Se, I and Mo. On the other hand, an excess of these
elements can cause toxicity problems. Some elements
such as As, Cd, Pb, Hg and Al have no or limited biological
function and are generally toxic to humans
Many of these elements are known as trace elements
because they generally occur in minute (mg/kg or ppm)
concentrations in most soils. Trace element deficiencies in
crops and animals are therefore commonplace over large
areas of the world and mineral supplementation programs
are widely practiced in agriculture. Trace element deficiencies generally lead to poor crop and animal growth and
to reproductive disorders in animals. These problems
often have the greatest impact on poor populations who
can least afford nutritional interventions for their animals.
Interactions, speciation and bioavailability
In addition to understanding both natural and anthropogenic sources of harmful substances in the environment,
it is also important to consider exposure and bioavailability.
Exposure is the qualitative and/or quantitative description
of total intake/assimilation of a given chemical substance
via a range of pathways. Bioavailability is the proportion of
a chemical available for uptake into the systemic circulation of a organism, following a given mode of exposure.
Bioavailability directly influences exposure and therefore
the effect and risk of health detriments. Large quantities
of a potentially harmful substance may be present in the
environment, but if it is in a non-bioavailable form, the risk
to health may be minimal. Bioavailability depends not only
on the physical and chemical forms in which the element is
present, but also on other factors in the environment, such
as pH, temperature and moisture conditions. The bioavailability and mobility of metals like zinc, lead and cadmium
is greatest under acidic conditions, while increased pH
reduces bioavailability. Also, soil type such as clay and
sand content and its physical properties affect the migration of metals through soils. The organisms present in soils
also affect metal solubility, transport and bioavailability
Furthermore, as will be demonstrated with the arsenic case study from Bangladesh, a potential hazard only
becomes a problem if there is an exposure route. The
potential hazard of high arsenic groundwater has existed
for thousands of years but it is only in recent years with the
sinking of water wells to access this water that an exposure
route has been established and a health effect manifested.
In the absence of exposure, there is no adverse effect.
Exposure pathways include ingestion (food, water and deliberate/inadvertent soil ingestion), dermal
absorption and inhalation. In terms of ingestion, much
emphasis has been placed on water, simply because it
is an easy sample type to analyze. However, soils and
food are likely to be far more important dietary contributors because the concentrations of potentially harmful
substances in soils are much greater (parts per million)
than in water (parts per billion). Whether soil ingestion
is inadvertent or via the deliberate eating of soil known
as geophagia, this exposure route should not be underestimated. For example, studies in Kenya have shown
that 60 – 90% of children between 5 – 14 years of age
practice geophagia and each child consumes an average
of 28g of soil per day.
In discussing medical geology it is also necessary to
know which elements are essential for humans and animals. The main essential elements are: calcium, chlorine,
magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, sodium and sulphur.
Essential trace elements are: chromium, cobalt, copper,
fluorine, iron, manganese, molybdenum, zinc, and selenium. Elements with probably no recognized biological
role are called non-essential elements, often with harmful properties, e.g. cadmium, arsenic, mercury and lead.
Exposure to heavy metals could result in negative effects
Most of the heavy metals are essential in different
amounts for biological functions of organisms (e.g. cobalt,
copper, manganese, molybdenum, zinc, nickel, and vanadium). They are called micronutrients. In high concentrations,
however, all metals produce adverse effects on organisms.
The large scale introduction of heavy metals in society
- the technosphere - and eventually into the biosphere has
given rise to toxic effects in animals and plants and non-
–2–
Olle Selinus
sustainable loading. Cadmium, mercury, lead, copper, and
other metals have all been linked to various toxic effects in
living organisms. Of these, mercury and lead do not seem
to serve any biological functions in living organisms.
Examples of medical geology.
Inorganic arsenic is one of the oldest known poisons.
Chronic arsenic exposure particularly affects the skin,
mucous membranes, nervous system, bone marrow, liver
and heart. Arsenic toxicity is strongly dependent on its
chemical form. Essentiality of arsenic has been shown
in studies with animals but not in humans. Worldwide
natural emissions of arsenic into the atmosphere in the
1980s were 1.1 to 23.5 tonnes per year, derived mostly
from volcanoes, wind-borne soil particles, sea spray and
biogenic processes. Coal combustion alone accounts for
20 percent of the atmospheric emission, and arsenic from
coal ash may leach into soils and water.
There is growing concern over the toxicity of arsenic
caused by exposure to elevated concentrations in the
geochemical environment. The danger to human health
due to arsenic poisoning has now been recognized by
the World Health Organization (WHO), which has lowered
the safe level for arsenic in drinking water from 50 mg/1 to
10 mg/l. Among the countries that have well documented
case studies of arsenic poisoning are Bangladesh, India
(West Bengal), Taiwan, China, Mexico, Chile and Argentina. The common symptom of chronic arsenic poisoning
is conjunctivitis, melanosis, depigmentation, keratosis and
hyperkeratosis. As in the case of India and Bangladesh,
the relationship between excess arsenic exposure and
skin and internal cancers is established in Taiwan. The
source of arsenic is geochemical, the element being present in many rock-forming minerals, including iron-oxides
and clays but mostly in sulphide minerals, especially in
pyrite and arsenopyrite.
Radon is a naturally occurring radioactive gas that is
colorless, odorless, and tasteless and can only be detected
with special equipment. It is produced by the radioactive
decay of radium, which, in turn, is derived from the radioactive decay of uranium. Uranium is found in small quantities
in all soils and rocks, although the amount varies from place
to place. Radon decays to form radioactive particles that
can enter the body through inhalation. Inhalation of the
short-lived decay products of radon has been linked to
an increase in the risk of cancers of the respiratory tract,
especially the lungs. Breathing radon in the indoor air of
homes contributes to about 20,000 lung cancer deaths
each year in the United States and 2,000-3,000 in the U.K.
Only smoking causes more lung cancer deaths.
Geology is the most important factor controlling the
source and distribution of radon. Relatively high levels of
radon emissions are associated with particular types of
bedrock and unconsolidated deposits, for example some,
but not all, granites, phosphatic rocks, and shales rich in
organic materials. The release of radon from rocks and
soils is controlled largely by the types of minerals in which
the uranium and radium occur. Once radon gas is released
from minerals, its migration to the surface is controlled by
the permeability of the bedrock and soil; the nature of the
carrier fluids, including carbon dioxide gas and groundwater; and meteorological factors such as barometric
pressure and rainfall.
Radon dissolved in groundwater may migrate over
long distances along fractures and caverns depending
on the velocity of fluid flow. Radon is soluble in water and
may thus be transported for distances of up to 5 km in
streams flowing underground in limestone. Radon remains
in solution in water until a gas phase is introduced. If emitted directly into the gas phase, as may happen above the
water table, the presence of a carrier gas, such as carbon
dioxide, would tend to induce migration of the radon. This
appears to be the case in certain limestone formations,
where underground caves and fissures enable the rapid
transfer of the gas phase. Radon in water supplies can
result in radiation exposure of people in two ways: by
ingestion of the water or by release of the radon into the
air during shower or bathing, allowing radon and its decay products to be inhaled. Radon in soil under homes is
the biggest source of radon in indoor air, and presents a
greater risk of lung cancer than radon in drinking water.
However radon in drinking water could be a problem for
small children.
The connection between goitre and iodine deficiency
is a classic example of medical geology even though
the relationships are somewhat more complicated than
formerly believed. The connection between geologywater-food chain-diseases can clearly be shown for
iodine. Goiter was common in ancient China, Greece,
Egypt and amongst the Inca, where the soil and/or water
is usually deficient in iodine, but was successfully treated
by seaweed which contains high levels of iodine. Iodine,
being a component of the thyroid hormone thyroxine, has
long been known as an essential element for humans and
mammals. Deficiency of iodine results in a series of Iodine
Deficiency Disorders (IDD) the most common of which is
endemic goiter. The areas where IDD are concentrated
tend to be geographically defined. Thus the most severe
occurrences of endemic goiter and cretinism have been
found to occur in high mountain ranges, rain shadow
areas, and central continental regions.
Goitre occurs due to enlargement of the thyroid gland
as it attempts to compensate for insufficient iodine. It has
been estimated for example that out of a population of 17
million in Sri Lanka, nearly 10 million people are at risk of
goitre. Iodine deficiency in pregnant mothers can also lead
to cretinism and impaired brain function in children. The
World Health Organization estimates that currently over
1.6 billion people are at risk from iodine deficiency and
that it is the single largest cause of mental retardation in
–3–
Medical Geology
the world today. China alone has 425 million people who
are at a risk in regard to IDD.
Another important element is fluorine. The geochemistry of fluorides in groundwater and the dental
health of communities, particularly those depending
on groundwater for their drinking water supplies, is
one of the best known examples of the relationships
between geochemistry and health. Many water supply
schemes, par ticularly in developing countries where
dug wells and deep bore holes form the major water
sources, contain excess fluoride and as such are harmful to dental health.
Fluorine is an essential element with a recommended
daily intake of 1.5 – 4.0 mg/day. Health problems such as
caries or dental mottling and skeletal fluorosis may arise
from deficiency or excess. Unlike other essential elements
for which food is the principal source, the main source of
fluoride is water. Fluorine in surface and groundwater is
derived from the following natural sources: (a) leaching of
the rocks rich in fluorine; (b) dissolution of fluorides from
volcanic gases by percolating groundwater along faults
and joints at great depth and discharging in springs; (c)
rainwater; which may acquire a small amount of fluoride
from marine aerosols and continental dust; (d) industrial
emissions and effluents:(f) run-off from farms, ostensively
using phosphatic fertilizers.
For example, after the eruptions of the volcano Hekla
in Iceland in 1693, 1766, and 1845, severe incidents of
fluorosis were recovered. Acute poisoning was described.
Since World War II, Hekla has erupted in 1947, 1970,
and 1980, and a number of analyses for fluorine have
been performed. The volcano delivered huge amounts
of fluorine and concentrations of 4,300 ppm in grass has
been found.
In the beginning of the 20th century it was known that
high contents of fluorine could cause fluorosis. The natural
concentration of fluorine in drinking water is normally 0.1-1
ppm. In many countries, however, the concentration could
be as high as 40 ppm that could lead to serious fluorosis.
Yes the picture is rather complicated because there are
also antagonistic effects. Molybdenum and selenium can
reduce the effects of high concentrations of fluorine. One
of the major benefits of fluorine seems to stem from its
antagonism with aluminum. In Ontario, Canada, there is
less Alzheimer disease where the drinking water contains
more fluorine.
One quite different aspect of medical geology is
geophagia, which is the deliberate eating of soil. In
many ancient and rural societies, and amongst a wide
variety of animals, exposure to chemical elements occurs principally through the deliberate ingestion of soil,
or soil-derived `medical’ preparations (often associated
with immigrant communities). Such behavior is medically
known as either pica or more specifically as geophagia.
Geophagia is common among traditional societies and
has been recognized since the time of Aristotle as a
cure-all for health problems. Soil from the ground may be
eaten in the form of paste but in many situations there is
a cultural preference for soil from special sources, such
as termitaria.
Even today the theory of geophagia as a subconscious response to dietary toxins or stress must be
balanced against the habitual eating of soil that has
been reported to develop into extreme, often obsessive,
cravings. These cravings are often reported to occur
immediately after rain. Typical quantities of soil eaten
by geophagists in Kenya have been reported to be 20
grams per day. This is almost 400 times more than typical quantities of soil thought to be ingested as a result of
inadvertent ingestion through hand-to-mouth contact (e.g.
50 milligrams per day). Whilst eating such large quantities
of soil increases exposure to essential trace nutrients, it
also significantly increases exposure to biological pathogens and to potentially toxic trace elements, especially
in areas associated with mineral extraction, or in polluted
urban environments.
Geophagia is also increasing in developing countries. Because of immigration the tradition of geophagia
is brought into western societies and imported soils can
often be found in local ethnic food stores for sale to immigrants.
Naturally Occurring Dusts. Exposure to mineral
dusts can cause a wide range of respiratory problems.
The health effects of exposure to mineral dusts have
been recognized for decades, with asbestos being the
classical example. Dust exposure can also affect broad
regions such as the dust stirred up by earthquakes in
the arid regions of the southwestern U.S. and northern
Mexico. Dust exposure can even take on global dimensions. Ash ejected form volcanic eruptions can travel
many times around the world and recent satellite images
have shown wind blown dust picked up from the Sahara
and Gobi deserts blown more than halfway around the
world. Of greatest concern for effects upon human health
are the finer particles of the respirable (inhalable) dusts.
In this regard, considerable work is being conducted in
identifying dust particles derived from soils, sediments
and weathered rock surfaces.
3.0 The future of Medical Geology
Naturally occurring materials such as rocks, minerals,
dust and water can have profound effects on the health of
humans, plants and animals. Understanding the complex
relationship between the natural environment and the
health of animals and humans requires close collaboration between medics, veterinarians, geoscientists, and
toxicologists for mitigation. The emerging field of medical
geology plays a key role in these fields of interdisciplinary
collaboration. It also requires close coordination between
developed and developing countries.
–4–
Olle Selinus
Medical geology is an interdisciplinary science
that is growing rapidly. Because of the importance
of geological factors on health the IUGS commission
COGEOENVIRONMENT (Commission on Geological
Sciences for Environmental Planning) established in
1996 an International Working Group on Medical Geology led by the Geological Survey of Sweden, SGU,
with the primary aim of increasing awareness of this
issue among scientists, medical specialists, and the
general public. In 2000 a new IGCP project was also
established by UNESCO; ”IGCP#454 Medical Geology”.
The International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU)
also sponsored 2002-2003 international short courses
in this subject, a cooperation involving SGU, United
States Geological Survey and the US Armed Forces of
Pathology in Washington DC. These courses have then
continued all over the world and the most recent one
was in Brazil, June 2005. As a result of the significant
achievements to date the Commission’s Working Group
was given a Special Project status by the IUGS. In March
2002 the IUGS announced that the International Working
Group on Medical Geology would be assigned Special
Project status operating directly under the IUGS. Olle
Selinus is Director of this activity. Jose Centeno and
Bob Finkelman are Co-Directors. A new international
association, International Medical Geology Association
(IMGA) is now also being established with one councilor
from Brazil. Further on the United Nations is planned to
decide on the Year of Planet Earth. One main topic of
this initiative will be medical geology.
Geological surveys, universities, and geological societies should take a continuing active role in providing useful geologic information related to medical geology and
encourage the development of local working groups of
multi-disciplinary medical geology experts. It would also
be useful to encourage research in the area to produce
more effective methodologies for the study of geological
factors in environmental medicine and formulate recommendations to mitigate the effects of natural and maninduced hazardous geochemical conditions.
–5–
M EDICAL GEOLOGY
IN BRAZIL
Cassio Roberto da Silva, cassio.silva@cprm.gov.br
Bernardino Ribero Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicamp.br
2
Eduardo Mello de Capitani, capitani@hc.unicamp.br
1
Geological Survey of Brazil– CPRM/RJ
2
State University of Campinas – UNICAMP
1
2
HISTORY
In Brazil, the integration of the specific knowledge of
Earth Sciences and Health Sciences has had a long and
relatively profitable history in the diagnosis and proposals
to control some endemic diseases. Studies that were more
concerned with descriptions of the climate, hydrography
and biogeographical conditions, at that time known as
botanical landscape and zoogeography, were the basic
components of Medical Geography. This was defined
as the study of the geography of diseases or pathology
in the light of geographical knowledge. Geographical
Pathology, Geopathology or Medical Geography were
synonyms with Geographical Medicine (Lacaz, 1972).
Geographical Medicine was considered to be a branch
of Geography, as were Biogeography, Human Geography
and Physical Geography.
Geomedicine, defined by Zeiss (apud Lacaz, 1972)
as the branch of medicine that studies the influence of
climatic and environmental conditions on health, was
included in Medical Geography, widening its horizons.
However, most studies in Medical Geography were related to infectious-parasitic diseases, within a theoretical
framework given by Tropical Medicine. This has always
valued climatic, physical and geographical aspects in its
epidemiological studies, investigating factors connected
to the ecology of transmitter insects and carriers of bacteria, virus and protozoa, for example. In these situations,
geological and geochemical aspects of the studied
regions were not taken into account, as the explicative
model of the diseases origins did not process this kind
of data. An atypical reference in the context of Medical
Geography, that usually privileged infectious-contagious
diseases, was the study carried out by the Manguinhos
Institute (Instituto de Manguinhos), today FIOCRUZ, and
the National Health Department (Departamento Nacional
de Saúde) on the prevalence of endemic goiter in various
Brazilian regions in the 1950s. A lower prevalence of the
disease in the coastal areas compared to the west-center
regions, where the diseased rate reached up to 54% of the
population, drew the attention to a causal geographical/
geological factor (Sampaio, 1972).
Since the 1980, researchers of the Federal University
of Bahia (Universidade Federal da Bahia) established
a field base to evaluate studies of children and adults
contaminated by lead and cadmium in Santo Amaro da
Purificação (BA). Here the waste of lead ore metallurgy had
contaminated the soil and the shallow city aquifer. They
became the pioneers of this approach to this kind of problem in Brazil (Carvalho et al. 1984; Carvalho et al. 1985).
More recently, Licht (2001), initiating a low density
geochemical survey, sampling sediment, water and soil
across the whole State of Paraná, identified dental fluorosis in children from the Itambaracá (PR) region associated
with the groundwater. Furthermore, bromide and chloride
in the soil was possibly related to the cancerogenic diseases occurring in the State’s northern area.
Researchers from the Campinas State University
(UNICAMP) the Minas Gerais State Environmental Agency
(Fundação Estadual de Meio Ambiente– FEAM) and other
institutions, in collaboration with the Freiberg University in
Germany (Matschullat, et al. 2000), identified high concentrations of As in the urine of children living near old Au
mines in ferriferous districts in Minas Gerais State (Quadrilátero Ferrífero). In Amapá state, Santos et al. (2003), of
the Evandro Chagas Institute (Instituto Evandro Chagas),
researched exposure to As in a population living near a
manganese refinery waste site (Mineração ICOMI). They
analyzed samples of hair and blood, without, however,
identifying any significant risk to the people.
Between 1998 and 2003, UNICAMP researchers,
in partnership with public health institutions, identified
lead contamination in the blood of children and adults
living near the Plumbum S.A. Plant in Adrianópolis, PR
(Paoliello, 2002; Cunha, 2003; Figueiredo, 2005). In the
same region, in Iporanga, São Paulo State, although
–6–
Cassio Roberto da Silva
anomalous concentrations of arsenic were found in the
soil and sediments, the levels of human exposure were
low, representing no risk to the population’s health (Sakuma, 2004).
Many studies on the human risk evaluation of mercury
assimilation from artisanal gold extraction sites (garimpo),
especially in the Amazon region, have been carried out
by researchers of CETEM, FIOCRUZ, Evandro Chagas
Institute (Instituto Evandro Chagas), UFPA, INPA, UFAM
and UFRO. In their websites several studies on this subject can be found.
In 2002, after the Brazilian Congress of Geology in
João Pessoa (PB), a research group formed from more
than ten universities and institutions, created a discussion
group called Environmental Geochemistry and Medical
Geology Research Network - REGAGEM (Rede de Pesquisa em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia Médica) –
regagem@ige.unicamp.br, currently with 345 members.
The group’s aim was to conceive and propose the National
Program for Environmental Geochemistry and Medical
Geology Research – PGAGEM (Programa Nacional de
Pesquisa em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia Médica)
and make available this program’s information, links and
other data related to medical geology on the website www.
cprm.gov.br/pgagem.
The first Brazilian medical geology event, the International Workshop on Medical Geology, was held in
October 2003 at UNICAMP. A mini-course was given by
Olle Selinus, Robert Finkelman and José Centeno from
the IGCP 454 of IUGS-UNESCO, to 110 Brazilian participants, mostly from the fields of geosciences, health and
chemistry. An interesting outcome of that occasion in the
scientific community happened as early as September
2004, at the Medical Geology Symposium of the 32nd
International Congress of Geology, held in Florence – Italy,
when 4 of the 33 presentations were given by Brazilian
researchers.
The second workshop took place in June 2005 in
Rio de Janeiro, hosted by the Brazilian Geologic Survey,
offering an updated version of the previous mini-course
conducted by the same international researchers mentioned above. In that event Brazilian research was represented by a surprising number of 56 studies (12 oral
presentations and 44 posters). 210 professionals from
different disciplines (geosciences-48%, health-16%,
chemistry-4%, other professions-11%, including undergraduate and graduate geology students-21%) participated in the event coming from many Brazilian states (Rio
Grande do Sul, Santa Catarina, Paraná, São Paulo, Rio
de Janeiro, Minas Gerais, Goiás, Distrito Federal, Bahia,
Pernambuco, Ceará, Rio Grande do Norte, Pará, Amazonas and Rondônia).
The quality and quantity of the studies presented by
Brazilian researchers at the International Workshop on
Medical Geology in Rio de Janeiro, which covered issues
related to As, Hg, F, Pb, asbestos, organic substances
and the quality of public water supplies, made it possible
to publish this book.
MEDICAL GEOLOGY
In Brazil, Medical Geology researchers are referred
to the books and articles by Selinus et al., (2005), Skinner & Berger (2003), Cortecci (2002), Singh (2002), Licht
(2001) and Figueiredo (2005b).
Therefore, based on these authors, Medical Geology
may be defined as “the study of the relationship between
natural geological factors and health, aiming at the wellbeing of people and other living organisms”. Another more
concise understanding is that it is “the study of the impact
of geological materials and processes on public health”.
According to this vision medical geology includes “the
identification and characterization of natural and anthropogenic sources of noxious material in the environment,
trying to foresee the movement and alteration of chemical
and infectious agents as well as other disease causing
agents over time and space, besides understanding how
people are exposed to such material and what can be
done to minimize or avoid such exposure”.
The link between geologists and other scientists from
the medical, odontological, biological and veterinary fields
was allowed by the medical geology research area, in an
effort to locally and globally solve health issues. It aims to
strengthen and integrate technical cooperation to reduce
environmental threats to health and improve the well-being
of humans and animals.
Issues associated with health usually refer to human beings and other living creatures, whereas the focus of geology is on the inanimate and the distant past.
Thus, although they may be part of distinct knowledge
domains or require different investigation approaches,
the direct relationship cannot be ignored. “Life develops in a matrix of materials from the earth – rocks,
minerals, soil, water, air – whose availability exerts a
deep control over what all living creatures ingest and
how they develop biologically and culturally”, so “we
are what we eat and drink”.
The air we breathe, the water we drink and the
nutrients we consume depend on the geological environment, which we can only partially control. As we
struggle to adapt to a world where 10 billion people
live, a better understanding of the processes through
which the natural environment influences our health
would allow more appropriate decisions in the future. It
is a general consensus that global changes are related
to the powerful impacts produced by humans on their
surroundings. It is precisely the noxious or beneficial
effects sometimes caused by geological material and
processes on human beings that constitute the main
concern of Medical Geology.
–7–
Medic Geology in Brasil
The combination of knowledge of the earth sciences
with that of medicine and life sciences offers an opportunity of several applications and possibilities to solve
questions concerning health. This integration of efforts
may improve the problem definition, help in approach
strategies, define and locate sources of drinking water
and develop economic solutions based on geological
principles that can help minimize and, most of all, hinder
suffering and disease.
There is an expectation that geoscientists, together
with health professionals, will significantly contribute to
the improvement of public health quality. According to
European geoscientists, the studies carried out in the last
15 years are only the tip of an iceberg, a little sample of
the research spectrum that is now initiating and that will
transit in the wide space between geology and medicine.
Medical Geology is a team “science”, requiring
teamwork and agreement with other sciences. In detail,
it studies regional or local variations in the distribution
of elements, especially the metallic and metalloids, their
geological-geochemical behavior, natural and artificial
contamination and the damages to human, animal and
vegetable health because of abundances or deficiencies.
Life on earth developed in the presence of all 97
elements that occur naturally, including the ones we call
essential, non-essential, toxic and possibly toxic (Garret,
2005). The human body needs 25 elements, recognized
until this moment, as essential for it to function properly.
Among these elements the most important one is carbon
(C), without which there would be no life as it is known
today. Carbon molecular chains are the structural basis
for thousands of different compounds constituting cells
such as proteins and the DNA. Since more than 60% of
the corporal mass is composed of water (H2O), oxygen
and hydrogen have a significant participation as essential elements. Oxygen surmounts in quantity any other
element in the human body (61% of the corporal mass)
because it is also present in the bone structure as calcium
phosphate. Nitrogen (N) is also part of this selected group
of the four most important essential elements (together
with O, H and C), since it participates in practically all
proteins and the DNA. The other 21 essential elements
are usually divided into macronutrients (which need to be
absorbed through diet in large quantities) participating
in the corporal mass in concentrations higher than 0,1%
(Ca, Cl, P, K, Na, S) and micronutrients, in corporal concentrations below 0,1% (Mg, Si, Fe, F, Zn, Cu, Mn, Sn, I,
Se, Ni, Mo, V, Cr, Co). Table 1.
Though not essential, many elements are regularly
absorbed through diet (food and water) and inhaled with
the breathed air. Therefore, there can be variable quantities of these elements that get deposited in the human
body according to their chemical affinity with certain
tissues, like, for example: aluminum (Al), barium (Ba),
cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), arsenic (As), mercury (Hg),
strontium (Sr), uranium (U), silver (Ag) and gold (Au)
(Emsley, 2001).
The element constituents of rocks, when they become available due to weathering, may be absorbed in
soil, get dissolved by runoff drainage and percolating
groundwater or be carried with soil into superficial water
bodies. In the soil they may be assimilated by plants,
becoming part of the food chain. They also become
part of the food chain when they are carried in solution
through drainage and assimilated by aquatic species.
However, besides through diet, the chemical substances
can also be assimilated by living beings through inhalation or through the skin.
Generally speaking, the soil, running water and plants
reflect the composition of the underlying rocks, their relationship being an important method to discover new ore
deposits. When feeding on vegetation, wild animals also
reflect the chemical fingerprint of the region where they
live. This relationship is observed in humans as well, there
being classical cases of diseases occurring along geological zones with lithological or geochemical anomalies
(Figures 1 and 2). Anomalies are also related to pollution
effects. However, natural contaminations such as the ones
provoked by the deposition of ashes ejected in volcanic
eruptions and by dust clouds generated in desert areas
cannot be ignored.
Figure 1 – Kaschin-Beck Disease, China. Bone formation disorder
affecting growth and producing deformities, caused by deficiency of
selenium in the water and soil.
–8–
Cassio Roberto da Silva
Table 1 – Function of the chemical elements in the human bodies (Scarpelli, 2003)
FUNCTION OF THE ELEMENTS CONSIDERED ESSENTIAL TO HUMAN BEINGS
O, H, N
and C
See discussion about these elements in the text above.
Ca
It is the most abundant metal in the human body in the form of calcium phosphate in bones and teeth. It is essential to
the regulation of cellular membranes activity, especially in muscular contraction and conduction of nervous impulses.
It participates in blood coagulation, cellular division and hormones liberation (total quantity in the body = 1200g).
Cl
Maintenance of the hydroelectrolytic balance balance and body secretions; digestion of food as hydrochloric acid
in the stomach (total quantity in the body = 95g).
K
Mg
Na
P
S
Co
Cr
Cu
F
Fe
I
Ni
Mn
Mo
Se
Si
Sn
V
Zn
Maintenance of the fluids balance on intracellular level (it is concentrated inside the cells), participating in muscular
contraction and nervous conduction (total quantity in the body = 110-140g)
It operates in the maintenance of the bones structure; it regulates the passage of substances through the cellular
membranes; it participates as a co-factor in more than 100 enzymes and in the production of proteins, being extremely
important to the normal growth and development process (total quantity in the body = 25g).
Maintenance of the hydroelectrwolytic balance, always remaining outside the cells, participating in muscular
contraction and nervous conduction (total quantity in the body = 100g).
Constituent of bones and teeth in the form of calcium phosphate. It is essential to the process of chemical energy
production through organic molecules of the ATP type (adenosine triphosphate), as well as being part of the DNA
molecule (total quantity in the body = 780g).
It is part of the structure of keratin, the main constituent of hair, nails and external layer of skin. It is part of several
enzymes that are essential to the normal metabolism and also of vitamin B1 (total quantity in the body = 140g).
Constituent of vitamin B12 involved in the maintenance of the nervous system’s integrity and in the production of
red blood cells.
Essential to the metabolism of glucose. Despite its probable relationship with the developing of diabetes mellitus in
adults, clinical cases of this element’s deficiency in humans have not yet been described.
Constituent of about ten enzymes important to the human metabolism such as the superoxide dismutase, involved
in the control of free radicals.
Essential to the maintenance of a healthy structure of teeth (enamel) and bones in minimal doses.
Component of hemoglobin, it is responsible for the transport of oxygen in the blood and for the reserve of this element in the muscles.
Essential to the normal functioning of the thyroid, since it is a constituent of the thyroid hormones, thyroxine and
triiodothyronine. The nutritional deficiency of hormones is well known for producing a deficit in normal growth and
serious mental and cognitive disorders.
Considered essential and linked to the control of growth, but not well known as to its action mechanisms in the
normal metabolism.
Though considered to be essential, its specific functions are little known; it participates in enzymatic reactions and
in the activity of vitamin B1 in minimal quantities.
Constituent of several important enzymes, among them the xanthine-oxidase, involved in the metabolism of proteins,
and the aldehyde-oxidase, involved in the biotransformation of ethyl alcohol.
The definition of selenium’s essentiality is recent (1975), when it was found that it is a constituent of the molecule of
glutathione-peroxidase enzyme, extremely important in the control of free radicals formation in the human metabolism. In 1991 it was found that it is also part of the deiodinase molecule, which participates in the production of the
thyroid hormones.
In 1972 it was defined that silicon is essential and linked to the process of bones growth.
It is still controversial as to its actual essentiality in humans. Effects of its deficiency are not known. It was previously
considered essential for its supposed participation in the gastrin hormone.
It is related to the regulation of the enzymes involved in the sodium-potassium balance in the nervous system. Less
than 0.5% of the ingested vanadium is absorbed in diet.
It exists in all tissues, especially in bones, muscles and skin; it acts in the immune system; it regulates corporal
growth, protection of the liver. Its deficiency reduces corporal growth.
–9–
Medic Geology in Brasil
- to contribute to the diagnosis of soils with deficiency
in micro and macronutrients for agriculture;
- to develop an environmental education program for
the affected populations in collaboration with public
health agencies
Figure 2 – More than a 100 million people in the world suffer from fluorosis.
In Brazil it occurs, mainly in children, in the regions of São Francisco (MG)
and Itambaracá (PR).
NATIONAL PROGRAM FOR ENVIRONMENTAL
GEOCHEMISTRY AND MEDICAL GEOLOGY
The National Program for Environmental Geochemistry and Medical Geology Research – PGAGEM, coordinated by the Brazilian Geological Service – CPRM, is
characterized by its multi-institutional and interdisciplinary
concept giving multi-usage results. It was elaborated
by researchers from: the Brazilian Geological Service
– (CPRM), Campinas State University (UNICAMP),
Paraná State Geological Survey (Minerais do Paraná –
MINEROPAR), São Paulo University (Universidade de São
Paulo – USP), Pará Federal University (Universidade Federal do Estado do Pará – UFPA), Londrina State University
(Universidade Estadual de Londrina – UEL), the Evandro
Chagas Institute (Instituto Evandro Chagas), the Adolfo
Lutz Institute (Instituto Adolfo Lutz), the National School of
Public Health (Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública – ENSP/
FIOCRUZ and the Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation (Empresa Brasileira de Agropecuária – EMBRAPA).
Today it enjoys international partnerships with the
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), U.S. Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AFIP), Geological Survey of Sweden
(SGU), International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS),
International Medical Geology Association (IMGA) and
the University of Freiberg – Germany.
This program was conceived in 2003 with the following specific objectives:
- to carry out geochemical studies, preferably through
partnerships, to identify and evaluate possible sources of
natural and anthropogenic contaminations, integrate the
data with information on public health, seeking to point out
which areas and communities are exposed to the adverse
effects related to the toxic elements and substances;
- to make available the analytic results for mineral
prospecting purposes;
- to subsidize studies of geo-environmental information, in partnership with governmental bodies, universities and research institutes in the fields of toxicology
and epidemiology;
- to indicate strategies and technologies in the field of
environmental geochemistry for studies on environmental remediation;
In addition, PGAGEM contemplates other developments, such as:
- establishing sampling methods and standards, as
well as standards and chemical laboratorial certification to develop analytical methodologies for geological materials in environmental studies;
- contribute to the development of the Environmental
Geochemistry and Medical Geology Research Network – REGAGEM, to establish partnerships with
city, state and federal institutions of public health and
environmental sectors, using possible correlations
between the geochemical data and the data on mortality and diseases incidence in humans and animals,
and in due course, make it available in Brazil;
- encourage and subsidize data integration studies
on environmental geochemistry, epidemiology and
ecotoxicology generated in the research network
using multidisciplinary teams;
- qualify human resources at graduate and undergraduate level for field and laboratory work and for
treatment and interpretation of geological and geochemical data with multidisciplinary purposes related
to the environment and public health, in addition to
mineral research;
- support the strengthening of analytical laboratories
infrastructure in the fields of geochemistry and toxicology in Brazil, encourage network collaboration in
specific projects, proficiency tests and interlaboratory
certification;
- create a referential data bank for the whole national
territory, with the field and laboratory information
generated by CPRM and participating actors;
and establish a collection of geological material
(sediment, soil and rock) related to environmental
studies.
Through these proposals, it is expected the program
will be useful to all participant institutions and for their
correlated multidisciplinary programs, such as:
– 10 –
- plan local public health policies in areas with identified contamination risks by chemical elements to the
population;
- plan environmental activities for the Ministries of
Health and Environment and other municipal and
state environmental institutions, the National Water
Agency (Agência Nacional de Águas – ANA) and
the hydrographic basins committees;
Cassio Roberto da Silva
- identify surface sources of natural or anthropogenic
contamination in urban or rural areas;
- the geochemical and environmental characterization
of aquifer recharge areas;
- determine the magnitude of the contamination plume
in surface and groundwater, especially those near
irregular waste disposal sites and landfills;
- elaborate soil and groundwater vulnerability maps
as well as risk maps;
generate information on soil geochemistry for pedological studies on fertility and for agricultural and cattle
breeding use.
The methodological procedures used by PGAGEM
were adjusted, as far as possible, to the geochemical standards set by the UNESCO–IUGS, IGCP-259 project and by
the Working Group on Global Geochemical Baselines of
IUGS – IAGC, to facilitate comparisons with similar studies
in other countries. The following projects are examples of
successful low density geochemical mapping to develop
multiuse maps: the “Environmental Geochemical Atlas of the
Central Barents Region” – Kola Project (600 sample locations in 188,000 km²), the Barents Ecogeochemistry (1,373
sample locations in 1,500,000 km²), the Geochemical Chart
of the Paraná State -Atlas Geoquímico do Estado do Paraná
(697 sample locations in 166,000 km²) and those made by
the CPRM in Rio de Janeiro State (200 sample locations in
44,000 km²), in the Mogi Guaçu and Pardo river basins (99
sample locations in 21,000 km²) and the Ribeira river valley
(187 sample locations in 28,000 km²).
PGAGEM encompasses the whole Brazilian territory,
focusing initially on regions and hydrographic basins
where health problems exist that may be related to the
environment. Areas with some alteration features in the
quality of water bodies and soil that may cause adverse
effects on the health of living beings will also be studied
as a priority.
The geochemical sampling includes surface water
sample collection (where they occur), with varying sampling densities, and active streambed sediments along
the region’s hydrographic basins. In the Amazon region,
due to the access problem, sampling will take place in
basins with catchment areas of about 2,000 km² (1,000
– 3,000 km²). In other regions the selected basins have
between 100 and 200 km².
Sampling campaigns of water for domestic use is also
foreseen in cities without efficient water treatment plants
or where there is none at all, and also of agricultural soils
(0-25 cm), at the rate of 3 samples from each region.
Figure 3 shows the sampling programs per region,
with around 29,700 sampling stations of sediment and
water that generate around 59,400 samples in total. A
further 5,000 samples of supply water and 10,000 soil
samples is estimated to be collected, totalizing 74,000
samples for the entire program.
North
3,800,000 km²
8,250 sampling locations
Northeast
1,600,000 km²
7,750 sampling locations
Center-west
1,614,000 km²
6,200 sampling locations
South
580,000 km²
2,900 sampling locations
Total
8,514,000 km²
29,700 sampling locations
Southeast
920,000 km²
4,600 sampling locations
Figure 3 – Regional distribution of the sampling stations for streambed sediment (streambed and flowing water).
More details about the methodological procedures
adopted by PGAGEM can be obtained at www.cprm.gov.
br/pgagem, Lins (2002).
Partial Results
In just two years, 2003 to 2005, several studies were
achieved within the scope of PGAGEM.
Under the responsibility of CPRM and partner institutions, about 4,041 samples of water, streambed sediments
and soils were collected. Of these, about 2,960 samples
were analyzed and the results of certain areas such as:
Parintins in the Amazon; the NE region of Pará State;
Lagoa Real in Bahia State; Vale do Ribeira, between
the States of São Paulo and Paraná; in Ceará State, and
Lavras in Rio Grande do Sul State, are to be found in this
book. Results of other regions (Rondônia State, Goiás
State, Teresina – capital of Piauí State - and Itinga –Minas
Gerais State) should be published in 2006.
Parintins island situated on the right bank of the
Amazon River about 350 km downstream of Manaus,
is nowadays an important tourist region because of the
traditional Boi-Bumbá festivity. The population had been
experiencing health problems, probably associated with
the bad quality of the public water supply, due to the
important population influxes, especially during festivity
time. The research activities developed on the island
by Marmos & Aguiar (2006) included the analysis of 6
– 11 –
Medic Geology in Brasil
samples of stream water and 33 from tubular wells. The
former group showed normal results, whereas among the
groundwater samples about 63% revealed high contents
of NO3 (11-49 mg/L), Al (0.3-2.0 mg/L) and ammonia (2.9
mg/L) that were attributed to anthropogenic contamination, as only the wells less than 65 meters deep presented
such high values.
In the Northeast of Pará State, according to Macambira & Viglio (2006), the results of the analysis of 77
samples from the public water supply, covering 80% of
the studied area, showed excessive values of Al and Pb,
respectively 18 and 145 times the maximum permissible
concentration according to the National Environmental
Council - CONAMA and WHO, followed by B, Cd, Fe,
Cu, K, Mn, Zn and P. This water quality data is being correlated with the high incidence of endemic diseases like
verminous diseases, digestive system diseases (cancer),
dental caries, anemia and hepatitis.
Frizzo (2006) presents analytical results obtained
from 234 samples of the public water supply from tubular
wells and hand dug wells, ponds and lakes, springs
and streams in Ceará State, in an area of 146,000 km².
Concentrations beyond those permitted by CONAMA
were detected in 43% of the samples for the elements
considered toxic: Al (0.11 – 0.80 mg/L), As (0.02 mg/L)
B (0.63 mg//L), Cd (0.001 – 0.02 mg/L) and Pb (0.01
– 0.46 mg/L) and for those considered toxic and essential: Ba (0.71 – 5.59 mg/L), Fe (0.31 – 12.1 mg/L), Mn
(0.11 – 1.21 mg/L), Ni (0.26 mg/L) and Zn (0.18 – 0.76
mg/L). This information was given to the state sanitation department, which is conducting a re-sampling
of the water to get a better definition of the mitigating
measures to be taken.
In Lagoa Real, Bahia State, Oliveira (2006) carried
out a sampling in groundwater (n=32), soil (n=32) and
streambed sediment (n=42), in a 1,126 km² area. He
recommends special attention to water consumption
in that region, considering the analytical results that
showed uranium concentrations in a range between
0.041 and 0.566 mg/L in 8 tubular wells, exceeding the
maximum admitted value of 0.02 mg/L of U. He also
foresees, in the near future, a shortage of the actual
groundwater and a lack of this mineral’s benefits due
to excessive extraction.
The Project Geochemical and Environmental Landscapes of the Ribeira Valley – Evaluation and Prevention of Risks to the Physical Environment and Human
Health Related to the Exposure to Arsenic and Heavy
Metals, carried out by geologists, chemists, doctors
and toxicologists of UNICAMP, Londrina State University
(Universidade Estadual de Londrina), the Adolfo Lutz
Institute (Instituto Adolfo Lutz) and the Brazilian Geological Survey – CPRM, according to Figueiredo (2005b),
created the Geoenvironmental Atlas (Upper and Middle
Ribeira Valley), the Geochemical Atlas of Sediment of
the Ribeira Valley and the generation of totally new data
about the exposure to Pb and As in ecosystems and
human settlements in the Upper and Middle Ribeira
Valley. Many of the results obtained from this project
are presented as papers in this book and in the website
www.ige.unicamp.br/geomed.
In southern Brazil, Grazia & Pestana (2006) studied
the auriferous district of Lavras do Sul – RS, in view of the
residues left by mining and artisanal ore extraction since
the end of the 19th century; 43 samples of streambed
sediments and 11 samples of soil were analyzed. The
soil samples indicated contamination, especially in the
areas close to the mining companies’ processing plants,
at levels higher than the intervention level of CETESB
(2005) of 5 ppm for Hg. The highest concentrations found
for Hg were (10.3 – 18.5 ppm), for As (24.5 – 163 ppm),
Cu (124 – 1,469 ppm) and Pb (719 – 1.465 ppm). The
authors recommend the remediation of the soil around
the processing plants of CRM, Chiapetta and Cerro Rico,
which may represent a risk factor to human health.
The examples above reveal that the activities under
development in the PGAGEM framework have reached
a significant level, though there is still much to be
done. Usually, after the identification and observation
of anomalous values of toxic elements that may cause
adverse effects on public health, the health professionals/institutions are expected to be able to take over the
issue to apply techniques of risk analysis to which the
public is subjected. The results related to geochemistry
as well as those concerning the medical aspects must
be communicated to the public health departments to
instigate coordinated actions yet avoid unnecessary
alarmist disturbances.
It is also advisable that, according to the analyzed
area and the type of contamination, communication programs of the risks and environmental education of the
affected population should be developed in partnership
with health departments.
PGAGEM may also serve as an incentive to the
researchers connected to REGAGEM to establish
partnerships, through their institutions, with SGBCPRM and others, to obtain resources from financing
agencies (CNPq, FINEP, Research Funds and Project
Funds) for the execution of new projects. There are
many other specific projects that may be proposed
for metropolitan regions, hydrographic basins, mining
districts and agriculture zones with active participation
of federal, state and municipal research bodies as well
as universities.
In this geochemical program we must emphasize
the importance of homogenization of sampling analysis
procedures by the institutions and researchers, therefore
ensuring consistency of the data bank for all Brazil, which
is available and accessible on the internet for all the scientific community and the public in general.
– 12 –
Cassio Roberto da Silva
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS
In parallel to the PGAGEM implementation and considering that Medical Geology is still an unknown and
innovative activity in Brazil, the REGAGEM participants
have carried out countless dissemination activities,
including the distribution of folders, in Portuguese and
English, seminars and courses. They have also participated in workshops at congresses and symposiums
related to geology, water resources, environment and to
the medical field, as well as in seminars promoted by
undergraduate geology students in several universities
around the country.
The Campinas State University – UNICAMP and
the Goiás Catholic University – PUC/GO, have already
included in their post graduate programs some Medical
Geology content. There is a growing tendency to include
this new subject at graduate and post graduate geology
and medicine courses, based on the diffusion of the
recently published text book “Essentials of Medical Geology”. Copies of this book were recently acquired and
distributed among Brazilian Geological Survey – CPRM
professionals and researchers from several institutions
and regions across the country.
The facts and data related above show that Medical
Geology in Brazil has had a significant growth since 2003
mainly due to the creation of the REGAGEM network, the
implementation of the national research program PGAGEM and the maintenance of its own website. With less
than 10 researchers in 2000, it is estimated that today
about 80 researchers work in the Brazilian Medical Geology field. To reinforce this progress, it is important that
periodic scientific meetings and mini-courses continue
to be held, henceforth counting on the support of the
International Medical Geology Association – IMGA.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
CARVALHO F.M.; BARRETO, M.L.; SILVANY NETO,A.M.;
WALDRON, H.A.; TAVARES, T.M. Multiple causes of
anaemia amongst children living near a lead smelter
in Brazil. Sci Total Environ, Amsterdam, v. 35, n. 1,
p. 71-84, Apr. 1984.
CARVALHO, F.M.; SILVANY-NETO, A.M.; TAVARES,T.M.;
LIMA, M.E.; WALDRON, H.A. Lead poisoning among
children from Santo Amaro, Brazil. Bull Pan Am
Health Organ. Washington, v. 19, n. 2, p.165-175,
1985.
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA DE SANEAMENTO AMBIENTAL. Decisão de Diretoria No 195/2005. Disponível em:<http://www.cetesb.sp.gov.br>. Acesso
em 01 jun. 2006.
CORTECCI, G. Geologia e Salute. Disponível em: <http://
www.dst.unipi.it/fist/salute/salute.htm>. Acesso em
31 jul. 2006.
CUNHA, F.G. Contaminação humana e ambiental por
chumbo no Vale do Ribeira, nos Estados de São
Paulo e Paraná, Brasil. 2003.111p. Tese (Doutorado
em Ciências)- Instituto de Geociências, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2003.
EMSLEY, J. Nature’s Building Blocks : an A-Z guide to
the elements. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
FIGUEIREDO, B.R. A contaminação ambiental e humana
por chumbo no Vale do Ribeira (SP-PR). Com ciência, Campinas, n. 71, nov. 2005. Disponível em:
<http://www.comciencia.br>. Acesso em: 31 jul.
2006.
FIGUEIREDO, B. R. Estudo geoquímicos e ecotoxicológicos do Vale do Ribeira. [S.l]: FAPESP; UNICAMP;
IAL; UEL; CPRM, 2005. 1 CDROM. Projeto Paisagens
Geoquímicas e Ambientais do Vale do Ribeira.
FRIZZO, S. J. Elementos químicos em águas de abastecimento público no Estado do Ceará. In: INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP ON MEDICAL GEOLOGY,
2005, Rio de Janeiro. [Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio
de Janeiro: CPRM, 2006.
GARRET, R.G. Natural distribution and abundance of elements. In: SELENIUS, O. (Ed). Essentials of Medical
Geology: impact of the natural environment on public
health. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2005. p. 17-41.
GRAZIA, C. A.; PESTANA, M.H. D. Contaminação por Mercurio Antrópico em Solos e Sedimentos de Corrente
de Lavras do Sul – RS – Brasil. In:INTERNATIONAL
WORKSHOP ON MEDICAL GEOLOGY, 2005, Rio de
Janeiro. [Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro:
CPRM, 2005.
LACAZ, C.S. Conceituação: atualidade e interesse do
tema: súmula histórica. in: In: LACAZ C.S. et al (Eds),
Introdução à Geografia Médica do Brasil. São Paulo:
Edgard Blücher; EDUSP, 1972. P.1-22.
LICHT, O.B. A Geoquímica multielementar na gestão ambiental: identificação e caracterização de províncias
geoquímicas naturais, alterações antrópicas da
paisagem, áreas favoráveis à prospecção mineral e
regiões de risco para a saúde no Estado do Paraná,
Brasil. Curitiba, 2001. 236 p. Tese ( Doutorado em
Geologia Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia, Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
LINS, C. A C. 2002. Programa Nacional de Pesquisa
em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia Médica.
Disponível em: <http://www.cprm.gov.br/pgagem>.
Acesso em: 31 jul. 2006.
MACAMBIRA E. B.; VIGLIO E. P. Caracterização geoquímica das águas de sistema de abastecimento
público da Amazônia Oriental. In: INTERNATIONAL
WORKSHOP ON MEDICAL GEOLOGY, 2005, Rio de
Janeiro. [Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro:
CPRM, 2005.
MARMOS, J.L.; AGUIAR, C.J.B.; Avaliação do nível de
contaminação das águas subterrâneas da cidade
– 13 –
Medic Geology in Brasil
de Parintins - AM - Brasil. In: INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP ON MEDICAL GEOLOGY, 2005, Rio de Janeiro.
[Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro: CPRM, 2005.
MATSCHULLAT, J.; BORBA, R.P.; DESCHAMPS, E.;
FIGUEIREDO, B.F.; GABRIO, T.; SCHWENK, M.
Human and environmental contamination in the Iron
Quadrangle, Brazil. Applied Geochemistry, [Amsterdam], v. 15, n. 2, p. 181-190, fev. 2000.
OLIVEIRA, J.E. Implicações de radioelementos no meio
ambiente, agricultura e saúde pública em Lagoa
Real, Bahia, Brasil. In: INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP
ON MEDICAL GEOLOGY, 2005, Rio de Janeiro. [Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro: CPRM, 2005.
PAOLIELLO, M.M.B. Exposição humana ao chumbo e
cádmio em áreas de mineração, Vale do Ribeira,
Brasil. 2002. 173p. Tese (Doutorado em Saúde Coletiva)- Faculdade de Ciências Médicas, Universidade
Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2002.
SAKUMA, A. M. Avaliação da exposição humana ao
arsênio no Alto Vale do Ribeira, Brasil. 2004. 197p.
Tese (Doutorado em Saúde Coletiva)- Faculdade
de Ciências Médicas, Universidade Estadual de
Campinas, Campinas, 2004.
SAMPAIO, A.A. Geografia do bócio endêmico no Brasil.
In: LACAZ C.S. et al (Eds), Introdução à geografia médica do Brasil. São Paulo: Edgard Blücher;
EDUSP, 1972. P.477-488.
SANTOS, E.C.O.; JESUS, I.M.; BRABO, E.S.; FAYAL, K.F.;
LIMA, M.O. Exposição ao mercúrio e ao arsênico
em Estados da Amazônia: síntese dos estudos
do Instituto Evandro Chagas/FUNASA. Revista
Brasileira de Epidemologia, São Paulo, v. 6, n. 2,
p. 171-185, jun. 2003.
SCARPELLI, W. Geologia Medica, palestra 2003. Disponível em www.cprm.gov.br.
SELINUS, O.; ALLOWAY, B.; CENTENO, J.A.; FINKELMAN, R.B.; FUGE, R.; LINDH, U.; SINGH, H.; SMEDLEY, P. Essentials of Medical Geology. Amsterdam:
Elsevier Academic Press, 2005.
SINGH, H. Theoretical Basis for Medical Geology.
Disponível em: <http://home.swipnet.se/medicalgeology/ PDF/MedGeo.pdf>. Acesso em: 01
ago. 2006.
SKINNER, H.C.W.; BERGER, A.R (Ed.). Geology and
Health: closing the gap. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, 2003.
– 14 –
EPIDEM IOLOGY
AND M EDICAL GEOLOGY
Eduardo de Mello De Capitani
capitani@fcm.unicamp.br
Department of Medical Clinic
Intoxication Control Center
Faculty of Medical Sciences
State University of Campinas-UNICAMP
INTRODUCTION
Medical geology is defined by Selinus (2005) as “the
science that deals with the relationships between natural
geological factors and human and animal health.” According to this author, it is also “… the science that seeks to
understand the influence of ordinary environmental factors
on the geographical distribution of such health problems”.
The term “factor” and the expression “health problems”
in this definition lead to the concept of “cause and effect”
that, in turn, leads to the concept of “epidemiology” in the
realm of health.
Epidemiology is the discipline that “studies the way
diseases or events related to the binomial health-disease
are distributed among populations and what are the
factors that determine such distribution” (Gordis, 1996).
Thus, it is at the base of epidemiology to study all the
possible factors involved in the health-disease complexity, such as genetic and infectious factors, those related
to habits (including the type of diet, tobaccoism, alcohol
consumption, the pattern of physical exercises practice,
etc.), occupational factors as well as those related to
the environment (including natural geological, scope of
medical geology and anthropogenic factors).
There are just a few diseases of environmental origin
that are pathognomonic in the sense that only that specific
exposure is related to that group of signs and symptoms.
Usually, several substances or chemical elements can
produce the same type of symptomatology or disease.
Likewise, there are several possibilities of habit, genetic
and occupational factors causing the same problems
(Nielsen & Jensen, 2005).
Therefore, in any study related to medical geology,
where it is necessary to define whether a certain natural
geological factor is associated or not with the cause of
the observed health problems, the cooperation with epidemiology is essential.
Epidemiology is based on the postulate that a disease
does not occur randomly; on the contrary, its occurrence is
linked to the specific characteristics of the given population. The definition of a cause related to a natural geological factor or an ordinary environmental one, as stated by
Selinus (2005), necessarily goes through an epidemiologic
study of that specific situation, where the geologic hypotheses will be one among other possibilities, at first.
EPIDEMIOLOGY GOALS
Epidemiology studies have the following goals (Gordis, 1996):
a) Identify the etiology (or cause) and the so-called
risk factors to the investigated disease occurrence, to
define the way it is transmitted or the mode of exposure,
for example;
b) Determine the extent of the disease within the
community;
c) Study the natural history of the disease (e.g.,
whether the appearance of the event is acute, sub-acute
or chronic; the duration of the problem; what is the prognosis concerning cure; chronicity; sequela and death);
d) Study the change in the disease distribution over
time as, for example, changes in the mortality pattern and
in the disease incidence according to gender, age group,
life expectancy, etc.;
– 15 –
Epidemiology and medical geology
e) Assess therapeutic and preventive measures;
f) Based on the results of the studies, create a
framework for public policies and decision making about
regulations related to problems of environmental contaminations, for example.
EPIDEMIOLOGIC APPROACH
Epidemiology studies are usually initiated by describing the situations based on the incidence and prevalence
data available or collected for that purpose.
The incidence of a disease or health event is defined
as the number of new cases over the number of people
exposed to the risk in that particular community (neighborhood, town, state, country, continent, etc.) per time period
(usually a year or during epidemics, a month or a week).
Prevalence relates to the number of cases accumulated during a certain time period, including the incidents
and those that became chronic or were not yet cured. This
is the data concerning morbidity.
Morbidity is a “generic term used to designate the set
of cases of a given infection or the total health incidents
that attain a group of individuals” (Pereira, 2000). The
estimations of morbidity for a given population are based
on different register sources such as health services dossiers; compulsory notification of certain diseases (usually
infecto-contagious); special registers for diseases like
cancer, tuberculosis, AIDS, leprosy; archives from pathologic anatomy laboratories; data on hospitalizations in the
Public Health System – (Sistema Único de Saúde – SUS),
and other sources. The quality of this data is always linked
to the extent of the register’s coverage and to the quality
of the medical assistance that is offered.
Data about mortality is also extremely important and,
depending on the situation, may carry more epidemiological relevance than the morbidity data.
The mortality data is founded on registers of internationally standardized death certificates or declarations
which must report information about: a) the basic cause
of death (that is, the disease or lesion that brought about
the series of pathologic events and resulted directly in
death); b) possible incurred complications; and c) other
significant pathologic states that did not have a direct
relation with the death.
The standardization of death certificate completion
has brought great benefits such as the possibility to compare data at an international level. However, the quality of
the procedure is still a big problem around the world since
it depends on: the local medical assistance level; the
specific training received by doctors; the personal interest
of the doctor; the standardization of medical terms; etc.
Thus, faced with morbidity or mortality data, it is necessary to ask, first of all, whether the data is authentic. In
other words, does it describes a given population health
situation and if it is comparable with other regions (sam-
pling quality, degree of that population health cover, etc.).
Any inference made at the epidemiological study close
dealing with a causal relationship among determined
factors (environmental, occupational, genetic, related to
food habits, etc.) has to refer to the quality of the morbidity
and mortality data.
Regarding the etiology definition of a given health
incident, the investigator must follow two essential steps
in the epidemiological reasoning: 1º) to determine whether
there is an ASSOCIATION between a factor (e.g., a given
environmental exposure) and the health incident and,
2º) in case the association exists, to derive appropriate
inferences about the existence of a causal relationship in
that association following well defined judgment criteria
(see below).
TYPES (DIAGRAMS) OF EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES
Epidemiological studies may be didactically divided
into observational and experimental (Table 1). The observational studies are divided into descriptive, on the one
hand, and analytical, on the other.
Experimental studies in epidemiology are basically
limited to the so-called controlled therapeutic clinical
tests, used to evaluate the effectiveness of new medicines or treatments. In such tests one tries to control
all the variables that interfere in the treatment process,
selecting the patients appropriately, defining criteria for
the diagnosis of the disease, determining exposure doses
and establishing the type of result expected from a new
medicine or treatment compared to the traditional ones
or even to a placebo treatment (medicine without active
ingredients, for example).
Table 1 - Types of epidemiological studies
OBSERVATIONAL
1. Descriptive (describe the situation and generate causal
relationship hypotheses )
• Prevalence / incidence
• Cross sectional studies
• Ecology studies
2. Analytical (investigate the cause)
• Case control studies (retrospective)
• Cohort studies (prospective sequence)
EXPERIMENTAL
1. Controlled therapeutic clinical tests
2. Intervention in the community
WWithin environmental epidemiology, experimental
studies are represented only by the study of the intervention in the community. It is useful when proposing, for
instance, to add a given vitamin supplement or chemical
– 16 –
Eduardo Mello De Capitani
element to the diet or drinking water of certain populations, based on preliminary studies that show a beneficial
effect of that addition (e.g., iodine in the salt, fluorine
in the drinking water, etc.). The experimental studies,
whether clinical with new medicines or of intervention in
the community, must consider and respect several ethic
aspects that are involved in their planning and execution.
Within observational studies, i.e., without experimental intervention, we have two basic types: the descriptive and the analytical. The descriptive studies, as
the name says, describe the situations and generate
hypotheses about possible statistical or epidemiological associations between certain factors and the health
incidents being studied. They investigate the incidence
and the prevalence of the problems being examined
and have, in general, a character of cross section in
time, that is, they study the situation within a narrow
time limit, producing a static portrait of the situation
at that moment. Investigating the factors that may be
related to the health incidents, these studies generate
causal relationship hypotheses from existing associations between the variables. However, they don’t have
the power to establish causal correlations in most of
epidemiological situations.
Inferences of the causal type are easier to make
using an analytical approach. In a study of this kind the
hypothesis in tested about the causal association generated by the descriptive study. To achieve this, three
basic sub-types of studies are available and they are
employed depending on the health incident characteristics being analyzed and on the specific exposure type
and characteristics.
In an analytical observational study such as the case
control type, the researcher starts with the diagnosed
health problem (a specific disease, a symptom, the result of a complementary examination, etc.) and tries to
define which type of factor is causally associated with it
in a retrospective way. The basic scheme of this kind of
study involves the grouping of several individuals with
the same problem (“cases”) that will be compared with
another grouping of individuals with a different kind of
problem (“controls”). In both groups the same factors will
be investigated (variables related to diet, past occupations, hobbies, use of medicines, habits, geographical
origin, ethnic group, etc.). The factor or variable that
predominates significantly in the study group (“cases”)
may be imputed as the probable causal factor, in case
it fulfills most of the epidemiological criteria of causation
established by Hill (1965) that are discussed later.
An analytical study of the cohort type, starts with
the common exposure of a given population group and
looks for the occurrence of the health incident over time,
comparing the incidence of the problem in that group
with a non-exposed population group. This is called a
prospective scheme over time. These studies demand
a lot of work and are very expensive as they imply all
kinds of operational problems related to the necessity of
keeping track of a large number of people during long
periods of time (the time period depends on the type of
health problem, whether it is acute, sub-acute or chronic).
For instance, a given type of cancer study and the environmental exposure to a particular chemical element. As
cancer is a disease of late occurrence, with long latency
periods – 20 to 30 years – gives an idea of the difficulty in
maintaining entire populations under surveillance for 30
or 40 years. This study type is quite powerful in the sense
of establishing the relation of the causal nexus between
exposure and the health incident.
Still, within the observational studies there are
ecological studies that compare data, such as weight,
height, weight at birth, nutritional data, prevalent diseases, specific laboratorial parameters on populations
in different geographical areas, or even comparing this
data in the same population in different moments. This
type of study is very descriptive, generating causal relation hypotheses that have to be tested using other more
appropriate schemes. The difference from the basic
descriptive studies is that it doesn’t collect individual
data. They are very useful in evaluations of the impact
of intervention measures in populations, such as health
programs (Kleinbaum et al., 1982).
CAUSAL ASSOCIATION CRITERIA
Faced with a statistically significant association between a variable (investigated factor) and the disease or
health incident (issue), the decision whether it is causal
or not goes through a series of logical considerations
that must be carefully examined. To make it easier and,
in addition, to standardize this reasoning, Hill has established a list of causation criteria (slightly changed over the
years) that must be fulfilled for an association between the
variables to be considered as of the causal nexus (Hill,
1965; Gordis, 1996). Table 2 exposes these criteria and
their meanings in a didactical way. For specific details
and examples, the reader should consult the references
cited at the end of this text. These criteria remain basically
the same until today, though modified by other authors so
as to make them clearer. The non-fulfillment of all criteria
does not necessarily exclude the possibility of the causal
nexus, but it weakens, more or less, the possible causal
inference in that situation.
This study does not intend to substitute the search for
more profound information in the many existing textbooks
on epidemiology. It only intends to raise the discussion
about the complexity of epidemiology involved in medical geology studies that may be developed in our midst.
In addition to the methodological and logistical aspects
involved in the planning and execution of epidemiological
studies, it must always take into account the ethical prob-
– 17 –
Epidemiology and medical geology
Table 2 - Judgment criteria of the causal association in epidemiological studies
Time relationship
Specificity
▪ the cause must always precede the effect
Strength of the Association
▪ the observed effect must not occur without the exposure to
the presumed cause (if this criterion is not fulfilled, this does not
deny the cause and effect relationship defined by other criteria)
Coherence with today’s knowledge
▪ the greater the relative risk (RR) or the chance rate (OR)
the greater the causal association strength
Relationship of response-dose
▪ the causal association must not conflict with already
established facts
Considerations of Alternative Explanations
▪ the risk of becoming ill must increase with the increase of the
exposure dose (in the same population the group of people
who are most exposed must have the greatest incidence of
health incidents)
Consistency (replication of the findings)
▪ interpretation of a causal association must go through a
discussion of all possible factors involved
Ceasing of the Exposition
▪ the causal relationship observed in this study must be
replicated in other studies
Biological Plausibility
▪ if a factor causes a disease, it is expected that the removal of
this factor will reduce or eliminate the disease occurrence
Analogy
▪ the causal relationship must be based on recognized
biological mechanisms
▪ similarity to other causal association accepted beforehand
lems that any type of study can impose on the involved
populations. Its purpose was not to raise this particular
discussion, but to state that it must be present every time
this kind of study is planned and that it must go through
the evaluation of an ethics committee of the research
institutions involved.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
GORDIS, L. Epidemiology. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders,
1996.
HILL, A.B. The environment and disease: association or
causation? Proc. R. Soc. Med., [S.l], v. 58, p. 295,1965.
KLEINBAUM, D.G.; KUPPER, L.L.; MORGENSTERN, H.
Epidemilogic Research: principles and quantitative methods. New York: John Wiley and Sons,
1982.
NIELSEN, J.B.; JENSEN, T.K. Environmental epidemiology. In: SELINUS, O. (Ed). Essentials of Medical
Geology: impacts of the natural environment on
public health. Amsterdam: Elsevier Academic
Press, 2005. p.529-540.
PEREIRA, M.G. Epidemiologia: teoria e prática. Rio de
Janeiro: Guanabara Koogan, 2001.
SELINUS, O. (Ed). Essentials of Medical Geology: impacts
of the natural environment on public health. Amsterdam: Elsevier Academic Press, 2005.
– 18 –
HEALTH SURVEILLANCE
RELATED TO CHEM ICALS
IN THE AM BIT OF THE
BRAZILIAN UNIFIED
HEALTH SYSTEM (SISTEM A
ÚNICO DE SAÚDE-SUS)
Guilherme Franco Netto, Doctor, Ph.D.
General Coordinator for Environmental Health Surveillance
Secretary for Health Surveillance
Ministry of Health
The Brazilian Federal Constitution promulgated in
1988, The Brazilian Federal Constitution promulgated
in 1988, establishes a set of obligations and rights that
are fundamental to improve the Brazilian population’s
life quality.
The Chapter on Health, established and expanded
in law nº8080, known as the Unified Health System
Law (Sistema Único de Saúde – SUS), determines that
health is a citizen’s right and a duty of the State, based
on principles that ensure the population’s universal
access to health promotion, prevention, treatment and
rehabilitation services.
The complexity of today’s life, in which development
and the application of science and technology on a large
scale coexist with deep social and economical inequity,
reveals multiple new health risks whether in formal or
informal work settings, domestic environments or public
and communitarian surroundings.
In this context, there is a constantly growing human
exposure to chemical substances derived from different sources and activities: products and services that
contain them; laboratories that produce and manipulate
them (mineral extraction, industrial processing and transformation); inappropriate waste disposal; environmental
contamination of water bodies, the atmosphere and soil,
among others.
International initiatives by the United Nations are
demonstrating it is important to treat the chemical security
issue appropriately. Thus, protocols and commitments
such as the International Forum for Chemical Security,
the Ban on Persistent Organic Products, the Preliminary
Report on the Commercialization of Chemical Products,
the International Regulation of Dangerous Waste Transport
and, more recently, the Global Strategy on Chemical Security endeavor to reduce health and environmental risks
by applying control mechanisms to chemical substances
throughout their life cycles.
In Brazil, the National Commission on Chemical
Security (Comissão Nacional de Segurança Química –
CONASQ) presided by the Ministry of the Environment
and where the Ministry of Health is a member, expresses
the concerns and initiatives of the Brazilian government
and society about this issue.
The Ministry of Health is structuring itself and organizing services that will collaborate with the chemical security
strategy. Among these should be highlighted the National
Program for Health Surveillance related to Chemical Substances (Programa Nacional de Vigilância em Saúde
Relacionada a Substâncias Químicas – VIGIQUIM), which
is already in a pilot stage.
VIGIQUIM seeks to detect, acquire knowledge,
map and monitor populations exposed to chemical substances that are known for their harmful effects to health.
At this stage, five contaminants have been elected as
priorities: asbestos; agrochemicals; benzene; lead and
mercury.
– 19 –
Health surveillance related to chemicals in the ambit of the Brazilian uniied health system (Sistema Único de Saúde-SUS)
Another initiative is the National Program for Health
Surveillance in Communities Exposed to Contaminated
Soil (Programa Nacional de Vigilância em Saúde de
Populações Expostas a Áreas com Solos Contaminados – VIGISOLO), which seeks to detect, assess,
map and monitor populations exposed to areas with
contaminated soil. Analyzed data obtained by the
Ministry of Health informs there are at least 689 sites
where health risk evaluation methodologies should
be applied.
The health risk control standards for water contamination by chemicals have been adjusted by Regulation
nº518 from the Ministry of Health. Its implementation
and monitoring is carried out by the National Program
for Health Surveillance related to Water Quality for Human Consumption (Programa Nacional de Vigilância em
Saúde Relacionada à Qualidade da Água para Consumo
Humano – VIGIÁGUA).
With these and other initiatives, the Ministry of Health,
in cooperation with other Ministries, is effectively contributing to the construction of a strong chemical security
agenda in Brazil, directed to ensure that public health
and environmental protection are taken into account in
the economic development.
– 20 –
SURFACE M ULTI-ELEM ENT
GEOCHEM ISTRY FOR RISK
AND ENVIRONM ENTAL
IM PACT ASSESSM ENTS,
PARANÁ STATE BRAZIL
Otávio Augusto B. Licht, otavio@pr.gov.br
State Geological Survey
Minerais do Paraná S.A. - MINEROPAR
INTRODUCTION
A proper environmental diagnosis necessarily
deals with an adequate knowledge of the chemical
characteristics of the physical environment. These
characteristics are identified through surveys based on
collecting samples from different environments, such as
water, soils and bottom sediments within hydrographic
basins. Geochemical maps present the distribution of
the elements and chemical compounds in natural material samples representing the sum effects of natural and
anthropogenic sources. Therefore, they are considered
as basic instruments for multipurpose environmental
assessments, including geo-medicine, medical geology and ecotoxicology. The compilation of geochemical
data produced by mineral exploration projects and the
elaboration of integrated geochemical maps may be a
first approach to reveal health risk regions. However, the
correct use of geochemical maps, when researching
correlations between environmental geochemistry and
endemic diseases, will only be successful if the data
produced is interpreted considering the bioavailability of
the elements and chemical compounds. Weak extraction
methods in active stream sediment samples and ions
determination in a filtered water sample are adequate
for this purpose, as they only identify a fraction of the
total element content liable to be absorbed by the food
chain. The comparison between geochemical maps of
some elements such as samples from water with bottom
sediment samples perfectly demonstrates this concept
as well as the considerable differences between total
chemical species in both environments (Figures 7, 8, 9
and 10). It is necessary to determine the largest possible number of analytical variables (physical-chemical
parameters, ions, elements and oxides) with the lowest
possible detection limits, to constitute a powerful data
base to make maps. Thus, many diverse interpretations
are possible and cause-effect correlations obtained
when the geochemical data is compared with the parameters of: spatial distribution of human and animal
mortality; agricultural fertility; diffused and point sources
of pollution among others. In this way multi and transdisciplinary interpretations may determine potential
areas for prospecting ore and identifying health risk
regions. The association of fluorine with dental fluorosis
occurrence as well as chlorides and bromides as risk
indicators for liver cancer areas are connections already
defined in the Paraná state. More research is necessary
to establish the real threats of some risk areas indicated
by barium, potassium, calcium, aluminum in water and
lead, lanthanum, cadmium and mercury in active stream
sediments and soil.
– 21 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Geo-Graphical Location
Paraná State is located in South Brazil and occupies
an area of 199,575 km² (ITCF, 1987 apud Licht, 2001a). To
the north it is bordered by São Paulo State, to the east by
the Atlantic Ocean, to the south by Santa Catarina State,
to the southwest by the Republic of Argentina, to the west
by the Republic of Paraguay and to the northwest by Mato
Grosso do Sul State (Figure 1). The Curitiba base map
(SG-22-X-D-I, 1:100,000) is situated in the Curitiba City
metropolitan region and includes the northern part of its
urban area in addition to the cities of Rio Branco do Sul,
Almirante Tamandaré, Colombo, Piraquara, Pinhais and
São José dos Pinhais (Figure 2).
THE GEOCHEMICAL DATA BASES
Geochemical surveys have been extensively applied everywhere in the world since the 1930s. They have
been directed to mineral prospection and there have
Figure 1 – Geographical location of Paraná State.
Figure 2 – Borders and main urban agglomerations of Paraná State.
– 22 –
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
been countless successful cases in all regions and environments. In Paraná State, geochemical surveys have
been employed since the 1970s by several private and
state organizations. They have resulted in the discovery
of several occurrences and processes of mineralization
such as the fluorite deposit in Volta Grande and the W-Sn
mineralized greisens of Cantagalo. In 1995, on an initiative
of Minerais do Paraná S.A. – MINEROPAR, the Low Density
Multi-elemental Geochemical Survey of Paraná State was
begun, based on the collection of 696 samples of water
and active stream sediments within hydrographic basins
across the whole 200,000 km² state area. In 2002, the second stage of the survey was carried out with a collection
of 307 samples of B horizons from soils in a regular grid.
The project followed the World Geochemical Map criteria
and standards established by the IGCP-259 and IGCP-360
projects (Darnley, 1995). According to those recommendations, 43 composite samples were produced from the
original ones, each one representing a unit cell of 80 x 80
km of the grid denominated GGRN (Global Geochemical
Reference Network) (Figures 3 and 4).
The geochemical sampling campaign of the Curitiba
Base Map, in its turn, was planned and executed in 1995
together with the Brazilian Geological Survey (Compan-
hia de Pesquisa de Recursos Minerais – CPRM), when
392 samples of active stream sediments were collected,
including the densely urbanized area of Curitiba city and
adjacent towns (Figures 5 and 6).
THE GEOCHEMICAL DATA BANK
Water from watersheds within Paraná State – The
696 original samples were analyzed in the Mineral Analyses Laboratory (LAMIN/CPRM) to determine Al³+, Ba²+, Br-,
Ca²+, Cl-, F-, Fe³+, K+, Mg²+, Mn²+, Na+, NO²-, NO³-, PO4²-,
SO4³-, Sr²+, pH and conductivity (Licht, 2001b).
Bottom sediments from watersheds within Paraná
State – The 696 original samples were analyzed in the
LAMIN/CPRM to determine Co, Cu, Cr, Fe, Li, Mn, Mo,
Ni, Pb, V, Zn (Licht, 2001b). The 43 GGRN samples were
analyzed in the Institute of Geophysical and Geochemical Exploration – IGGE laboratory, situated in Lanfang,
China, to determine Ag, Al2O3, As, Au, B, Ba, Be, Bi, Br,
CaO, Cd, Ce, Cl, Co, Cr, Cs, Cu, Dy, Er, Eu, F, Fe2O3, Ga,
Gd, Ge, Hg, Ho, I, K2O, La, Li, Lu, MgO, Mn, Mo, Na2O,
Nb, Nd, Ni, P, Pb, Pd, Pr, Pt, Rb, S, Sb, Sc, Se, SiO2, Sm,
Sn, Sr, Tb, Te, Th, Ti, Tl, Tm, U, V, W, Y, Yb, Zn, Zr, with
analytical detection limits lower than the respective Clarke
(Licht, 2001a).
Figure 3 – The GGRN unit cells in the Paraná State, the watershed
and the stream sediment collection sites (Licht, 2001).
Figure 4 – The GGRN unit cells in the Paraná State and the
soil – horizon B collection sites (Licht and Plawiak, 2005).
Figure 5 – Main urban concentrations and road network of the
Curitiba base map (SG-22-X-D-I).
– 23 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Figure 7 – Geochemical surface of F- in 696 water samples from
watersheds .
Figure 6 – Hydrographic network (blue) and the 392 watersheds
(red) of the Curitiba base map (SG-22-X-D-I).
B-horizon from soils of the Paraná State – The GGRN
samples were analyzed in the IGGE to determine Ag, Al2O3,
As, Au, B, Ba, Be, Bi, Br, CaO, Cd, Ce, Cl, Co, Corganic, Cr, Cs,
Ctotal, Cu, Dy, Er, Eu, F, Fe2O3, Ga, Gd, Ge, Hf, Hg, Ho, I, In,
K2O, La, Li, Lu, MgO, Mn, Mo, N, Na2O, Nb, Nd, Ni, P, Pb,
Pd, Pr, Pt, Rb, S, Sb, Sc, Se, SiO2, Sm, Sn, Sr, Ta, Tb, Th, Ti,
Tl, Tm, U, V, W, Y, Yb, Zn, Zr, with analytical detection limits
lower than the respective Clarke. In addition, to determine
U, K, Th and total counting through gamaespectrometry
and magnetic susceptibility was carried out by the Applied
Geophysics (LPGA) Laboratory of the Paraná Federal University (Universidade Federal do Paraná – UFPR). Finally,
the agricultural chemistry parameters were determined in
the Laboratory for Soil and Vegetal Tissues of the State Agronomic Institute (Instituto Agronômico do Paraná – IAPAR).
These parameters were: pH, Alchangeable, Caassimilable, Mgassimilable,
Passimilable, Kassimilable, C, H+ + Al³+ , Cuextractible, Znextractible, Feextract, Mnextractible, Sextractible, Bextractible, Al%, V% (bases saturation),
ible
T (sum of the positive changeable charges) and S (sum of
the changeable bases) (Licht & Plawiak, 2005).
Bottom sediments from watersheds of the Curitiba
base map – The 392 samples were analyzed in the LAMIN/
CPRM and in a commercial laboratory, with determination of
Hg, Nb, F, Zr with strong extractions and P, Cr, Li, W, As, V,
Sc, Ni, K, Sr, La, Mg, Mn, Na, Y, Co, Pb, Cu, Ca, Zn, Al, Ba
and Fe with weak extractions (Licht, 2001c).
– 24 –
Figure 8 – Geochemical surface of F in 39 GGRN samples
(composed of 698 samples of active stream sediments).
Figure 9 – Geochemical surface of Ba²+ in 696 water
samples of watersheds.
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
RESULTS OBTAINED
Figure 10 – Geochemical surface of Ba 39 samples GGRN
(composed of 698 samples of active stream sediments).
Evaluations made so far with the geochemical data
base produced by the previously described survey associated with sanitary and epidemiological data, revealed
a clear scenario of the cause-effect relationships in some
regions bearing health risk potential. A special reference
should be made of fluorides in the water and the prevalence of dental fluorosis, as well as chlorides and bromides as risk area indicators considering the prevalence
and increased mortality rate by hepatic neoplasias. To
better spatially define the risk area to start epidemiological studies as in the case of mercury in stream sediments
and soils, other results are being analyzed. There is other
data still awaiting more detailed analysis, for example,
lanthanum, mercury and lead in the Curitiba region.
Table 1 - Prevalence and severity of dental fluorosis in school children in the São Joaquim do
Pontal borough of Itambaracá, Paraná.
N = 135 patients (Morita et al, 1998)
Normal
Uncertain
Very mild
Mild
N = 1129 patients (Cardoso et al, 2001)
Moderate
Normal
Uncertain
Very mild
Mild
Moderate
Severe
52
5
31
38
9
410
30
478
165
41
5
38.52%
3.7%
22.96%
28.15%
6.67%
36.3%
2.7%
42.3%
14.6%
3.6%
0.4%
Figure 11 – Geochemical map of F- (mg/L) in water samples from watersheds. The fluorine-anomalous area situated
in the north of the state is the cause of the high incidence of dental fluorosis in children.
– 25 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Fluorides and dental fluorosis – this is a concrete
example of the cause-effect relationships between geology and human health. Its confirmation was based on
two epidemiological investigations carried out in the
fluorine-anomalous region, previously delimited by the
geochemical survey (Table 1).
The anomaly of about 10,000 km², situated in the north
of Paraná State (Figure 11) includes 47 cities and a population of about 700,000 inhabitants. It is a region where the
water for human consumption is taken from deep tubular
wells which has high fluoride content, reaching 2.2 mg/L
F- and causing serious sanitary problems with endemic
characteristics (Figure 12). Surface water from local drainages also present high fluoride content, identified by the
Geochemical Survey, reaching 0.9 mg/L F-.
Bromides, chlorides and hepatic neoplasias – The
Paraná State northern region is a traditional coffee beans
and cotton growing area (Figures 13 and 14). For a long
time, until its ban, chlorinated and bromated pesticides
were freely used in the control of crop pests building an
environmental passive of unknown dimensions. Marzochi
et al. (1976) had already identified not only the prevalence
but also the high mortality rate due to hepatic neoplasias
(liver cancer) in that region. They related this health prob-
lem to the use of agrochemicals, especially those with
chlorine and bromide.
The Geochemical Survey identified the existence of an
increase in background concentrations of bromides and
chlorides in river basin surface waters (Figures 15 and 16).
Based on these results and on the Ministry of Health
Mortality Data Bank – DATASUS, Licht (2001a) the spatial
Figure 12 – The teeth of the superior dental arcade are corroded by
the continual intake of water with high doses of fluorides.
Figure 13 – Area (in hectares) planted with cotton in the 1995 harvest.
– 26 –
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
Figure 14 - Area (in hectares) planted with coffee beans in the 1995 harvest.
Figure 15 – Map of the distribution of Clˉ (mg/L) in the waters of 696 watersheeds.
– 27 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Figure 16 – Map of the distribution of Br- (mg/L) in the water of 696 watersheds.
relationship was established between the mortality rates,
crop types and geochemical anomalies, considering chlorides and bromides in the surface water as a geochemical
indicator for that sanitary problem.
The prevalence of hepatic neoplasias as well as
the increase in mortality rates is indeed associated with
the use of chlorinated and bromated agrochemicals accumulated for decades in the areas of coffee and cotton
plantations building geochemical anomalies of Cl- and Br
(Figures 17, 18 and 19).
The mortality rates due to hepatic neoplasias in Brazil
increase from the northern region (2.14/100,000) towards
the south (3.64/100,000) (Figure 20), following the tradition and intensity of the agricultural activity. Mortality rates
in the ten cities of Paraná with the highest values (from
7.47/100,000 to 9.29/100,000) (Figure 21) can be twice
to three times higher than those of the southern region of
Brazil as a whole (Figure 20).
The ten cities with the highest mortality rates are included in the large chlorides and bromides anomalous spot.
is why they are used in medicine as a contrast medium for
X-Rays. Barium compounds that are very soluble in water,
however, may aggravate human health, since this element
is highly toxic in its ionic form (Koljonen et al., 1992 apud
Licht & Plawiak, 2005). High levels of Ba intake can cause
problems like high blood pressure, breathing difficulties,
changes in the cardiac rhythm, stomach soreness, muscular flaccidity and damage to the heart, liver, kidney and
other organs (ATSDR, 1999 apud Licht & Plawiak, 2005).
Barium – Barium does not have a known biological
function (Winter, 1998 apud Licht & Plawiak, 2005). The
insoluble compounds are not dangerous to health and that
– 28 –
Figure 17 – Mortality rates due to hepatic neoplasias (1980-1997
period) related to Cl- (mg/L) in the water of 696 watersheds.
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
Data obtained by the Low Density Regional Survey
with water samples from 696 watersheds (Figure 22),
showed a large positive anomaly, in the northwest of
Paraná State, coincident with areas of cretaceous sedimentary rock outcrops of the Bauru and Caiuá groups.
These siltites, sandstones and conglomeratic sandstones
were deposited in a desert environment, in close association with chemical sediments justifying the existence
of the hydrogeochemical anomaly with contents up to
0.3 mg/L Ba²+. The public water supply, in this region,
is mainly provided by tubular wells with water entrance
levels situated at this sedimentary sequence. The Maximum Permitted Value (VMP) established in the Ministry
of Health Regulation nº 518 is 0.7 mg/L Ba²+, but in some
of these wells the Ba²+ concentration of the 30 m deep
groundwater fluxes reached 1.3 mg/L. The Paraná State
Sanitation Company (SANEPAR) solved the problem by
sealing undesired groundwater entrances at specific
depths and admitting groundwater influxes from shallow
aquifers (SANEPAR, personal communication, 2005).
Figure 18 – Mortality rates due to hepatic neoplasias (1980-1997
period) related to Br- (mg/L) in the water of 696 watersheds.
Arsenic - Concentrations higher than 10 µg/L As in
drinking water are considered to be a human and animal
health risk factor. Several endemic affections have been
reported in regions with high arsenic contents, especially
skin and mucous membrane lesions, hyperpigmentation, keratosis, skin and lung cancer, peripheral vascular
disorders and damage to the respiratory, circulatory and
central nervous systems (Varsányi et al., 1991 apud Licht
& Plawiak, 2005). Contrary to mercury, the inorganic compounds of As are more toxic that the organic. Many studies have shown that As in its inorganic form can increase
the risks of skin, lung, bladder, liver, kidney and prostate
cancer (ATSDR, 1999 apud Licht & Plawiak, 2005).
The geochemical map of As around Curitiba (Figure
23) identifies a regional anomaly of SW-NE orientation coincident with the transcurrent fault system of the Lancinha
Fault, as well as the flanks of the Setuva antiform. The
groundwater tapped from tubular wells by the Paraná
State Sanitation Company from karst aquifer have As concentrations below the VMP of 0.01 mg/L As (SANEPAR,
personal communication, 2005).
The geochemical map of As around Curitiba (Figure
23) identifies a regional anomaly of SW-NE orientation coincident with the transcurrent fault system of the Lancinha
Fault, as well as the flanks of the Setuva antiform. The
groundwater tapped from tubular wells by the Sanitation
Company of the Paraná state from karst aquifer have As
concentrations below the VMP of 0.01 mg/L As (SANEPAR, personal communication, 2005).
Figure 19 – Mortality rates due to hepatic neoplasias (1980-1997
period) related to the area planted with cotton in the 1995 harvest.
Figure 20 – The five regions of Brazil with their respective mortality
rates due to hepatic neoplasias. Deaths average/100,000 between
1980-1997.
Mercury The toxicity of mercury is especially known
in the vapor form and for its organic compounds. The
methyl-mercury is produced by bacterial activity on metallic mercury mainly in reducing conditions.
– 29 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Figure 21 – The ten cities in Paraná with the highest (in red) and lowest (in blue) mortality rates due to cancer.
Average deaths/100,000 between 1980-1997.
Figure 22 – Geochemical map of Ba (mg/L) in the water from 696 watersheds in Paraná. The great positive anomaly
in the northwest coincides with the sandstones of the Bauru and Caiuá Groups.
– 30 –
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
Figure 23 – Geochemical map of As (ppm) in the Curitiba base map. The large positive anomaly with SW-NE orientation is related to the Zone
of the Lancinha Fault and Setuva Antiform.
Figure 24 – Geochemical map of Hg (mg/Kg) in the GGRN unit cells (composed of 696 samples of active stream sediments).
– 31 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Figure 25 – Geochemical map of Hg (mg/Kg) in the GGRN unit cells (composed of 307 samples of soil – horizon B).
The maps of mercury distribution in active stream
sediments (Figure 24) as well as in soils (Figure 25) in the
northeast of the Paraná State show great regional anomalies. The anomaly situated in the Ribeira valley (Figure
25) in the northeast region of the state is related to the
mineralization of Pb-Zn-Ba with contents reaching 14,000
ppb Hg (Daitx, E.C. personal communication, 2005). The
anomalies situated in the central portion of the state might
be related to Hg concentrations in sedimentary rocks
rich in organic matter and coal which might have been
mobilized by thermal waters. Its migration would occur
along deep fractures up to the surface where it would be
deposited due to the abrupt temperature drop (Plawiak
et al., 2005). Even if this Hg low content migration occurs,
expressed in the range between 40 and 80 ppb, there will
be transport of the metal through the surface water and
deposition in water bodies such as dam lakes. Thus, these
anomalies configure health risk areas, being evident targets for epidemiological and toxicological investigations.
The eastern Paraná coastal region deserves investigations of this nature too because of its history. Paraná
was occupied by European colonizers as early as the 16th
century, when from the village of Cananéia in the São Paulo
State, an expedition was sent by Martim Afonso de Souza
searching for alluvial gold (Carneiro, 1962; Martins, 1969
apud Licht & Plawiak, 2005). The first gold mines were in
this environmentally fragile region where frequently mercury
was used for gold retrieval with a consequent built up of
an environmental passive in soil and bottom sediments of
the Antonina and Paranaguá bays. The anomaly coincident
with the Curitiba urban region, for instance, may result from
the impacts of several activities, from dentists’ clinics to
mercury vapor lamps for public lighting (Figure 26).
Lead - The industrial sources of lead are mainly related to batteries and energy accumulators (50–70% of
the total consumption), electrical cables coating (3–4%),
pipes and bars, alloys, paint pigment (red and white)
and anti-radiation shields. Its use as an anti-detonation
additive (5%) in gasoline is quickly declining due to its
environmental impact (Koljonen et al., 1992 apud Licht
& Plawiak, 2005). In spite of its virtual elimination as an
anti-detonation agent in fuel (gasoline and diesel oil) the
impacts of the use of this form of lead are evident in the
map constructed with the data of Pbchangeable in the
bottom sediments of some watersheds of the Curitiba
base map (Figure 27). A general increase of the bottom
contents with strong positive anomalies, coincides with
the urban concentrations as well as with the outline of
the main roads which support a large volume of vehicles.
– 32 –
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
Figure 26 – Geochemical map of Hg (ppb) in the Curitiba base map. The anomaly situated in the center-south
portion coincides with the densely urbanized area.
Figure 27 – Geochemical map of Pbchangeable (ppm) in the Curitiba base map. The anomaly situated
in the center-south portion coincides with the densely urbanized area.
– 33 –
Surface Multi-Element Geochemistry for risk and environmental impact assessments Paraná State Brazil
Calcium – The region situated to the northwest of
Curitiba, encompassing the cities of Almirante Tamandaré, Rio Branco do Sul and Colombo. It is an area of
traditional calcitic and dolomitic limestone exploration
used in the making of cement, quicklime and lime for
agriculture. The activity of a large number of mining and
transformation companies of these raw materials generate an environmental impact in the form of suspension
dust that, through the prevailing winds, is disseminated
and deposited throughout a large area. The geochemical
map of Cachangeable in the Curitiba Basic Map (Figure
28) delimits with great accuracy the outline of road PR092, known as the Road of Ores (Rodovia dos minérios),
where calcareous rock mining and processing activities
are concentrated. The risks for human health, however,
are more linked to the inhaling of solid particulates in
suspension, especially near the triturating and grinding
stations, than through geochemical impacts.
Lanthanum – Lanthanum doesn’t have a known function
in the animal aLanthanum doesn’t have a known function in
animal and vegetal physiology. However, all La compounds
must be treated as highly toxic since lanthanum salts can be
aggressive and damage the liver funtion (Winter, 1998 apud
Licht & Plawiak, 2005). In the tertiary sediments of the Guabi-
rotuba Formation, in the Curitiba Basin, there are occurrences
of the double carbonate of La and Nd (Nd-lanthanite) that
were deposited under supergenic conditions in the form of
cement and veins in arkosic sandstone horizons and lenses
(Licht, 2001a). Up to this moment epidemiological investigations related to La are not known, although the anomalous
area (Figure 29) is situated near the Curitiba urban area with
a dense human occupation.
CONCLUSIONS
Geochemical cartography has proved its usefulness
as a territorial diagnosis and characterization instrument.
Geochemical surveys with low density sampling are useful
to support larger structures that, at another opportunity,
could be a more detailed investigation seeking to obtain
more knowledge about its characteristics as well as its
origin and possible reflections on the trophic chain. Traditional techniques of geochemical exploration, followed
by multi-elemental analyses with low limits of analytical
detection are imperative for the success of this kind of
research. The results obtained with surface geochemical
surveys are essential tools to determine the health risk
areas, needing multidisciplinary teams for trustworthy
interpretations.
Figure 28 – Geochemical map of Cachangeable in the Curitiba base map. The large anomaly in the northwest
portion coincides with the limestone exploration and lime and cement production areas.
– 34 –
Otávio Augusto B. Licht
Figure 29 – Geochemical map of La in the Curitiba Basic Map. The grayish spot in the center-south portion
represents the densely urbanized region.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author wishes to thank the president of
MINEROPAR, Dr. Eduardo Salamuni and the Technical Director Rogério da Silva Felipe for authorizing the
publication of the company’s data; the Paraná Sanitation
Company – SANEPAR for the supply of chemical data
on water springs and tubular wells completed by the
company and also the authorization to publish them; Dr.
João Bosco Strozzi – Paraná Catholic University (Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Paraná), Dr. Luiz Antônio
Negrão Dias – Hospital Erasto Gaertner and the League
of Women Against Cancer (Liga Paranaense de Combate
ao Câncer) and Dr. Maria Celeste Morita – Department of
Odontology of the State University of Londrina.
REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS
CARDOSO L. MORITA, M.C., LICHT, O.A.B., ALVES, J.C.
Anomalia hidrogeoquímica e a ocorrência de fluorose dentária em Itambaracá - PR. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE GEOQUÍMICA, 8., 2001, Curitiba;
SIMPÓSIO DE GEOQUÍMICA DOS PAÍSES DO MERCOSUL, 1., 2001, Curitiba. Anais. Curitiba: SBGq,
2001. 1 CD-ROM.
CARNEIRO, D. Formas estruturais da economia do
Paraná. Curitiba: Ed. da UFPR, 1962. DARNLEY, A.
et al. Global geochemical database for environmental and resource management: recommendations for
international geochemical mapping: final report of
IGCP Project 259. Paris : UNESCO, 1995.
LICHT, O. A. B. A Geoquímica multielementar na gestão
ambiental: identificação e caracterização de províncias geoquímicas naturais, alterações antrópicas da
paisagem, áreas favoráveis à prospecção mineral e
regiões de risco para a saúde no Estado do Paraná,
Brasil. Curitiba, 2001. 236 p. Tese (Ddoutorado em
Geologia Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia, Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
LICHT, O. A. B. 2001 b . Atlas geoquímico do Estado do
Paraná. Curitiba : MINEROPAR, 2001. Escalas variam.
LICHT, O. A. B. Atlas geoquímico da Folha Curitiba. Curitiba: MINEROPAR, 2001.
LICHT, O.A.B.; PLAWIAK R.A.B. Projeto Geoquímica
de Solos, Horizonte B: levantamento geoquímico
multielementar do Estado do Paraná: relatório final.
Curitiba: MINEROPAR, 2005. 2 v.
MARZOCHI, M.C.A.; COELHO, R.B.; SOARES, D.A.; ZEITUNE, J.M.R.; MUARREK, F.J.; CECCHINI, R.; PASSOS, E.M. Carcinogênese hepática no norte do Paraná
e uso indiscriminado de defensivos agrícolas. Ciência
e Cultura, São Paulo, v. 28, n. 8, p. 893-901, 1976.
MORITA M.C; CARRILHO, A.; LICHT, O.A.B. Use of geochemistry data in the identification of endemic fluorosis areas. In: WORLD CONGRESS OF HEALTH IN
URBAN ENVIRONMENT, 1., 1998, Madrid. Proceedings.
Madrid: [s.n.], 1998.
PLAWIAK R.A.B.; LICHT, O.A.B.; VASCONCELLOS, E.M.G.
2005. Mercury: natural occurrences in the State of
Paraná, Brazil. In: WORKSHP INTERNACIONAL DE
GEOLOGIA MÉDICA, 2005, Rio de Janeiro. [Trabalhos
apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro: CPRM, 2005.
– 35 –
GEOCHEM ISTRY
OF BRAZILIAN SOILS:
PRESENT SITUATION
¹Daniel Vidal Pérez, daniel@cnps.embrapa.br
¹Celso Vainer Manzatto, manzatto@cnps.embrapa.br
²Sarai de Alcântara, sarai@iq.ufrj.br
³Maria Angélica Vergara Wasserman, angelica@ird.gov.br
¹Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation , Soil Unit - EMBRAPA/RJ
²Chemistry Institute - UFRJ
³Institute for Radioprotection and Dosimetry - CNEN/RJ
S = f (Cl, O, R, M.O., T)
ABSTRACT
Geochemical soil analysis is largely used to identify
areas with high and low concentrations of trace-elements.
It is also an excellent criterion to assess a given metal’s
accumulation in the soil, to guide studies on potential
occurrences of nutritional (in plants and animals), human
health and environmental problems.
The chemical composition data of Brazilian soils is
scarce and concentrated in a few regions of the country,
particularly São Paulo, and only for a couple of elements,
usually micro-nutrients.
This study presents an up-to-date panorama of soil
geochemistry research in Brazil and suggests improvement initiatives to establish reference trace-metal values
important to human health.
INTRODUCTION
Pedology (the study of soil) evolved to the state of
science in 1883 when the Russian scientist Dokuchaev
realized the soil is, in fact, a natural and dynamic body,
result of differentiated and organized entities and not
merely a heap of mineral particles with organic matter
on its surface (Moniz, et al.,1972). Hans Jenny in his
book “Factors of Soil Formation” (1941), based on the
ideas of soil genesis, until then diffusely presented,
offered for the first time an equation to mathematically
express the relationship between the properties and
variables of soil:
Thus, it is understood that any property of the soil
(S) is a function of the climate (Cl), living organisms (O),
relief (R), source material (M.O.) and time (T). It must be
pointed out that McBratney et al. (2003) also included the
question of spatialization as a key factor in digital mapping
issues, as examined later.
In this sense, geology, through source material studies by petrology and geochemistry, had a strong influence
on the research at that time, since the development of genesis studies and soil classification was largely dependent
on the stage of the basic correlated sciences (Moniz, et
al., 1972). Considering that the American School is one
of the world’s most influential in geology and soil studies,
its development will receive a greater emphasis.
Shacklette & Boerngen (1984) reported the United
States have used soil analysis in mineral prospection
since the 1940s. However, there were serious hindrances
to trace-element analyses due to the lack of equipment
with better detection limits. This situation changed in
the 1960s with the introduction of the first commercial
atomic spectroscopy equipment. Nevertheless, only in
the 1970s a substantial improvement occurred in traceelement detection limits following a series of new instrumentation developments of atomic absorption/emission
spectrophotometers (Cienfuegos & Vaitsman, 2000).
Then also the first studies were produced to establish
a relationship between human health problems and the
geographical distribution of metals in the soil (Shacklette
– 36 –
& Boerngen, 1984). The development of new research
confirmed that source material was the primary origin of
trace-elements in the soil (Alloway, 1995; Kabata-Pendias
& Pendias, 2001). In that view, one would expect basic
rock originated soils to have higher contents of Zn, Cu,
Ni, Mn and others, than those originated from granites,
gneisses, limestones and sandstones. However, several
works, especially Chen et al. (1993), have indicated that
besides the source material, other pedogenetic factors
exert a fundamental role in trace-element distribution in
soil. In the last 20 years, the focus of geochemical soil
analysis has been to establish reference values for toxic
metals to introduce legislation that regulates the use of
soil in relation to domestic/industrial waste and agriculture
(USEPA 40 CFR Part 503 and Council Directive 86/278/
EEC). It should be noted most European countries have
established maximum permissible main toxic element
(Cd, Zn, Cu, Cr, Hg, Ni and Pb) limits in soils (Table 1).
Countries such as Spain, Portugal and the United Kingdom have even established variable values according to
the soil pH. However, only a few countries followed the
USA example to maintain a long established routine of
soil analyses to form a data bank. This is able to indicate,
more precisely, the mean trace-metal values in “natural”
soils and man- changed soils (Shacklette & Boerngen,
1984; Holmgren et al., 1993; Burt et al., 2000; Burt et
al., 2003). The limit values established, though, are still
arbitrary, usually based on 95%.
In Brazil, like the United States, most geochemical
soil studies initially followed the international tendency
to give mineral prospection support and to understand
soil genesis (Melfi & Pedro, 1977; Melfi & Pedro, 1978).
With improved analytical techniques, new studies were
directed towards correlating trace-element amounts with
soil formation and classification (Araujo, 1994; Horbe,
1995; Ker, 1995; Oliveira, 1996; Castro, 1998; Lacerda,
1999). Following these initiatives, Ker (1995) and Lacerda
(1998), for example, cite several authors who indicate
certain iron oxides in the soil are important trace-element
sources, particularly, Zn, Cu, Co and Ni. Specific Brazilian
soil characterization studies of various metal concentrations (micronutrients, toxic or trace) have not been well
developed and most, initially, were concentrated in São
Paulo State (Valadares, 1975; Valadares & Catani, 1975;
Furlani et al., 1977; Valadares & Camargo, 1983). Based
on that same international concern, some Brazilian groups
began searching for background values of several elements in national soils. Pérez et al. (1997) analyzed 30
samples (A horizon and B diagnostic) of 15 Brazilian soil
profiles for several elements (Co, Cr, Cu, Mo, Pb, Zn,
Mn, Fe, Cd, Sr, Zr, Ba, Rb, U, Th, La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu,
Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb, Lu). Besides developing a
pedogenetic field thesis Marques (2000) also produced
new data on a series of trace-elements in soils in Minas
Gerais State. However, Cetesb (2001) defined soil quality
reference values on the base of specific sampling, following Dutch methodology. From 13 different representative
soil profiles of São Paulo, 84 composite samples were
collected, representing the 0-20 and 80-100cm depth
levels. The following elements were analyzed: aluminum,
antimony, arsenic, barium, cadmium, lead, cobalt, copper, chromium, iron, manganese, mercury, molybdenum,
nickel, silver, selenium, vanadium, zinc. Finally, Fadigas et
al. (2002), analyzing a set of 256 Brazilian soil samples,
separated in seven groups based on their soil properties
similarities, determined reference values for Cd, Co, Cr,
Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn.
OBTAINING REFERENCE OR BACKGROUND VALUES
If tIf there is no knowledge of what can be considered
the “natural” level of a given element in the soil, how can
it be determined if it was anthropogenically contaminated, for instance, or if it had a considerable chemical
deficiency that may affect the nutrition of living beings?
The national data base, as mentioned above, is
concentrated on certain elements and limited to São
Paulo State. Moreover, the soil sampling, preparation
and extraction methodologies are usually different and
not correlatable. However there are ways of planning the
sampling to obtain mathematical functions that, through
correlation with other soil properties (Pedotransfer), facilitate data prediction in unsampled regions. Fadigas et al.
(2002), for example, suggested a model to estimate the
Table 1 – European limits of heavy metal concentration (mg/kg) in soils.
EU Directive 86/2781
Cd
Cr
Cu
Hg
Ni
Pb
Zn
1-3
----
50-140
1-1.5
30-75
50-300
150-300
France²
2
150
100
1
50
100
300
Germany²
1.5
100
60
1
50
100
200
Italy²
1.5
----
100
1
75
100
300
Netherlands²
0.8
100
36
0.3
35
85
140
Sweden²
0.4
60
40
0.3
30
40
100-150
1.Long (2001); 2. Europe (2005)
– 37 –
“natural” contents of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn based
on silt, clay, Mn, Fe contents and CEC. Data spatialization, as part of digital mapping procedures, contributes
considerably to the pedotransfer validating process and
reorientation of new sampling campaigns. According to
(McBratney et al., 2003) few of the mentioned studies are
considering these methodologies.
With respect to the analytical methods, extraction and
analysis provided “Totals” produce little useful information
since the chemical element’s ecotoxicological effects and
environmental behavior (transport, reactivity, mobility, etc.)
totally depend on its chemical form (Allen, 1993; Tack &
Verloo, 1995; Hani, 1996; Quevauviller, 1998; Kot & Namiesnik, 2000; Abreu et al., 2001). Methods considered
“Pseudo-Total” allow the anthropogenic influence to be
determined and therefore can be used for environmental
monitoring (Alloway, 1995; Walter & Cuevas, 1999; Scancar et al., 2000). However, if no standard analytical methodology is chosen, the data bank consolidation question
returns, since most methodologies do not have the same
extraction capability (Mattiazo et al., 2001). Likewise, there
are methods that assess a given element’s transference
potential to a plant (“available”). In that case, however,
care must be taken not to use internationally recognized
methods that have not been developed for our conditions and therefore do not allow proper interpretations.
An example is shown in Figure 1, taken from Wasserman
(1977), which presents Cs transfer factors from the soil to
the plant (absorption similar to K) in some Brazilian soils
and based on international data. The important difference
found is a result of physical-chemical processes that typi-
cally occur in tropical soils and that have little influence
in Northern Hemisphere soils. In Brazil, the most usual
extraction methods for “available” micronutrients as well
as “available” toxic metals, are DTPA and Mehlich 1 solutions (Cantarella et al., 2001; Mattiazo et al., 2001). Some
research aimed at using this type of result to determine
reference values for certain toxic elements in soils is being
developed. Finally, there are other studies based on the
complexity of possible soil reactions that use sequential
extractions to identify where a given element is located
(Ure, 1991; Das et al., 1995; Hayes & Traina, 1998). Most
environmental studies that involve this technique generally
consider the following stages (McLean & Bledsoe, 1992;
Das et al., 1995; Morrow et al., 1996):
▪ soluble in water
▪ changeable
▪ linked to carbonates
▪ linked to Fe/Mn oxi-hydroxide
▪ linked to organic matter
▪ residual
There are several extraction technique problems
(Ross, 1994; Hayes & Traina, 1998; Kot & Namiesnik,
2000): i) the lack of extractor selectivity; ii) element readsorption and redistribution during the extraction process; iii) the soil-extraction solution relationship influence
on the analyzed element distribution; iv) the mineral and
organic compounds solubility change during the extraction progress. Even though, as it allows the comparison of
chemically similar fractions, sequential extraction is pre-
Figure 1 – Transference factors of Cs137 to radish, carrot, soybean, black bean and cassava crops in some Brazilian soils compared to international data generated in temperate climate (IUR).
– 38 –
ferred in soil solid phase speciation studies to determine
the mobility potential and environmental bioavailability of
several metals and radionuclides (Candelaria & Chang,
1997; Dean et al., 1998, Quevauviller, 1998; Wasserman
et al., 2002). Figure 2, extracted from Mavropoulos et al.
(2005), illustrates this case. Note, although the Pb total
content remains unchanged in both soils (7.0g/kg), there
was an element differential migration to distinct phases,
representing a different mobility risk potential and bioavailability.
Figure 3 – Availability of several elements related to the soil pH
(Nascimento, 1995).
Figure 2 – Participation percentage of Pb obtained from two soils
(RJ in an yellow-red Argisoil, LV is a red Latosoil) contaminated with
7.0g/kg and submitted to three remediation treatments (T1, T2, T3)
in the six extractible phases in water (H2O), changeable (Chang.), in
carbonates (Carb), in Fe and Mn oxides (FeMn), in organic matter
(MO) and residual (Res). TO is the control sample.
sufficient amounts for its nutrition, although often no visual
deficiency symptom is perceived (“hidden hunger”). However, this nutritional shortage may affect the animals and
humans that depend on the plant for their nourishment
(Welch & Graham, 2005)..
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS
EXCESS X DEFICIENCY
The main purpose to establish soil reference values
has always been linked to concerns regarding its contamination. However, due to the development of high-tech
agriculture there is a strong tendency of certain micronutrients deficiencies because of the soil’s low restoration
ability, the low use of agrochemicals based on these
elements and the low effectiveness of micronutrients in
fertilizers (Yamada & Lopes, 1998; White & Zasoski, 1999;
Welch & Graham, 2005). In Brazil, for instance, there is
ample literature indicating the natural deficiency of Zn
and Cu in our soils (Abreu et al., 2001). Furthermore,
the misuse of certain agricultural practices, especially
soil liming (soil pH correction with limestone), can lead
to the unavailability of otherwise naturally available micronutrients in soils, such as Fe and Mn (Figure 3). So,
confirming previous observations, it is more important to
know the conditions of the soil in which an element occurs than knowing its total content as a way of predicting
its availability.
It is important to note, in cases of metal pollution of
soil, plants have “defense” mechanisms that guarantee
the low transference of these elements to the various
vegetal organs, in particular those situated in the aerial
parts (Shaw, 1989). However, if there is a given micronutrient deficit in the soil, the plant will hardly absorb it in
Having recognized the need to establish trace-metal
reference values, be they micronutrients or potentially toxic, it is fundamental to standardize the sampling, sample
preparation and soil analysis methodologies based on
a national work commission. However, because of the
large area to be covered, it is evident that studies have
to be carried out at a regional level, with a view to build
a national geo-spatialized data bank. Efforts are being
made in some states to research regional reference values
but most of them collide with the lack of funds. Thus, it is
extremely important to raise awareness among decision
makers (the competent authorities), to enable state and
federal Science & Technology development agencies to
create specific research funds to subsidize this kind of
study.
Finally, for those who intend to make a profound study
of the implications of soil in human health, there are some
international references that merit examination, namely:
Oliver (1997); Dissanayake & Chandrajith (1999); Abrahams (2002); Deckers & Steinnes (2004).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
To CNPq for conceding the productivity grant to the
first author and to CNPq, FUJB and FAPERJ for their
financial support and to the research carried out by the
– 39 –
authors. To Dr. Neli do Amaral Meneguelli and Dr. Maria
de Lourdes Mendonça for the technical proofreading.
To the librarian Maria da Penha Delaia for her untiring
effort to obtain most of the bibliographic material used
in this study.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ABRAHAMS, P.W. Soils: their implications to human health
The Science of the Total Environment, Amsterdam,
v. 291, n. 1, p.1-32, maio 2002.
ABREU, C.A. de; FERREIRA, M.E.; BORKERT, C.M. 2001.
Disponibilidade e avaliação de elementos catiônicos: zinco e cobre. In: FERREIRA, M.E.; CRUZ, M.C.P.
da; van RAIJ, B.; ABREU, C.A. De. Micronutrientes
e elementos tóxicos na agricultura. Jaboticabal:
CNPq; FAPESP; POTAFOS, 2001. p.125-150.
ALLEN, H.E. The significance of trace metal speciation
for water, sediment and soil quality criteria and
standards. The Science of the Total Environment,
Amsterdam, Supplement Part 1, p.23-45, 1993.
ALLOWAY, B.J. Heavy metals in soils. 2nd ed. Glasgow,
UK: Blackie, 1995. 368p.
ARAUJO, E.S. Geoquímica multielementar de crostas
e solos lateríticos da amazônia oriental. 1994. 278
p.Tese (Doutorado)-Universidade Federal do Pará,
Belém, 1994.
BURT, R.; WILSON, M.A.; MAYS, M.D.; KECK, T.J.; FILLMORE, M.; RODMAN, A.W.; ALEXANDER, E.B.;
HERNANDEZ, L. Trace and major elemental analysis applications in the U.S. cooperative soil survey
program. New York, Commun. soil sci. plant anal.,
v.31, p.1757-1771, 2000.
BURT, R.; WILSON, M.A.; MAYS, M.D.; LEE, C.W. Major
and trace elements of selected pedons in the USA.
Journal of Environmental Quality, Madison, Wis., v.
32, n. 6, p.2109-2121, nov. 2003.
CANDELARIA, L.M.; CHANG, A.C. Cadmium activity
solution speciation and solid phase distribution
of Cd in cadmium nitrate and sewage sludge
treated soil systems. Soil Sci., v.162, n.10, p.722732, 1997.
CANTARELLA, H.; WIETHOLTHER, S.; BERNARDI,
A.C.C.; VITTI, G.C.; CANTARUTTI, R.B.; MUNIZ,
A.S.; OLIVEIRA, M.H. Programas de avaliação de
qualidade das análises de solo e de planta no Brasil.
Boletim Informativo Sociedade Brasileira Ciência do
Solo, v.26, n.1, p.20-24, 2001.
CASTRO, A.C.J. de. Uma abordagem geoquímica e ambiental sobre os efeitos das queimadas da floresta
sobre os solos nos bordos sul da Amazônia Legal.
1998. 355 p. Tese (Doutorado)-Universidade Federal
do Rio de Janeiro. 355p., Rio de Janeiro, 1998.
CHEN, J.S.; DENG, B.S.; PAN, M.; WANG, X.J.; ZENG,
S.Q.; HE, Q. Geographical tendencies of trace ele-
ment contents in soil derived from granite, basalt and
limestone of Eastern China. Pedosphere, Beijing, v.
3, p.45-55, 1993.
CIENFUEGOS, F.; VAITSMAN, D. Análise Instrumental.
Rio de Janeiro: Interciências, 2000. 606p.
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA E SANEAMENTO AMBIENTAL. Relatório de estabelecimento de valores
orientadores para solos e águas subterrâneas. São
Paulo, 2001. 1 CD-ROM.
DAS, A.K.; CHAKRABORTY, R.; CERVERA, M.L.; DE LA
GUARDIA, M. Metal speciation in solid matrices.
Talanta, Amsterdam, v. 42, n. 8, p.1007-1030, ago.
1995.
DEAN, J.R.; BUTLER, O.; FISHER, A.; GARDEN, L.M.;
CRESSER, M.S.; WATKINS, P.; CAVE, M. Atomic
spectrometry update: environmental analysis. J.
anal. at. spectrom., London, v. 13, p. 1R-56R,
1998.
DECKERS, J.; STEINNES, E. State of the art on soil- related geo-medical issues in the world. Advances in
Agronomy, San Diego, v. 84, p. 1-35, 2004.
DISSANAYAKE, C.B.; CHANDRAJITH, R. Medical geochemistry of tropical environments. Earth-Science
Reviews, Amsterdam, v .47, n. 3-4, p. 219-258,
1999. EUROPA. 2005. Disponível em: <http://europa.
eu.int/comm/environment/waste/sludge/sludge_disposal2a.pdf>. Acesso em: 15 abr. 2005.
FADIGAS, F. de S.; AMARAL SOBRINHO, N.M. B. do;
MAZUR, N.; BEHLING, M. Proposição de valores
de referência para a concentração de Cd, Co, Cr,
Cu, Ni, Pb e Zn em solos brasileiros. In: REUNIÃO
BRASILEIRA DE FERTILIDADE DO SOLO E NUTRIÇÃO DE PLANTAS, 25., 2002, Rio de Janeiro.
Resumos expandidos ... Rio de Janeiro: SBCS,
2002. 1 CD-ROM.
FURLANI, P.R.; BATAGLIA, O.C.; VALADARES, J.M.A.S.
Cobalto em solos do Estado de São Paulo. Revista
Brasileira de Ciência do Solo, Campinas, v. 1, p.6567, 1977.
HANI, H. Soil analysis as a tool to predict effects on the
environment. Commun. soil sci. plant anal., v. 27, n.
3-4, p. 289-306, 1996.
HAYES, K.F.; TRAINA, S.J. Metal ion speciation and its
significance in ecosystem health. In: SOIL CHEMISTRY AND ECOSYSTEMS HEALTH. St. Louis, 1998.
Proceedings. Madison: SSSA. p.45-84. 1998. Special Publication, 52.
HOLMGREN, G.G.S.; MEYER, M.W.; CHANEY, R.L.; DANIELS, R.B. Cadmium, lead, zinc, copper, and nickel
in agricultural soils of the United States of America.
Journal of Environmental Quality, Madison, Wis., v.
22, p.335-348, 1993.
HORBE, A.M.C. 1995. Evolução mineralógica e geoquímica multielementar de perfis de solo sobre lateritos
e gossans na Amazonia. 1995. 213 p. Tese ( Dou-
– 40 –
torado em Geologia e Geoquímica)-Universidade
Federal do Pará. Belém, 1995.
KABATA-PENDIAS, A.; PENDIAS, H. Trace elements in
soils and plants. 3rd ed. Boca Raton, FA: CRC Press,
2001. 413p.
KER, J.C. Mineralogia, sorção e dessorção de fosfato,
magnetização e elementos-traços de latossolos do
Brasil. 1995. 212 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geociências)- Universidade Federal de Viçosa, Viçosa, 1995.
KOT, A.; NAMIESNIK, J. 2000. The role of speciation in
analytical chemistry. Trends in Analytical Chemistry,
Amsterdam, v. 19, n. 2-3, p. 69-79, 2000.
LACERDA, M.P.C. Correlação geopedológica em solos B
texturais na região de Lavras, MG. 1998. 300 p. Tese
(Doutorado em Geociências)-Universidade Federal
de Lavras, Lavras, 1998.
LONG, K. 2001. The use of biosolids (sewage sludge) as
a fertilizer/soil conditioner on dairy pastures. Victoria,
Australia: DFSV, 2001. 41p.
MARQUES, J.J.G. de S. M. Trace element distributions in
brazilian cerrado soils at the landscape and micrometer scales. 2000. 172 p. Tese (Doutorado)-Purdue
University, West Lafayette, 2000.
MATTIAZO, M.E.; BERTON, R.S.; CRUZ, M.C.P. da. 2001.
Disponibilidade de metais pesados potencialmente
tóxicos. In: FERREIRA, M.E.; CRUZ, M.C.P.
da; VAN RAIJ, B.; ABREU, C.A. de. Micronutrientes e elementos tóxicos na agricultura. Jaboticabal: CNPq;
FAPESP; POTAFOS, 2001. p. 213-234.
MAVROPOULOS, E.; KEDE, M.L.; ROCHA, N.; PEREZ,
D.V.; BERTOLINO, L.C.; MOREIRA, J.; ROSSI, A.
2005. Lead immobilization by Brazilian phosphate
rock. In: INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON
HEAVY METALS IN THE ENVIRONMENT, 13., 2005,
Rio de Janeiro. Proceedings… Rio de Janeiro: [s.n.],
2005.
MCBRATNEY, A.B.; MENDONÇA-SANTOS, M.L. MINASNY, B.O. On digital soil mapping. Geoderma, Amsterdam, v. 117, n. 1-2, p. 3-52, nov. 2003.
MCLEAN, J.E.; BLEDSOE, B.E. 1992. Behaviour of metals
in soils. Washington: EPA. 1992. 25 p.
MELFI, A.J.; PEDRO, G. Estudo geoquímico dos solos e
formações superficiais do Brasil. Parte 1. Caracterização e repartição dos principais tipos de evolução
pedogeoquímica. Revista Brasileira de Geociências,
São Paulo, v. 7, p. 271-286, 1997.
MELFI, A.J.; PEDRO, G. Estudo geoquímico dos solos e
formações superficiais do Brasil. Parte 2. Considerações sobre os mecanismos geoquímicos envolvidos
na alteração superficial e sua repartição no Brasil.
Revista Brasileira de Geociências, São Paulo, v. 8,
p.11-22, 1978.
MONIZ, A.C.et al. Elementos de pedologia. São Paulo:
Polígono; EDUSP, 1972. 459p.
MORROW, D.A.; GINTAUTAS, P.A.; WEISS, A.D.; PIWONI,
M.D.; BRICKA, R.M. Metals speciation in soils: a
review. Vicksburg: U.S. Army Corps of Engineer,
1996. 108 p. (Technical report, IRRP-96-5).
NASCIMENTO, R.A.M. Fundamentos da ciência do
solo (IA-305):gráficos, desenhos, tabelas. Itaguaí:
UFRRJ, 1995. 112p.
OLIVER, M.A. Soil and human health: a review. European
Journal of Soil Science, Oxford, v. 48, p. 573-592,
1997
OLIVEIRA, T.S. de. 1996. Metais pesados como indicadores de materiais de origem de solos. 1996. 135 p.
Tese (Doutorado)-Universidade Federal de Viçosa,
Viçosa, 1996.
PÉREZ, D.V.; SALDANHA, M.F.C.; MENEGUELLI, N. do A.;
MOREIRA, J. da C.; VAITSMAN, D.S. Geoquímica de
alguns solos brasileiros. Rio de Janeiro: EMBRAPACNPS, 1997. 14p. (EMBRAPA-CNPS. Pesquisa em
andamento, 4).
QUEVAUVILLER, P. Operationally defined extraction procedures for soil and sediment analysis I. Standardization. Trends in Analytical Chemistry, Amsterdam,
v.17, n. 5, p.289-298, maio 1998.
ROSS, S.M. Retention, transformation and mobility of toxic
metals in soils. In:______ . Toxic metals in soil- plant
systems. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, 1994.
P.63-152.
SCANCAR, J.; MILACIC, R.; STRAZAR, M.; BURICA, O.
Total metal concentrations and partioning of Cd, Cr,
Cu, Fe, Ni and Zn in sewage sludge. The Science
of the Total Environment, Amsterdam, v. 250, n. 1,
p. 9-19, abr. 2000.
SHACKLETTE, H.T.; BOERNGEN, J.G. Element concentrations in soils and other surficial materials of the
conterminous United States. Alexandria VA: U.S.
Geological Survey, 1984. 105p. (Geological Survey
Professional Paper, 1270).
SHAW, A.J. Heavy metal tolerance in plants: evolutionary
aspects. Boca Raton, FA: CRC Press, 1989. 355p.
TACK, F.M.G.; VERLOO, M.G. Chemical speciation and
fractionation in soil and sediment heavy metal analysis: a review. Int. J. Environ. Anal. Chem., v. 59, p.
225-238, 1995.
URE, A.M. Trace element speciation in soils, soil extracts
and solutions. Mikrochimica Acta, Viena, v. 2, p.
49-57, 1991.
VALADARES, J.M.A.S. Cobre em solos do Estado de São
Paulo: 1: cobre total. Bragantia, Campinas, v.34, n.1,
p.125-132, 1975.
VALADARES, J.M.A.S.; CATANI, R.A. Zinco em solos do
Estado de São Paulo. Bragantia, Campinas, v. 34,
n.1, p. 133-139, 1975.
VALADARES, J.M.A.S.; CAMARGO, O.A. de. Manganês
em solos do Estado de São Paulo. Revista Brasileira
de Ciência de Solo, Campinas, v. 7, n. 2,p. 123-130,
1983.
– 41 –
WALTER, I.; CUEVAS, G. Chemical fractionation of heavy
metals in a soil amended with repeated sewage
sludge application. The Science of the Total Environment, Amsterdam, v. 226, n. 2-3, p.113-119,
fev. 1999.
WASSERMAN, M.A. Soil-to-plant transfer of 137Cs in
tropical areas. In: IAEA. Transfer of radionuclides
from air, soil and freshwater to the food-chain of man
in tropical and subtropical environments: report of a
final research co-ordination meeting. Viena: IAEA,
1997. p.128-137.
WASSERMAN, M.A.; PEREZ, D.V.; BARTOLY, F. Biogeochemical behavior of 137Cs and 60Co in tropical
soils. Radioprotection – Colloques, [S.l.], v. 37, C1,
p.227-282, 2002.
WELCH, R.M.; GRAHAM, R.D. 2005. Agriculture: the
real nexus for enhancing bioavailable micronutrients in food crops. Journal of Trace Elements
in Medicine and Biology, v. 18, n. 4, p. 299-307,
2005.
WHITE, J.G.; ZASOSKI, R.J. 1999. Mapping soil micronutrients. Field Crops Research, Amsterdam, v. 60,
n. 1, p. 11-26, jan. 1999.
YAMADA, T.; LOPES, A.S. 1998. Balanço de nutrientes na
agricultura brasileira. Informações Agronômicas, n.
84, Encarte Técnico, 1998. 8p.
– 42 –
BIOFORTIFICATION
AS A COM BAT
TOOL FOR
M ICRONUTRIENT
DEFICIENCIES
Marilia Nutti; marilia@ctaa.embrapa.br
José Luiz V. Carvalho; jlvc@ctaa.embrapa.br
Edson Watanabe; edswat@ctaa.embrapa.br
Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation - EMBRAPA
INTRODUCTION
Diets with a lack of iron and zinc can provoke anemia,
a work capability reduction, immune system problems,
development retardation and even death. Iron-deficiency
anemia is probably the most important nutritional problem in Brazil, with a prevalence ranging from 30 to 80%
in groups of children under five. It is remarkable that
this deficiency occurs independently of social class or
geographical distribution. Black beans (32%) and meat
(20%) are the most important iron sources for the Brazilian population are the absorption potential of this mineral
ranges between 1 and 7%.
Although zinc deficiency is not studied with the same
intensity as iron deficiency, considering the same source
foods provide these nutrients, a high incidence of the
former can be expected. Biochemical data obtained from
population groups with this nutrient lack in their diets, sustain this tendency and therefore, it should be considered
as important. Zinc participates in more than 300 enzymes
active in the immune system, in the genetic expression,
among other functions. Little is known about zinc deficiencies in developing countries, however, in general, sources
rich in bioavailable iron are also rich in bioavailable zinc.
The micronutrient content variations in food can
be attributed to: 1) the plant characteristics, such as
its age, maturation, species, variety, cultivation, diet;
2) the environmental variables, such as climate, soil,
rainfall, season, and; 3) processing factors such as
storage duration, temperature, preservation methods,
food preparation.
The importance of calcium should also be observed.
Its nutritional ingestion in Brazil varies between 300mg
and 500mg per day, whereas the DRI (Dietary Reference
Intake) recommended value for the USA and Canadian
populations, is between 1000mg and 1200mg for adults.
Brazil is a tropical country offering the population sufficient vitamin D giving a greater efficiency in calcium
absorption and utilization. However, because of skin
cancer risks, the population is increasingly concerned
about protection from UV rays using solar filters that will
certainly diminish this vitamin’s synthesis by the organism. The long term effects of this attitude could result
in an increased incidence of rickets, osteomalacia and
osteoporosis.
Selenium is another important nutritional element,
not only because of its role in the antioxidant defense
system but also because of its likely action in cancer risk
reduction, which is still under evaluation. In Brazil the
selenium content in food varies according to the soil, as
demonstrated by food obtained in São Paulo and Mato
Grosso States has an inferior content of this element,
– 43 –
Biofortiication as a combat tool for micronutrient deiciencies
whereas food from Ceará or Amazonas States has higher
values. Furthermore, selenium deficiency is correlated
to the individual’s nutritional state regarding iodine, as to
transform T4 into T3 (the thyroid hormone active form), a
selenium dependent deiodinase is needed.
Vitamin A is an essential micronutrient for good vision
and a healthy immune system. It is estimated that a vitamin
A deficiency has a significant effect on school children’s
health in about 80 countries all around the world. Vitamin
A deficiency is a serious problem in developing countries,
causing blindness in thousands of children. Increased
pro-vitamin A or carotenoids intake is a preconized means
to fight this deficiency.
NUTRIENT INGESTION IN BRAZIL
Literature data indicates the Brazilian ingestion of
some elements (iron, calcium, zinc and selenium) is below
recommended levels or they have low dietary bioavailability. This indicates the biochemical parameters are below
the reference values in the population’s risk groups, thus
confirming the need for intervention. A joint action by the
scientific and industrial communities together with the
government, to seek and implement dietary alternatives,
may be a possible solution to minimize this problem.
More than 840 million people do not have sufficient
food to meet their basic daily energy needs. A much
larger number of people – about three billion – suffer
from micronutrients deficiency effects due to being too
poor to buy adequate quantities of red meat, chicken,
fish, fruit and vegetables. Women and children from the
Sub-Saharan Africa, South and Southeast Asia, Latin
America and the Caribbean are those who present the
greatest risk of contracting illnesses, premature death
and cognitive ability deterioration because of their essential micronutrient limited diets – particularly iron,
vitamin A, iodine and zinc.
World Health Organization data on micronutrients
deficiency have shown this is not only a developing
countries problem but also of developed countries as
well. The deficiency in minerals and vitamins can affect
the people’s full development, with both physical and
socio-economical consequences interfering in the country’s development. Among the most studied micronutrients, iron, vitamin A and iodine continue to be indicated
as those representing the greatest public health problem
in Brazil, as well as on a world scale. Calcium, zinc,
selenium and copper, among other essential elements
are also of extreme importance to a proper nutrition and
proper human development.
FOOD FORTIFICATION AS A PUBLIC POLICY IN BRAZIL
Countries that have adopted public policies
to solve micronutrients deficiency problems, have
obtained successful results with food fortification
programs and/or medicated supplements. In Brazil,
measures have been introduced to fortify salt with iodine, the fluoridation of water supplies in some regions
and, more recently, with the compulsory fortification of
wheat and corn flour with iron and folic acid, aimed
at reducing high levels of anemia and neural tube
defects, respectively.
Vitamin A and iron fortified food, as well as the distribution of micronutrient supplements to target populations
have been the most frequent strategies used in most
developing countries to fight hypovitaminosis A and irondeficiency anemia. Recent research has demonstrated
that the development of plants with higher vitamin A
contents and other minerals can help improve the human
diet and this is the research project goal being developed
by EMBRAPA.
The approach to fight malnutrition in developing
countries is with vitamin supply and mineral supplements to pregnant women and young children, in
addition to the food fortification with these nutrients
through post harvest processes. Many results have
already been achieved with this strategy. In regions
with appropriate infra-structure and facilitated with well
established distribution markets for processed food
such as salt, sugar and cereal flour, the food fortification can greatly improve the intake of micronutrients
by the vulnerable populations.
BIOFORTIFICATION – A TOOL FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF HUMAN HEALTH
However, there are limits for food fortification and
the supply of commercial supplements. It is possible
that fortified food may not reach a large part of the needy
population due to a poor distribution infra-structure.
Likewise, supplements depend on a health system with
a highly functional infra-structure which is rarely found
in developing countries. So, considering that new approaches are necessary to complement interventions
already in process, the Biofortification proposal emerges,
as a new paradigm for agriculture and a tool to improve
human health.
The introduction of biofortified agricultural products – improved varieties bearing a higher content of
minerals and vitamins – will complement the existing
nutritional interventions and will provide a sustainable
and low cost way of reaching populations with limited
access to formal market and health systems. Once the
investment in the development of nutritionally improved
varieties in centralized research facilities is made, the
obtained seeds can be adapted to growth conditions in
many different countries. Biofortified varieties present
the potential to provide continuous benefits in devel-
– 44 –
Marília Nutti
oping countries, at lower recurrent costs than those of
supplementation and post harvest fortification.
The final solution for the eradication of malnutrition in
developing countries is to substantially increase the consumption of red meat, chicken, fish, fruit and vegetables
by the destitute population, which can take many decades
and cost billions of dollars. Biofortification, however, may
reduce malnutrition by approaching the food system in
an integrated way. It attacks the root of the malnutrition
problem, has as its target the most deprived population,
uses incorporated distribution mechanisms, is scientifically viable and effective in terms of cost, in addition to
complement other interventions to control micronutrients
deficiencies. It is, in short, an essential step that will allow
families in need to improve their nutrition and health in a
sustainable way.
The Biofortification HarvestPlus Challenge Program
The Biofortification HarvestPlus Challenge Program
was elaborated to improve the nutritional qualities of the
main food crops that are adapted to the world’s marginal
zones. It was idealized to guarantee the advances in science and technology be used to enrich the nutritional diet
of poor populations who practice subsistence agriculture
in tropical regions.
The focus of biofortification is based on solid scientific
principles. Preliminary research analyzed the viability of
the employment of plant improvement, to increase the
micronutrient content of staple food products by identifying the following premises: there is a considerable and
useful genetic variation in basic agricultural products;
the plant breeding programs can easily manipulate nutritional quality characteristics, since they are inherited in
high proportions in some agricultural products and are
easy to be selected; desirable characteristics are stable
enough in a great variety of agricultural environments; and
characteristics of high nutrient content can be combined
with agronomical characteristics of superior quality and
high yield characteristics.
The International Center for Tropical Agriculture
- CIAT and the International Food Policy Research
Institute - IFPRI coordinate the phyto-improvement
activities, human nutrition, diffusion, policies analysis
and impact assessment to be carried out in international research and agricultural extension centers and
in vegetal production and human nutrition departments
in universities of developed and developing countries.
Non-governmental Organizations (NGOs) of developed
and developing countries, farmer organizations and
partnerships between the public and private sectors will
consolidate this alliance and promote the connection
with consumers. The first initiatives on biofortification
will concentrate on six staple food crops, for which
pre-viability improvement studies have already been
concluded: black beans, cassava, maize, rice, sweetpotato and wheat.
The program will also study the nutrients content
improvement potential in ten other products that are
important diet components of populations showing micronutrients deficiency: banana, barley, cowpea-beans,
peanuts, lentils, millet, guandu beans, potato, sorghum
and yam.
HarvestPlus is a Global Challenge Program of the
Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research
(CGIAR), which involves not only several associated research centers such as the International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT), the International Maize and Wheat
Improvement Center (CIMMYT), the International Potato
Center (CIP), the International Center for Agricultural
Research in Dry Areas (ICARDA), the International Crops
Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT),
the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI),
International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), the
International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), but also several collaborative partner institutions such as the National
System for Agricultural Research (SNPA) in developing
countries; human nutrition departments of universities in
developed and developing countries; NGOs; Adelaide
University; Freiburg University; Michigan State University;
US Plant, Soil and Nutrition Laboratory, the US Department
of Agriculture; the Agricultural Research Service (USDAARS); the Children’s Nutrition Research Center and the
Baylor College of Medicine.
The Biofortification HarvestPlus Challenge Program
has been conceived for a 10-year period and counts on
the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation for financial support, the Danish Agency for International Development
(DANIDA), the Swiss Agency for International Development (SIDA), the American Agency for International
Development (USAID) and the World Bank.
The goals of HarvestPlus are:
From the 1st to the 4th year:
determine nutritionally optimal breeding objectives;
• select germoplasm from CGIAR bearing high levels
of iron, zinc and beta-carotene and initiate crossbreeding of the highly adaptive and high yielding
selected germoplasm;
• make a survey on farming practices and food processing to determine their effect on the micronutrient content and bioavailability;
• study the genetics related to high levels of micronutrients and identify the available markers
to facilitate the transference of characteristics
through conventional breeding and new breeding
techniques;
• perform studies in vitro and with animals in order
to determine the bioavailability of high contents of
micronutrients in promising varieties;
– 45 –
Biofortiication as a combat tool for micronutrient deiciencies
• initiate studies on bio-effectiveness in humans
in order to determine the biological effect of the
biofortified products in the micronutrient levels in
nutrition;
• initiate tendencies identification studies and sensitivity factor analysis considering the quality of
malnourished populations’ diet;
• make a cost-benefit analysis of plant breeding
strategies and other interventions related to food
to control micronutrients deficiency..
From the 5th to the 7th year:
• continue bioeffectiveness studies;
• initiate breeding with the farmers’ participation;
• adapt the high yield varieties, with high micronutrients contents and conventionally improved, to the
selected regions;
• make new conventionally improved biofortified
varieties available to farmers;
• identify genes with a potential to increase the nutritional value beyond that obtained with conventional
improvement methods;
• produce transgenic varieties in an experimental
level and select them for their micronutrients content before testing them according to the biosecurity norms;
• develop and implement a marketing strategy to
promote the improved varieties;
• start production and distribution.
From the 8th to the 10th year:
• increase the production and distribution scale of
the improved varieties;
• determine the nutritional effectiveness of the program and identify factors that affect the adoption
of the biofortified food, the impact on the destitute
families’ resources and the effects on the individuals’ health.
HarvestPlus in Brazil
In Brazil, currently the main component of HarvestPlus, is the Research Program on Biofortified
Crops for Better Human Nutrition. This project aims
to define the population segregation of/for manioc,
black beans and maize with agronomical potential and
higher nutritional value (higher contents of iron, zinc
and pro-vitamin A), which can improve the population’s
health and promote sustainable development, more
social equality and larger use of these products in the
international market.
The research network participants at the moment are:
Embrapa-Food Technology , Embrapa-Rice & Beans, ,
Embrapa-Cassava & Tropical Fruits, Embrapa-Maize &
Sorghum, Embrapa-Genetic Resources & Biotechnology, Embrapa-Mid-North and Campinas State University
(Unicamp). The inclusion of Embrapa-Soils, which can
supply data referring to the composition of micronutrients
in Brazilian soils, has been suggested.
The vegetables included in the HarvestPlus program are already largely produced and consumed in
this country, which means that farmers and consumers
do not have to change their nutrition habits to benefit
from biofortification. Besides, the improvement to upgrade the mineral content does not necessarily have
to change the aspect, flavor, texture, or the culinary
quality of the food.
In those cases where a high micronutrient content
can be combined with a high yield, the adoption of the
improved products by farmers and markets is almost
ensured. In fact, research demonstrates that high levels
of minerals in seeds also contribute to the plant’s nutrition
thereby increasing expectations of productivity gains of
biofortified varieties.
One way to ensure the farmers interest in the new
varieties is to let them give their opinion on which characteristics should be improved in the plants. During the
plant improvement process, the scientists consider the
farmers’ perspectives and preferences, which is more
cost-effective than to confine the improvement to research
stations.
A common developing country problem is the
lack of a delivery and distribution system for certain
products – for example, health supplies or agricultural
products – to the poorest populations. HarvestPlus
is overcoming this limitation through the use of technologies that are based on the seed, according to
the biofortification approach mentioned above. When
micronutrient rich food is cultivated in family farming,
the micronutrients distribution system is incorporated in
the existing production and market process. Once the
farmers have adopted the new seed, little intervention
or investment is necessary. In addition, micronutrient
rich seeds can be easily stored or shared even by the
poorest families.
The EMBRAPA centers have a valuable experience in creating and promoting local seeds distribution systems, thanks to the work they have developed
with seed production systems and their contribution to
programs that offer assistance during natural disasters.
These established systems, facilitate the dissemination
of biofortified seeds. In particular, local agricultural
committees and small-scale seed processing factories
will play a crucial role in getting the micronutrient rich
varieties to the farmers.
RESULTS ALREADY OBTAINED AND FINAL
CONSIDERATIONS
In the project’s first year about 3,000 varieties of
manioc, black beans and maize were selected and
– 46 –
Marília Nutti
multiplied, and 1,000 samples of each crop will be
evaluated as to their contents of iron, zinc, total carotenoids and beta-carotene. The promising varieties will
be further improved to develop the biofortified varieties. By 2005 the studies on retention of beta-carotene
in manioc and iron and zinc in black beans, will have
been made in conventional varieties, to estimate the
nutrients’ losses during processing and stocking the
goods.
An interesting integration between Latin American,
Caribbean, African and Southeast Asian countries is
also foreseen in this project, where Brazil is expected to
develop and transfer not only the biofortified crops but
also post harvest technology.
– 47 –
RISK EVALUATION
A SOCIAL AND
ENVIRONM ENTAL
M ANAGEM ENT TOOL:
THE CASE STUDY OF THE
NORTHERN REGION OF THE
STATE OF M ATO GROSSO
Sandra Hacon, shacon@ensp.iocruz.br
2
Renato Farias
3
Reinaldo Calixto de Campos
4
Julio C. Wasserman
1
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation - ENSP
2
State University of São Paulo - UNESP
3
Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro - PUC/RJ
4
Fluminense Federal University - UFF
1
INTRODUCTION
Gold was discovered in the Northern region of Mato
Grosso State in 1978 followed by two decades of intense
mining activity. This region became the second most
important mining center of the Amazon Basin; an area
1,878Km2 was mined for gold during the whole of the 80’s
until the middle 90’s. During this period, this region’s gold
production reached between 200 and 300 tons (Hacon et
al. 2003). The extracted gold became the major income
source for the entire region whereas mercury, used as amalgam, became in the 90’s, the most serious risk factor for the
environment and human health. As a direct consequence,
the region experienced changes in its socio-economic
profile as well as in the relationships between health and
the environment among the urban and rural population
(Hacon 1996). According to Farias et al (2001), while gold
commercialization estimates for the Alta Floresta region
reach 800 kg/year, a large amount of this gold originated in
the neighboring Pará State. Despite the accentuated decline in the actual mining activity, the region’s fish stocks
continue to show high mercury concentrations, reflecting
a process of large scale biomagnification in the Northern
region of Mato Grosso. In 1994, aquaculture projects
were launched in the region as new socioeconomic opportunities for ex-gold miners.. Former mining areas are
considered to be large environmental and social liabilities
for landowners and local authorities. However, the first
aquaculture projects were implemented without any risk
evaluation of the mercury contamination in relation to fish
– 48 –
Sandra Hacon
consumption from fish farming sites. From 1999 to 2001,
fish production from aquaculture projects in the region was
estimated at 100 tons/year, with less than 30% supplying
the local markets and the rest being exported to other
markets around the country (Hacon et al. 2003). The main
fish species currently farmed in the aquaculture projects
are: Tambaqui (Colossoma macropomum); an hybrid
from the Tambacú (Colossoma macropomum) with Pacú
(Piaractus mesopotamicus), all being non-piscivorous,
Pintado (Pseudoplastystoma corrruscans) and the Jundiá
(Leiarius marmoratus), both piscivorous.
2. CASE STUDY AND METHODOLOGY
The studied region is situated between latitudes 7º 37’
to 11º 00’ South and longitudes 52º 31’ to 58º 13’ West;
see Figure 1. There are 5 sites , which were selected considering factors such as, the existence of former mining
degraded areas, the production and commercialization of
gold, the location of aquaculture projects and the fish species that are farmed and consumed in the region. The Alta
Floresta urban area, with 46,982 inhabitants (IBGE 2000),
was the main gold commercialization center. Paranaíta
and Matupá were important mining areas, with extractions located mainly in the Teles Pires River basin. This
area consequently became extensively and intensively
contaminated with mercury in the 80’s. This transformed
it into a potential pathway for methylmercury exposure to
humans due to interactions with the mercury loadings in
the MeHg production. However, the magnitude and timing
of this outcome vary with the type of Hg contamination
and the ecosystem characteristics (Hacon et al 1995).
Figure1 – Localización de la región Norte del Mato Grosso.
– 49 –
Risk Evaluation a social and environmental management tool: The case study of the northern region of the State of Mato Grosso
Figure 2 – Relación entre la producción de oro y el contingente demográfico durante el período de la “fiebre del oro” en la
región norte del Mato Grosso (Farias 2002).
Paranaíta has a population of 10,250, Matupá 11,300,
Nova Monte Verde 6,500 and Nova Bandeirante 9,535
inhabitants (IBGE 2000). During the “gold rush” period,
from the end of the 70’s until the early 90’s, demographic
growth reached annually rates of 12%. The relationship
between gold production and the demographic influxes
during the gold rush period in the Northern region of Mato
Grosso is illustrated in Figure 2 (Farias 2002). For this
study, two reference areas around Nova Monte Verde and
Nova Bandeirantes were selected as sites for mercury
contamination comparison, since they have never had
mining activity.
Since its earlier stages, the study was developed in
an inSince the outset, the study was developed with the
integrated social participation from cooperative representatives, aquaculture associations, public sector and the
local university. Approximately 180 aquaculture project
initiatives from five regions were visited from which, 36
were then selected according to a defined criteria, such
as i) fish production for subsistence as a first priority and
ii) for regional and national commercialization as a second priority; iii) how long a time this activity is operating
and; iv) the fish farming system. In order to evaluate the
emerging aquaculture activity in the region interviews
based on qualitative and quantitative questions were
applied to workers directly and indirectly engaged in
the industry. The questionnaire dealt with variables related to the social and nutrition behavior with emphasis
on the consumption and origin of the fish, water quality
in the dams, aquaculture project location in relation to
old degraded mining areas. In total 254 fish from the
main rivers and regional fish farms were sampled and
analyzed between September 2000 and April 2002.
Researchers from Mato Grosso State University (Universidade Estadual do Mato Grosso - UNEMAT) identified
the species, measured and weighed the fish. Total mercury content was carried out by Rio de Janeiro Catholic
University (Pontificia Universidade Católica do Rio de
Janeiro - PUC) based on cold vapor spectrophotometry
as described by Campos & Curtis (1990). The analytical
quality control included blank analysis and duplicate
samples for further comparisons with reference results. A
data bank was built of all the information collected in the
interviews, whereas all field data was geo-referenced. All
the data was analyzed using the statistical software SPSS
version 8.0 and Epinfo version 6.0. Descriptive statistics
were used for the mercury concentrations analyses in the
fish and their relationship with the other variables in the
– 50 –
Sandra Hacon
exposure model. Comparisons of the mean values through
parametric and non-parametric trials complemented the
final analysis. Evaluation of different exposure scenarios
and uncertainties were classified using the software Cristal Ball version 2000. Exposure estimates were obtained
by considering daily fish ingestion by part of the adult
population in every region through the general equation
to assess chronic exposure.
GENERAL EqUATION TO EVALUATE EXPOSURE
SCENARIOS:
Daily ingestion of Hg (mg/kg/d) = Concentration of Hg in fish (mg/
kg) x daily rate of fish ingestion (kg/d) / body weight of the exposed
individual.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In the Northern region of Mato Grosso, the aquaculture activity started as a joint initiative between the Alta
Floresta Municipality and the Mato Grosso State University
(UNEMAT). In order to strengthen the region’s economic
activity, a project called “Peixe“ (fish) was created in 1994.
The aquaculture projects evaluation study revealed that
the majority of the fish farms were based on extensive
systems, meaning little control over farming environmental conditions and physical-chemical water parameters
resulting in low fish production rates as seen in Table 1.
Today, there are many discussions and uncertainties
regarding the sources and mercury types in the Amazon
(Wasserman et al 2003). Nevertheless informal gold mining and the use of large quantities of metallic mercury as
amalgam is still a reality in the Amazon region. However,
comparing today’s extraction levels with those reached 20
years ago, the informal gold mining represents very low
activity scales, only 3-5% of the overall gold production
in the Amazon region. Despite this, informal gold mining
is still the main anthropogenic mercury source, causing
high concentrations of methylmercury in piscivorous
fish caught in the Amazon Basin. These high levels of
mercury pose a serious risk for the sustainability of the
aquaculture activity in some areas of Mato Grosso. This
study measured mercury levels in 19 fish species, those
most consumed by local communities in the five studied
areas. The results of mercury levels, shown in Table 3,
are from river fish as well as from fish farms around those
communities.
As indicated in Table 2, the Paranaíta and Alta Floresta regions present higher mercury concentrations in fish
samples from the Brachyplatystoma spp (Piraíba) species, caught in the Apiacás River, with a mean concentration of 2.02 mg/kg (SD±1.04) ranging from 1.2 to 3.5 mg/
kg, and samples from the Paulicea lutkeni (Jaú) species,
caught in the Paranaíta River with a mean concentration
of 1.03 mg/kg (SD±0.4) ranging from 0.5 to 1.7 mg/kg.
Both rivers were intensively affected by mining activity in
the last decades. The statistical analysis based on the
Kruskal-Wallis test made evident a significant difference
(p< 0.001) between piscivorous and non-piscivorous species from both rivers and fish farms. The mercury levels
found in piscivorous river fish are two times higher than
the concentrations measured in the same species taken
from fish farms.
There are many ways to explain the different mercury
concentration levels in fish from the Teles Pires River
basin and the aquaculture activity. Emphasis was put
on the size, weight and age of the piscivorous fish, together with their trophic level, food availability, exposure
period and ecosystem characteristics. The mean mercury concentration in piscivorous fish (n=125 samples)
is about 0.6 mg/kg (SD±-0.54) and in non-piscivorous
fish (n=129 samples) is about 0.03 mg/kg (SD±0.03).
The mercury levels measured in piscivorous fish were
statically significant (p< 0.001). The Matupá region had
the highest mercury levels in farmed fish; in Tambacús
and Tambaquis, both non-piscivorous fish mercury levels
reached values higher than 0.1 mg/kg. This was an un-
Table 1 - Aquaculture characteristics in the northern region of Mato Grosso
Variables Localities/
Total Area IBGE 1998 (km2)
Nº of evaluated aquaculture sites
Alta Floresta
Matupá
Nova Monte
Verde
Nova
Bandeirante
Paranaíta
9310
7213
4898,2
9172
4857,3
71
16
55
16
22
Nº of selected aquaculture sites
15
3
4
4
10
Mean Fish Production (t/2001)
30
5
2
1,5
32
Area degradated by mining (km2)
19
50
0
0
60
Cultivation Period (year)
7
4,2
3,1
4
2,6
Nº of evaluated aquaculture sites
3
14
0
0
9
Nº of aquaculture with water quality control
5
7
1
0
5
– 51 –
Risk Evaluation a social and environmental management tool: The case study of the northern region of the State of Mato Grosso
Table 2 - Mercury levels in fish from the northern region of Mato Grosso
Trophic level (n)
Mean mg/kg
(w.w)
± SD Hg
Range concentration
Hg
P* (27)
NP** (56)
0.541
0.002
0.658
0.001
0.020 – 2.700
0.015 – 0.110
Paranaíta
P (53)
NP (30)
0.674
0.003
0.627
0.002
0.086 – 3.500
0.010 – 0.100
Matupá
P (13)
NP (5)
0.359
0.156
0.123
0.005
0.230 – 0.640
0.090 – 0.210
Nova Monte Verde
P (7)
NP (24)
0.564
0.003
0.412
0.002
0.073 – 1.100
0.015 – 0.097
Nova Bandeirante
P (25)
NP (14)
0.457
0.005
0.346
0.003
0.140 - 1.800
0.15 – 0.110
Sites
Alta Floresta
* P = Piscivorous
** NP = Non Piscivorous
expected result considering both species. In the Matupá
aquaculture projects these species indicated a smooth
tendency for mercury bioaccumulation. In two reference
areas of Nova Monte Verde and Nova Bandeirante (n=70),
mercury levels in non-piscivorous fish (n=38) presented
mean values of 0.04 mg/kg (SD±0.02) and a range from
0.01 to 0.11 mg/kg. For piscivorous fish (n=32), the mean
value was 0.5 mg/kg ( SD±0.36) with a range from 0.73
to 1.10 mg/kg. These results appear statistically significant when related to the trophic levels (p= < 0.001). The
medians shown in Figure 3, 5%, 25%, 75% and 95% are
the mercury levels in piscivorous and non-piscivorous
species from rivers and aquacultures consumed by the
population in the different studied areas. Extreme values
were removed from the descriptive analyses for a better
representation of the actual exposure magnitude. The
results emphasize the differences in mercury concentrations in piscivorous and non-piscivorous species from
rivers and aquaculture projects. The migratory specie
Tucunaré, known to be an invader specie, showed mean
values of 0.33 mg/kg (SD±0.16) and a range from 0.06 to
0.66 mg/kg in Alta Floresta and Paranaíta region farmed
fish. That particular specie, depending upon the food
availability, can reach 5 kg and may become a threat to
the aquaculture activity due to its fast growth and mercury
biomagnification capacity. A large number of studies show
a strong correlation between mercury levels, weight and
growth among piscivorous fishes (Farias 2002, Wasserman et al 2003).
For the statistical analyses, Pearson’s correlation
between mercury levels and fish specie standard length
or weight was used. Some Tucunaré specie samples
taken both from the Teles Pires River and some fish farms
in the region exhibited significant results (p < 0.01) with
correlation coefficients about 0.95 and 0.51 respectively.
Despite non-piscivorous species from aquaculture projects presented higher mercury levels than those from
rivers, these results were not statistically significant.
Some values related to mercury levels in farmed fish
consumed by local communities in this region of Mato
Grosso are presented in Table 3. Comparing the results
according to the fish source, 37% of the fish caught in rivers bear mercury levels higher than the maximum values
recommended by the WHO, against only 6% for farmed
fish. These results indicate a potential risk in river fish
consumption in the region, mainly from the Teles Pires,
Apiacás and Paranaíta Rivers.
The exposure variation rates in the five sites visited
are presented in Table 4. The Nova Bandeirante site
revealed the lowest Hg doses, 0,09 mg/kg/d, indicating
that the fish can be consumed with no risk to the com-
Figure 3 – Distribution of mercury levels in different municipalities in
the northern of Mato Grosso.
– 52 –
Sandra Hacon
Table 3 - Comparison of mercury levels in aquaculture and river fish
from the Northern region of Mato Grosso
Fish source
<0,3mg/kg
Piscicultures
n=219
Rivers
n=106
67,5% (NP)
14,5% (P)
27% (NP)
13% (P)
0,3-0,5 mg/kg
>0,5mg/kg
12% (P)
6% (P)
22,5% (P)
37% (P)
P=Piscivorous; NP=Non Piscivorous
munity. The remaining sites showed small mean value
variations in the exposure dose values. Matupá has the
highest exposure dose (0.,5 mg/kg/d) and Paranaíta the
largest dose variability (0.03 – 3.9 mg/kg/d). The most
important justification factors for this variability are: fish
consumption rates; the fish consumption preference by
part of the rural and urban community and; the mercury
level of consumed fish in the different evaluated communities. Fish is the principal protein source in the diet
for 70% of the rural population.
These results highlight that fish consumption in the region is deep rooted in local diet habits and, consequently,
increasing the potential risk of mercury contamination. In
a majority of the areas, the non-piscivorous Tambaqui and
Tambacú may be consumed without posing risk to human
health, with the exception of the Matupá site. Here, with
mercury levels in contaminated fish higher than 0.5 mg/
kg, exposure management should be a priority policy
in the region. This study has sought to emphasize the
importance of risk evaluation processes as planning and
management tools to develop sustainable projects. These
results are intended to support local decision makers
and their communities to face the risks associated with
mercury contamination and take remedial action.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of this study indicate the environmental liability of mercury contamination is a reality in the
Northern region of Mato Grosso. This occurs in many
areas such as rivers and sites with or without a mining
background, and presents strong evidence of extensive
mercury transport mechanisms. The consumption of large
quantities of piscivorous fishes, such as 700g/week may
represent an exposure risk to the communities. The Jaú
fish specie presents a higher risk for human contamination
due to its lower cost and therefore, higher accessibility to
poorer communities. The daily mercury dose for an adult
population should not exceed 0,3 µg/kg/d, considered as
an acceptable exposure limit.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
FARIAS, R.A.; HACON, S.; CAIRES, S.M.; ROSSI, A.P.;
CAMPOS, R.; ARGENTO, R.; CASTRO, S.E. Evaluation of Contamination by Mercury in Fish Farming
in Garimpo Mining Area in the Northern Region of
Mato Grosso, Brazil. In: INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MERCURY AS A GLOBAL POLLUTANT,
6., 2001, Minamata, Japan. Book of abstracts. [S.l.:
s.n.], 2001. p. 214.
FARIAS.R. A. Piscicultura na região norte Matogrossense:
criação de peixes em cavas de antigos garimpos,
com ênfase na avaliação os níveis de mercúrio.
2002. 224 p. Dissertação (Mestrado)-Instituto de
Saúde Coleta, Cuiabá, 2002.
HACON, S. S. Avaliação do Risco Potencial para a Saúde
Humana da exposição ao mercúrio na área urbana
de Alta Floresta. MT - Bacia Amazônica – Brasil.
1996. 182 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geoquímica Ambiental)- Universidade Federal Fluminense, Niterói,
1996.
HACON, S. S.; FARIAS, R. A.; CAMPOS R. C.; ARGENTO,
R.C.; ROSSI, A. P.; VALENTE, J.; WASSERMAN, J.
The new human exposure scenarios to mercury in
the North region of Mato Grosso - Amazon Basin.
Environmental Science, [S.l.], v. 10, n. 2, p. 121-134,
2003.
IBGE. Censo 2000: resultado do universo. Disponivel em:
<http://www.ibge.gov.br>. Acesso em 03 ago. 2006.
SECRETARIA MUNICIPAL DE AGRICULTURA DE ALTA
FLORESTA. Relatório de Finanças. Alta Floresta,
2000-2001.
Table 4 - Potential dosis (mg/kg/d) of mercury exposition in the northern region of Mato Grosso
Localities
Mean Dosis
± SD
Dosis Variation
(min –max)
Confiability limits
(95%)
Paranaíta
0,36
0,31
0,03-3,9
1,2
Matupá
0,5
0,24
0,13-1,3
0,9
Alta Floresta
0,4
0,07
0,19-0,7
0,5
Nova Bandeirante
0,09
0,11
0,01-0,9
0,3
Nova Monte Verde
0,4
0,28
0,09-1,8
1,0
– 53 –
Risk Evaluation a social and environmental management tool: The case study of the northern region of the State of Mato Grosso
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. Mercury
study report to Congress: health effects of mercury and mercury compounds. Cincinnati: National
Center for Environmental Assessment; Office of Research and Development., 1996. (EPA) 452/ R-96-.
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. Exposure Assessment In: ______ . Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund: 600/8/89/043. 157. [S.l.], 1989.
WASSERMAN.J.C.; HACON.S.; WASSERMAN.M. A.
Biogeochemistry of Mercury in the Amazon Environment. Ambio, Estocolmo, v. 32, n. 5, ago. 2003.
ISSN 0044-747.
WORDL HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO). Environmental Health Criteria for Methylmercury. International Programme on Chemical Safety. Geneva,
1990, p.
– 54 –
RISKS
TO HEALTH
FROM ORGANIC
SUBSTANCES
Carlos Siqueira Bandeira de Mello,
carlosbandeira@petrobras.com.br
Dennis James Miller,
miller@petrobras.com.br
COPPE/GEOQ/CENPES/PETROBRAS
INTRODUCTION
The last century saw important changes for humanity, with the great international conflicts in 1914-18 and
1939-45, followed by the enormous population and
industrial growth which brought great hopes and life
improvement, on the one hand, yet caused serious environmental degradation, on the other. The first books that
approached these ominous facts, such as “Silent Spring”
by Carson (1962) began to appear in the second half of
the 20th century. They gave rise to the need to control the
environmental impacts, showing the close link between
the binomial cause-effect, health and environment. Also
worth mentioning is the classic book “The Tragedy of the
Commons” in which Hardin (1968) warned of the dangers
and consequences of a future nuclear war to humanity
and the environment.
In spite of this gradual awakening to environmental
issues, the perplexed world watched monumental incidents, such as the accident of Minamata, Japan (Allchin,
2002), related to the noxious effects of mercury, or the
chemical leak of methyl-isocyanate and other lethal gases
that killed thousands of people in Bhopal, India (Greenpeace, 2002). Other important environmental accidents
happened elsewhere in the world, such as the dioxin
release in Saveso (Italy), the Chernobyl nuclear disaster
in the Soviet Union, the 50 million liters of petroleum spill
in Alaska by the ship Exxon Valdez, the deliberate burning
of oil wells during the Gulf War. These tragedies make it
clear to all mankind urgent actions ought to be taken to
respect the environment. Consequently, from the 1970’s,
a series of events occurred, including reports, protocols,
conventions, resolutions, conferences, assemblies, treaties, summit meetings and agreements resulting in statements to be assumed in international agency forums and
even UNESCO. Among the vital issues considered, the
following are highlighted: the environment, growth limits,
wild species extinction danger, ozone layer destruction,
sustainable development, climate change, chemical
weapons convention, the struggle against desertification,
nuclear tests ban and the implementation of Agenda 21
(UNEP, 2002).
During this paradigm breaking period and great
environmental impact caused by industrial activity, it
was thought that contaminant agents were essentially of
anthropogenic origin.
Nevertheless, with the evolution of studies, it was
also established that substances of natural origin such
as asbestos, radon, mercury, arsenic and crystalline
silica were noxious to human beings when used without
security criteria (Geotimes Staff, 2001). Furthermore,
population statistics indicated a high correlation between endemic areas and specific geologic structures
such as mining zones and certain litho-structural features. The results indicated, for instance, skin cancer
incidences related both to arsenic of the carboniferous
– 55 –
Risks to health from organic substances
zones in China, and to the pyritic zones in Bangladesh (Fazal & Kuwushi, 2001). In Brazil there is an
incidence of fluorosis in zones in Paraná State (Licht,
2001), where the water supply is based on fluoride rich
groundwater extraction. At the end of the 20th century,
many nations, especially those most developed, such
as England, Finland and France, started to map their
territories to know the real potential of natural elements
and obtain basic data to assess their risks to living
organisms.
The evaluation of substances and elements affecting
public health and their behavioral and distribution processes, including environmental management, is today
the assignment of Medical Geology, which was created
in the last century and is undergoing strong development
in this 21st century. Medical Geology concentrates mainly
on the knowledge of natural risk sources to health and
human well-being, thus contributing to prevent diseases
caused by excesses or shortages of given substances
and elements in the geological substrate (Moeller, 1997,
Cunha et al., 1997). In short, Medical Geology seeks to
understand of the correlation and interactions between
geological, physical and biological processes of the Earth
system (Sigh, 2000).
THE ORGANIC SUBSTANCES APPROACH IN
MEDICAL GEOLOGY
Although the classical Medical Geology approach
takes into account the inorganic elements and substances
because of their noxious effects provoked in living beings,
as is the case of mercury, arsenic, lead, fluorine, selenium,
zinc, aluminum, cadmium, asbestos, silica and others
(Oliveira et al., 2002, Pinese et al., 2002), the natural
organic substances have been presented as responsible for many troubles that affect living beings as well
(ATSDR, 2001, WHO, 2000). Many of these substances,
such as benzene, benzopyrene, polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons in general (PCAs), including benzofluoranten, together with some of the inorganic substances
mentioned above, appear in the list of the 20 most toxic
substances according to the Agency for Toxic Substances
and Disease Registry – ATSDR. Natural organic contamination such as the groundwater rich in BTEX (benzene,
toluene, ethyl-benzene and xylene) found in aquifers next
to oil fields, oil and gases exudations existing abundantly
in the region of the Mexican Gulf among others, phenol
rich waters found in coal mines, hydrocarbons released
by mud volcanoes, organic contaminations carried by
intercontinental sand storms, are all significant examples
for study in the field of Medical Geology (Bandeira et al.,
2004, Bandeira & Françolin, 2003). Finally, one should
remember that many organic substances are responsible
for asphyxia processes, toxicity, respiratory system attacks, cancer and even death.
UNDERSTANDING THE INTERRELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN THE DIFFERENT SPHERES ON EARTH
The Earth can be divided in four main domain
spheres: geosphere, hydrosphere, atmosphere, biosphere (Larocque & Rasmussen, 1998). These domains
are interconnected through physical, chemical and
biological processes (Figure 1). The geosphere is the
original source of the entire planet matter except for the
mass originated in space as meteors or cosmic dust.
Exchanges occur between the geosphere and the hydrosphere, biosphere and atmosphere domains, as well as
the relationships interconnecting the geosphere and the
atmosphere. The organic compounds contribution has
its main origin in aerosol emanations, volcanic gases including those originated in mud volcanoes, gaseous
hydrocarbons and vapors originated in sedimentary
basins through natural seeps, and intercontinental sand
storms. From the geosphere to the hydrosphere there
are the organic products from the chemical weathering
of mineral substances such as coal phenols and solid,
liquid and gaseous hydrocarbons.
The relationship between the hydrosphere and
biosphere occurs through the consumption and excretion of organic products by animals and vegetables
that live in an aqueous environment. These products
include the chemosynthetic communities found in the
bathyal seep zones rich in gaseous hydrocarbons, from
oil producing basins of the geosphere (Mbari, 2005,
Dunaway, 2005).
The biosphere and the atmosphere relate to each
other through the burning of biomass and the biogenic
aerosols with biogenic hydrocarbons. The hydrosphere
and the atmosphere are connected through marine
aerosols, the rain and also through gaseous hydrocarbons and vapors that are released from hydrocarbon
enriched zones. In fact, the atmosphere is the pathway
of many nutrients such as nitrates, ammonium, nitrogen organic compounds and other bioactive elements
(Solas, 2004).
EFFECTS OF ORGANIC PRODUCTS
AND THEIR ORIGINS
The list of anthropogenic organic products that are
harmful to living beings is immense and every day new
ones are produced. However, this study focuses on the
principal organic substances from geological sources.
These substances can either have a gradual continuous action, like gas hydrates, aerosols and hydrocarbon
seeps, or, a catastrophic and often lethal impact as in
the case of sand storms, volcanoes and mud volcanoes.
The main natural organic products and their respective
effects of organic substances on living beings is shown
in Table 1.
– 56 –
Carlos Siqueira Bandeira de Mello
Figure 1 – Relationships between the earth’s domain spheres
Table 1 - Effects caused by organic substances and their natural sources
Product
BENZENE
Effects
Natural Sources
Dizziness, drowsiness, loss of
consciousness. Long
exposures cause effects on
bone marrow and anemia and
leukemia. Death.
Petroleum systems in
general. (Uinta Basin USA).
References
ASTDR (2001)
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts3.html
BTEX (benzene,
toluene, ethylbenzene, xylenes)
Effects on liver, kidneys, heart and lungs.
Acute toxicity for aquatic life. Skin irritation
and nervous system depression.
CARBON DIOXIDE
Asphyxia. Greenhouse effect.
PHENOLS
Liver damage, diarrhea, hemolytic anemia.
METHANE (C1)
Fossil fuels in genAsphyxia. Greenhouse effect. Ability to aceral (oil, gas and coal).
cumulate 21 times more heat p/molecule
Seeps, volcanoes, mud
than CO2.
volcanoes.
NAPHTHALENE
Destruction or damage to red blood cells.
Fossil fuels (Oil, gas and ASTDR (2001) http://www.
atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts115.html
coal).
POLYCYCLIC
AROMATICS
(PAHS)
Some are carcinogenic if inhaled.
Volcanoes, dust particles
petroleum systems,
sandstorms
Volcanoes and mud
volcanoes.
ASTDR (2001)
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts67.html
Coal Mines
– 57 –
NIOSH – National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
http://www.skcinc.com/nioshdbs/rtecs/
pa16bc50.htm#W
ASTDR (2001) http://www.
atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts69.html
Risks to health from organic substances
Aerosols
Global aerosols are composed of multiple components such as dusts from windstorms (crustal elements);
biomass smoke (organic); marine salts (NaCl); biogenic
(sulfate and organic); volcanic (sulphuric acid and diverse
gases) and industrial urban fogs (Husar et al., 2001). Each
aerosol component has specific sources and peculiarities,
occurring in a particular region and at preferential strata.
Some aerosols occur naturally following sandstorms,
volcanoes, fires and oceanic sprays (NASA, 2001).
Sands Storms
Most sediments carried by “sand” storms are, in fact,
less than silt-size granulometry. They affect crops, people,
villages, climates and can have an intercontinental character. In 1971 the planet Mars was entirely covered by
a sandstorm. This phenomenon, repeated in 2001, was
observed and photographed with the Hubble telescope
(NASA, 2001). Atmospheric temperatures were affected
during such storms both through absorption and reflection of solar radiation by the particles. Marine primary
products influence the climate with consequences on
the engendered cloud convection activities. When a
sandstorm originates in a region of dry lakes it produces
a high salinity environment. The resulting particles are
harmful to the lungs. The high incidence of respiratory
diseases in the recently exposed Aral Sea area may be
linked to these kinds of sandstorms.
To Meskhidze (2005) sandstorms are not always
a source of pollutants. They may also contribute to the
formation of nutrients in oceanic zones. The process
occurs when a sandstorm containing dusts rich in iron
oxides passes over an industrialized area. Under special
circumstances sulfur dioxide and several types of acid
may be captured. Continuing over an oceanic area, the
iron may suffer reduction through chemical reactions and
transform into soluble iron, which will help form micronutrients for the marine phytoplankton.
Nowadays, scientists study the types of reactions
that may occur during sandstorms which, in many
cases, can travel thousands of kilometers. In April
1988, a sandstorm removed fine sediments from the
Gobi desert in Mongolia and the polluted industrial area
in China. Having crossed the Pacific Ocean, it covered
25% of North America – Canada and United States
(Guo et al., 2004). The phenomenon occurred again
in 2001 when NASA satellites detected a dust cloud
larger than 2,000 km. Originating in China, covering
Japan and North Korea, crossing the Pacific Ocean
and reaching North America, from Alaska to Florida,
it spread dust and contaminants from one continent
to another. Tracking the dust cloud revealed, though
it passed over China and Mongolia, it had, in fact,
originated in Siberia. Satellites also observed that between April 6-9, millions of tons of dust from the Takla
Makan deserts in China and the Gobi in Mongolia were
transported away. On April 7 the Baicheng streets, in
Jilin Province, Northern China, were covered by a thick
dust cloud (NASA, 2001).
In 2004, scientists from Hong Kong and Chinese
universities studied 18 samples from three different sandstorms in 2002 in Qingdao village – China. The chemical
analyses revealed that besides elements from the Earth’s
crust, organic compounds such as phenanthrene, fluoranthene, pyrene, benzopyrene, benzofluoranthene,
perylene, anthracene and coronene were also detected.
Through the carbon preference index (CPI) and other
analyses, Guo et al., (2004) concluded that they were
petroleum residuals originated from anthropogenic contributions that included aromatic polycyclic, fatty acids,
as well as hydrocarbons from vehicles. They also detected organic products related to waxy plants probably
originated from the abrasion of the storm particulates in
contact with the leaf cover.
In the Middle East deserts, sandstorms happen most
frequently between April and May. On April 26, 2005 the
air force base of Al Asad, in Iraq, was struck by a heavy
sandstorm. The dust cloud front progressed at a speed
estimated at 60 miles/hour. In May 2005, the dust clouds
from the Sahara reached the Canary Islands and more
distant areas situated in Europe and the Amazon Region.
In the latter, it was estimated that the total dust originated
in the Sahara every year lay between 20-50 kg per hectare
(Artaxo et al., 2004).
Besides the possible consequences to eyes and
lungs caused by the particulates, sandstorms help
disseminate microorganisms. In Sub-Saharan Africa, it
was observed that the bacteria causing cerebrospinal
meningitis (inflammation of the spinal marrow or of the
brain) develop more during certain year periods when
sandstorms occur coinciding with the low rain and
humidity season (FAPESP, 2005). Facing this reality,
doctors have been researching the large dust clouds
that were triggered in the Sahara desert and reached
many African countries, using the European Space
Agency (ESA) satellites. This weekly monitoring task
seeks to discover possible connections between the
dust and epidemics.
Until recently UV rays were supposed as lethal to
the microorganisms found in sandstorms. However,
observations do not support this hypothesis in reality. In
England a direct relation has been established between
sandstorms and the viral foot-and-mouth disease, which
affects domestic livestock, and which has sometimes
been mistaken for mad cow disease (Mckie, 2001). Also
the disease occurring in Caribbean sea corals has been
identified as caused by a fungi commonly found in soils,
namely the Aspergillus sydo-wii. Since this fungus does
not multiply in sea water, its origin depends on a fresh
source of continuous soil spreading, which occurs through
– 58 –
Carlos Siqueira Bandeira de Mello
Mud Volcanoes
Mud volcanoes originate in petroleum and gas rich
zones forming structures of tens of meters in height
and diameter, with the expulsion of solid and gaseous
material provoking the deposition of breccia and gas
ignition. During each eruption hundreds of tons of mud
and millions of cubic meters of gases are expelled,
usually in the form of huge flaming mushrooms (Table
2). Such explosions have been registered since 1882.
The last big explosion was in 2001. After the explosive
event the volcano usually becomes dormant, a stage
that can last for decades. During this stage it continues
to pour mud, gases and petroleum in structures called
gryphons that are situated inside or near the main crater.
In some volcanoes there are also circular structures that
expel salty water and gas, called salsas. There are more
than 700 mud volcanoes in the world distributed in 25
countries. Most of them are situated in Azerbaijan (“fire
country” in the Azeri language) and nearby regions that
include the Caspian Sea region (Françolin, 2002). The
hydrocarbons can burn for several days and involve
colossal gas volumes, generating flames hundreds of
meters high. In 1947, some 500 million cubic meters
of gas were ejected into the atmosphere during the
Tourogay mud volcano eruption. During their dormant
period the total of gas emitted by the Charagan and
Dashgil mud volcanoes was, respectively, to 44,000
m³/year and 165,000 m³/years (Akper, 2003) The most
serious accidents with people and animals are due to
the colorless methane flame and its sudden spontaneous ignition.
The Caspian Sea, around Baku, capital of Azerbaijan,
usually has a hydrocarbon film on its surface due to the
mud volcanoes and also to faulty piping formerly used in
oil and gas exploration (Françolin, 2002).
Table 2 - Mean gas content of various volcanoes in Azerbaijan
(Akper, F., 2003).
– 59 –
Gases
Volcanoes
Volcanoes generally occur explosively and spread
chemical products and substances from the planet’s
interior over the Earth’s surface. In June 1991 the Pinatubo volcano in the Philippines, ejected 42 million tons
of carbonic gas, great amounts of rocks, water and
sulphates as well as smaller, though significant, quantities of chlorides and heavy metals such as zinc, copper,
chrome, lead, nickel, cadmium and mercury (Terrence
et al., 1996). The aerosols originated from that explosion
affected the global climate for 3 years (Gerlach, 1996;
Selinus, 2004).
Volcanic explosions can project large quantities
of fragments, dusts and gases to great altitudes. On
October 1, 1994 NASA satellites detected an eruption
of the Klyuchevskaya volcano, situated 4,750 meters
above sea level, in Russia. The contamination plume
reached an altitude between 10 and 14km (NASA, 2005).
The Tambora volcano eruption in 1815 on the island of
Sumbawa, Indonesia, ejected about 100km³ rocks into
the atmosphere and the average temperature in central
England decreased by about 4.5o F. The main emission of
the Etna volcano, in Italy, is carbonic gas, but important
methane emissions are also present (Veschetti et al.,
1999 and Pecoraino & Giammanco, 1998). There are
volcanoes that emit sulphidric gas, which can provoke
serious effects on human health. Also, there are reports
of health risks caused by volcanic pollution in Hawaii,
where there is a relationship between mortality rates
and the distance from eruptions and gases (Grattan et
al., 2002, 2003).
(Methane)
C1
(Nitrogen)
N2
(Carbonic gas)
CO2
(Ethane)
C2
Percentage
sandstorms that have happened in the region (Pohl, 2003
and Goudie et al., 2004).
In dry regions of the USA and Mexico a disease
caused by the Coccidioides immitis fungus, the coccidioidomycosis or valley fever, often endangers the
respiratory system of people, cattle, dogs, horses, llamas
and, sometimes, cats through infections (Finkelman,
2001, Deaner & Einswtein, 1999). The disease presents
a granulomatous form in the respiratory system and,
secondarily, disseminates in the entire organism, affecting
especially skin, bones, articulations and the meninges
(Costa, 2003). The fungi vegetative life stage presents
two types of mycelia that, reaching the lungs transform in
spongean or coccidian spheres (Kuhl, et al.,1995). Many
endospores develop and the spheres are capable of
producing new spherules that constitute the saprophytic
stage of the disease. The dissemination and the most
severe cases of the disease usually occur in the aftermath
of earthquakes, when the removed soils are taken by the
wind as dust, reaching great distances, as occurred in
Northridge in 1994. In some situations the disease can
be lethal (Williams et al., 1979).
As a consequence, sandstorms have the capability
to transport both the organic versus inorganic contaminations naturally found in nature, and those of anthropogenic
origin as well. The storm field has been the target of
many studies which are being carried out by concerned
governmental agencies of several nations.
84.0
9.0
5.0
2.0
Risks to health from organic substances
Gas Hydrates
Also known as clathrates (from Latin – cage), they
resemble compact snow or ice and are, in reality, a crystalline structure composed of 46 water molecules and 8
gas molecules, with a predominance of methane (REDQ,
2002), or other gases with low molecular weight such as
ethane, propane and also carbon dioxide (Sloan, 1998
and Clennell, 2000). Methane can have a thermogenetic
as well as biogenic formation. In the biogenic case,
it comes mainly from the initial diagenesis stages of
organic matter and may be part of the hydrates found
in continental shelf sediments. There are also biogenic
gases that proceed from the bacterial decay originated
in petroleum reserves. In the thermogenetic case,
methane relates to gas fields situated in sedimentary
basins. Geologically, hydrate gases may occur in two
distinct situations, namely in marine shelf sediments of
worldwide distribution or in onshore polar regions situated beneath the polar ice layer (permafrost). Under
appropriate pressure, the hydrates may exist in temperatures significantly above the water freezing point.
On the other hand, the maximum temperature for the gas
hydrate existence depends on the gas composition and
its resident pressure. Methane, for example, in the presence of water with 600 psia forms hydrates at 5oC. At
this same pressure, if the composition has 1% propane,
it can form gas hydrates at 10oC. Other factors such as
salinity can also influence the hydrates (Edmonds et al.,
1996). According to Kvenvolden (1993), the amount of
gas contained in a cubic meter of hydrate, when dissociated in the atmosphere under normal temperature
and pressure conditions, may form 164 m³ of natural
gas and 0.8 m³ of water.
Methane is listed in the Kyoto protocol as one of the
6 gases that cause the greenhouse effect. The potential
of a gas to build the greenhouse effect depends on its nature and respective life time in the atmosphere. Thus, the
methane global warming potential for 20 years (GWP20)
is 62 times higher than CO2, whereas its potential for 100
years (GWP100) is only 23 times higher (UKERC, 2004).
In fact, methane has the capacity to accumulate 21 times
more heat per molecule than CO2, though proportionally it
occurs in smaller amounts. In England, in 2002, methane
with a much lower percentage than carbonic gas was
responsible for 7% of the greenhouse effect, compared
to 84% of CO2 (UKERC, 2004).
The amount of potential energy generated by the
methane in hydrates worldwide, far from being negligible,
is equivalent to twice the energy of the fossil fuels found up
to the present (Clennell, 2000). In the United States alone,
the United States Geologic Survey – USGS - has estimated
the existence of 600 trillion m³ of methane, which would
be enough to supply the nation for 2000 years - (REDQ,
2002). The detection of hydrates is usually made through
seismic profiling, geochemical and drilling surveys. The
largest hydrates deposits are situated in Alaska, in the
Mackenzie delta, on the Canadian archipelago, in the
Siberian Basin and the Vilyuy Basin in Russia. In Brazil
hydrates are reported in the Pelotas and Amazon Basins
(Clenell, 2000).
Hydrocarbon seeps
Seeps are natural hydrocarbons leakages evident
on the surface originated from gas and oil fields in
sedimentary basins. They can occur both on the seabed
and on the continent. On the coast of California alone,
there are more than 2,000 natural seeps. The largest
seep is situated in the town of Santa Barbara where
100 oil barrels and 2 million m³ gas are collected daily
(WSPA, 2001). In the seep called Coal Oil Point, near
Santa Barbara (Table 3) 16,400 m³ of hydrocarbons,
predominantly methane, are produced daily (Washburn, 1998). The methane collection zone is situated in
a 70-meter deep water table and is the main source of
atmospheric pollution in that town. The hydrocarbons
found there contain reactive organic gases (ROGs) that
are the precursors of ozone. The oil seeps bring to the
surface benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene and xylene
(BTEX) contaminations endangering the marine biota. In
addition, the gaseous seeps emit gases that contribute
to the greenhouse effect.
Table 3 - Composition of the gases of the Coal Oil Point Seep
(Washburn, 1998).
Gaseous components
Percentage
(methane) C1
87.5
(ethane) C2
5.1
(propane) C3
3.1
(butane) C4
1.3
(carbonic gas) CO2
1.3
(nitrogen) N2
0.8
(pentane) C5
0.5
(hexane) C6+
0.3
(oxygen) O2
0.1
CONCLUSIONS
The organic products of non-anthropogenic origin
can also affect the health of living organisms, influence
the climate, contribute to the greenhouse effect and affect
the ozone concentrations on the planet.
The amount of natural organic products generated
in geological activities in the environment through aerosols, sandstorms, volcanoes, mud volcanoes, hydrates
and seeps must be taken into account by the scientific
community and be carefully studied, especially through
Medical Geology.
– 60 –
Carlos Siqueira Bandeira de Mello
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are grateful to Dr. Luiz Antonio F. Trindade, geochemistry manager of CENPES/Petrobras, for his encouragement and to our colleague Joelma P. Lopes of COPPE/
UFRJ, for her important corrections and suggestions.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ALLCHIN, D. The Poisoning of Minamata. [Minneapolis]:
Ships Resource Center University of Minnesota,
2002. (Ethics & Environment).
AKPER, F. Geological Conditions and Peculiarities of
the Mud Volcanoes Formation. In: AAPG ANNUAL
CONVENTION, 2003, Salt Lake City, Utah. [Trabalhos
apresentados]. [Slat Lake City]: AAPG, 2003.
ARTAXO, P.; PAULIQUEVIS, T.M.; RIZZO, L. V.; LARA,
L.L. Environmental implications of aerosol particles
in the Amazonian atmosphere: results from the LBA
experiment. In: INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
ENVIRONMENTAL GEOCHEMISTRY IN TROPICAL
COUNTRIES, 4., 2004, Buzios, RJ. Abstract. Rio de
Janeiro: [s.n.], 2004.
BANDEIRA, C.S.; FRANCOLIN, J. B. L. Study of oil spills
and seeps using geological profiles in a river from the
Negro basin, Amazon rain forest, Brazil. In: INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ENVIRONMENT 2010:
situation and perspectives for the European Union,
2003, Porto, Portugal. [Trabalhos apresentados].
[S.l.: s.n.], 2003.
BANDEIRA, C.S.; GRACIANO, J.; MENEZES, R. M. 4.
The importance of the inclusion of natural organic
substances in geomedicine. In: INTERNATIONAL
SYMPOSIUM ON ENVIRONMENTAL
GEOCHEMISTRY IN TROPICAL COUNTRIES, 4., 2004,
Buzios, RJ. [Trabalhos apresentados]. Rio de Janeiro: [s.n.], 2004.
BHOPAL: o desastre continua (1984-2002). Disponível em:
<http://www.greenpeace.org.br/toxicos/pdf/ bhopal_
desastrecont.pdf>. Acesso em: 04 ago. 2006.
CARSON, R. Silent Spring. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1962.
CLENNELL, M. B. Hidrato de gás submarino: natureza,
ocorrência e perspectivas para exploração na
margem continental brasileira. Revista Brasileira de
Geofísica, São Paulo, v. 18, n. 3, 2000. Disponível em:
<http://http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_
arttext&pid=S0102-261X2000000300013>. Acesso
em: 04 ago. 2006.
COSTA, A.B. Fungo pode comprometer saúde de quem
trabalha com o solo. Com Ciência, Campinas,
out./2003. Disponível em: <http://www.comciencia.
br/200412/busca/ framebusca.htm>. Acesso em:
jul. 2006.
CUNHA, F. G.; BANDEIRA, C.S.; MACHADO, G. J. The
application of geochemical data to environmental
concern in the Minas Gerais State, Brazil. INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
ENVIRONMENTAL GEOCHEMISTRY, 4., 1997, Vail, Colorado. [Proceedings]. [S.l.: s.n.], 1997.
DEANER, R.M.; EINSTEIN, H. Valley fever: a primer for
non-medical people. Disponível em: < http://www.
valleyfever.com/primer.htm>. Acesso em: 04 ago.
2006.
DILLON, W. Gas (Methane) Hydrates: a new frontier. (U.S.
Geological Survey. Marine and Coastal Geology
Program). Disponível em: <http://marine.usgs.gov/
fact- sheets/gas-hydrates/title.html>.Acesso em: 04
ago. 2006.
DUNAWAY, M. E. Biological communities near natural oil
and gas seeps. Disponível em: <http://www.mms.
gov/omm/pacific/enviro/seeps2.html>. Acesso em:
04 ago.2006.
EARTH materials and public health. Geotimes, Alexandria,
Va, nov. 2001. Disponível em: <http://www.agiweb.
org/geotimes/nov01/feature_earthsubst.html>.
Acesso em: 04 ago. 2006.5
EDMONDS, B.; MOORWOOD R.; SZCZEPANKSKY, R.
.A practical model for the effect of salinity on gas
hydrate formation: SPE Paper 35569. [S.l.]: Society
of Petroleum Engineers, 1996.
ENVIRONMENTAL Health Indicators: development of a
methodology for the WHO - World Health Organization, European Region, Interim Report, Euro Publication EUR/00/ 5026344. [S.l.]: WHO, 2000.
ESTADOS UNIDOS. Agency for Toxic Substances and Desease Registry. Top 20 hazardous substances from
the CERCLA priority list of hazardous substances
for 2001. Atlanta, GA, 2001.
ESTADOS UNIDOS. Agency for Toxic Substances and
Desease Registry. Phenol. Atlanta, GA, 2001.
ESTADOS UNIDOS. Agency for Toxic Substances and
Desease Registry. Naphthalene. Atlanta, GA,
2001.
FAZAL, A.; KAWACHI, T. Extend and severity of
groundwater arsenic contamination in Bangladesh. Water International, Urbana, IL, v. 25, n.
3, p.370-379, Sep. 2001. Disponível em: <http://
www.sos-arsenic. net/english/contamin/>. Acesso
em: 04 ago. 2006.
FINKELMAN, R. B.;SKINNER, C. W.; PLUMLEE, G. S.;
BUNNELL, J. E. Medical Geology. Geotimes, Alexandria, Va, nov. 2001.
FRANÇOLIN, J. B. L. Relatório de viagem ao Azerbaijão:
relatório interno. Rio de Janeiro: CENPES/PETROBRAS RVGE 005/02, 2002. 27 p.
GAS hydrates and cold sweeps. [S.l.]: MBARI, 2005. Disponível em: <http://www.mbari.org/volcanism/Margin/
Marg-Hydrates.htm>. Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
GERLACH, T.M.; WESTRICH, H.R.; SYMONDS, R.B.
Pre-eruption vapor in magma of the climatic
– 61 –
Risks to health from organic substances
Mount Pinatubo eruption: source of the giant
stratospheric sulfur dioxide cloud. Disponível em:
<http://vulcan.wr.usgs.gov/Projects/Emissions/
Reports/Pinatubo/pinatubo_abs.html>. Acesso
em: 07 ago. 2006.
GIAMMANCO, S.; OTTAVIANI, M.; VALENZA, M.; VESCHETTI, E.; PRINCIPIO, E.; GIAMMANCO, G.;
PIGNATO, S. Major and trace elements geochemistry
in the ground waters of a volcanic area: Mount Etna
(Sicily, Italy). Water Research, Oxford, v. 32, n. 1, p.
19-30, 1998.
GRATTAN, J.P.; DURAND, M. Distant volcanic eruptions, human health and morality. In: RAYNAL, J.P.;
ALBORE-LIVADIE, C.; PIPERNO, M. (Ed.). Humans
and volcanoes. [S.l.]: Arhéo-Logis/CDERAD; Goudet, 2002. p. 15-22. ISBN 2-9517138-2-7.
GRATTAN, J.P.; DURAND, M.; TAYLOR, S. Illness and
elevated human mortality coincident with volcanic
eruptions. In: OPPENHEIMER, C.; PYLE, D.M.;
BARCLAY, J. (Ed.). Volcanic degassing. London:
Geological Society, 2003. P. 401-414. (GSL Special
Publications, 213).
GOUDIE, A., S.; LANCASTER, N.; VANCE, R. E.;
BROOKS, N.; TAYLOR, G. Dust transport: geoindicator. Disponível em: <http://www.lgt.lt/geoin/doc.
php?did=cl_dustra>. Acesso em: 04 ago. 2004.
GUO, Z. G.; FENG, J. L.; FANG, M.; CHEN, H. Y. L.; LAU,
K. H. The elemental and organic characteristics of
PM2.5 in Asian dust episodes in Qingdao, China,
2002. Atmospheric Environment, Oxford, v. 38, n.
6, p. 909-919, Feb. 2004.
HARDIN, G. The tragedy of the commons. Science, [S.l.],
v. 162, n. 3859, p. 1243-1248, Dec. 1968. Disponível
em: <http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/
full/162/3859/1243> Acesso em: 07 aogo. 2006.
HIDRATOS de metano: o combustível do fututro ou
uma ameaça à humanidade? QMCWEB Revista
Eletrônica do Departamento de Química - UFSC,
Florianópolis, n. 26, 20 abr. 2000. Disponível em:
<http:/quark.qmc.ufsc.br/qmcweb/artigos/hidratos_metano.html>. Acesso em 07 ago. 2006.
HUSAR, et al. Asian dust evens of April 1998, J. Geophys.
Res., Richmond, Va., v. 106, 2001.
INTEGRAÇÃO entre o meio ambiente e o desenvolvimento: 1972- 2002: capítulo 1. Disponível em: <http://
www2.Ibama.gov.br/~geobr/geo3-port/geo3port/
capitulo1.pdf>. Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
IMGA – International Medical Geology Association, 2004.
Disponível em: <http://www.medicalgeology.org/>.
Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
KUHL, I. A.; KUHL, G.; LONDERO, A.; DIÓGENES, M. J.
N.; FERREIRA, M. F. Coccidioidomycosis laríngea:
relato de caso. Revista Brasileira de Otorrinolaringologia – RBORL, [S.l.], v. 62, ed. 1, p. 48-52, jan./
fev. 1996. ISSN 1806-9312. Disponível em: <http://
rborl.org.br/acervo/acervo.asp?id=2159>. Acesso
em: 07 ago. 2006.
KVENVOLDEN, K. A. Gas hydrate as a potential energy
resource: a review of their methane content. In: D. G.
Howell (Ed). The future of energy gases. Washington:
United States Government Printing Office, 1993. p. 555561. (U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1570).
KVENVOLDEN, K. A. A primer on as hydrates. In: D.G.
Howell (Ed). The future of energy gases. Washington:
United States Government Printing Office, 1993.
P.279-291. (U.S. Geological Survey Propfessional
Paper 1570).
LAROCQUE, A. C. L.; RASMUSSEN, P. E. Environmental
Geology , Berlin, v. 33, n.2-3, Feb. 1998.
LICHT, O. A. B. A geoquímica multielementar na gestão
ambiental. 2001. 236 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geologia Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia, Universidade do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
MCKIE, R., 2001. Deadly dust ‘brought foot and mouth
here’: viruses were carried to Britain in a storm from
the Sahara, claim scientists: special report foot
and mouth disease. Disponível em: <http://www.
guardian.co.uk/footandmouth/story/0,7369,%20
549041,00.html>. Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006. The
Observer. Sunday September 9.
MESKHIDZE, N. Pollution can convert airborne iron into
soluble form required for phytoplankton growth. Science Daily. [S.l.], 2005. Disponível e: <http://www.
sciencedaily.com/releaes/2005/02/050213130304.
htm>. Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
MOELLER, D.W. 1997. Environmental health. Cambridge,
Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1997.
NATURAL hazards: eruption of Klyuchevskaya volcano.
[S.l.]: Earth Observatory NASA, 2005. Disponível em:
<http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/NaturalHazards/
natural_hazards_v2.php3?img_id=12754>. Acesso
em: 07 ago. 2006.
OLIVEIRA, S. M. B.; LARIZZATI, J. H.; FAVARO, D. I. T.
Comportamento do mercúrio e outros elementostraço em solos lateríticos da província aurífera do
Tapajós. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 41.: a geologia e o homem, 2002, João
Pessoa. Anais. João Pessoa: Sociedade Brasileira
de Geologia, 2002.
PERIGOSAS nuvens de pó. In: AGÊNCIA FAPESP. 2006.
Disponível em: http://www.fapesp.br/agencia/boletim_dentro.php?data[id_materia_boletim]=3713>.
Acesso em: 04 ago. 2006.
PINESE, J. P. P.; ALVES, J. C.; LICHT, O. A. B.; PIRES,
E.O.; MARAFON, E. Características geoquímicas
naturais da água de abastecimento público da
porção extremo norte do Estado do Paraná, Brasil.
In:CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 41.:
a geologia e o homem. Anais. João Pessoa: Sociedade Brasileira de Geologia, 2002.
– 62 –
Carlos Siqueira Bandeira de Mello
POHL, O. Disease dustup: dust clouds may carry infectious organisms across oceans. [S.l.], Scientific
American, jul. 2003. Disponível em: <http://www.
sciam.com/article.cfm?articleID=000ECFD9-15AB1EE1-A2D1809EC5880000>.
SINGH, H. Theoretical basis for medical geology.
Disponível em: <http://home.swipnet.se/medicalgeology/PDF/MedGeo.pdf>. Acesso em: 07
ago. 2006.
SLOAN, E.D. Clathrate hydrates of natural gas. 2nd ed.
New York: Marcel Dekker, 1998. 436 p.
THE PERFECT dust storm strikes Mars. [S.l.]: Science
NASA, 2001. Disponível em: <http://science.nasa.
gov/headlines/y2001/ast11oct_2.htm>. Acesso em:
07 ago. 2006.
THE REGISTRY of toxic effects of chemical substances,
methane: RTECS#:PA1490000, CAS# 74-82-8.
[S.l.]: National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health, 2000. Disponível em: <http://www.skcinc.
com/nioshdbs/ rtecs/pa16bc50.htm>. Aceso em:
07 ago. 2006.
US SOLAS Working Group 4 report: atmosphere impacts on marine biogeochemical processes. [S.l.],
2004. Disponível em: <http://www.google.com.br/
search?hl=pt-BR&q=solas+The+atmosphere+is+
a+source+or+a+transport+path+for+many+differ
ent+nutrients+&btnG= Pesquisar&meta=>. Acesso
em: 07 ago. 2006.
UK ENERGY RESEARCH CENTRE (UKERK) SEMINAR:
”Workable metrics for the EU emissions trading
scheme”, 2004, Oxford. Proceedings. Disponível
em: <http://www.Eci.ox.ac.uk//pdfdownload/energy/
workablemetricsproceedings.pdf>. Acesso em: 07
ago. 2006.
VESCHETTI, E.; FERRARI, C.; MINELLI, L.; OTTAVIANI, M.;
GIAMMANCO, S.; VALENZA, M.; GIAMMANCO, G.;
PIGNATO, S. Monitoraggio della qualità delle acque
sotterranee del Monte Etna: risultati preliminari. Acqua & Aria, Milano, n. 5, p. 77-86, 1999.
WILLIAMS PL, SABLE DL, MENDEZ P, SMYTH LT.,
1979. Symptomatic coccidioidomycosis following a severe natural dust storm. An outbreak at
the Naval Air Station, Lemoore, Calif. Chest. 1979
Nov.76 (5):566-70. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&li
st_uids=498830&dopt=Abstract.
WSPA, 2001. Natural Oil and gas seeps on the Central
Coast. http://www.wspa.org/cra_naturalseeps.htm.
– 63 –
HUM AN EXPOSURE
TO ARSENIC
IN BRAZIL
¹Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicam.br
²Ricardo Perobelli Borba, borba@iac.sp.gov.br
³Rômulo Simões Angélica, rsa@ige.unicamp.br
¹Agronomic Institute of Campinas - UNICAMP
³Geosciences Center - UFPA
INTRODUCTION
There has been a growing concern of scientists
and public opinion regarding arsenic contamination of
humans since the disclosure of the tragedies in West
Bengal, Bangladesh, Mexico and other countries. There
is very little reference in the literature to Brazil in respect
of human and environmental exposure to arsenic due to
the lack of research on this subject in the country. Arsenic
is a metalloid of low mean concentration on the Earth’s
crust (1.8 ppm) and it occurs in different types of mineral
deposits, mainly as arsenopyrite (FeAsS) and arseniferous pyrite. These mineral phases can be altered to arsenates and sulfo-arsenates on the surface, the arsenic
can be partially released to water and also immobilized
via adsorption in iron oxides-hydroxides, aluminum and
manganese or in clay minerals.
In water, the most common forms are As(V) oxyanions
in high to moderate Eh conditions, and As(III) in more
reducing conditions. The As concentration in drinking
water, according to the World Health Organization, should
not exceed 10 mg/L. This value was also adopted by the
Brazilian Ministry of the Environment for surface water
suitable for treatment for human consumption, according to Resolution 357 of CONAMA March 17 2005 (http://
www.mma.gov.br/port/conama/res/res05/res35705.pdf).
Arsenic is a carcinogenic substance and its inorganic
form is the most harmful to humans. The As(III) species
toxicity is considered to be several times higher than the
As(V) species. The most common human exposure path is
through contaminated water consumption but gas inhalation and dust ingestion may also be important. Chronic
As exposure can cause serious metabolic problems in
people, including hyperkeratosis, skin cancer, lung cancer, nervous system disorders, increased frequency of
spontaneous abortions and other serious body disorders
(Abernathy et al., 1997).
The most serious cases of arsenic intoxication occurred in West Bengal, Bangladesh and, in Latin America,
in Mexico, Chile and Argentina. Those cases were principally caused by contaminated groundwater consumption,
pumped from regional aquifers formed by arseniferous
geological formations (Smedley & Kinniburgh, 2002).
To date, integrated studies on environment and human
exposure to arsenic have only been carried out in three
areas in Brazil. These areas are indicated in Figure 1: (i) the
Quadrilátero Ferrífero, in Minas Gerais, where a large quantity of arsenic has been released to drainages, soils and the
atmosphere as a result of centuries long gold mining; (ii)
the Ribeira Valley, in Paraná and São Paulo, where arsenic
was released to the environment from mining activities
and metal refining in the Upper Valley and also, naturally,
through rock weathering and the formation of arsenic rich
soils in the Middle Valley; (iii) Santana, in Amapá, where
the arsenic was associated with the manganese ore mined
from the Serra do Navio over the last 50 years.
The human exposure evaluation studies carried out
in these 3 areas included As concentrations analyses in
children and adult urine in 5 towns of the Ribeira Valley
and 2 towns in the Quadrilátero Ferrífero area, as well as
– 64 –
Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo
Figure 1 – Situation map of the study areas and geologic-tectonic unities of Brazil.
As detection in hair and blood samples from Santana
inhabitants.
On the other hand, integrated studies of nonpoint
sources of arsenic, such as geologic formations or large
shallow aquifers, described in other parts of the world
(Smedley & Kinniburgh, 2002), have never been carried
out in Brazil.
This study seeks to gather the available information
on these 3 contaminated areas and other As occurrences
taken from literature. Furthermore, it contributes to the
discussion of surface geochemical processes that favor
the mitigation and reduction of exposure risks of arsenic
to populations in tropical and subtropical regions.
METHODS AND MATERIALS
In the 3 targeted areas, the composition of surface
water and stream sediments were sampled and studied
from 1998 to 2003. The filtered water samples (millipore
0.45mm) were collected at least twice a year and the
physical-chemical parameters of water quality were
measured in situ. The As concentrations were determined
through HG-AAS and the total compositions (cations and
anions) by ICP-OES and ionic chromatography. Similar
procedures were followed for water samples from natural
springs, mine drainages and tap water from residences.
The sediment and soil samples were naturally dried,
homogenized and sieved using a nylon mesh. Both sediments (according to the granulometric fraction <63µm)
and the soils (in the fraction <177µm) were analyzed by
FRX and, in the case of As contents in sediments from
Santana, HG-AAS analysis were also carried out. The
analytical accuracy was controlled by means of simultaneous analysis of certified reference material.
First morning urine samples, collected from residents
in Ribeira Valley, were analyzed (Sakuma, 2004) for As
– 65 –
Human exposure to arsenic in Brazil
(As3+ + As5+ + MMA + DMAA) by hydride generation
atomic absorption using a flow injection system, at the Adolfo Lutz Institute (São Paulo), according to a procedure
recommended by Guo et al. (1997) and using certified
reference material NIST 2670 (0.06µm/mL As).
Arsenic concentrations in urine samples collected in
the Quadrilátero Ferrífero area, refer to total inorganic As,
determined using HG-AAS (Matschullat et al., 2000). At
the Evandro Chagas Institute, blood and hair samples,
from the town of Santana, were analyzed in a graphite
furnace using Zeemann background correction (Santos
et al., 2003).
RESULTS
In the three denominated study areas arsenic exposure can be identified with processes induced by
mining and metallurgy activities. However, in the Ribeira
Valley, besides the contamination caused by the industrial activities in the Upper Valley, the occurrence of the
geochemical anomaly of As associated with the rocks and
soils of the Piririca Unit (Açungui Group) characterized
in previous CPRM (1982) and Perrota (1996) studies is
also considered.
Arsenic in the quadrilátero Ferrífero (MG)
The Quadrilátero Ferrífero area is the most important
auriferous province in Brazil. It is produced about 600t
of gold in the last 300 years. The gold ore contains arsenic in minerals such as arsenopyrite and lollingite or
as an impurity in pyrite. The lithologies are composed
of: metabasalts, metamorphic banded iron formations,
schists and granitoids that present important carbonatic
alteration in the vicinity of the deposits. These sites of
Archean and Paleoproterozoic age represent an important As geochemical anomaly in the Southern portion
of the São Francisco Craton. The contribution of mining
and metallurgy activities to the processes of As release
to the environment has been studied by several authors
like Oliveira et al. (1979), Borba et al. (2000), Deschamps
et al. (2002), Borba et al. (2003) and Borba & Figueiredo
(2004).
In the entire region the As concentrations in the
stream sediments (<63µm) were elevated, and reached
4,000mg/kg As in the mine surroundings. However, the
surface water rarely presented concentrations higher
than 50µm/L As, which was, at the time, the legislation established limit for non-treated water. A few water
samples from natural springs also presented low arsenic
concentrations, while the samples collected from mine
surroundings and tailings presented 350 µg/L As and
samples from mine drainages, up to 3,000 µg/L As.
In 1998 a human monitoring campaign was carried
out among populations of school age children (7-12
years) in the towns of Santa Bárbara and Nova Lima,
using arsenic in urine as a bioindicator (Matschullat
et al., 2000). The average As concentration in the 126
urine samples was 25.7 µg/L As and 20% of the examined children presented more than 40µg total inorganic
As per urine liter, a threshold above which long term
adverse effects on health may occur. The most likely
means of arsenic exposure would have been with soil
and dust contact, since the As concentrations in drinking water were well below 10µg/L (limits established by
the Ministry of Health and World Health Organization
for drinking water).
Monitoring campaigns carried out at the same
schools in subsequent years revealed average values
inferior to those of 1998 and the percentage of children
with concentrations above 40µg/L As in urine did not exceed 5% of the population sampled in 2002 (Matschullat,
2004, oral communication).
Arsenic in Ribeira Valley (PR-SP)
The Ribeira Valley extends from the Northeast of
Paraná to the South coast of São Paulo State and supports
a great part of the remaining Atlantic Tropical Forest - Mata
Atlântica - and has an important fresh water reserve of
the country’s Southeast region.
During the 20th century, the Upper Valley region
hosted several Pb-Zn-Ag mining operations, as well as
a lead refining plant (Plumbum), in Adrianópolis town
(PR), operating from 1945 to 1995. The region’s main
mineralization contained significant amounts of arsenic
(arsenopyrite and tennantite), especially in the filonean
deposits of Panelas and Furnas, hosted in Mesoproterozoic dolomitic limestones.
In the Middle Valley, the Mesoproterozoic Piririca Unit,
made up of schists and metabasic rocks, with quartz,
gold and sulfide veins (including arsenopyrite), extends
between the towns of Iporanga and Itapeúna. High As
concentrations in stream sediments and soils define a NE
direction zone (CPRM, 1982; Perrota, 1996), that represents a natural As anomaly, because modern mining was
never established in that area.
Human monitoring campaigns for arsenic were carried out in five towns throughout the Upper Valley regions
(1999-2001) and Middle Valley (2001-2003). The As
concentrations in early morning urine collected among
children and adults were determined (Sakuma, 2004).
The population of Cerro Azul town (PR), situated outside
the area under mining influence and distant from the natural arsenic anomaly, was chosen as a reference group.
Among the mining area communities of the Upper Valley,
the highest As medians in urine (8.94 µg/L in children,
n=89, and 8.54 µg/L in adults, n=86) was from the Bairro
da Serra neighborhood in Iporanga. This is situated near
the Furnas and Ribeirão Betari mines, which was known
for its high arsenic and lead concentrations in sediments
at the time of the mining activities.
– 66 –
Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo
In the Middle Valley 6 communities were monitored
and the average As concentrations in urine of children
and adults varied between 2.24 and 11.35 µg/L As. These
results are indicated in Table 1, where the medians of
Cerro Azul and the Bairro da Serra neighborhood are
shown for comparison purposes (Sakuma, 2004 and De
Capitani et al., 2005).
Though the arsenic concentrations in urine cannot be
considered elevated, some average contents keep a statistically significant difference compared with the results
obtained for the Cerro Azul reference group (3.60 µg/L
As in children, n=73 and 3.87 µg/L As in adults, n=83).
In Cerro Azul the highest medians were the populations
of Galvão, São Pedro, Ivaporunduva and Castelhanos,
coincidently those closest to the Piririca arsenic anomaly.
Whereas the lowest medians were the communities that
are the farthest away from the anomaly.
The surface water quality of the Ribeira River and
tributaries in the Middle Valley region was monitored from
2001-2003 in 5 sampling campaigns. The As concentrations varied between 1 and 9 µg/L and the highest concentrations were found in the Piririca creek which drains
rocks presenting auriferous veins and arsenic rich soils
(Takamori & Figueiredo, 2002). In that same creek, previous studies had indicated contents of up to 345 mg/kg As
in stream sediments (Toujague, 1999). Soils rich in arsenic
and heavy metals occur in the Piririca zone too, resulting
from the intense chemical weathering that affected rocks
and arsenic mineralization. Abreu & Figueiredo (2004)
found concentrations from 25 to 754 mg/kg in surface
soil (0-30 cm depth) in that area.
Arsenic in Santana (AP)
In Amapá State, arsenic occurs in arsenopyrite associated with Precambrian magnesiferous formations, mined
for over 50 years in the famous Serra do Navio mine. The
arsenic source is not situated in the mine but in Santana,
350 km away, on the Amazon River margins, where the
manganese ore was processed and loaded. In the town,
ore and wastes exposed in an open pit contained up to
0.17% As and groundwater sampled in monitoring wells
close to those deposits had high arsenic concentrations
of up to 2,000 µg/L.
Geochemical studies carried out in the area (Lima,
2003), revealed As concentrations in surface water
between 5 and 231 µg/L As (2001-2002) but most values were below 50 and 10 µg/L As. Samples of fluvial
sediments and suspension material presented contents
varying from 1,600 to 696 mg/kg As. On the other hand,
concentrations in tap water from residences did not exceed 0.5 µg/L As.
The local population (about 2,000 inhabitants) was
assessed for arsenic exposure using blood and hair
analyses (Santos et al., 2003). Inorganic arsenic has a
special affinity with hair and other keratin rich tissues,
so the As content in these tissues is a good exposure
bioindicator. Concentrations of up to 1 ppm of arsenic in
hair and fingernails can be considered normal, according
to Choucair & Ajax (1988) and Franzblau & Lilis (1989),
threshold also used by ASTDR (2000).
A population of 512 people analyzed in Santana,
produced a median of 0.20 g/g As in hair (Table 2). According to other countries’ results (Granero et al., 1998;
Pazirandeh et al., 1998; Saad & Hassanien, 2001, among
others), the arsenic exposure levels in the Santana
community cannot be considered elevated, although
complementary data of urinary arsenic are still necessary in the area.
Table 2 - Arsenic Concentrations in hair – Santana, Amapá
State (2001-2002)
Table 1 - Arsenic concentration in children and adults urine
in the Ribeira Middle Valley (2002-2003), Cerro Azul and
Bairro da Serra (Iporanga)
Locality
n
Median
µg/L As
Min
µg/L As
Max
µg/L As
Cerro Azul
156
3.86
1
34.12
Bairro da Serra Iporanga
175
8.90
1
62.54
Iporanga
112
8.14
1
33.49
Pilões
73
3.97
1
68.92
Castelhanos
58
9.48
1
60.32
Galvão
35
15.02
2.36
55.69
São Pedro
51
11.35
1
76.19
Ivaporunduva
30
10.02
1.77
34.57
Nhungara
22
5.84
1
25.95
Source: Sakuma(2004) and De Capitani et al. (2005)
Population
n
Median
µg/L As
Min
µg/L As
Max
µg/L As
Men
182
0.200
0.074
1.936
Women
330
0.200
0.063
1.855
Total
512
0.200
0.063
1.936
Source: Santos et al.(2003)
Other arsenic occurrences in Brazil
The above three cases represent the only examples
of integrated studies on environmental geochemistry and
human exposure assessment being performed. They are
related to environmental impacts induced by mineral refining and ore processing activities, in the form of exposed
mining tailings and soil contamination and surface drainage. Their pollution sources may be considered punctual
even though along the Piririca Belt in the Middle Ribeira
Valley, arsenic rich soils cover a large area.
– 67 –
Human exposure to arsenic in Brazil
Other arsenic point sources can be identified in the
auriferous districts of the Itapicuru River greenstone belt
(Bahia State), Crixás (Goiás State) and Paracatu (Minas
Gerais State). In these sites, auriferous ore, rich in arsenopyrite, as described in the Quadrilátero Ferrífero area,
is or was mined, except these mining activities are more
recent compared to those in the Quadrilátero area in
Minas Gerais.
In the South Region of Brazil, arsenic associated
with coal deposits has also been confirmed. Coal mining in Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul States has
produced significant environmental impacts, caused by
huge mining waste deposits and sulfurous lagoons.
A wider assessment of the literature and geological
documentation in Brazil is still to be made, to identify diffuse sources of arsenic. In the geochemical data bank
of the Brazilian Geological Service (Lins, 2004, oral communication) up to 18,670 analyses of stream sediment
and soil samples for arsenic can be found. About 20%
of the samples presented arsenic contents higher than
100 ppm. The highest sediment and soil concentrations
were found in the Ribeira Valley (Piririca zone), the gold
prospection areas in the greenstone belts of Amapá State,
in the Quadrilátero Ferrífero area and in certain places in
the Northeast region of Rondônia State.
Inferences of probable non-point As sources can
be drawn from the low density geochemical mapping of
Paraná State. Licht (2001) has described a positive As
anomaly associated with the occurrence of bituminous
shales and Paleozoic carboniferous formations of the
Paraná Basin, as well as an occurrence of arsenic associated with the carboniferous and uraniferous formation
in the Figueira region, in Paraná State.
With regard to surface water in humid tropical
regions, the As concentration data in this study is coherent with those obtained at other sites in the country.
It is difficult to find more systematic information about
arsenic occurrence in groundwater, especially in those
regions where the population and economic activity
depend on shallow aquifers. Similarly, no information
can be found concerning the release of arsenic to the
environment due to agricultural activities (intensive
use of pesticides).
CONCLUSIONS
In Brazil, as in other developing countries, exposure
to toxic substances affects mainly the lower income
population being also subject to food deficiency. In the
North and Southeast regions, referred to in this study, the
population has access to abundant water resources, being areas with high rainfall, as compared to the different
situation experienced in regions of serious As intoxication
levels, where populations depend on groundwater for
their consumption.
The tropical climate favors the predominance
of chemical rock weathering processes resulting in
deeper soil profiles, enriched in iron and aluminum,
as well as fine sediments, that function as geochemical barriers preventing the release of As to the water.
These processes could explain the reason for the low
As concentrations in surface water and, in some cases,
in samples from springs found in the studied areas,
contrasting with the elevated As concentrations in soils
and sediments.
In the three described areas regardless of their industrial activity, they present natural arsenic anomalies.
To the natural availability processes of Arsenic, significant
As amounts are also released into the environment from
ore mineral processing and refining activities. Fortunately,
however, the current low levels of human exposure to
the toxic element represent a controllable and reversible
risk situation. In addition, for a proper risk evaluation,
complementary studies are necessary on As speciation
in water and As availability in soils and sediments, as total
As concentrations in the different geochemical compartments alone are not sufficient.
At yet, Arsenic rich geological formations and contaminated aquifers, such as those indicated in other
World regions by Smedley & Kinniburgh (2002), have not
been described in Brazil. A more complete inventory of
Arsenic occurrences in Brazil is still a challenge for the
Geosciences to face in the future.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This study is based on a presentation made at the
Medical Geology Symposium, during the 32o Geological
International Congress, Florence, Italy-2004 and on the
paper to be published in Environmental Geochemistry
& Health (Special Issue, 2006). The research was sponsored by FAPESP (Proc. no. 2002/00271-0) and CNPq.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ABERNATHY, C.O.; CALDERON, R.L.; CHAPPELL,
W.R.(Eds.). Arsenic exposure and health effects.
[S.l.]:Chapman & Hall, 1997. 429 p.
ABREU, M.C.; FIGUEIREDO, B.R. Mapeamento geoquímico de arsênio e metais pesados em solo da
unidade Piririca, Vale do Ribeira (SP). In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 42., 2004,
Araxá, MG. [Anais]. Araxá: SBG, 2004. 1 CD-Rom.
AGENCY FOR TOXIC SUBSTANCES AND DISEASE REGISTRY (ASTDR). Toxicological profile for arsenic.
Atlanta, GA: U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services, 2000.
BORBA, R. P.; FIGUEIREDO, B. R.; MATSCHULLAT, J.
Geochemical distribution of arsenic in waters, sediments and weathered gold mineralized rocks from
– 68 –
Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo
Iron Quadrangle, Brazil. Environmental Geology,
Berlin, v. 44, n.1, p. 39-52, 2003.
BORBA, R.P.; FIGUEIREDO, B.R. A influência das
condições geoquímicas na oxidação da arsenopirita
e na mobilidade do arsênio em ambientes superficiais tropicais. Revista Brasileira de Geociências,
São Paulo, v. 34, n. 4, p. 489-500, 2004.
BORBA, R.P.; FIGUEIREDO, B.R.; RAWLLINS, B.G.;
MATCHULLAT, J. Arsenic in water and sediment
in the Iron Quadrangle, Minas Gerais state, Brazil.
Revista Brasileira de Geociências, São Paulo, v. 30,
n. 3, p.554-557, 2000.
CHOUCAIR, A.K.; AJAX, E.T. Hair and nails in arsenical neuropathy. Ann. Neurol., Boston, v. 23, n.6, p.
628-629, 1988. COMPANHIA DE PESQUISA DE
RECURSOS MINERAIS. Projeto Eldorado: relatório
iIntegrado final de pesquisa. São Paulo, 1982. 200 p.
DE CAPITANI, E.M.; SAKUMA, A.M.; PAOLIELLO, M.M.B.;
FIGUEIREDO, B.R.; OKADA, I.A.; DURAN, M.C.;
OKURA, R.I. Exposição humana ao arsênio no Médio
Vale do Ribeira, São Paulo. Disponível em: <http://
www.cprm.gov.br/pgagem/workshop/paineis/Painel01.pdf>. Acesso em: 08 ago. 2006.
DESCHAMPS, E.; CIMINELLI, V.S.T.; LANGE, F.T.;
MATSCHULLAT, J.; RAUE, B.; SCHMIDT, H. Soil
and sediment geochemistry of the Iron Quadrangle,
Brazil: the case of arsenic. Journal of Soils and Sediments, [S.l.], v. 2, n. 4, p.216 – 222, 2002.
FRANZBLAU, A.; LILIS, R. Acute arsenic intoxication
from environmental arsenic exposure. Arch. Environ.
Health, Washington, D.C., v. 44, n. 6, p. 385-390,
1989.
GRANERO, S.; LLOBET, J.M.; SCHUHMACHER, M.; CORBELLA, J.; DOMINGO, J.L. Biological monitoring
of environmental pollution and human exposure to
metals in Tarragona, Spain: I.levels in hair of school
children. Trace Elements and Electrolytes, Berlin, v.
15, p. 39-43, 1998.
GUO, T.; BAASER, J.; TSALEV, D.L. Fast automated determination of toxicologically relevant arsenic in urine
by flow injection-hydride generation atomic absorption spectrometry. Anal. Chim. Acta, Amsterdam, v.
349, n. 1-3, p. 313-318, 1997.
LICHT, O.B. 2001. A Geoquímica multielementar na
gestão ambiental: identificação e caracterização de
províncias geoquímicas naturais, alterações antrópicas da paisagem, áreas favoráveis à prospecção
mineral e regiões de risco para a saúde no Estado
do Paraná, Brasil. 2001. 236 p. Tese (Doutorado
em Geologia Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia,
Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
LIMA, M.O. Caracterização geoquímica de arsênio total
em águas e sedimentos em áreas de rejeitos de
minérios de manganês no Município de Santana –
Estado do Amapá. 2003. 85 f. Dissertação (Mestrado
em Geoquímica)-Centro de Geociências, Universidade Federal do Pará, Belém, 2003.
MATSCHULLAT, J.; BORBA, R.P.; DESCHAMPS, E.;
FIGUEIREDO, B.F.; GABRIO, T.; SCHWENK, M.
Human and environmental contamination in the Iron
Quadrangle, Brazil. Applied Geochemistry, Oxford,
v. 15, n. 2, p. 181-190, Feb. 2000.
OLIVEIRA, J.J.C.; RIBEIRO, J.H.; SOUZA OKI, S.; BARROS, J.R.R. Projeto Geoquímica do Quadrilátero Ferrífero: levantamento orientativo e regional: relatório
final. Belo Horizonte: CPRM, 1979. 133 p.
PAZIRANDEH, A.; BRATI, A.H.; MARAGEH, M.G. Determination of arsenic in hair using neutron activation. Appl.
Radiat. Isotopes, Oxford, v. 49, p. 753-759, 1998.
PERROTA, M.M. Potencial aurífero de uma região no Vale
do Ribeira, São Paulo, estimado por modelagem
de dados geológicos, geoquímicos, geofísicos e
de sensores remotos num sistema de informações
geográficas. 1996. 149 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geociências)- Instituto de Geociências, Universidade de
São Paulo, São Paulo, 1996.
SAAD, A.; HASSANIEN, M.A. Assessment of arsenic level
in the hair of the no occupational Egyptian population: pilot study. Environment International, New York,
v. 27, n. 6, p. 471-478, Dec. 2001.
SAKUMA, A.M.A. Avaliação da exposição humana ao
arsênio no Alto Vale do Ribeira, Brasil. 2004.196
p. Tese (Doutorado em Saúde Coletiva)-Faculdade
de Ciências Médicas, Universidade Estadual de
Campinas, Campinas, 2004.
SANTOS, E.C.O.; JESUS, I.M.; BRABO, E.S.; FAYAL, K.F.;
LIMA, M.O. Exposição ao mercúrio e ao arsênio em
estados da Amazônia: síntese dos estudos do Instituto Evandro Chagas/FUNASA. Revista Brasileira
de Epidemiologia, São Paulo, v. 6, n. 2, p. 171-185,
2003.
SMEDLEY, P.L.; KINNIBURGH, D.G. A review of the
source, behaviour and distribution of arsenic in
natural waters. Applied Geochemistry, Oxford, v.
17, n. 5, p. 517–568, may 2002.
TAKAMORI, A.Y.; FIGUEIREDO, B.R. Monitoramento
da qualidade de água do rio Ribeira de Iguape
para arsênio e metais pesados. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 41., 2002, João Pessoa. Anais. João Pessoa: SBG Núcleo Nordeste,
2002. p. 255.
TOUJAGUE, R. R. Arsênio e metais associados na região
Aurífera do Piririca, Vale do Ribeira, São Paulo,
Brasil. 1999. 56 f. Dissertação (Mestradoem Geociências)- Instituto de Geociências, Universidade
Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 1999.
– 69 –
ARSENIC IN
GROUNDWATER IN
OURO PRETO (M G)
José Augusto Costa Gonçalves, costa@degeo.ufop.br
Margarete Aparecida Pereira, margaret@degeo.ufop.br
José Fernando Paiva
Jorge Carvalho de Lena
Ouro Preto Federal University - UFOP
INTRODUCTION
Water used for human consumption with As (arsenic)
concentrations above the limits established by the environmental control agencies are considered dangerous
for human health (Hopemhayn-Rich et al., 1996; National
Research Council, 1999).
Arsenic is found in a long list of minerals such as
sulfides, arsenides and sulfo-arsenides, the later being
the most common. In natural water As occurs in organic
and inorganic compounds. In solution, the inorganic compounds encountered in water with high to moderate Eh
conditions are H3AsO4, H2AsO4-, HAsO42-, AsO43- whereas
H3AsO3 predominates in reducing conditions with As in
the oxidized states 3+ and 5+ (Thornton & Farago, 1997).
As is a toxic and carcinogenic element. The main
pathologies caused by acute and chronic As intoxication
are: metabolism problems, skin tumors, ulcers, gastritis,
diarrheas, cardiac arrhythmia, pancreas and lung cancer,
spontaneous abortions, low weight fetus, headaches,
mental confusion and anemia (Hutton, 1987; Morton &
Dunnette, 1994; Chen & Lin, 1994; USEPA, 2000; WHO,
2001).
In Ouro Preto city, the public water supply relies on
surface sources, spring catchments and groundwater
drawn from tubular wells and also old goldmines. Considering its geological environment, there is a possibility
the water has a high As concentration, turning the water
inappropriate for human consumption.
Geographically As is distributed in the Quadrilátero
Ferrífero area rocks, in close association with sulfide-rich,
gold bearing rocks.
The origin of As in the water, soil and sediments, is
due to a natural anomaly of this element in the region.
This anomaly is related to the genesis of the auriferous
deposits. Weathering of rocks with anomalous As contents
promotes the metal liberation to the environment.
This is a hydrogeochemical study of the Ouro Preto
water supplied to its population, by means of periodic
monitoring of the As temporal behavior, from January
2003 to January 2004.
GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE STUDIED AREA
The studied area is located in the Southeastern
portion of the Quadrilátero Ferrífero area of 7,200
km², situated in the Southern center portion of Minas
Gerais State. The geological constitution of Ouro Preto
(Figure 1) is a set of metasedimentary and metavolcanic rocks belonging to the Minas and Rio das Velhas
Supergroup.
The Ouro Preto climate is a Cwb type, according to
Rodrigues (1966), who adopted the KOPPEN international
classification that is, humid mesothermic, with a dry winter
and mild summer.
A large part of the Ouro Preto urban area is settled
in a valley formed between the Itacolomi and Ouro Preto
ridges, with elevations varying from 1,060 to 1420m.
– 71 –
Arsenic in groundwater in Ouro Preto (MG)
Figure 1 – Geological map of Ouro Preto, modified from Barbosa
(1969) and Quade (1982).
HYDROGEOLOGY – THE AqUIFER SYSTEMS: DESCRIPTION AND CHARACTERIZATION
Three categories of aquifer systems were identified:
a granular aquifer characterized by weathering mantles
and undivided detrital covers; a granular-fractured aquifer,
constituted by itabiritic rocks; and a fractured aquifer,
represented by chists and quartzite rocks, (Chart 1).
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Among the several groundwater and superficial
water extraction sources used by the population of Ouro
Preto, 17 sampling sites (SS) were chosen for study. The
water samples (Table 1) were collected along the year
2003, during six sampling campaigns (SC) in January,
March, Mai, July, September and November. In each
sampling site in situ measurements of pH, Eh, temperature, total dissolved solids and electric conductivity were
taken.
The analysis method for As speciation was by
square wave voltammetry (Gonçalves et al., 2004).
The experiments were carried out using a Metrohm
polarograph, model 757 VA Computrace, equipped
with a working dropping mercury electrode, a reference electrode Ag/AgCl/KCl 3mol.L-1 and an auxiliary
platinum electrode.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Of the 17 studied sites (Table 1), 13 didn’t show the
presence of As. However, in four sites, the As (V) was
detected in concentrations that varied between 9 and
224 µg.L-1. Of the total water samples that were analyzed,
75% had presented As concentrations above the values
– 72 –
José Augusto Costa Golçalves
compatible for human consumption, which is 10 µg.L-1 of
As (FUNASA, 2001). The most toxic As form, the As(III),
was not detected in any of the water samples analysed.
The water samples that presented As concentrations
inadequate to human consumption were found in the
sampling sites SS14 (Mina do Chiquinho), SS15 (Chafariz/
fountain – Barão Street), SS16 (Piedade-Tassara) and
SS17 (Biquinha of Santa Rita Street – Mina Velha).
The direct and narrow relationship between the
climate seasonality and the As concentrations, found in
some of the water sites studied (SS14, 15, 16 and 17) is
clearly shown in Figure 2.
In all of these sites the curves representing the rain
rates and the As concentration values, show the same
tendency, that is, the periods of greater rain incidence
are also the ones that present the highest values for As
contents (period between December and March).
On the other hand, in the driest season, between June
and September, the As concentration in water presented
the lowest values whereas in the sites SS14 and 16 As
was not detected at all. For all the sites with As presence,
the maximum and minimum As content values coincide
with the maximum and minimum pluviometric rate values.
Two hydrogeochemical conditions can lead to variations in water quality (Rose et al., 1991):
the decline in the water levels after the rainy season
promotes the beginning of the oxidation processes in the
aquifer systems;
during rainy periods the salts formed in the oxidation zones during the dry period are dissolved and
transported;
In addition to the climatic conditions and operating concomitantly, the trajectory of the rainfall, both by
superficial runoff and infiltrated waters, finds, in the geomorphology and in the abrupt relief of the area the proper
conditions for rapid flows, enabling interactions between
water and rock, causing dissolution and transport of
higher quantities of substances and elements.
The existing aquifer systems also contribute significantly to the dissolution and liberation of As to the
environment. Phyllites and ferruginous quatzites, Cercadinho Formation rocks (fractured aquifer), and mainly
the Caue Formation itabirites and dolomitic itabirites,
Gandarela Formation dolomitic phyllites and dolomitic
iron formations, schistose rocks (granular-fractured
aquifer) present good porosity and permeability conditions, a dense network of fractures, micro-fractures and
foliation planes. In these formations, which correspond
to the points where As was detected in groundwater,
oxidized sulfide minerals and secondary minerals are
exposed in the surface.
The oxidation of sulfide mineral bodies starts with
the reduction of water inflow at the end of the rainy period, extending throughout the dry period, producing a
considerable amount of soluble salts. These first reactions occur mainly in the recharge areas of the groundwater and slopes, where the weathering processes in
the non-saturated zone, rich in free O2, cause the oxidation of sulfide minerals, in special arsenopyrite. The
arsenopyrite oxidation reaction, according to Plumlee
(1999) is: FeAsS + 3.25O2 + 1.5H2O = Fe2+ + 2H+ +
HAsO42- + SO42-.
Under these acid conditions, As is highly mobile (Mok
et al. 1988), being released from the mineralized rocks by
means of inorganic or biotic processes (Nordstron and
Southam 1997).
Chart 1 - The aquifer systems, predominant lithologies and associated geological units (modified from IGA, 1995)
Aquifer Systems
Predominant Litology and Geological Units
Granular media
Aquifers in weathering mantle and detrital covers
This system constitutes the superficial aquifers associated with the weathering mantle
(saprolites, colluvia, lateritic covers, and canga) and detrital deposits of the TertiaryQuaternary cover.
Granular – Fractured media
Aquifers in Itabiritic rocks
Finely-laminated itabirite and dolomitic itabirite from the Cauê Formation / dolomitic phyllite
and dolomitic iron formations from the Gandarela Formation
Fractured media
Aquifers in schistose rocks
Aquifers in quartzitic rocks
Schists, chloriteschists, quartzchlorite, quartz-chlorite-sericite schist from the Nova Lima
Formation / dolomitic phyllite, phyllite and iltite from the Fecho do Funil Formation / mica,
chloriteschists and quartzites from the Sabará Formation
Quartzite, ferruginous quartzite, and phyllite from the Cercadinho Formation / conglomeratic
quartzite from the Itacolomi Group
– 73 –
Arsenic in groundwater in Ouro Preto (MG)
Table 1 - Situation of the sampling sites (SS) and chemical composition of the groundwater
SS01
Rua Tomé Vasconcelos – 438 / Bairro São Cristóvão————— Water Catchment: Old gold mine—————As not detected over the year
SS02
Travessa Sargento Francisco Lopes-1————— Water Catchment: Spring————— As not detected over the year
SS03
Travessa Sargento Francisco Lopes-2————— Water Catchment: Old gold mine ————— As not detected over the year
SS04
Jardim Botânico————— Water Catchment: Superficial stream————— As not detected over the year
SS05
Água Limpa – Caixa 4 (Quadra de Futebol)———— Water Catchment: Spring ———— As not detected over the year
SS06
Água Limpa – Caixa 5 (Banheira)————— Water Catchment: Spring ————— As not detected over the year
SS07
Nossa Senhora do Carmo————— Water Catchment: Superficial stream ————— As not detected over the year
SS08
Saramenha de Cima————— Water Catchment: Superficial stream ————— As not detected over the year
SS09
Morro São Sebastião————— Water Catchment: Tubular well————— As not detected over the year
SS10
Estação de Tratamento do Itacolomi————— Water Catchment: Superficial stream ————— As not detected over the year
SS11
Biquinha – Rua 13 de Maio (Frente ao número 160)————— Water Catchment: Old gold mine ————— As not detected over the year
SS12
Mina do Bem Querer————— Water Catchment: Old gold mine ————— As not detected over the year
SS13
Morro São João————— Water Catchment: Tubular well————— As not detected over the year
SS14
Mina do Chiquinho
Water Catchment: Old gold mine
pH
Temp
TDS
CE
Eh
As III
As V
Na
Mg
Al
K
Ca
Mn
Fe
Ba
SC1
7.43
19.7
14.12
21.38
0.397
<5
27
1.06
0.26
< LQ
0.94
1.35
58.8
< LQ
7.87
SC 2
6.62
19
16.38
25.15
0.433
<5
14.8
1.8
0.4
< LQ
1.03
1.35
127.9
< LQ
6.27
SC 3
6.57
17.5
17.39
25.99
0.488
<5
<5
1.78
0.5
< LQ
1.03
1.23
124.4
< LQ
5.96
SC 4
6.37
18.3
16.63
25.9
0.398
<5
<5
1.58
0.49
< LQ
1
1.2
53.1
< LQ
26.87
SC 5
6.3
20
16.5
25.35
0.383
<5
<5
1.61
0.48
< LQ
1.04
1.22
7.58
< LQ
14.13
SC 6
6.59
20.6
15.13
22.63
0.387
<5
<5
1.68
0.44
< LQ
0.88
1.23
18.05
< LQ
4.75
SS 15
Chafariz – Rua do Barão-30 (Vicentão)
Water Catchment: Spring
pH
Temp
TDS
CE
Eh
As III
As V
Na
Mg
Al
K
Ca
Mn
Fe
Ba
SC 1
7.16
19.6
54.21
80.85
0.399
<5
71
7.15
1.12
< LQ
2.8
4.28
10.34
< LQ
9.03
SC 2
6.24
19.4
48.24
73.33
0.497
<5
62.9
7.32
1.02
< LQ
2.62
2.97
15.51
< L.Q.
7.42
SC 3
6.28
18.6
48.23
71.49
0.469
<5
48
7
1.1
1.76
2.53
2.45
14.95
4.33
7.59
SC 4
6.67
18.2
49.03
75.45
0.335
<5
25
6.9
1.08
< LQ
2.6
2.43
15.04
< L.Q.
39.61
SC 5
7.82
19.5
49.25
74.65
0.412
<5
25
7.14
1.02
3.13
2.64
2.46
15.38
5.05
28.5
SC 6
7.31
20.7
49.95
73.9
0.365
<5
26.5
1.26
0.44
38.2
0.35
1.22
9.49
12.3
4.72
pH
Temp
TDS
CE
Eh
As III
As V
Na
Mg
Al
K
Ca
Mn
Fe
Ba
SC
1 7.21
18.7
46.7
69.5
0.42
<5
29
5.65
0.93
3.35
2.3
3.63
29.6
< L.Q.
13.61
SC
2 6.65
18.6
48.43
73.55
0.488
<5
22.8
6.7
1
7.97
3.17
3.38
31.54
< L.Q.
12.95
SC
3 6.61
18.4
47.15
69.83
0.517
<5
<5
6.23
1.07
5.83
2.92
2.75
32.38
< L.Q.
12.13
SC
4 6.55
18.1
49.22
75.75
0.414
<5
<5
5.65
1.04
< LQ
2.78
2.73
27.19
< L.Q.
25.25
SC
5 6.53
19
42.87
64.88
0.4
<5
15.2
5.46
0.99
3.83
2.72
2.73
31.63
< L.Q.
22.16
SC
6 6.73
20.4
41.47
61.13
0.408
<5
9
6.6
1.12
4.49
2.93
3.58
30.26
< L.Q.
13.2
Fe
Ba
SS16
Piedade
SS17
Water Catchment: Old gold mine
Biquinha da rua Santa Rita (Mina Velha)
pH
Temp
TDS
CE
Eh
As III
As V
Water Catchment: Old gold mine
Na
Mg
Al
K
Ca
Mn
SC 1
7
19.2
90.74
135.7
0.42
<5
224
8.36
2.02
30.4
3.86
11.96
20.53
< L.Q.
12.73
SC 2
6.92
19.2
82.05
125
0.495
<5
125.9
8.97
1.74
27.76
3.6
9.53
38.6
< L.Q.
11.51
SC 3
6.42
18.6
82.88
123.01
0.532
<5
68
9.39
1.84
7.41
3.75
6.79
57.3
< L.Q.
14.61
SC 4
5.93
18.4
82
126.5
0.408
<5
17
9.47
1.85
< LQ
3.9
6.3
68
< L.Q.
33.64
SC 5
6.56
18.6
80.9
122.7
0.388
<5
<5
9.93
1.74
11.53
3.97
6.09
71.1
< L.Q.
25.86
SC 6
6.87
19.1
85.94
127.1
0.397
<5
27
9.44
2.03
25.33
3.37
10.73
30.18
< L.Q.
11.3
(5μgL-1)
(5µgL-1)
(0.15mgL-1)
(0.01mgL-1)
(4µgL-1)
(0.05mgL-1)
(0.01mgL-1)
(4µgL-1)
(9µgL-1)
(0.2µgL-1)
Limits for the Quadrilátero (LQ)
– 74 –
José Augusto Costa Golçalves
Figure 2 – Graphic representation of the relationship between rainfall rates and As(V) concentrations from December 2004 until November 2004
Borba (2002) attributes the presence of As in the
groundwater, some Ouro Preto mines and in the Passagem
de Mariana mine, to this mineral and to its incongruent
dissolution, due to the pH increase. In the Zimapa´m
Valley in Mexico, Armienta et al. (2001) report groundwater contamination by As resulting from the oxidation of
arsenopyrite and dissolution of the scorodite present in
sulfide mineralizations hosted by carbonaceous rocks.
STUDY OF AS PRESENCE IN RESIDENCES OF THE
PADRE FARIA NEIGHBORHOOD
The Padre Faria neighborhood is supplied with water
from several sources. Water samples were collected in
42 residences of that neighborhood (Table 2), chosen in
order to guarantee the randomness of the sampling sites.
The residences were selected by systematic sampling,
where one in every ten residences existing in the street
was selected.
CONCLUSIONS
The method used allows a quick quantification of the
inorganic species As(III) and As(V) in natural waters at
a relatively low cost and with high sensitivity. Contents
above 5 lg L-1 can be easily determined, covering an
ample range of concentrations. The answers for real
sample analyses are perfectly similar to those of the
standards, with no detrimental interference from the
matrices.
– 75 –
Arsenic in groundwater in Ouro Preto (MG)
measures must be taken by the municipal agencies responsible for the water supply. An effective and efficient
water supply system must contemplate the identification
and characterization of contaminated areas, an inventory
of all water catchments, and the preparation of a control
system that includes a systematic water monitoring plan.
Table 2 - Total As concentrations in some residences of the Padre
Faria neighborhood
Sample
As µg/L
Sample
As µg/L
PF 01
< D.L.
PF 22
189
PF 02
< D.L.
PF 23
9.88
PF 03
8.66
PF 24
10.76
PF 04
8.57
PF 25
7.47
PF 05
8.82
PF 26
55.52
PF 06
8.54
PF 27
16.11
PF 07
< D.L.
PF 28
9.74
PF 08
9.23
PF 29
10.91
PF 09
9.62
PF 30
< D.L.
PF10
11.51
PF 31
< D.L.
PF 11
9.9
PF 32
< D.L.
PF 12
10.14
PF 33
< D.L.
PF 13
< D.L.
PF 34
< D.L.
PF 14
< D.L.
PF 35
7.47
PF 15
8.9
PF 36
< D.L.
PF 16
8.42
PF 37
< D.L.
< D.L.
PF 17
8.04
PF 38
PF 18
8.17
PF 39
< D.L.
PF 19
< D.L..
PF 40
< D.L.
PF 20
127
PF 41
< D.L.
PF 21
13.46
PF 42
< D.L.
PF – Padre Faria
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
D.L. – Detection Limit
According to Smedley et al., 2002, the great spatial
variability of the As concentrations is a remarkable characteristic of areas presenting high As contents. Thus, it
can be difficult or impossible to predict the As concentration of a single sampling site considering the results
of neighboring springs or wells. Aquifers contaminated
by As may be restricted to certain environments, show
an erratic spatial behavior and seem to be the exception
rather than the rule.
The variation of As concentrations in the groundwater
of the studied area, along a period of one year, is related
to the climatic seasonality. During seasons of pluviometric
deficit, the reduction of water levels in the aquifers favors
the oxidation of sulfide minerals. During the rainy seasons,
the dissolution of those minerals will occur, mobilizing and
lixiviating the As to the environment (Banks et al., 1997;
Freeze & Cherry, 1994), increasing the concentrations of
this element in the groundwater, at the same time that the
original concentrations are diluted. The As concentration
values found in the water samples are representative of
the time of sampling and the season, varying to higher or
lower values along time.
Due to the presence of As in groundwater used by
the population of some neighborhoods of Ouro Preto city,
ARMIENTA, M.A.; VILLASENÕR, G.; RODRIGUES, R.;
ONGLEY, L.K.; MANGO, H. The role of arsenic- bering rocks in groundwater pollution at Zimapan Valley,
Mexico. Environmental Geology, Berlin, v. 40, n. 4-5,
p. 571 – 581, Feb. 2001.
BANKS, D.; YOUNGER, P.; ARSENEN, R.; IVERSEN, E.;
BANKS, S. Mine-water chemistry: the good, the bad
and the ugly. Environmental Geology, Berlin, v. 32,
n. 3, p. 157 – 174, Oct. 1997.
BARBOSA, A . L. M. Geologic map of the Ouro Preto,
Mariana, Antonio Pereira e São Bartolomeu quadrangles, Minas Gerais, Brazil. Washington, DNPM/
USGS, 1969. U.S. Geological Survey Professional
Paper, 641; plates 7,8,9,10.
BORBA, R.P. Arsênio em ambiente superficial: processos geoquímicos naturais e antropogênicos em
uma área de mineração aurífera. 2002. 202 p.
Tese (Doutorado em eociências)-Instituto de Geociências, Universidade Estadual de Campinas,
Campinas, 2002.
BRASIL.Fundação Nacional de Saúde. Portaria nº01469/
2000, de 29 de dezembro de 2000 : aprova o
controle e vigilância da qualidade da água para
consumo humano e seu padrão de potabilidade.
Brasília: FUNASA, 2001. 32 p.
CHEN, C.; LIN, L. Human carcinogenity and atherogenicity induced by chronic exposure to inorganic arsenic.
In: Nriagu, J. O. (Ed.). Arsenic in environmental: part
II: human health and ecosystem effects. New York:
John Wiley & Sons, 1994. P. 109 – 132.
FREEZE, A. R.; CHERRY, J.A. Groundwater. Englewood
Cliffs, NY: Prentice Hall, 1994.
GONÇALVES, J.A .C.; PAIVA, J. F.; TEÓFILO, R. F.; LENA,
J.C.; NALINI JR, H.A. 2004. Determinação das
espécies de arsênio em águas naturais utilizando
voltametria de onda quadrada. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE GEOQUÍMICA, 9., Belém. Anais.
Belém: Sociedade Brasileira de Geoquímica, 2003.
P. 304 – 305.
HOPENHAYN-RICH, C.; M.L. BIGGS; SMITH, A.H.; KALMAN, D.A.; MOORE, L.E. Methylation study in a
population environmentally exposed to high arsenic
drinking water. Environmental Health Perspectives,
[S.l.], v. 104, n. 6, p. 620-8.
HUTTON, M. Human health concercns of lead, mercury,
cadmium and arsenic. In: Hutchinson, T. C.; Meema,
– 76 –
José Augusto Costa Golçalves
K. M. (Ed.). Lead, mercury, cadmium and arsenic
in the environment. New York: John Wiley & Sons,
1987. p. 53 – 68.
INSTITUTO DE GEOCIÊNCIAS APLICADAS (IGA). Desenvolvimento Ambiental de Ouro Preto: microbacia do
Ribeirão do Funil. Belo Horizonte, 1995.
MOK, W. M.; RILEG, J.; WAI, C. M. Mobilization of arsenic
in contaminated rivers waters. Water Resources,
New York, v. 22, p. 769 – 774, 1988.
MORTON, W. E.; DUNNETTE, D. A . Health effects environmental arsenic. In: Nriagu, J. O. (Ed.) Arsenic in
environment: part II: human health and ecosystem effects. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994. p. 17 – 34.
NATIONAL RESEARCH CONCIL (NRC). Arsenic in drinking water. Washington, DC: National Academic
Press, 1999. 310 p.
NATIONAL primary drinking water regulations: arsenic and
clarifications to compliance and new source contaminants monitoring: proposed rule. Federal Register,
Washington, DC, v. 65, n0 121, p. 38888 – 38983,
Jun. 22, 2000.
NORDSTRON, D.K.; SOUTHAM, G. Geomicrobiology of
sulfide mineral oxidation. In: Banfield, J.F.; Nealson, K.
(Ed.). Geomicrobiology–interactions between microbes
and minerals. Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Washington, DC, v.35, p. 361 – 390, 1997.
PLUMLEE, G. S. The environmental geology of mineral
deposits. In: Plumlee, G.S.; Logsdon, M.J. (Ed.). The
environmental geochemistry of mineral deposits: part A:
processes, techniques, and health issues. Reviews in
Economic Geology, Chelsea, MI, v. 6A, p. 71 –116, 1999.
QUADE, H.W. Mapa Geológico da Região de Ouro Preto.
[Ouro Preto]: Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto,
[19-]. 1 mapa. Escala 1:10.000.
RODRIGUES, D.M.S. Condições Climáticas de Minas
Gerais. Boletim Mineiro de Geografia, Belo Horizonte, ano 7, n. 12, 1966.
SMEDLEY, P. L.; KINNIBURGH, D. G. A review of the
source, behaviour and distribution of arsenic in
natural waters. Applied Geochemistry, Oxford, v.
17, n. 5, p. 517 – 568, may 2002.
THORNTON, I.; FARAGO, M. The geochemistry of arsenic.
In: ABERNATHY, C.O.; CALDERON, R.L.; CHAPPELL, W. R. (Ed.). Arsenic exposure and health
effects. New York: Chapman & Hall, 1997. p. 1 – 16.
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO). United Nations synthesis report on arsenic in drinking water.
Geneva, 2001.
– 77 –
ARSENIC IN ESTUARIAL
SEDIM ENTS OF THE
ANTONINA BAY ACCESS
CHANNEL,
PARANÁ STATE BRAZIL
¹Fabian Sá, fabianbgm@ufpr.br
¹E.C. Machado,
²J.R. Ângulo,
¹Ocean Studies Center - UFPR
²Geology Department - UFPR
INTRODUCTION
The estuarial complex of the Paranaguá
Bay, situated on the south coast of Brazil,
between 25°16’ and 25°34’ S and 48°17’ and
48°42’ W, is formed by the Paranaguá Bay itself
including the region of Antonina and Laranjeiras
(Figure 1).
This system is of extreme importance
to the coastal ecosystem and in the social
and economic development of the State
of Paraná, once it constitutes a favorable
geographical area for industrial and harbor
facilities, fishing activities (reproduction
and growing site of commercially interesting species) and tourism. The region of
Antonina Bay, situated in the most internal
portion of the estuarial complex of Paranaguá Bay, has undergone a reactivation
of the harbor facilities due to the growth of
Figure 1 – Map of the E-W axis of the Paranaguá Bay estuarial complex.
these activities in the region. As a consequence, the remodeling of the Paranaguá and
Antonina harbors access channels has become
METHODS
necessary demanding periodical dredging for
the improvement of drought.
The surface sediment sampling in May 2001, (Figure
In the region of the estuarial complex of the Paranaguá Bay urban, harbor and industrial (fertilizer, storage of 3) was carried out at nine sites distributed in three sections
chemical products and bulk grain) activities coexist along along the 12 km channel between the Ponta do Félix and
with fishing activities, dredging and many others (Figure 2). Petrobras terminals.
– 78 –
Fabian Sá
Figure 2 – Industrial/urban and harbor activities that occur concomitantly in the region: a) un-planned waste dumping;
b) dredging activities; c) domestic/industrial sewage emissary.
Figure 3 – Sampling point locations and identification of the access channel to the Harbor Terminals
Ponta do Félix and Barão de Teffé, Antonina.
– 79 –
Arsenic in estuarial sediments of the antonina bay access channel, Paraná State Brazil
A strong extraction using HF and HNO3 with heating was made to completely dissolve the whole grain
crystalline structures present in the sediment, releasing
both the natural metallic elements and those resulting
from anthropogenic activities. The element arsenic was
identified through the atomic absorption spectrophotometry method (AAS) in the Geological Oceanography
Laboratory (Laboratório de Oceanografia Geológica) of
the Rio Grande Federal University Foundation (Fundação
Universidade Federal de Rio Grande -FURG).
Table 1
Station
Cd
(ppm)
Pb
(ppm)
Cr
(ppm)
Cu
(ppm)
Ni
(ppm)
Hg
(ppm)
1
2.075
24.750
57.250
15.250
30.922
0.400
2
1.394
21.663
48.805
13.197
21.499
0.930
3
2.225
23.250
52.000
9.250
20.982
0.247
4
2.488
19.652
28.358
5.224
14.112
0.262
5
1.990
18.657
27.363
4.478
18780
0.094
6
2.498
25.475
48.202
15.734
19.986
0.091
7
2.714
19.173
34.114
5.976
7.900
0.076
8
2.545
19.212
44.162
10.978
19.795
0.299
9
2.679
21.825
29.018
5.456
9.006
0.047
PHYSICAL FACTORS
Marone & Jamiyanaa (1997) classified the Paranguá
Bay Estuarial Complex tide as micro-tide, predominantly
semi-diurnal with diurnal differences, the mean amplitude
being 1.4m neap tide and 1.7 spring tide. Knoppers et
al., (1987) interpreted the E – W sector of the Paranaguá
Bay Estuarial Complex as a partially mixed type 2 estuary, in the Stratification – Circulation diagram of Hansen
& Rattray (1965).
According to Noernberg (2001) this sector suffers a
greater fresh water inflow influence in its drainage basin
compared to the N – S axis. The former presenting a
quicker and more intense response to the water column
stratification processes of the, saline intrusion, fluvial sediments supply and formation of a maximum turbidity zone
(MTZ). This author mapped the maximum turbidity zone in
this sector between the Gererês Islands and Paranaguá
Harbor and he added; this zone is directly related to the
estuarial body’s geometry, the tide current flow intensity
and the stratification of the water column.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The As concentrations detected in the surface sediment samples varied between 7.9 and 30.9 ppm (Figure
4). Analyzing the As concentration distribution in the
surface sediments from the estuarial complex E – W axis,
a significant increase towards the town of Paranaguá
was observed (Figure 5), demonstrating the maximum
turbidity zone influence on this element’s removal from
the water column. A study conducted by Sá (2003) also
found high concentrations at this same site for several
other metallic elements (Table 1). This author also warned
a potential source could exist in Paranaguá town as the
arsenic concentrations are even higher around the city.
Another important aspect of this kind of system is
the abundant fish diversity, which widens the metallic
elements access routes from its water and sediments to
the local urban population centers where the diet is based
on seafood. These populations generally access a variety
of food sources such as fish and some invertebrates:
shellfish, mollusks - sururu (Mytella guyanensis), oysters
in general, crabs and siris (Callinectes danae). Kolm et
Figure 4 – AS Concentration in the field samples.
al. (2002) conducted analyses of metallic elements in the
liver of Cathorops spixii (Ariidae), from Antonina Bay. The
results showed Arsenic concentrations of up to 518.69 µg/
kg, demonstrating bioaccumulation and biomagnification
processes in this environment, suggesting a still unknown
amount of this element exists in a bioavailable form.
Due to the incomplete range of geochemical information from the Paranaguá Bay estuarial complex region,
studies continue to gather knowledge about the speciation of the different elements in the surface sediments,
establishing reference levels (background) and actual
concentrations in the water column. These studies will
serve: i) future scientific research; ii) the management of
dredging activities; iii) support decision making regarding issues such as the destination of dredged material
and the main sources of these elements into the system.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
HANSEN, D. V.; RATTARAY JÚNIOR, M. Gravitational
circulation in straits and estuaries. J. Mar. Res., New
Haven, v. 23, p. 104-122, 1965.
– 80 –
Fabian Sá
Figure 5 – Map of Arsenic concentrations in surface sediments with emphasis on the Harbor Terminal Ponta do
Félix and the Gererês Islands near Paranaguá city.
KNOPPERS, B. A.; BRANDINI, F. P.; THAMM, C. A.).
Ecological studies in the Bay of Paranaguá: II: some
physical and chemical characteristics. Nerítica,
Curitiba, v. 2, n. 1, p. 1-36, 1987.
KOLM, H.E. et al. Avaliação dos impactos de correntes da
construção de um píer pela FOSPAR – Fertilizantes
Fosfata dos do Paraná S.A.: relatório técnico.Pontal
do Paraná: UFPR-CEM-FOSPAR, 2002. 184 p.
MARONE, E.; JAMIYANAA, D. Tidal characteristics and a
variable boundary numerical model for the M2 tide for
the Estuarine Complex of the Bay of Paranaguá, PR,
Brazil. Nerítica, Curitiba, v. 11, n. 1-2, p. 95-107, 1997.
NOERNBERG, M. A. Processos morfodinâmicos no Complexo Estuarino de Paranaguá: um estudo utilizando
dados Landsat-TM e medições in situ 2001. 118 f.
Dissertação (Doutorado em Geologia Ambiental)Departamento de Geologia, Universidade Federal
do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
SÁ, F. Distribuição e fracionamento de contaminantes
nos sedimentos superficiais e atividades de dragagem no Complexo Estuarino da Baía de Paran
guá, PR. 2003. 92 p. Dissertação (Mestrado em
Geologia)-Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2003.
– 81 –
HUM AN EXPOSITION
TO ARSENIC IN THE
M IDDLE RIBEIRA VALLEY,
SÃO PAULO STATE BRAZIL
¹Eduardo de Mello Capitani, capitan@fcm.unicamp.br
²Alice M. Sakuma, alice@ial.sp.gov.br
³Bernardino Ribeiro Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicamp.br
4
Monica M. Bastos Paoliello, monibas@sercontel.com.br
²Isaura A. Okada
²Maria Cristina Duran
²Roberta I. Okura
¹Medical Sciences Faculty - UNICAMP
²Adolfo Lutz Institute - IAL
³Geosciences Institute - UNICAMP
4
Londrina State University - UEL
INTRODUCTION
The hydrographic basin of the Ribeira do Iguape
River extends from the Southeastern regions of São Paulo
State (SP) to the East of Paraná State (PR). The region’s
mining and metallurgy activities had highly polluting
processes and they contributed to the contamination
of streams and soils surrounding a refinery situated in
Adrianópolis town (PR).
The degree of arsenic exposure in children and
adult residents in the Upper Ribeira Valley was evaluated by Sakuma (2004) in a previous epidemiological study. In that study, the investigated population
included residents of the urban areas of Ribeira (SP),
Adrianópolis (PR), and small rural villages, such as Vila
Mota and Capelinha. These two villages are situated
500 and 1,000 meters from the former lead refinery
(Adrianópolis), deactivated in 1995, and another,
Bairro da Serra situated in the rural area of Iporanga
(SP), was near the old Furnas mine. In both studies
the population used as the non-exposed control reference group were from Cerro Azul (PR), a town situated
upstream of the contaminated areas, away from the
mining and refining areas.
In the Middle Valley, As rich rock and soils are
found especially throughout the Piririca zone, situated
between Iporanga and Eldorado towns. This zone has
soil with up to 2,000 mg/kg As resulting from the weathering of rocks with auriferous veins containing sulfides
and arsenopyrite (Toujague, 1999; Braga & Figueiredo,
2002). The level of habitation in those areas justified the
work of the exposure assessments. The population of
the Middle Ribeira Valley is mainly composed of slave
descendents who worked in the mines until the end of
the 19th century. They still maintain their ancient traditions based on the use of local natural resources, and
subsistence farming practices.
Environmental exposure to high arsenic levels
(trivalent and pentavalent inorganic forms) can cause
vascular and skin diseases as well as lung, liver,
bladder and skin cancer. The absorption of arsenic
depends on several factors such as the nutritional
state of the individual, the ingested dose and the
exposure period time (Sakuma et al., 2003; ATSDR,
2000). The methylated arsenic compounds (organic
forms) react less with the tissues and are excreted
faster than the inorganic forms, therefore presenting
a lower toxicity.
This study sought to evaluate the As degree of exposure of the Middle Ribeira Valley population, especially in
the region influenced by the natural As anomaly (Piririca
zone), by analyzing their urinary arsenic levels. The study
also endeavored to identify the socio-demographic factors
that influence the degree of exposure.
– 82 –
Eduardo Mello De Capitani
about their socioeconomic conditions, food habits, occupational activities and hobbies.
STUDY POPULATION
The Middle Valley studied population was made up
of 378 children and adults from eight different places,
grouped according to their respective geologic characteristics (inside or outside the Piririca zone – Figure 1).
Group 1 had 112 participants, resident from the urban area of Iporanga (SP), outside the Piririca zone, but
likely to be influenced by the Furnas mining activities.
Group 2 had 192 residents from the neighborhoods of
Nhunguara and Castelhanos and the settlements of São
Pedro, Galvão and Ivaporunduva, rural regions located
within the extension of the Piririca zone. The residents
from the Pilões and Maria Rosa settlements, situated in
a more distant region, outside the Piririca zone, formed
group 3 with 74 participants.
The control group (Cerro Azul) referred to in the results were obtained from the 156 inhabitants previously
studied by Sakuma (2004).
Terms of consent, properly approved by the Ethics
Committee of the Medical Sciences Faculty of UNICAMP,
were read and individually signed by each participant or
the participant’s legal representative. Then a questionnaire was given to the participants to gather information
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Between April 2003 and March 2004 first morning
urine samples were collected in polyethylene flasks,
previously decontaminated with nitric acid. They were
maintained refrigerated and with no conserving additives
until delivered to the laboratory.
The arsenic compounds were identified through
HG-AAS. An atomic absorption spectrometer, PerkinElmer, Analyst 100 model, with hydride generator and
flow injection system Perkin-Elmer, FIAS 400 model,
was used. The analytical method describe by Guo et
al. (1997) was applied. It is based on the complexity
of the toxicologically important arsenic compounds:
As(III) + As(V) + monomethylarsenic acid (MMA) + Dimethylarsenic Acid (DMA) with cysteine. The analytical
method was previously validated, using certified reference material (NIST 2670), with a certified value of 60
µg L-1. The method quantification limit was 0.4 µgL-1 in
the five times diluted samples, corresponding to 2.0 µg
L-1 As in the sample.
The statistical analyses were
made with the SPSS 10.0 program for windows (Statistical
Package for Social Science). For
the arsenic in urine results (As-u)
below the detection limit (LD), the
value of 1.0 µg L-1 was attributed,
which corresponds to half the
analytical method’s detection
limit. No adjustment was made
regarding urinary creatinine.
RESULTS
Figure 1 – Location of the Ribeira Valley and Piririca zone.
– 83 –
The Box plot of the results
of As-u median concentration
(µg L-1) in the control population
(Cerro Azul) compared to the
groups 1, 2 and 3 are shown in
Figure 2.
The descriptive analysis of
As-u concentration for each of
the studied groups are presented
in Table 1.
The urinary arsenic median concentrations for groups
1 (8.07 µg L-1) and 2 (11.04 µg
L-1) were statistically different
when compared to the control
group (3.86 µg L-1) (r < 0.0001).
On the other hand the median
Human exposition to arsenic in teh middle Ribeira Valley, São Paulo State Brazil
concentration of group 3 (3.62 µg L-1), outside the Piririca
zone, was not statistically different from the control group
median (r=0.92). It is clear the As exposure is greater in
the population resident in the Piririca zone area, where
there is a natural presence of As.
Comparing the As-u medians between children
and adults, in the three groups there is an absence of
significant differences, showing the following results:
r=0.707; r=0.544 and r=0.811, for groups 1, 2 and 3,
respectively.
Of the total analyzed samples, 11.6%, 10.4% and
39.2% of the individuals, respectively in groups 1, 2 and
3, presented As concentrations lower than the detection limit of the study (2.00 µg L-1). Whereas, the control
Figure 2 – Box Plots of As-u(μg.L-1) from the population of Cerro Azul and group 1, 2 and 3 population.
Table 1 - Urinary As concentrations in the target population
minimum
maximum
N(%)
>
40 µg.L
73
3.60
1.00
34.12
0 (0%)
83
3.87
1.00
16.00
0 (0%)
total
156
3.86
1.00
34.12
0 (0%)
Iporanga (urban area)
children
82
8.35
1.00
33.49
0 (0%)
outside Piririca zone
adults
29
7.42
1.00
27.55
0 (0%)
total
111
8.07
1.00
33.49
0 (0%)
Location
Age
N
Controle
Ribeira de Iguape River spring
children*
Cerro Azul – PR (pop. control)
adults
1
2
As-Urine (µg.L-1)
median
Group
Piririca zone
children
67
9.85
1.00
55.69
3 (4.5%)
Nhunguara, Castelhanos, Galvão,
adults
123
11.68
1.00
76.19
7 (5.7%)
São Pedro, Ivaporunduva
total
190
11.04
1.00
76.19
10 (5.3%)
outside Piririca zone
children
28
3.64
1.00
31.28
0 (0%)
Pilões, Maria Rosa
adults
46
3.11
1.00
68.92
2 (4.3%)
total
74
3.62
1.00
68.92
2 (2.7%)
children
177
7.99
1.00
55.69
3 (0.8%)
adults
198
9.09
1.00
76.19
9 (2.4%)
total
375 *
8.21
1.00
76.19
11 (2.9%)
3
Total
* 7 to 14 years
Middle Valley
** Detection limits (2,00 μg.L-1)
– 84 –
N(%)
< LD
51 (32.9%)
13 (11.6%)
20 (10.4%)
29 (39.2%)
62 (16.4%)
Eduardo Mello De Capitani
group (Cerro Azul) presented 32.9% cases below the
detection limit.
There was no statistically significant difference between the medians related to gender among both children
and adults.
In this study, other variables that could influence the
levels of urinary arsenic were evaluated, such as: the
consumption of milk, meat, chicken, fish, vegetables and
fruit locally produced, besides the water consumption
(White & Sabbioni, 1998), since the nutritional state influences directly the absorption of arsenic (Mandal et al.,
1998). Residents were asked about their weekly intake of
meat, chicken, fish, milk, fruit and vegetables cultivated
in their own backyards. For statistical evaluation of the
consumption of meat and chicken, the population was
divided into: “consumes once a week or less” and “more
than once a week”. With respect to the other types of
food, a qualitative evaluation was made with the options
“consumes” or “does not consume”.
Considering only the child population, those with the
habit of playing in contact with the soil did not present an
As-u median statistically different from those who do not.
Table 2 shows that there is no significant difference
between the As-u medians of those who consume fish,
meat or chicken at least once a week and those who
don’t. However, people from groups 1 and 3 who do not
consume milk and dairy products have higher As-u median concentrations.
Using the multiple logistic regression model, the
variables which together best explain the As-u concentrations were: living location (variable “population group”),
number of times meat is consumed per week, and number
of times fruit and vegetables are consumed per week (r
< 0.10) (Table 3).
DISCUSSION
The value of 40 µg L-1 for As-u is considered critical
for long term exposure, since adverse effects to health
may occur above this limit (Trepka, 1996). The mean As-u
value obtained by Matschullat et al. (2000) was of 27.7 ±
19.2 µg L-1 in the Nova Lima and Santa Bárbara mining
region, Southeast Minas Gerais State. They noted 19.2%
of the children presented levels above 40 µg L-1. The per-
Table 2 - Median As-u Concentrations according to food consumption among children and adults within
three Middle Valley groups
Ρ Values
Meat Consumption
(more than once a week)
Group
Chicken consumption
(more than once a week)
Milk and dairy products consumption
Adults
Children
Total
Adults
Children
Total
Adults
Children
Total
1
1.000
0.117
0.141
–
0.964
1.000
0.054
0.223
0.027
2
0.914
1.000
0.953
1.000
0.24
0.612
0.838
0.723
0.856
3
0.549
0.678
1.000
0.749
0.678
0.445
0.412
0.041
0.027
Table 3 - Multiple logistic regression analysis with the influence variables regarding selected population from the Middle Valley
(Final Model As > 3,86 μg.L-1 [median de As-u from the control group])
Multiple logistic regression ( As > 3,86 µg.L-1 / control Group)
Variable
Constant
Chance Rate (CR)
β
ρ
0.728
0.040
2.071
Estimative
ICI (95%)
ICS (95%)
Meat
Weekly meat consumption
-0.181
0.024
0.835
0.714
0.976
Vegetable and Fruits
Weekly consumption of vegetables and fruits home
cultivated
-0.130
0.042
0.878
0.774
0.995
Group 3 ( Pilões; Maria Rosa)
Place of living
0.000
Group 1 ( Iporanga , área urbana)
1.417
0.000
4.126
1.903
8.945
Group 2 ( Nhunguara; Castelhanos;
São Pedro; Galvão; Ivaporunduva )
1.596
0.000
4.934
2.680
9.082
– 85 –
Human exposition to arsenic in teh middle Ribeira Valley, São Paulo State Brazil
centage in this study was equal to 0%, 5.2% and 2.7%,
respectively, in groups 1, 2 and 3. The control group did
not present results above this limit.
In Sakuma’s research (2004), children living near
the Furnas mine (neighborhood of Iporanga Ridge), presented the As-u median of 8.94 µg L-1 (interval of 1.00 –
63.0), whereas children living near the lead refinery that
processed arsenic containing ore, presented a median
of 6.40 µg L-1 (interval of 1.00 – 50.0).
The studied populations of group 1 (Iporanga, urban
zone, outside the Piririca zone, but likely to be environmentally influenced by the Furnas mine proximity) and
group 2 (inhabiting the Piririca zone), presented 4.126
and 4.934 times more chance (CR) of presenting arsenic
concentrations superior to 3.86 µg L-1 (control population
As-u median), respectively, compared to group 3 (living
outside the Piririca zone).
The main non-occupational arsenic exposure path is
through ingesting water or food. The total daily As intake
depends on dietary habits. Takamori & Figueiredo (2002),
evaluated the Piririca zone surface water, analyzed in five
campaigns between 2001 - 2003. No sample presented
As concentrations exceeding 10 mg L-1. Groundwater
consumption by local populations from tubular wells
indicated similar low concentrations.
This study investigated the probable As food sources,
and found the increase of a single unit in the weekly intake
of meat, fruit and vegetables avoids As concentrations in
urine higher than 3.86 µg L-1.
In the Middle Ribeira Valley, the natural presence of
arsenic in the Piririca zone rocks and soils, is the probable
source of the As-u concentrations found in the local inhabitants. However, the magnitude of the urinary concentrations found (medians of 8.07 µg L-1 in Iporanga – urban
zone, and 11.04 µg L-1 in the Piririca zone inhabitants) do
not indicate an elevated risk to human health. The results,
however, warn the need to seek solutions for the region’s
economic development, preserving the natural land cover
to avoid deforestation and erosion, risking exposure of the
naturally rich arsenic soil.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to thank the residents of the studied
sites, through their community leaders, the local authorities and professionals, their teachers and headmasters for
their support and the children’s parents who collaborated
voluntarily in this study.
Thanks to FAPESP – the São Paulo State Research
Foundation Project 2002/0271-0, to IAL – the Adolfo Lutz
Institute, São Paulo and to UNICAMP – Campinas University, São Paulo for the financial and logistic support.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ATSDR. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. Toxicological profile for arsenic. Atlanta, GA : US.
Department of Health and Human Services, 2000.
BRAGA, P. S.; FIGUEIREDO, B. R. Comportamento de metais pesados em solos na região do Vale do Ribeira
(SP). In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA,
41., 2002, João Pessoa, PB. Anais. João Pessoa :
SBG. Núcleo Nordeste, 2002. p: 231.
GUO, T.; BAASER, J.; TSALEV, D.L. Fast automated determination of toxicologically relevant arsenic in urine by
flow injection-hydride generation atomic absorption
spectrometry. Anal. Chim Acta, v. 349, p. 313-8,1997.
MANDAL, B.K.; CHOWDHURY, T.R.; SAMANTA, G.;
MUKHERJEE, D.P.; CHANDA, C.R.; SAHA, K,C.;
CHAKRABORT, D. Impact of safe water for drinking
and cooking on five arsenic-affected families for 2
years in West Bengal, India. Sc ence Total Environmental, v. 218, p. 185-201, 1998.
MATSCHULLAT, J.; BORBA, R. P.; DESCHAMPS, E.;
FIGUEIREDO, B.R.; GABRIO, T.E.; SCHWENK, M.
Human and environmental contamination in the iron
quadrangle, Brazil. Applied Geochemistry, v.15,
p.181-90, 2000.
SAKUMA, A.M. Avaliação da exposição humana ao arsênio
no Alto Vale do Ribeira, Brasil. 2004. 197 p. Tese
(Doutorado), Faculdade de Ciências Médicas, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, 2004l.
SAKUMA, A. M.; CAPITANI, E.M.; TIGLEA, P. Arsênio. In:
AZEVEDO, F.A.; CHASIN, A.A.M. Metais gerenciamento da toxicidade, São Paulo : Atheneu, 2003.
p.203-38.
TAKAMORI, A. Y.; FIGUEIREDO, B. R. Monitoramento
da qualidade de água do rio Ribeira de Iguape
para arsênio e metais pesados. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 41., 2002, João Pessoa, PB. Anais.João Pessoa, PB : SBG. Núcleo
Nordeste, 2002. p: 255.
TOUJAGUE, R. Arsênio e metais associados na região
aurífera do Piririca, Vale do Ribeira, São Paulo, Brasil.1999. 94 p. Dissertação (Mestrado) - Instituto de
Geociências, Universidade Estadual de Campinas,
Campinas, 1999.
TREPKA, M.J. et al. Arsenic burden among children in
industrial areas of eastern Germany. Science Total
Environmental, v. 180, p.95-105, 1996.
WHITE, M.A.; SABBIONI, E. Trace element reference
values in tissues from inhabitants of the Europe an
Union. X. A study of 13 elements in blood and urine
of a United Kingdom population. Science Total Environmental, v. 216, p. 253-70, 1998.
– 86 –
LEAD AND
ARSENIC IN SEDIM ENTS
OF THE RIBEIRA DE IGUAPE
RIVER, SP/ PR
¹Idio Lopes Jr.; idiojr@sp.cprm.gov.br
²Bernardino R. Figueiredo; berna@ige.unicamp.br
²Jacinta Enzweiler; jacinta@ige.unicamp.br
²Maria Aparecida Vendemiatto; aparecida@ige.unicamp.br
¹Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/SP
²Geosciences Institute - UNICAMP
INTRODUCTION
The Ribeira do Iguape River hydrographic basin
has an area of about 28,000 km² and is situated in the
Northeast of Paraná State and Southeast of São Paulo
State (Figure 1). It has more than two million hectares of
forest, roughly 21% of the Atlantic Forest (Mata Atlântica)
remnants in the country. The Ribeira River is 470 km long,
of which 120 km is in Paraná and 350 km in São Paulo.
The Upper Ribeira Valley saw intense mining activity
during decades, directed at lead, zinc and silver production. In 1996 the last mines were closed down, leaving
damage to the vegetation and the landscape, especially
from the open pit mines. With the ore processing (Rocha
and Panelas Mines) and metal refining, tailings of waste
were produced that are still exposed and subject to
periodic flooding. On the Ribeira River right margin, in
Adrianópolis, residents continue to be exposed to lead
intoxication, even after the lead plant’s shutdown. In the
Furnas Mine region, studies carried out in 2003, with
fish from the Furnas stream, showed that two species
of sheatfish and catfish were contaminated with lead.
These bottom fish species search for food in the clayish
sediments where the lead fraction is more concentrated
and therefore suffer a serious impact. In the Furnas Mine,
the lead is associated with arsenic. In fact, the arsenic
begins to present anomalous concentrations from the
Betari River onwards, a tributary on the Ribeira River
left margin, where the former Furnas mining fronts are
situated. A little further downstream, in the Castelhanos
and Nhunguara neighborhoods and especially in the
São Pedro and Ivaporunduva rural settlement areas, on
the floodplains of their designated rivers (Ribeira River
left margin), there were ancient gold mineralization sites
(known since the Portuguese colonization) associated
with arsenopyrite. This region, where the predominant
lithology is metapelites intercalated with metabasic/ultrabasic rocks, is geologically known as the Piririca zone.
All these facts motivated the UNICAMP Geosciences
Institute together with the Brazilian Geological Survey
(Serviço Geológico do Brasil – CPRM/SP), the Adolfo
Lutz Institute, the UNICAMP Medical Science Faculty
and the Londrina State University to elaborate and execute this study, financially sponsored by the São Paulo
State Research Foundation - FAPESP. The study seeks
to assess the impact of arsenic and lead on the health of
local inhabitants and the environment. The Low Density
Multi-elemental Geochemical Mapping was accomplished
– 87 –
Lead and arsenic in sediments of the Ribeira de Iguape River, SP/PR
Figure 1 – Location of the Ribeira do Iguape River Basin showing administrative limits, the Basin contour and Atlantic Forest remnants.
using stream bottom sediment samples of the Ribeira
Basin to observe how these elements are distributed or,
in other words, to discover its geochemical landscapes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The geochemical mapping was based on 187 stream
sediment samples from all over the Ribeira do Iguape
River Basin. An additional 25 “overbank” samples were
collected to observe the paleo-landscapes and compare
them with those of today. The samples were gathered
during the dry season to obtain the most representative
material of the basin upstream, avoiding lateral contributions that always occur during torrential rain periods.
Before each sample was extracted, fluvial water physicalchemical parameters were measured with appropriate
equipment: pH, Eh, DO (dissolved oxygen), conductivity,
turbidity and temperature. The “overbank” samples were
taken from the first 30 cm of top soil of paleo alluvial cover.
In the IG-UNICAMP laboratories these sediment
samples were dried, sieved and analyzed through fluo-
rescence X-ray, in the fractions smaller than 180µm (80#)
and 63µm (230#), for 10 oxides (SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, Fe2O3,
MgO, CaO, Na2O, K2O, P2O5) and 21 trace-elements (As,
Ba, Co, Cr, Cu, Ga, Mo, Nb, Ni, Pb, S, Sb, Sn, Sr, Th, U, V,
Y, Zn, Zr). Stream sediment geochemical mappings for As
in Brazil, like other countries, usually the fractions smaller
than 180mm are analyzed. However, considering that
in many Medical Geology/Environmental Geochemistry
studies it is very common to analyze fractions smaller than
63mm, in this study both granulometric fractions were analyzed. In due course it was confirmed that the responses
of both fractions, with regards to geochemical anomalies
identification, are very similar. All the results are gathered
in the Geochemical Atlas of the Ribeira Valley (2005).
ARSENIC
Arsenic (As) can occur in four oxidation states: arsenate (+5), arsenite (+3), arsine (-3) and the metal (0).
The soluble species are, generally, in the oxidation states
+3 and +5. It rarely occurs in the free form and it is usu-
– 88 –
Idio Lopes Jr.
ally bound to sulfur, oxygen and iron (sulfides). The As
compounds present different toxicities depending on the
chemical form. Thus, the As(III) species are ten times
more toxic than As(V). In environmental and biological
monitoring it is important to know which chemical species
are present, and therefore, the geochemical speciation
tests with arsenic are fundamental.
Arsenic has an average mobility, a little higher than
lead, both in acid and alkaline environments, which explains its proximity to its source, as observed in the geochemical maps (Figures 2 and 3). The main host of gold
is arsenopyrite, but as the gold exploration here was not
intense, on the contrary to lead, there was no As pollution
due to this activity along the Ribeira River.
On the maps, the sub-basin sediments enriched and
very enriched with As (Figures 2 and 3) accurately reflect
the influence areas of the ancient lead mines strongly
associated with arsenic (Rocha, Panelas, Laranjal and
Furnas Mines). They also reveal the zones with gold mineralization associated with arsenic, zinc and copper sulfides
(Piririca zone-São Pedro, focused on the Ivaporunduva
River, represented by the sub-basin sampling point 132
and the headwaters of the Pedro Cubas River, upstream
of the sampling site 140). The sub-basins, which contain
the Ribeira River whose sediments are enriched with As
in the Piririca zone, reflect a geochemical dispersion effect of those mineralized zones, as well as the presence
of mineralized veins that intersect the Ribeira River in the
Castelhanos neighborhood. The values found in stream
sediments are always lower that those found in the soils
that originated the geochemical anomalies. According
to the D.D. nº 195-2005 of 11.23.2005 from CETESB, the
As intervention value (above which there are direct or
indirect potential risks to human health, considering a
generic exposure setting) for agricultural soils is 35 ppm
and 55 ppm for residential soils.
During the multidisciplinary project, the populations
exposed to those arsenic geochemical anomalies were
studied through urinary arsenic analysis of adults and
children. Although surface water monitoring has shown
an As enrichment in the rivers that drain the mineralized
zones, its concentrations are inferior to the limit of 10
g/L established by the National Environmental Council
(Conselho Nacional de Meio Ambiente- CONAMA) and
by the WHO (World Health Organization).
LEAD
Lead is a naturally occurring element, relatively
abundant on the Earth’s crust, almost always as lead
sulfide (galena), generally associated with other elements such as zinc, copper, cadmium, silver and gold.
In contaminated aquatic systems, most of the metal is
strongly fixed to bottom sediments. In aquatic organisms,
the lead accumulation in sediments is influenced by sev-
eral environmental factors such as temperature, pH, Eh,
salinity, in addition to the humic acids content. As a salt,
lead presents high toxicity for aquatic invertebrates, in
concentrations above 0.1 mg/L for fresh water organisms
and 2.5 mg/L for sea organisms. High metal levels in soil
can lead to its capture by plants and lixiviation to surface
and groundwater. In São Paulo State, the CETESB established reference values for soil and groundwater (D.D. nº
195-2005-E of 11.23.2005). For lead in agricultural soil,
the intervention value is 180 ppm and for residential soils
300 ppm. Considering the high geochemical anomalies
in the Ribeira Valley stream sediments, and that these
concentrations are considerable diluted compared to
the corresponding soil anomalies, therefore, there is a
constant exposure risk to lead toxicity by the various
valley settlements.
Lead exploration in the Ribeira Valley, until the midnineties, is well portrayed on the geochemical lead maps
(Figures 4 and 5). The ore wastes thrown into the drainages and stocked on their margins, associated with steep
topography and frequent torrential rains, were responsible
for the enrichment of the Ribeira River sediments from
the Rocha Mine in Paraná State until its mouth in the
Iguape-Cananéia estuarial complex on the South coast
of São Paulo.
The Panelas Mine, which belonged to the Plumbum
Company, in Adrianópolis –Paraná State, may be considered principally responsible for the lead concentrations
on the Ribeira River bed. That company, situated on the
river’s right margin, processed the ore (predominantly
galena) and, in addition to dumping residues and effluents directly into the river, piled up waste and refining
residues on it’s margins, as observed until recently.
Part of the contaminated material has also reached
the streets and yards of the workers settlements (Mota
and Capelinha Neighborhoods) adjacent to the mine.
Previous studies developed in that region, with 7 to
14 year-old children, showed mean concentrations of
11.89 g/dL Pb in their blood (health control agencies
stipulate a maximum value is 10 g/dL), reaching 37.8
g/dL in some of them.
Lead is an element that has low mobility in any
environment (oxidant, reducing, acid and alkaline) and
co-precipitates easily with Fe-Mn oxides; therefore the
stream sediments quickly lose Pb content from an occurrence or a mineral deposit. The SGB/CPRM developed
gold research during many years in the Piririca zone-São
Pedro and finally discovered a gold deposit associated
with arsenic, lead, zinc and copper sulfides. This deposit is situated at the watershed of the São Pedro River
(Figures 4 and 5 - a drainage on the Pilões River left
margin, a little upstream from sampling point 133, close
to the Pilões River mouth with the Ribeira River) and the
Ivaporunduva River (sub-basin of the point 132). Here
– 89 –
Lead and arsenic in sediments of the Ribeira de Iguape River, SP/PR
– 90 –
Figure 2 – Arsenic geochemical pattern in fractions < 180μm. The blue sub-basin area presented samples with values < 2,3ppm; green between 2,3 and 11,9ppm and the regional
background samples presented values; orange, between 12 and 34ppm and red values > 34ppm.
– 91 –
Idio Lopes Jr.
Figure 3 – Arsenic geochemical pattern in fractions < 63μm. The blue sub-basin area presented samples with values < 3ppm; green between 3 and 12,3ppm and the regional background samples presented values; orange between 12,4 and 29,6ppm and red values > 29,7ppm.
Lead and arsenic in sediments of the Ribeira de Iguape River, SP/PR
– 92 –
Figure 4 – Lead geochemical pattern in fractions < 180μm. The blue sub-basin area resented samples with values < 14ppm; green between 14 and 36,9ppm, and the regional background samples presented values; orange between 37 and 124ppm and red values > 124ppm.
– 93 –
Idio Lopes Jr.
Figure 5 – Lead geochemical pattern in fractions < 63μm. The blue sub-basin area presented sample with values < 18ppm; green between 18 and 49,9ppm and the regional background samples presented values; orange between 50 and 123ppm and red values > 123ppm.
Lead and arsenic in sediments of the Ribeira de Iguape River, SP/PR
the lead anomalies in the soil exceeded values of 500
ppm, whereas in the stream sediments sampling points,
close-by, they were not anomalous (point 133) or did not
exceed 124 ppm (point 132).
Thus, the difference between the lead ionic dispersion in the Piririca zone-São Pedro and the predominantly clastic dispersion (ore and slag particulate) in
the Ribeira River bed stands out as being the only
source of the sediments anomalous values hundreds
of kilometers downstream from the last lead source.
This is even with the daily removal of tens of tons of civil
construction sand from the Ribeira River channel near
the town of Registro.
Lead was not found in the Ribeira River water or
its main tributaries between Iporanga and Eldorado
cities, confirmed by the monitoring during the project,
and thus presenting no risks to health and the environment. However, the same does not apply to the Ribeira
River bed sediments and all its tributaries that have lead
mines in their catchments. In a study of fish from Furnas
Creek, sampled between 1998 and 2000 by a team from
Chalmers Technology University of Göteborg, Sweden,
two species of catfish and sheatfish were found, that
presented 50% less enzyme ALAD activity, compared to
those of the same species from non-contaminated rivers.
(This enzyme is related to red blood cells synthesis and
normally used as an environmental lead presence indicator.) These bottom fish species are affected by pollution
because they take their food from the clayish sediments
where lead is highly concentrated. High concentrations
of Pb were observed in these fish tissues, as well as a
lower relation length/weight, low reproductive capacity
and consequently a smaller number of fish (75% less)
per area compared to other non-contaminated creeks of
similar size in the region.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
AZEVEDO, F. A.; CHASIN, A. A. M. Metais: gerenciamento
da toxidade. São Paulo: Atheneu, 2003. 554 p.
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA DE SANEAMENTO
AMBIENTAL – CETESB. Decisão de Diretoria Nº 1952005-E: de 23 de novembro de 2005. São Paulo:
[s.n.], 2005. 4 p. CONSELHO NACIONAL DO MEIO
AMBIENTE – CONAMA. Resolução nº357: de 17 de
março de 2005. 23 p.
CUNHA, F. G. Contaminação humana e ambiental por
chumbo no Vale do Ribeira nos Estados de São
Paulo e Paraná. 2003. 111p. Tese (Doutorado) –
Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Instituto de
Geociências, Campinas, 2003.
FIGUEIREDO, B. R. Minérios e ambiente. Campinas:
Editora da Unicamp, 2000. 401 p.
GREENWOOD, N. N.; EARNSHAW, A. Chemistry of the elements. 2.ed. [S.l.]: Elsevier Science, 1997. 1305 p.
HOWARTH, R. J.; THORNTON, I. Regional geochemical mapping and its applications to environmental
studies. In: APPLIED environmental geochemistry.
London: Academic Press, 1983. p. 41-78.
LEVINSON, A. A. Introduction to exploration geochemistry. Ottawa: Applied Publishing Academic Press,
1974. 612 p.
LICHT, O. A. B. et al. Levantamento geoquímico multielementar de baixa densidade no Estado do Paraná:
hidrogeoquímica - resultados preliminares. A Terra
em Revista, Belo Horizonte, v. 3, n.3, p. 34-46, 1997.
LOPES JR., I. Atlas geoquímico do Vale do Ribeira. [S.l.]
: FAPESP; CPRM-SGB, 2005. 77 p.
LOPES JR., I. et al. A prospecção geoquímica descobrindo novas mineralizações auríferas no Vale do
Ribeira. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 38.,1994, Balneário de Camboriú. Anais.Balneário de Camboriú : SBG, 1994. 3v. v. 3., p.170-171.
LOPES JR., I.; VASCONCELOS, C. S. de; WILDNER, W. ;
SILVA, L. A. C. Geoquímica das Folhas Jacupiranga
e Rio Guaraú (1:50.000). In: SIMPÓSIO DE GEOLOGIA DO SUDESTE, 6., 1999, São Pedro, SP. Boletim
de Resumos. São Paulo : SBG, Núcleos São Paulo/
Rio de Janeiro/ Espirito Santo, 1999. p. 38.
LOPES JR., I. 2001. Projeto Mogi-Guaçu / Pardo. Levantamento Geoquímico das Bacias dos Rios MogiGuaçu e Pardo, SP. São Paulo: CPRM – Serviço
Geológico do Brasil ; Secretaria de Estado do Meio
Ambiente de São Paulo, 2001. 77 p.
MINERAIS DO PARANÁ S. A. – MINEROPAR . Atlas Geoquímico do Estado do Paraná. Curitiba, 2001. 80 p.
MORAES, R.; GERHARD, P.; ANDERSSON, L.; STURWE,
J.; RAUGH, S.; SVERKER M. Establishing causality
between exposure to metals and effects on fish.
Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, v. 9, n. 1,
p. 149-169, 2003.
ROSE, A. W.; HAWKES, H. E.; WEBB, J. S. Geochemistry
in Mineral Exploration. 2.ed. New York : Academic
Press, 1979. 657 p.
THORNTON, I. Applied Environmental Geochemistry.
London : Academic Press, 1983. 501 p.
WRIGHT, J. Environmental Chemistry. London: Routledge,
2003. 409 p.
– 94 –
ENVIRONM ENTAL
AND HUM AN HEALTH
DIAGNOSIS:
LEAD CONTAM INATION
IN ADRIANÓPOLIS,
PARANÁ STATE BRAZIL
¹Fernanda Gonçalves da Cunha, fernanda.cunha@cprm.gov.br
²Bernardino Ribeiro de Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicamp.br
³Mônica Maria Bastos Paoliello, monibas@sercomtel.com.br
4
Eduardo Mello de Capitani, capitani@hc.unicamp.br
¹Geologic Survey of Brazil - CPRM/RJ;
²Geosciences InstituteI -UNICAMP;
³State University of Londrina -UEL
4
Medical Sciences Faculty - UNICAMP;
INTRODUCTION
During many decades the Upper Ribeira Valley had
been under the influence of lead mining activities and a
refining and processing plant for the ore produced in the
region’s Plumbum Company mines. All operations ceased in
1996, leaving the Ribeira River margins heaped with waste
and slag residues from the refinery’s activities. During the
50 years of Plumbum operations, a great amount of lead enriched particulate material was released into the atmosphere
which became deposited on the surrounding soil surface.
The local population also used these residue materials for
street paving in Mota and Capelinha neighborhoods, rural
areas of Adrianópolis, near Plumbum, in Paraná State.
Between 1999 and 2001 an environmental assessment associated with a human monitoring program was
developed in the Upper Ribeira Valley region with residents in areas close to the mines and to the Plumbum
plant: Ribeira and Iporanga (Serra neighborhood) in São
Paulo State and Adrianópolis (Mota, Capelinha and Porto
Novo neighborhoods), in Paraná State. The assessment
also included the Cerro Azul population situated upstream
of the mining area, in Paraná. It sought to investigate if
environmental contamination caused by the lead mining
activities was impacting the populations living in the Upper Ribeira Valley.
PHYSIOGRAPHIC ASPECTS
The studied area is situated in the Ribeira Valley, in the South of São Paulo State and the East of
Paraná State, delimited by the coordinates latitudes
– 95 –
Environmental and human health diagnosis: lead ontamination in Adrianópolis, Paraná State Brazil
25º00’ - 25º30’ South and longitudes 48º30’ - 49º30’
West (Figure 1).
The Ribeira do Iguape River hydrographic basin
consists of the areas (about 25,000 km²), drained by
the Ribeira River and its main tributaries, 61% in São
Paulo State. On its initial course the Ribeira river stretches
120km across Paraná State, acting as a border between
the two states for about 90km. After being joined by the
Pardo River, it extends for a further 260km in São Paulo
State until reaching its mouth in the important IguapeCananéia estuarine-lagoon complex on the South coast
of São Paulo.
The region’s climate is humid subtropical. The mean
annual temperatures oscillate around 20ºC. On the coastal
area, December, January and February are the hottest
months with average temperatures of 25ºC, and May
through August the coldest with average temperatures
of 18ºC. In June and July minimum daily temperatures
of 0ºC are common, frost occurring quite frequently. The
average annual rainfall is around 1,500 and 2,500 mm.
The coastal and mountain areas receive more of the rain.
The heaviest daily rainfalls occur between October and
March. According to the National Meteorological InstituteInstituto Nacional de Meteorologia, the predominant winds
in the Upper Valley area are West-Southwest (WSW).
The high regional rainfall contributes to the exuberance of the Sub-deciduous Tropical Forest that still covers
vast extents of the region and that are preserved as primitive forests. These areas constitute reserves and state
parks. The secondary forests already occupy a much
larger area than the primary ones and they are spreading even further due to the parks’ insufficient delimitation
and control. Completing the vegetation cover pattern,
about 30% of the region is occupied by banana and tea
plantations, shrubs and pastures.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC ASPECTS
In the past the Ribeira do Iguape Valley was one of
the largest lead metallogenetic provinces in Brazil and
had the Plumbum refining plant, as a parallel activity to
mining. It was installed at the entrance to the Panelas de
Brejaúva Mine, in Vila Mota neighborhood, in Adrianópolis and used to process the ore produced in the whole
region. Mineral production in the Ribeira Valley today is
reduced to non-metal exploration such as limestone, clay,
ornamental rocks and fluorite.
The mining activities represented a temporary prosperity period for the Upper Ribeira Valley region and its
decline lead to a significant fall of income and employ-
Figure 1 – Location of the Ribeira Valley.
– 96 –
Fernanda Gonçalves da Cunha
ment levels for the local population. The human development indexes (IDH-M) of these cities, according to PNUD,
are the lowest in the Ribeira Valley and far inferior to the
São Paulo and Paraná States’ means. The different social
indicators, such as income level, employment, industrial
investments, education, infant mortality and public health
converge characterize the Ribeira Valley as relatively poor,
though some areas, more oriented to the banana culture,
trade and tourism, present a greater economic dynamism.
GEOLOGY
The Ribeira Valley region, from the geotectonic point
of view, is inserted in the Ribeira Fold Belt Zone, characterized by a large number of longitudinal sub-vertical
faults representing shear zones. These shear zones affect both the basement rocks and the metasedimentary
sequences that define a corridor about 100km wide and
1,000km long, denominated Apiaí-São Roque Fold Belt
Zone. It is NE-SW oriented, characterized by intercalation of low to medium degree metamorphic sets, granite
complexes and gneiss-granite and/or gneiss-migmatitic/
granulitic complexes (Daitx, 1996; Dardenne & Schobbenhaus, 2001).
The Archean gneisses and migmatites, which were
described as the basement (crystalline complex) for the
supracrustal sequences belonging to the Açungui Group
(deposited in the medium-superior Proterozoic), predominate regionally. The Açungui Group is subdivided in the
Setuva (basal), Capiru, Itaiacoca, Votuverava and Água
Clara Formations, Lageado Subgroup, Perau Complex
and the Turvo-Cajati Sequence. The lithostratigraphic
units (carbonates) showing (Pb-Zn) mineralization are in
the Perau Complex and in the Lageado Subgroup.
LEAD: HUMAN CONTAMINATION
Both children and adults are susceptible to ill-health
effects due to lead exposure. However, the exposure
path and the effects can be very different. Children are
more exposed in regions presenting environmental contamination due to their behavior and physiology, whereas
adults are more exposed in their working activities, as in
industries and refineries.
The lead absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract
in older children and adults comes mainly from the ingestion of food and water, whereas in younger children it
comes from the inhalation of dust and ingestion of small
soil particles (WHO, 1995).
Children are considered a high risk group since they
absorb and retain a greater quantity of the ingested lead
than adults.
The CDC (1991) recommended, as a maximum limit,
10mg Lead/dL blood in children to define a high lead dose
exposure risk and consequent long term adverse effects.
Chronic exposure to levels above this value can lead to
damaging effects to health irreversibly compromising the
central nervous system and also causing anemia, renal
and vitamin D metabolism alterations.
Adults with contents between 40 and 60 g/dL Lead
in the blood may present neurobehavioral symptoms
such as humor disorders and peripheral neuropathies as
well as general symptoms such as fatigue, somnolence,
irritability, dizziness, muscular pains and gastrointestinal
problems. Levels above 60 g/dL can produce significant
symptoms of mental and neurological alterations in addition to typical abdominal cramps.
POPULATION AND METHODS
To put into practice the human monitoring program,
the project had to be submitted to the Ethics Committee
of the UNICAMP Medical Sciences Faculty, followed by
meetings with city representatives and health secretaries
involved in the study. Subsequently, school headmasters,
teachers, parents and those responsible for public school
children received explanations about the goals of the assessment and request their authorization for the voluntary
participation.
Blood samples of 335 children between 7 and 14
years old and 350 adults between 15 and 70 years old
were collected in Ribeira and Iporanga cities in São Paulo
State and Adrianópolis (Capelinha, Vila Mota and Porto
Novo) and Cerro Azul in Paraná State.
At the time of the blood sampling, questionnaires
were applied for information about food habits, health,
parents’ occupation, time of residence, among other
questions, necessary for the final data interpretation.
The lead in the blood samples was analyzed through
atomic absorption spectrophotometry coupled to a graphite oven, in the Adolfo Lutz Institute, in São Paulo.
To address the environmental contamination, 13
samples of domestic tap water used for consumption
were collected from some residences situated within the
studied area. In addition to those, 21 surface soil samples
(0-20cm depth) at a distance of up to 9.5km from Plumbum, including 4 samples of domestic vegetable garden
soil, were collected as well as samples of the waste piles
and slag.
The water consumed by the population living in
the urban area of Adrianópolis and Cerro Azul is supplied by the Paraná State Water Services CompanyCompanhia de Saneamento do Paraná (SANEPAR),
and in the urban area of Ribeira and Iporanga by the
Water Company of São Paulo-Companhia de Saneamento Básico do Estado de São Paulo (SABESP). The
residences of the rural area of Vila Mota, Capelinha and
Porto Novo do not belong to the treated water network
instead they take water from springs and directly from
the Ribeira River.
– 97 –
Environmental and human health diagnosis: lead ontamination in Adrianópolis, Paraná State Brazil
The selection of the residences
was based on random assignments,
but at least one sample was collected
in each studied area and from different
sources used by the population.
The water samples were filtered in
0.45m cellulose acetate membranes
and stored in sterilized 50ml centrifuge
type polyethylene tubes and soon after
acidified with 1ml nitric acid 1:1, maintaining the pH 2, to preserve the sample
until analyzed.
For the analysis of lead concentrations in soils, the granulometric fraction
smaller than 177µm (fine sand to very
Figure 2 – Lead content arithmetic mean in the blood samples of children.
fine clay) was used, considering that
the soil contamination by this metal
Azul (2.37 g/dL) is twice to three times less than those
through atmospheric sources (refinery
of the other studied populations. Cerro Azul is situated
emissions) tends to disperse as fine particles. It is in this
upstream of the Upper Valley lead mines and did not
finer fraction that lead tends to accumulate.
suffer the influence of the mining activities. Therefore the
Lead contents in water, soils and waste samples
value 2.37 g/dL can be considered as a reference value
were analyzed through atomic absorption spectrometry
or background for lead in the blood of children living in
with plasma source (ICP/AES), in the Mineral Analysis
the Upper Ribeira Valley region.
Laboratory-Laboratório de Análises Minerais (LAMIN),
The differences of lead concentration means beof SGB, in Rio de Janeiro.
tween boys and girls were significant in all of the studied
populations. Boys presented higher values than girls
RESULTS
(Figure 3).
The questionnaire data assessment confirmed that
Human contamination
the children who ate home grown vegetables showed
higher Pb S contents than those who ate food from other
Children
sources. This may indicate that food is one of the lead
The lead content arithmetic mean in the blood
entrance paths to a child’s organism (Figure 4).
samThe lead content arithmetic mean in the children’s
The assessment results showed that all particiblood samples (PbS) was 7.40 g/dL, varying between
pant
children, except those from Cerro Azul, had Pb S
concentrations lower than 1.8 g/dL and 37.8 g/dL. Figure
above
10 g/dL, characterizing a long term health risk,
2 shows the lead content arithmetic means of the children
according to the sampled
sites.
The highest arithmetic mean occurred among
children living closer to the
Plumbum refinery and to the
Panelas Lead Mine in a 2km
perimeter in Vila Mota and
Capelinha, rural area of Adrianópolis. Vila Mota showed
the highest values for PbS, a
value corresponding to nearly
four times the value suggested
by CDC (1991) and WHO
(1995) as a limit to maintain
children’s health (10 g/dL). On
the other hand, the arithmetic
mean found in the children
population living in Cerro
Figure 3 – Lead content arithmetic mean in the blood samples of children according to their sex.
– 98 –
Fernanda Gonçalves da Cunha
according to CDC (1991). Furthermore,
it was evident that 59.6% of the children
living in Vila Mota and Capelinha, in the
Plumbum refinery proximity, presented
even higher lead contents, needing periodical medical examinations, and 12
children showed lead contents in blood
above 20 g/dL, already requiring medical
intervention.
Adults
The results showed that the adults
living in the Plumbum refinery proximity,
in Vila Mota and Capelinha, presented
blood lead contents higher than those
of the other populations (Paoliello et al.
2003), similar to the analytical data found
Figure 4 – Lead content arithmetic mean in the blood samples of children according
for children (Figure 5).
to their food ingestion behavior.
According to the questionnaire data,
the adults who presented the highest
lead content in blood were male who had worked in the Surface soils, material from the piles of waste and slag
lead refining plant. This means part of the lead found
The lead concentrations in the soil samples varied
in the blood samples can be residual. Recent studies between 21 and 916 µg/g, the highest contents occurring
showed that the adult male, even when exposed to in the sites closer to the Plumbum refining plant (Table
low concentrations, can present health problems as, 1). In the slag residues and waste, concentrations were
for example, a diminishing of the cognitive functions.
respectively 2.5% and 0.7% of lead. These are extremely
high values, especially considering these are places
Environmental Contaminatio
where children play everyday.
According to the CETESB (2001), soils with lead
Drinking water
contents above 100µg/g can indicate a quality alteration
Lead concentrations in residential tap waters were presenting a potential risk to human health, and values
veryLead concentrations in residential tap water were exceeding 350µg/g remediation environmental studies
very low (<0.005 to 0.008mg/L) compared to the allowed become necessary. Based on this evidence the soil in the
value for lead in drinking water according to the Brazilian Plumbum proximity can be considered lead contaminated
Ministry of Health (Brasil, 2005). This showed that domes- presenting a health risk to the populations living there.
tic water was not contaminated with lead, independent These results include the residential garden soil that deof its origin.
mand further investigation regarding the lead contents in
the food cultivated there.
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS
Figure 5 – Lead content arithmetic mean in the blood samples of adults.
– 99 –
The results for lead in the blood of the
Upper Ribeira Valley inhabitants and in the
soil samples indicate that the activities resulting from the lead ore refining processes
by Plumbum affected all the assessed population, except for the reference population
(Cerro Azul).
However, the Vila Mota and Capelinha
child populations had the highest number
of blood samples with lead values above
10µg/dL (about 60%) compared to the other
populations (about 8%). Several factors may
have contributed to these results, such as
the direct involvement of a family member
at the refinery (work position); nevertheless
Environmental and human health diagnosis: lead ontamination in Adrianópolis, Paraná State Brazil
Table 1 - Lead Concentration in topsoil samples
4
63
6.2
1km
5
672
6.7
1km
6*
904
6.5
300m
health risks, though more recent studies point to health
risks in even lower concentrations.
The lead in the particulate material dispersed through
the refinery’s chimney and deposited on the adjacent soil
surface (residual contamination) suggest that currently the
children of Vila Mota and Capelinha are exposed to lead
intoxication and, consequently, present the most elevated
lead blood contents.
These results show the necessity of environmental
studies to rehabilitate the area and provide medical assistance and monitoring programs, especially designed
for the children living close to the Plumbum refinery.
7
397
6.5
500m
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
8
916
6.3
900m
9*
802
5.5
900m
10
76
5
1km
11
117
6.7
1.4km
12
245
5.9
1.5km
13*
217
7.2
1.7km
14*
293
6.3
1.8km
15
37
5.9
2km
16
52
5.6
3.5km
17
76
5.9
3.6km
18
58
5.8
4.5km
19
21
5.6
6.5km
20
37
5.8
6.0km
21
26
5.5
9.5km
Sample
Number
Lead content
(ug g-1)
pH
Distance from
Lead Plant
1
175
6.6
5km
2
432
6.6
2.5km
3
343
7.9
1.2km
* soil from residential gardens
the proximity to the refinery, where the soils presented
high lead concentrations, was the most important one.
The children’s habits of putting dirty hands and toys in
their mouth make the ingestion of soil particles possible,
characterizing an entrance path of the metal into the
child’s organism.
The results of the adult population blood samples
analyses showed that those living near the Plumbum
refinery presented higher lead levels, similar to the analytical data found for children. The adults who presented
the highest blood lead contents (48µg/dL) were males
who had worked in the lead refining plant. According to
WHO (1995) these lead contents in adults do not present
BRASIL. Ministério da Saúde. Portaria ms nº 528/2004.
Brasilia, DF, 2001. 28p. Disponível em <http://portal.
saude.gov.br/portal/arquivos/pdf/potaria_518_2004.
pdf. Acesso em: 04 maio 2005.
CDC – CENTERS OF DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION. U.S.Department of Health and Human Services, Atlanta. Preventing lead poisoning in young
children. 1991. Disponível em: <http://www.astdr.
cdc. gov/lead5.htm>. Acesso em: 03 julho 2001.
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA DE SANEAMENTO AMBIENTAL - CETESB. Relatório de estabelecimento de
valores orientadores para solos e águas subterrâneas
no Estado de São Paulo. São Paulo, 1996. 73p.
DAITX, E.C. Origem e evolução dos depósitos sulfetados Tipo-Perau (Pb-Zn-Ag), com base nas jazidas
Canoas e Perau (Vale do Ribeira, PR). 1996. 453p.
Tese (Doutorado em Geociências)-Universidade
Estadual Paulista, Rio Claro, SP, 1996.
DARDENNE, M.A.; SCHOBBENHAUS, C. Metalogênese
do Brasil. Brasília: Ed. UNB, 2001. Cap. 3, p. 232238.
PAOLIELLO,M.M.B.; CAPITANI,E.M.; CUNHA,F.G.;
CARVALHO,M.F.; MATSUO,T.; SAKUMA,A.;
FIGUEIREDO, B.R. Determinants of blood lead
levels in an adult population from a mining area in
Brazil. Journal de Physique IV, [S.l.], v. 107. P. 127,
may 2003.
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO). International
Programme on Chemical Safety. Environmental
Health Criteria 165. Inorganic lead. Geneva, 1995.
300 p.
– 100 –
STUDY OF AEROSOLS
ISOTOPIC (Pb)
COM POSITION AND
SOURCES
IN BRASÍLIA (DF) –
CENTRAL BRAZIL
¹Simone M.C.L. Gioia, sgioia@unb.br
²Márcio M. Pimentel
³Américo Kerr
¹Geosciences Institute, University of São Paulo - USP
²Geosciences Institute, University of Brasília - UnB
³Physics Institute, University of São Paulo - USP
ABSTRACT
This study reported the first Brazilian aerosols composition data using both TIMS, to determine Pb concentrations and isotopic compositions, and PIXE, to obtain
multi-elemental chemical concentrations. The particulate
material was collected at the University of Brasília (UnB),
in Brasília and in a remote area, to characterize the
background composition. The atmospheric particulate
was separated in two fractions of mean aerodynamic
diameter of (Ф)– 2.5µm< Ф <10µm (coarse or PM10-2.5)
and Ф < 2.5µm (fine or PM2.5), with a 12-hour sampling
(day and night). Two sampling periods, one in winter and
the other in summer allowed specific seasonal characterization. The project’s goal was to investigate the impact
of increased anthropogenic activities in the region and
identify the main local sources of air pollution.
There was a contribution of the larger elements in
both fractions, showing the geogenic input was quite
significant during winter. The anthropogenic elements
in the fraction PM2.5 (as Pb and S) represented, mainly,
the combustion of fossil fuels, though it may be also
attributed to increased human activity and spot fires in
the savannah (cerrado). The isotopic Pb compositions
defined a diagram with ternary mixtures, indicating
the contribution of: (i) anthropogenic sources, such as
vehicle exhaust (combustion), (ii) industrial emissions
and (iii) rocks and soils, which represent the natural
sources.
INTRODUCTION
The chemical and isotopic composition of atmospheric particulate material and aerosols has been extensively used as a reliable tool to track pollution sources all
over the world (Chow et al., 1975; Rosman et al., 2000).
In Brazil more detailed studies of this kind are rare (e.g.,
Aily, 2001), therefore, this study, made a comprehensive
investigation of the chemical and isotopic composition of
aerosols in Brasília.
– 101 –
Study of aerosols isotopic (pb) composition and sources in Brasília (DF) – Central Brazil
The construction of Brasília, the Federal Capital of
Brazil, started in 1956, in the Brazilian Central Highlands.
The climate is very dry and mild in winter and hot and
humid in summer. In 2000, the population of the Pilot Plan
(Plano Piloto) and some adjacent areas reached 272,000
inhabitants. The city’s progressive increase in the surrounding area infrastructure introduced many expressive
environmental changes to the region such as, the transit
of 733,000 vehicles (IBGE, 2005; http://www.ibge.gov.br).
The air quality had been considered excellent; however,
such an intense urban growth suggests that a routine air
quality control should be established.
The atmospheric particles were collected at two
sites (one urban the other remote), in two fractions with a
mean aerodynamic diameter of PM10-2.5 and PM2.5, during
12-hour periods (day and might), in summer and winter.
Pb concentration and isotopic composition, chemical elements and total mass were investigated in the aerosols,
associating these with the seasonal variability and the
sources’ location. Two methods were used to analyze
the aerosols: 1) Particle Induced X-ray Emission (PIXE),
to determine the chemical elements with atomic number
higher than 12; 2) Isotopic Dilution-Thermal Ionization
Mass Spectrometry (ID-TIMS) to determine the concentration and the Pb isotopic compositions (204Pb, 206Pb,
207
Pb and 208Pb).
EXPERIMENTAL
Local Geology
The local geology (Figure 1) is characterized by
the low degree metamorphic rocks of the Meso- to the
Neoproterozoic, represented by pelitic, psamitic and
carbonatic metasediments, belonging to the Canastra,
Paranoá, Araxá and Bambuí Groups.
Sampling Procedures
Sample data of the urban and the remote sites in
Brasília (Figure 1) is shown in Table 1. The remote area
lies approximately 40km to the Southwest of the UnB
(University of Brasília) sampling site. Fuel samples and
particulate material from industrial emissions and landfill
soils (considered here to be the main anthropogenic pollution sources) were analyzed. The rock and soil samples
were analyzed to characterize the isotopic composition
of geogenic Pb in the region.
TIMS Analytical Procedure
The soil, rock and particulate samples were treated
with a mixture of HF, HNO3 and HCl acids for total decomposition. The whole procedure for the particulate material,
fuel, rock and soil analyses is detailed in Gioia (2004).
The Pb isotopic ratios were measured by thermionic mass
spectrometry, using a Finnigan MAT 262 multi-collector,
at the Geochronology laboratory of the University of
Brasília. The Pb analytical white for the total procedure
was=120 pg.
PIXE Analytical Procedure
The analyses were made according to the procedure
set by the LAMFI Ion Beam Materials Laboratory of the
Physics Institute of the University of São Paulo. The data
reduction was made using the software Axil (Espen et
al., 1991), the spectrum adjustment having presented x
2 smaller than 2.0.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Pb isotopes
The urban aerosols (at the UnB site) showed
206
Pb/207Pb and 208Pb/206Pb ratios varying from 1.1219
to 1.2062 and 2.0094 to 2.1337, respectively, forming a
linear trend (Figure 2).
Most samples include 206Pb/207Pb ratios in the interval
between 1.150 and 1.200, approximately, and concentrations between 10.7 and 0.07ng/m3, during summer,
and 25.4 and 0.04ng/m3, during winter (Figure 3a). At
the remote area (CIAB site) the interval of the 206Pb/207Pb
ratios was very similar to those found at the UnB site,
although with low Pb concentrations (Figure 3b). Usually,
the particulate compositions were very homogeneous.
They were, however, more radiogenic and tend to present low concentrations during the winter and in summer
during the night; elevated Pb concentrations occur by day
Table 1 - Sampling sites (Brasília, summer and winter 2003)
Sampling Sites
Ident.
Samples (1W2h, day and night)
Location
Summer
Winter
Period
Samples
Period
Samples
UNB
Urban – University Campus (UNB)
01/16-23
01/28-02/21
47
07/14-20
07/28-08/23
56
CIAB
Remote – Preserved Area (CIAB)
01/29-02/08
10
08/12-08/23
12
– 102 –
Simone M.C.L. Giota
Figure 1 – Schematic geological map of the Federal District (modified by Freitas-Silva & Campos 1998) and sampling site locations.
Figure 2 – Comparison between the 208Pb/206Pb and 206Pb/207Pb
rates obtained in this study.
Figure 3a – Comparison between the 206Pb/207Pb rates and the Pb
concentration for summer and winter at the UNP sampling point.
– 103 –
Study of aerosols isotopic (pb) composition and sources in Brasília (DF) – Central Brazil
with the increase of human activity and natural fires,
very common in winter. The isotopic results showed that
the anthropogenic sources are common to the vehicle
exhaust (fossil fuels combustion) and cement industrial
emissions, whereas the natural sources are rocks and
soils.
Although Brasília has a good air quality, the inhalable
particulate concentrations are smaller than 24.1 ± 7.2 µg/
m³ (winter) and 11.0 ± 4.3 µg/m³ (summer), showing an
evident influence of urbanization. Within the urban fringe,
concentrations are higher than in the remote area – 19.7 ±
5.3 µg/m³ (winter) and 10.1 ± 3.9 µg/m³ (summer) – when
compared to the same sampling period.
Figure 3b – Comparison between the 206Pb/207Pb rates and the Pb
concentration for summer and winter at the CIAB sampling point.
during winter. That indicates an important anthropogenic
contribution by day, when human activity is elevated and
the traffic is more intense. Less radiogenic compositions
were observed mainly in the fraction PM2.5 by day.
Comparing the Brasília aerosol data with the Pb isotopic compositions in fuel (206Pb/207Pb = 1.1298-1.192),
industrial filters collected at the central bus station in Brasília (206Pb/207Pb = 1.1682) and in industries (206Pb/207Pb
= 1.2240-1.2569 to the North and 1.1740 to the South), it
became clear that vehicle exhaust represents the main contributor to air pollution both in the remote (CIAB) and UnB
areas, whose Pb isotopic compositions were found in the
interval of the atmospheric particulate samples (Figure 04).
However, the study shows geogenic sources also
contribute with Pb in aerosols. This is demonstrated by
the isotopic compositions of the region’s rocks and soils
(Figure 4). The rocks presented 206Pb/207Pb rates/ratios
varying between 1.1643 and 1.5993 and the most radiogenic came from the PPC unit samples of the Paranoá
Group carbonates, situated to the North of Brasília. The
soil samples presented an interval of 1.1762-1.2569 for
the 206Pb/207Pb rate/ratio; however soils that were lixiviated
with weak acid attack, presented less radiogenic isotopic
compositions than those obtained with total attack: for lixiviated (206Pb/207Pb = 1.1762-1.2228) and total (206Pb/207Pb
= 1.1976-1.2569).
Multielemental Analyses with PIXE
Significant contributions of the elements Al, K, Si,
Ti and Fe (Figure 4) were observed during winter and
summer in the coarse fraction that is typical of the geogenic contribution. In urban environments the elements
Pb and S (Figure 5) are normally associated with the
anthropogenic sources. They are found in the fine and
coarse particles but S is abundant in the PM2.5 fraction
that represents the burning of fossil fuels. This identifies
CONCLUSION
The contribution of larger elements in the fraction
PM2.5-10 is very significant during winter showing an elevated geogenic contribution. Pb and S were present in the
fine and coarse fractions indicating both anthropogenic
and geogenic action. Pb was more abundant during winter in the coarse fraction, according to the isotopic data.
The Pb isotopic compositions define a ternary diagram, indicating the contribution from: (i) anthropogenic
sources, such as vehicle exhaust (combustion), (ii) industrial emission and (iii) rocks and soils of the Paranoá,
Bambuí and Canastra Group, representing the natural
sources. There was a minority sample group with less
radiogenic and torogenic isotopic composition similar to
alcohol and galena deposits of the Brasília Belt (Morro
do Ouro, Morro Agudo, Paracatu and Vazante). Probably
the residence time of this material was elevated in the
atmosphere to transport the Pb long distances depositing
it mainly in the fine filters.
The seasonal difference between the PM10-2.5 and
PM2.5 concentrations has an important correlation with the
winter season in Brasília, characterized as an extremely
dry period. The presence of anthropogenic elements (Pb
and S) in the PM2.5 fraction represents particularly the
burning of fossil fuels, though it may be also attributed to
increased human activity and wild fires of the savannah.
Low Ca concentrations can be attributed to the cement
industries to the North of the city. The aerosols isotopic
pattern differs totally from other industrialized cities, showing an elevated contribution of geogenic material and low
anthropogenic action.
Additional research will be necessary to evaluate the
influence of traffic, as well as other anthropogenic sources,
which will probably increase with a population growth.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank the Shell engineer
Adair Narazeth Santos Júnior, who supplied some of the
fuel samples; the technician Ana and Dr. Manfredo, of the
– 104 –
Simone M.C.L. Giota
Figure 4 – Results from the PIXE analysis of major elements during summer and winter at both sampling sites (UnB and CIAB).
Figure 5 – Results from the PIXE analysis of trace elements during summer and winter at both sampling sites (UnB and CIAB).
– 105 –
Study of aerosols isotopic (pb) composition and sources in Brasília (DF) – Central Brazil
Physics Institute of the São Paulo University; Dr. Maria
de Fátima Andrade, of the Institute for Astronomy and
Geophysics of the São Paulo University and meteorologist
Maria Cristina G. Costa, of INMET.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
AILY, C. Caracterização Isotópica de Pb na atmosfera:
um exemplo da cidade de São Paulo. 2001. Dissertação (Mestrado) - Universidade de São Paulo,
São Paulo, 2001.
CHOW, T.J.; SNYDER, C.; EARL, J. Isotope ratios of lead
as pollutant source indicators. Proceedings of the
IAEA-SM-191/14, Vienna, 1975. p. 95-108.
ESPEN, P.V.; JASSENS, SWENTER, S, 1AXIL X-Ray
Analysis software: users manual. Bebelux : Packard,
1991. 72 p.
GIOIA, S.M.C.L. Caracterização da assinatura isotópica de Pb atual na atmosfera e no sistema lacustre
do Distrito Federal e pré-antropogênica em Lagoa
Feia – GO. 2004. Tese (Doutorado) - Instituto de
Geociências, Universidade de Brasília, Brasília,
2004.
ROSMAN, K.J.R.; LY, C.; VAN DE VELDE, K.;
BOURTRON, C.F. A two century record of lead
isotopes in high altitude Alpine snow and ice.
Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 176, p.
413-424, 2000.
VERGARA, M.C. Caracterizações isotópicas e percentuais de material particulado respirável e de matérias fontes afins da cidade de Santiago do Chile
usando Pb Sr e Nd como traçadores naturais. 2001.
Tese (Doutorado) - Universidade de São Paulo, São
Paulo. 2001.
– 106 –
DENTAL FLUOROSIS
AND FLUORINE
ANOM ALIES IN
GROUNDWATER
OF SÃO FRANCISCO
TOWN, M INAS GERAIS
STATE BRAZIL
¹Leila Nunes Menegasse Velásquez; menegase@netuno.lcc.ufmg.br
¹Lúcia Maria Fantinel; fantinel@ufmg.br
²Eigênia Ferreira e Ferreira; eigenia@uai.com.br
²Lia Silva de Castillo; liacastilho@ig.com.br
¹Alexandre Uhlein; uhlein@dedalus.lcc.ufmg.br
²Andréia Maria Duarte Vargas ; vargasnt@task.com.br
¹Paulo R. Antunes Aranha; aranha@igc.ufmg.br
¹Geology Department - UFMG
²Faculty for Odontology - UFMG
ABSTRACT
The main water source for the rural population’s
consumption in São Francisco, North Minas Gerais, is
the karstic aquifer in the carbonate rocks of the Bambuí
Group. Epidemiologic and geologic-hydrogeologic studies found fluoride anomalies in those water sources and
established a relationship between the anomalies and
dental fluorosis incidence in that area. Minerals with fluorine occur disseminated in the Bambuí Group rocks and,
especially, fluorite disseminated in fractures and calcite
veins throughout the limestone. There is a remarkable
correlation between the stratigraphy, the rock fractures
system, the wells’ discharge and the fluorine concentrations in the groundwater. A hydrogeochemical survey of
78 tubular wells revealed a fluoride variation from 0 to
3.9mg/L and background of 0.45mg/L. In 16.7% of the
wells, the fluoride concentrations exceeded the local
potability limit (0.8mg/L). The epidemiologic and clinical
survey of the population between 6 and 22 years old
indicated a dental fluorosis prevalence rate of 81.5% to
97.7% in four districts, with 30% of the teeth in a severe
– 107 –
Dental luorosis and luorine anomalies in groundwater of São Francisco Town Minas Gerais State Brazil
damage stage. In these four districts, the water consumed
by the population is taken from karst aquifers that have
fluorine concentrations higher than 1.18mg/L.
INTRODUCTION
Integrated water resources management practices
imply quality assessments of surface water and groundwater especially that destined for human consumption.
In the karstic terrains of carbonate provinces, that assessment is also necessary to prevent and control of
hydric diffused diseases. The karstic areas situated in
the Middle São Francisco River hydrographic basins, in
the North of Minas Gerais State, were chosen as a case
study. These areas are characterized by a rainfall concentration in just a few months, higher rates of seepage
through the carbonate substrate and across sub-surface
karstic structures and a consequently larger groundwater
availability compared to the surface bodies. Thus, the
aquifers in the carbonate rock domains constitute the
main water sources for human and animal consumption
and for agricultural and industrial activities.
In these domains, several inorganic chemical
substances, present as mineral phases in limestone
and associated rocks, are naturally incorporated to
the groundwater by dissolution processes. Many of
these mineral substances are central to human health,
but their effects in the organism depend, among other
factors, on the quantities taken by each individual. A
paradigmatic example of this relationship concerns
fluorine and fluorosis.
Fluorine assimilation in appropriate doses is beneficial to health, since it promotes increased mineral matrix
resistance of the teeth and bones. However, the continuous assimilation of quantities exceeding the maximum
recommended can induce deformities of the dental
enamel (dental fluorosis) and even of the bones (skeletal
fluorosis or osteofluorosis).
Dental fluorosis is an anomaly of the teeth’s development linked to enamel deformation following a prolonged
fluorine intake in excessive amounts in children up to 5
years old, when the enamel is being formed. The disease
is characterized by increased enamel porosity, which
becomes opaque and stained with white or even brown
or black spots. The maximum fluoride content in water for
human consumption depends on the local climatic conditions, as established by the World Health OrganizationWHO (1999). This limit varies according to the maximum
mean air temperature values, which are related to the
volume of water consumed by a given population. In São
Francisco, the mean maximum air temperature is 32.3°C,
indicating a recommended maximum limit for fluoride
concentration in potable water of 0.8mg/L, according to
Resolution 1469/00 from the Ministry of Health (Brazil,
2000).
In São Francisco, dental fluorosis affects mainly
children and young adults living in the rural area. The
disease, of permanent character, requires corrective
treatment and dental restoration, usually inaccessible
to the affected populations. This treatment consists of
polishing the porous external enamel until the stain
caused by the food pigments impregnation is removed.
In severe cases it is necessary to implant crowns or
dental facets.
São Francisco is situated in the North macro-region
of Minas Gerais State, in the Middle São Francisco River
hydrographic basin, about 578km from Belo Horizonte
(Minas Gerais State capital). It has a population of 52,639
inhabitants (IBGE, 2003), 46% of which live in the rural
area. The population faces many difficulties caused by
the lack of an integrated water resources planning, which,
combined with the socio-economical background of significant poverty rates, contributes to the occurrence of
water transmitted diseases.
The limited availability of surface water results from
the combination of two main factors: 1,132.9mm/year
rainfall concentrated in four months followed by a long
drought period and high water infiltration rates through the
karstic domain of fractured Bambuí Group limestones. On
the other hand, there are important groundwater springs
which represent the only water resources available during
the whole year in the rural area.
The water supply for the urban area population situated on the São Francisco River margins is provided by
the Minas Gerais State Water Works Company - Companhia de Saneamento de Minas Gerais (COPASA MG),
mainly through the catchment and treatment of the river’s
water. The rural area’s water supply is the responsibility
of the city administration and is provided mainly through
tubular wells drawing groundwater. These wells are the
main water source for the geographically dispersed rural
communities, which are often situated in areas where the
perennial surface water bodies do not exist. In the late
1970´s several tubular wells were drilled in the rural zone
to minimize the serious water supply problem and the first
wells started functioning in the 1980´s.
The Mocambo public supply well, situated 14km
South of São Francisco, was opened in 1979. Fifteen years
later, the region’s community and dental surgeons diagnosed the nature of the stains in their children’s permanent
teeth. In 1995, following a request of the São Francisco
administration the National Health Foundation - FUNASA
analyzed the Mocambo tubular well water, where it found
3.2mg/L of fluoride, four times the region’s recommended
maximum limit Between 1995 and 1997, two other wells
were built in Mocambo without being pumped due to the
elevated fluorine contents in the water.
In 2002 and 2003, five of this survey’s authors sought
to characterize the endemic in some communities by assessing the local aquifer systems (geometry, dynamics
– 108 –
Leila Nunes Menegasse Velásquez
and hydrogeochemical characteristics) to determine the
elevated fluorine content origin in the groundwater. The
taskforce was based on interdisciplinary methodologies
and on the search for interrelations of the epidemiological data with the geologic-hydrogeologic investigation.
(http://www.odonto.ufmg.br/odonto/geologia_saude.
html).
The study recognized the intake of naturally enriched
fluorine groundwater as the cause of dental fluorosis and
confirmed the fluoride concentrations correlation with the
tectonic structures, stratigraphy and aquifer hydraulic
parameters. The results indicate the areas of greater
vulnerability to fluorine rich groundwater and also technical criteria for well locations were established. At present
the study is expanding methodologically and geographically towards North São Francisco, where 24 other cities
present similar geological contexts together with isolated
cases of dental fluorosis.
THE INTERDISCIPLINAR RESEARCH OF DENTAL
FLUOROSIS IN SÃO FRANCISCO
Methods in the Field of Geosciences
This study included the geological mapping, stratigraphic sequence definition, the macro- and microscopic
petrographic and deformational structures characterization and the associated karstic dissolution features.
The regional geological mapping was made in the
scale 1:250,000. However, more detailed mapping was
done to better characterize the fluorite occurrences and
elevated prevalence of dental fluorosis in the Mocambo
district. This included a (1:60,000) map of the Mocambo
creek sub-basin and of two key-areas (1:25,000) with an
emphasis on the facies associations and the stratigraphic
control of the fluorite occurrences.
The hydrogeologic assessment included the physical
and hydrochemical characterization of the aquifers and
the elaboration of a conceptual model explaining its dynamics and flow system. Beginning with a well inventory,
the groundwater sampling and hydrochemical analyses
were carried out pursuing the following goals: a general
hydrogeochemical characterization of the groundwater,
quantify the fluorine contents, confirm the associations
between fluorine and other hydrochemical parameters
and the fluorinate background definition. The sample was
considered to be contaminated when the concentration
was above 0.8mg/L, maximum value recommended for
the region.
The sampling procedures, preservation and water
analyses were carried out according to the 20th Standard
Methods for the Examination of water and wastewater
(1998). The most important analyzed parameters were: pH,
CE, T, DTS, alkalinity (total, bicarbonate, carbonates and
hydroxides), total hardness, major ions and F-. The statistical analyzes were made with the software SSPS – Statistical
Package for the Social Science – SSPS and contour maps
were elaborated using the software Surfer32.
Methods in the Field of Health Sciences
For the clinical and epidemiological studies, four
districts of the São Francisco rural area with cases of the
disease were selected (Mocambo, Vaqueta, Alto São
João, Novo Horizonte) and a district as a control area
(Retiro), where the water supply is under the responsibility
of COPASA-MG.
For the epidemiological inquiry, 288 individuals,
between 6 and 22 years old were examined, regarding
the presence of permanent teeth and length of time the
water had been consumed. The clinical examinations
were conducted by a single examiner, under natural light,
after teeth brushing and using sterilized gauze to dry the
teeth. An inquiry on teeth brushing with dentifrice and
other methods of fluorine application, information about
the duration of residence in the area and the consumed
water origin was included. In the assessment, the CPOd indexes (decayed, lost and filled teeth) according to
WHO (1997) and TF-Thylstrup and Fejerskov criteria (Fejerskov et al., 1994) were employed. The data base was
developed in the software EPI INFO of WHO. The data
collection was carried out with the authorization of the City
Council, after written information was sent to the parents
or guardians of the children to be examined.
To evaluate the local resident’s perception of fluorosis, interviews were made with affected individuals and
teachers in the four communities that presented excessive
fluorine intake. The methodology used in the qualitative
assessment was based on open and semi-structured
interviews with result analysis according to Bardin (1977).
In the case of adolescents, the interviews were divided
into the following contexts: dental health, perception
of fluorosis and expectations. The sample comprised
of 17 young people between 12 and 22 years old who
presented staining due to fluorosis in degrees between
1 and 9 in the TF index.
GEOLOGICAL CONTEXT
São Francisco is located in the central compartment
of the São Francisco Basin, in a less deformed neoproterozoic cover area in the central South of the São Francisco
craton. There is a predominance of rocks with horizontal
to sub-horizontal structures, represented, from bottom to
top, by a carbonatic-pelitic Neoproterozoic sequence of
the Bambuí Group, Cretaceous sandstones, shales and
siltites of the Areado Group; Cenozoic colluvial-alluvial
sediments, probably Tercio-Quaternary and, finally, Quaternary alluvial sediments (Figure 1).
The limestone lithotypes of the Bambuí Group consist
mainly of allochemical rocks, with a predominance of
calcareous sandstones and calcareous lutites. Among
– 109 –
Dental luorosis and luorine anomalies in groundwater of São Francisco Town Minas Gerais State Brazil
the allochemical components, the most common are
peloids, intraclasts, ooids and microphytoliths. They
consist of grains dispersed in a matrix of thin carbonate
mud or the framework of calcareous sandstones and
calcareous rudites with micritic matrix and spatic cement. Locally, dolomite terms may occur. The terrigenous
lithotypes are predominantly pelites, metaclaystones and
metasandstones. The faciological observations suggest
paleoenvironmental conditions of tide plains, intern platform and platform bars with sedimentation cycles marked
by recurrences of storm events.
Purple to pink fluorite crystals with 0.3mm-2cm edges
occur in a small proportion, disseminated preferably in
re-crystallized white calcite veins, associated with fractures sub-parallel to calcareous sandstones bedding. The
fluorite occurrences partly respond for the anomalous fluorine concentrations in the groundwater, but other fluorine
carrying minerals, neither identifiable macroscopically nor
through conventional optical microscopy, may be present.
The Areado Group is represented by pelite basal
facies and psamitic facies thicker than the former and
covering a larger area. The pelite facies are formed by
claystones and finely laminated shales and the psamitic
facies, with a thickness up to 40m, consists of quartz
sandstones with mature texture.
The Cenozoic sediments usually present less thickness and reduced area extension. The alluvial deposits of
greater extension correspond to the sandy covers developed from the cretaceous sandstones that are distributed
on the tabular elevations above 700m. They are generally
associated with colluvial sediments and clastic material
built after a relief regression process.
The fracture pattern defined by photoanalysis and
field work consists of a distensive system N70°-90°W, a
decompressive system N0°-30°E, a dextral shear system
N50°-70°E and a sinistral shear system N30°-50° W.
In São Francisco, the altitudes vary from 455m to
815m, with a predominance of flat and dissecated areas,
developed mostly on the metasediments of the Bambuí
Group. Extensive and tabular platforms, situated in the
most elevated areas, especially in the South portion of the
city, correspond to cretaceous sandstones deposited on
top of the Bambuí Group metasediments.
HYDROGEOLOGY
outcrop thickness around 170m. The carbonate units
have undergone an intense karstification and fracturing
process. The areas with greater storage capabilities are
the zones more intensively fractured in the carbonate
and politic sequences or in the zones with pronounced
karstic dissolution evidence in the carbonate sequences.
Generally, the karstic-fractured system is considered
to be unconfined, with a water table around 14m, even
though locally the pelitic sequences may confine the
carbonate sequences, acting as aquicludes, giving rise
to artesianism. With regard to anisotropic media, such
as karstic-fractured aquifers, the flow directions and
gradients are extremely complex and depend mostly
on the rock discontinuity patterns. Therefore, in the
politic aquifers the vertical components of the hydraulic
gradients are larger whereas in the karstic-fractured
aquifers the horizontal components predominate. The
recharge in the karstic aquifers occurs in three different
ways: i) through the Areado Group sandstones (East and
Southeastern side of the city) and the Tercio-quaternary
detrital cover; ii) by leakage through the pelitic units; iii)
directly due to the pluviometric infiltration in limestone
outcrop areas through open fractures and karstic features. The discontinuity directions representative of the
main water flow are N70°-90°W, N0°-30°E, N50°-70°E
and N30°-50°W. The extremely variable well discharge
rates vary from a few m3/h to 260m3/h reflecting the high
aquifer anisotropy and the need for precise geological
knowledge to enhance drilling success. This aquifer
system is the most important water source for the rural
population.
The granular aquifer system is made up of the following units: Areado Group sedimentary sequences,
Tercio-quaternary detrital cover and recent alluvionarcolluvionar deposits. Recharge of the granular system is
through direct precipitation. Despite being exploited by
deep wells (Areado Group) and by hand dug wells (detrital cover), this aquifer system receives the discharge
of some surface streams which drain the area.
The regional groundwater flow is towards the São
Francisco River main channel, which is also the regional
base flow level. However, many other local flow directions
can be expected when dealing with karstic domains.
RESULTS
The stratification of carbonate and Bambuí Group
pelitic rocks and the Cenozoic cover sandy sediments and
the Areado Group sediments define two aquifer systems
hydraulically connected: one a karstic-fractured system
and the other a sedimentary granular system.
The karstic-fractured system is made up of the
BamThe karstic-fractured system is made up of the
Bambuí Group carbonate politic rock sequences (75%
of the area), sub horizontally accommodated with an
Epidemiology
The epidemiological survey of dental fluorosis
showed a prevalence rate of 81.5% to 97.7%, with 30%
of the teeth in a severe stage of damage (Figure 2).
The fluorosis prevalence exceeded 80% in all the
affected districts (Table 1). Considering the TF equal or
superior to 4 (most severe aesthetic and/or functional
tooth failure), the fluorosis prevalence affected 45.6%
– 110 –
– 111 –
Leila Nunes Menegasse Velásquez
Figure 1 – Dental fluorosis in Mocambo – (Photo: E.F.Ferreira, 2008).
Dental luorosis and luorine anomalies in groundwater of São Francisco Town Minas Gerais State Brazil
of the examined people in Alto São João, 61.5% in Mocambo, 72.3% in Vaqueta and 82.2% in Novo Horizonte
(Table 2). Such numbers are most alarming and show a
typical public health problem related to the environment.
In the four communities where dental fluorosis occurs,
the consumed water comes from the carbonate aquifer,
with fluorine concentrations higher than 1.18mg/L. In
the district of Retiro, the control area, fluorosis does not
occur, due to the low fluorine concentration at that site
(0.2 mg/L).
Table 2 - Prevalence of people with fluorosis in a degree
equal or superior to 4 (TF), per district, 2002 (percentage)
Age
Mocambo
Vaqueta
Novo
Horizonte
Alto São
João
Retiro
7a9
21.0
63.6
86.6
28.0
0
10 a 12
65.2
81.2
76.9
33.3
0
13 a 15
92.8
100
81.8
83.3
0
16 a 22
88.8
60.0
83.3
62.5
0
Total
61.5
72.3
82.2
45.6
0
The interviews showed that young people exhibit
socialization problems, difficulties to participate in collective school activities as well as feelings of embarrassment and shame due to the teeth lesions. The youths
affected by fluorosis relate it mainly to the ingestion of
calcareous water and are worried that the fluorine stains
may be mistaken as a “lack of hygiene”. Individuals
who present fluorosis in the anterior labial region tend
to systematically hide their smile (putting their hand in
front of their mouth, smiling with lips shut), avoid taking pictures, believe that the fluorosis stains may upset
their professional future and, finally, they believe that
fluorosis stains may upset affective relationships with
the opposite sex.
The characteristics (explicitly named in the interviews) related to the present state of the teeth and
smile of the studied population: ugly, dirty, yellow
and rusty. Adolescents report that they feel ashamed,
sad and without freedom which is confirmed by the
teachers.
Figure 2 – Dental fluorosis in Mocambo – (Photo: E.F.Ferreira, 2008).
Table 1 - Prevalence of people with fluorosis (TF), per district,
2002 (percentage)
95.5
Novo
Horizonte
100
Alto São
João
88.0
87.0
100
100
75.0
0
92.8
100
100
91.6
7.7
16 a 22
100
60
83.3
100
0
Total
81.5
93.6
97.7
87.7
0.3
Age
Mocambo
Vaqueta
7a9
57.8
10 a 12
13 a 15
Retiro
0
Fluorine hydrochemistry in the groundwater
The epidemiological survey in the endemic communities identified the fluoride anomalies in groundwater
as the main fluorine intake source and the cause of the
dental fluorosis.
The hydrogeochemical evaluation of 78 tubular
wells indicated a fluoride variation between 0 and
3.9mg/L and background of 0.45mg/L. In 16.7% of the
wells the concentrations exceeded the local potability
limit (0.8mg/L). These samples correspond to the most
recent wells.
The pH showed a variation between 7.0 and 8.8 with
a 7.5 median. The Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) varied
between 43.3mg/L and 517mg/L with a 407.5 median
and 370.2mg/L mean. The alkalinity of bicarbonate varied
between 94mg/L CaCO3 and 481.3mg/L CaCO3 with a
median of 39.3mg/L CaCO3.
The hydrochemical facies verified in the Piper
diagram (Figure 3) revealed three main hydrochemical
types: calcium bicarbonate (32.3%); sodium bicarbonate, sodic-calcic a calcic-sodic (21.5%) and bicarbonate calcic-magnesian (15.4%). The direct association of
– 112 –
Leila Nunes Menegasse Velásquez
shear system 0,73mg/l and in the decompressive system, 0,8 mg/l. Among the five (5) wells located in the
distensive system coinciding with the higher productivity zone, bearing fluoride concentrations higher than
0,8mg/l, four (4) of them show lower yields, between 2,5
and 10,56m3/h. The relationship between the fluoride
concentration and altimetry of the water entries inside
the wells substantiate that it is closely associated with
carbonate sandstones of the Bambuí Group inferior
and middle parts in the area (45,8% of the wells with
fluoride above 0,8mg/l are lying on altitudes between
480 and 600m).
Nine (9) other communities were identified, whose
water supplies are taken from new wells are contaminated
with fluoride, however no measure have been adopted to
warn the exposed population.
Figure 3 – Piper diagram (points’ dimension is proportional to the
fluorine concentration).
CONCLUSIONS
fluorine with sodium is clear, given the high solubility of
the latter.
The areas of higher natural vulnerability to contamination risk (>0.8mg/L) are distributed according
to the alignment N40 E, parallel to the São Francisco
River main direction, in the central and Southeastern
portions of the studied area. In the latter, fluoride is
found in the limestones under the Areado Group sediments.
Relationships of fluoride with geological factors
The wells have a great production variation, which
reflects the aquifers’ great heterogeneity and anisotropy.
There are dry wells and wells with discharges of 264m3/h;
most of them however (56%) have discharges of up to
20m3/h.
Based on the field observations, two more developed karstification directions were confirmed: N70-90
W (distensive system) and N0-30 E (decompression
system). Two other systems identified are a shear zone
oriented N50-70E (dextral) and N30-50 W (sinistral).
The higher well discharges (around 100m 3/h reaching exceptionally 260m3/h) indicate a high degree of
karstification as well as artesianism conditions. Once
the relationship between well discharge and fracturing
system is established it can be confirmed that karstification occurs in all fracturing directions and that the
higher yields are associated with the distensive system
N70-90 W.
The F- concentrations are higher in those systems
showing smaller productivity, that is, according to the
decompressive and sinistral shear directions. The average concentration of fluoride in wells located distant
from shear zones is close to the background values,
0,49mg/l, whereas, along the distensive system, mean
concentration reaches 0,54mg/l, along the sinistral
The interdisciplinary methodology applied to this
study was fundamental to understand the geoenvironmental processes and the characteristics of the dental
fluorosis endemic in São Francisco.
The epidemiological study of dental fluorosis
confirmed that there is a worrying endemic situation,
requiring immediate action to provide corrective treatment for the already developed lesions and prevention
of new cases. The fluorosis lesions cause great embarrassment in affected youths, and can even make social
contact difficult in some cases. Measures to correct the
fluoride content of the wells and odontological facilities
for oral health, including the broadcast of information as
to the lesions’ origin, need to be undertaken to achieve
a comprehensive health improvement for the affected
population.
Fluoride anomalies in the studied communities’ water
indicate that the groundwater is the main fluorine intake
source and the main cause of fluorosis. The disseminated
fluorite crystals in calcite veins across the Bambuí Group
calcarenites are the groundwater natural contamination
source-mineral, but other minerals with fluorine may be
present in the Bambuí Group carbonate and pelite facies, also contributing to the fluoride anomalies in the
groundwater.
The fluoride concentrations in the groundwater
reach a maximum of 3.9mg/L. The association of Fconcentrations with the brittle structures, the stratigraphy and the wells’ hydraulic parameters provide the
technical criteria to locate new tubular wells in regions
with lower vulnerability to fluorine contamination. The
most important being: to avoid the directions N0-30
E and N30-50 W; to prioritize the direction N70-90 W,
which is also the most promising in terms of production and finally to prioritize water entries with altitudes
above 600m.
– 113 –
Dental luorosis and luorine anomalies in groundwater of São Francisco Town Minas Gerais State Brazil
Nine other communities were found in the same
town, whose water supply came from newer wells contaminated with fluoride. This is a worrying fact, since
no measure has been adopted to warn the exposed
population.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors want to thank the institutions that supported this study, especially: the Research Foundation
of Minas Gerais – FAPEMIG, the project’s financing
agency (Process CRA 294/99), the Geoscience Institute of UFMG, the Ministry of Health (Fundação Nacional de Saúde Coordenação Minas Gerais – FUNASA),
The City Council of São Francisco, the Companhia
de Saneamento of Minas Gerais – COPASA MG, the
Development Company of the São Francisco Valley
(Companhia de Desenvolvimento do Vale do Rio São
Francisco – CODEVASF), the Nuclear Technology
Developing Center (Centro de Desenvolvimento da
Tecnologia Nuclear – CDTN/CNEN), and to the population of São Francisco who authorized the realization
of the odontological clinical exams.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BARDIN, L. 1977. Análise de conteúdo. Lisboa: Edições
BARDIN, L. 1977. Análise de conteúdo. Lisboa:
Edições 70, 1977. 228 p.
BRASIL. Ministério da Saúde. Portaria nº 1469 de 29 de
dezembro de 2000. Controle e vigilância da qualidade da água para consumo humano e seu padrão
de qualidade.
FANTINEL, L.M. et al. Fluorose dentária e anomalias de flúor nos
aquíferos do Grupo Bambuí em São Francisco, MG. Disponível em: <http://www.odonto.ufmg.br/odonto/site%20
04/geologia_saude.html>. Acesso em: 18 maio 2005.
FEJERSKOV, O. et. al. Fluorose dentária: um manual para
profissionais de saúde. São Paulo: Ed. Santos, 1994.
FUNDAÇÃO INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA E
ESTATÍSTICA – IBGE. Disponível em: <http://www.ibge.
gov.br.> Acesso em 2003. ORGANIZAÇÃO MUNDIAL
DE SAÚDE. Manual de levantamento epidemiológico
em saúde bucal. São Paulo: Ed. Santos, 1999.
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. Oral health survey: basic methods. 4th ed. Geneva: WHO, 1997. p. 35-36,
41-46. – 117 – Leila Nunes Menegasse Velásquez.
– 114 –
FLUORINE GEOCHEM ISTRY
IN FLUVIAL WATERS AND
SEDIM ENTS OF THE CERRO
AZUL REGION, PARANÁ
STATE: DEFINITION OF
RISK AREAS FOR HUM AN
CONSUM PTION
¹Maria Jimena Andreazzini, jimena@ige.unicamp.br
¹Bernardino R. Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicamp.br
²Otávio A. B. Licht, otavio@pr.gov.br
¹University of Campinas - UNICAMP
² Mineral Company of Paraná - MINEROPAR
consumption to define the mineral phases that bring
fluorine to the water and sediments.
INTRODUCTION
Fluorine is ingested mainly through water intake, and
is considered an essential element for human health,
though excess ingestion may cause problems with teeth
and bones, a disease known as fluorosis.
In the Ribeira Valley region, near the towns of Cerro
Azul and Adrianópolis, Paraná State, there are large
fluorite deposits (CaF2), and the operational Mato Preto
mine (Figure 1). These deposits coincide with fluorine
anomalous areas, identified from previous studies of
fluvial sediments and soils (Biondi et al., 1985, Martini,
1985, Mattos, 1989, Licht et al., 1996a, Licht et al., 1996b,
Licht et al., 1997, Licht 2001). Weathering mechanisms
on these soils and rocks can lead to a fluorine enrichment
of surface and groundwater.
This study seeks to determine the surface water
quality in the fluorite deposit regions of Volta Grande (VG)
and Mato Preto (MP) and define exposure risk zones.
Additionally, it analyzes the region’s population water
FLUORINE GEOCHEMISTRY
Fluorine is commonly related to the igneous processes (Bell, 1998). During the magmatic evolution, fluorine
usually occurs as a volatile phase component, becoming
concentrated in the final stages of the evolution in alkaline
rocks, carbonatites, hydrothermal deposits, alteration
zones and pegmatites (Dardenne et al.,1997), generally
as fluorite and fluorapatite.
Released by mineral weathering, fluorine is transferred to the supergenic aqueous solutions in the form of
the dissolved free fluoride ion (F-), with high mobility. In
low pH, the HF species may be stable (Bell, 1998). The
fluorine mean concentration in sea water is 1-1.3mg/L F-.
In groundwater it can vary from less than 1 to more than
35mg/L F-, whereas in river and lake waters the concentrations are usually low (0.01-0.3mg/L) (UNICEF, 2003).
– 115 –
Fluorine geochemistry in luvial waters and sediments of the Cerro Azul Region, Paraná State: deinition of risk areas for human consumption
Among the factors that control the fluoride concentration
in natural water are: temperature, pH, presence of ions
and complexation inducer colloids, solubility of fluorine
containing minerals, ion exchange capacity of the aquifer’s material (OH- for F-), size and type of geologic formations percolated by the water and the length of time the
water is in contact with a particular formation (Apambire
et al., 1997).
Fluorine is found in silicate rock constituents, where
apatite, Ca10(PO4)6F2, is one of the minerals richest in
fluorine. Only in fluorite (CaF2) and topaz (Al2SiO4(OH,F)2)
is fluorine an essential component. It can also be fixed
in hydroxy-silicates and complex hydroxy-aluminumsilicates, in which the hydroxyl ions (OH)- can be extensively substituted by F-, as is the case of the amphiboles
and minerals of the mica group (biotite and muscovite)
(Goldschmidt, 1970). Allmann & Koritning (1972) comment on studies made on the change-adsorption of F-/
OH- in clay minerals, where the concentrations and pH
of the percolating solutions had a great influence on the
F lixiviation and adsorption.
In most environments, fluorite is the main mineral
that controls the fluoride geochemistry in natural water.
The F- concentration in water is limited by the fluorite
solubility. Its low solubility product (at 20°C it is 3.9x10-11)
implies that water with low calcium content could have
high fluorine concentrations (Bell, 1998). The amount of
F released by the fluorite dissolution in water with low
ionic potential is around 8-10ppm, but the concentration
of Ca2+, Na+, OH- and certain complexing ions, such as
Fe, Al, B, Si, Mg and H can modify this F- concentration
interval (Apambire et al., 1997).
The ionic exchange (OH- for F-) involving several
types of clay is a process that can explain very high Fconcentrations in water (values above 30mg/L). This ionic
Figure 1 – Location of the studied area and regional geological context (Ronchi et al. 1995).
exchange process also includes the bases exchange
(Ca2+ and Mg2+ for Na+), promoting the progressive pH
elevation to alkaline values (pH 9-10.5) (Apambire et
al.,1997). Thus, the Ca2+ reduction in water favors higher
fluoride concentrations.
FLUORINE AND HUMAN HEALTH
People can be exposed to fluoride through the air,
food, contaminated soils and water intake, the latter being the main intoxication path. The F- maximum content
in drinking water, recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO, 1996) is 1.5mg/L, with variations admitted mainly due to the region’s mean annual temperature
(18°C = 1.2mg/L; 19-26°C = 0.9mg/L; 27°C or more =
0.7mg/L F-). In Brazil, the National Environmental Council
-CONAMA Resolution 020/86 establishes an acceptable
maximum content of 1.4mg/L F-, and the Administrative
Act N 518 of the National Agency for Sanitary Vigilance
- Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária - ANVISA of
1.5mg/L F- For São Paulo State, Resolution SS-293/96
establishes classification criteria for the water distributed
by public supply systems and considers adequate F- contents of between 0.6 and 0.8mg/L.
The affinity of calcified tissues for fluorine determines
its persistent and cumulative retention in bones, being
greater in growing organisms (Ortiz Ruiz, 1997). Drinking
water containing about 1mg/L F- promotes a significant
caries reduction in children (ATSDR 2001). Fluorine plays
a re-mineralizing role, through the chemical reactions in
the surface enamel. If a reasonable level of F- is present
in the diet during the teeth growth stage, a significant
amount of fluorapatite (Ca10(PO4)6F2) is incorporated in
the enamel in place of hydroxy-apatite (Ca10 (PO4)6(OH)2).
Fluorapatite is less soluble in the buccal environment acids, making the teeth less susceptible to caries. Fluorine
also performs a bacteriostatic function, since its presence
in the buccal environment inhibits the bacteria enzymatic
system, blocking the sugar unfolding and the consequent
formation of acids that act on the enamel.
However, if fluorine is ingested in excess, during the
teeth growth period, a chronic intoxication may occur and
originate dental fluorosis, a pathology that is manifested
through whitish to brownish stains on the teeth surface
enamel or even through losses in its structure (Cardoso et
al., 2001, UNICEF, 2003). Skeletal fluorosis also develops
a hardening or abnormal increase of the bones density
in people who continually ingest quantities higher than 3
or 4mg/L F-. The maximum adverse effects are detected
in the neck, back, knee, pelvis and shoulder articulations as well as hands and feet articulations (Gupta &
Deshpande, 1998).
Fluorosis is endemic in at least 25 countries including China (where more than 100 million people suffer
from fluorosis), Mexico (with 5 million people affected
– 116 –
Maria Jimena Andreazzini
by fluorine in groundwater), India (UNICEF, 2003) and
Argentina (Bonorino et al., 2002, Warren et al., 2002,
Blarasín et al., 2003).
Cangussu et al. (2002) observed a great variability of
fluorosis prevalence in Brazil, according to the region, but
confirmed that even with high prevalence, the proportion of
people who present moderate or severe forms is still small.
This incidence, increases only in sites where fluorosis is
endemic due to the high content of fluoride in natural water.
In the Mocambo and Boca do Mato communities, in
São Francisco, North Minas Gerais State, the groundwater
fluoride content in some areas varies between 1,17 and
5,2mg/L F- (Meneasse et al., 2002). In this town, prospective surveys for fluorite and galena have been carried out
in areas of the Bambuí Group carbonate rocks.
Several articles (Licht et al., 1996b, Licht et al., 1997;
Licht 2001), based on the Low Density Multielemental
Geochemical Survey of Paraná, have delimited a large
anomalous area in the North of the State, where contents
up to 1.9mg/L F- were found in water samples. In the São
Joaquim do Pontal community, in Itambaracá, the prevalence of dental fluorosis found among the school children
population was 72%; 61% of which had severity levels 4
and 5 (Cardoso et al., 2001).
Another fluorine exposure path is through inhalation. Finkelman et al., (1999) describe health problems
caused by fluorine excess, emitted from stoves that use
coal and clay with high fluorine contents, for food drying
and house warming.
GEOLOGICAL CONTEXT OF THE STUDIED AREAS
The Ribeira Valley lithological units belong to a NE
Proterozoic mobile belt made up of an East domain
(coastal complex) formed by Archean gneisses, migmatites and granulites reworked in the superior Proterozoic,
and a West domain (Apiaí folding belt) which includes
Proterozoic low to medium metamorphic grade volcanosedimentary sequences and a small domain of Archean
rocks. The metamorphic event happened between 600
and 700 Ma and both domains were intruded by granitoids ((Três Córregos and Itaóca) during the Brasiliano
orogenic cycle (450-700 Ma) (Ronchi et al. 1995). During
the Mesozoic, intense fissural basic volcanism correlated
with the Paraná Basin igneous spills, took the form of
Jurassic diabase dykes in a N45E direction. In the Cretaceous the emplacement of alkaline- carbonatite intrusions
(sometimes bearing F, F, P and REE mineralization) occurred. The Phanerozoic sedimentary sequences from the
Paraná Basin protected the Proterozoic mobile belt until
its Tertiary uplift, when weathering processes ended up
exposing basement rocks (Ronchi et al. 1995). In the VG
deposit, fluorite is embedded in enclaves of carbonate
rocks within the Três Córregos granites. The carbonate
rocks were affected by a substitution processes involving
fluorite and silica (Ronchi et al. 1987). The deposit is built
of three main bodies 460m in length, varying between 5
and 20m thick and as deep as 120m (Ronchi et al. 1995).
Reserve estimations equals 1.1 Mt of ore bearing 35-40%
of CaF2, with the ore mainly composed of fluorite, quartz
and secondarily by calcite, dolomite, pyrite and mica
(muscovite and biotite), and very often the presence of
barite and adularia (Dardenne et al. 1997).
The MP alkaline-carbonatite complex is situated on
the margins of the Pinheirinho and Mato Preto Rivers,
both tributaries of the Ribeira River. It shows a reserve of
2.16 Mt of ore with an average 60% CaF2 content (Jenkins
1987).The complex builds a small stock located along the
Morro Agudo fault zone, which represents the contact
between metasedimentary rocks from the Açungui Group
and the Três Córregos granites.
Many alkaline metamorphic stages had alternated
in the complex formation and late-magmatic phenomena
were responsible for silicification and fluorite enrichment
processes. The alkaline rocks are Cretaceous and they
are represented mainly by carbonatites, nepheline syenites and phonolites (Mattos 1989).
In the central Northwest part of the complex lays the
largest volume of fluorite and sulfide rich carbonatites
(Loureiro & Tavares 1983). The fluorite occurs in four N5060E subparallel lenticular bodies measuring 250m long,
80m thick and up to 120m deep, according to soundings
(Jenkins 1987). The carbonatite building activity has
promoted, besides the fluorites, a concentration and
enrichment process in magnetite, apatite, pyrite, bornite
and in elements such as REE, niobium, thorium, zirconium,
titanium and uranium (Loureiro & Tavares 1983).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Surface water samples were collected from 18 sites during two sampling campaigns (July 2003 and March 2004),
as well as two groundwater samples near the town of Cerro
Azul. Water supplied by SANEPAR for consumption in Cerro
Azul, as well as water from a spring that supplies the Mato
Preto community were also collected. The physical-chemical parameters (pH, Eh, conductivity, dissolved oxygen,
temperature, turbidity, SDT) were measured in situ. On the
same day as sampling, the alkalinity analyses in non-filtered
samples were made, through the titration method, using four
drops of bromocresol and H2SO4 0.16 N. The samples for
cation analyses were acidified with 4 drops of concentrated
HNO3 in a 50ml sample. The filtered water samples (Millipore
<0.45µm) were analyzed by the Laboratory for Mineral Analysis - Laboratório de Análises Minerais (LAMIN), the anions
Cl-, NO2-, Br-, NO3-, PO4-3 and SO4-2 by ionic chromatography
and the cations Al, As, B, Ba, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe,
Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Ni, Pb, Sc, Se, Si, Sn, Sr, Ti, V, W and Zn,
by ICP-OES. Na and K were analyzed by atomic absorption
spectrophotometry.
– 117 –
Fluorine geochemistry in luvial waters and sediments of the Cerro Azul Region, Paraná State: deinition of risk areas for human consumption
The F- contents were determined at the Geosciences
Institute (IG) of UNICAMP with an ion selective electrode
(EIS), Orion, model 96-09. The calibration curve was build
from three reference solutions, each of them prepared with
a 5ml solution of TISAB III, 50ml of standard solution 0.1, 1
and 10 mg/l of F-, respectively. To determine F-, 50ml of the
filtered sample water and 5ml of the TISAB III solution were
used, always in plastic beakers. In the same field campaign,
another 14 flow sediment samples were collected (July 12
and march 2), which were analyzed for 30 elements in the
granulometric fractions < 177mm and < 63mm, by an FRX
at the IG of UNICAMP, using pressed powder samples. The
F- content was determined following procedures proposed
by Hopkins (1977), consisting
of the sample’s fusion with
a Na2 and K2CO3 solution,
followed by nitric acid addition and a buffer solution of
sodium citrate before the EIS
analysis. Two different reference materials were used for
the F- analysis, giving acceptable results. The mineralogical
composition of the sediments
was determined by DRX at
the X-Ray Laboratory of the
Center for Geosciences of
the Federal Pará University
(UFPa). In some samples, the
separation of dense minerals
using bromoform and its difratometric analysis was carried
out whereas in others, the clay
fraction was analyzed (oriented, glycolated and heated
sample). Complementary
observations were made with
a scanning electronic microscope (MEV).
water – including elements that represent a health risk were compared with the maximum values allowed by the
ANVISA Administrative Act Nº 518. Most of the analyzed
water was found to be within the potability standards after
conventional treatment.
The pH values were between 7.3 and 8 in the July/03
sampling and between 7.7 and 8.3 in March/04. The other
water quality parameters presented these variations, respectively in the two sampling periods: Eh in the intervals
452-532 mV and 444-502 mV; electric conductivity/conductance 0.06-0.21 mS/m and 0.10-0.34 mS/m; OD 8.1-10.3
mg/L and 7.8-10.1 mg/L.; temperature 14.7-18.5 °C and
21.1-27.8 °C. During the March sampling the total dissolved
RESULTS AND
DISCUSSION
Water quality
In the Piper diagram the
water shows a calcic bicarbonate type composition.
Only sample 24 (groundwater)
was within the limit between
the fields of calcic bicarbonate
and sodic bicarbonate water
(Figure 2).
The physical-chemical
parameters and the different ions analyzed for the
Figure 2 – Piper Diagram for water classification.
– 118 –
Maria Jimena Andreazzini
solids concentrations (TSD) varied between 0.06 and 0.22
g/L, and the turbidity values between 2 and 45 UTN.
The concentration of Be, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, Sc,
Se, Sn, Ti, W and V were below their respective detection
limits in all samples.
Fluorine contents exceeding the permitted limits were
detected in the streams near the MP mine. The F- concentrations in surface water varied between 0.07 and 2.54mg/L
F-, the highest values corresponding to the samples situated in streams influenced by both mineralizations (Figure
3). It must be noted the July/03 sampling was planned to
represent the dry period; however, there were strong rains
the day before sampling, which provoked the dilution of
the water samples. Thus, it was not possible to determine
the maximum F- contents in the region’s water. Therefore
it is possible there are other streams exceeding the permitted limit, for example the Pinheirinho River, where the
F- concentration was close to this limit.
For both campaigns, the samples with highest F- contents also presented higher concentrations of Ca2+, Sr2+
and Ba2+, elements with geochemical affinity, whereas the
highest values of F- did not always coincide with the highest
values of Si4+. In the groundwater samples (both situated
within the granitic environment) contents of 1.13 and 0.33
mg/L F- were detected.
The water catchment area for treatment and distribution
to the Cerro Azul population by SANEPAR is situated in the Três Barras creek,
where sample 12 was collected. This presented
0.12 and 0.14 mg/L F- in
the July and March campaigns, respectively. The
F- contents in the samples
of consumption treated
water were 0.84 and 1.02
mg/L F- for Cerro Azul, in
July and March, respectively and 0.23mg/L F- for
the Mato Preto community
in March.
Preto mine (15a and 15b), due to its proximity to the spring
and the shorter transport distance (Figures 4 and 5). It
should be noted for some samples the difference between
the contents determined for both fractions is within the
analytic error of the method.
Of these mineral phases, those that possibly bring
fluorine to the sediments are hornblende, illite and smectite.
In the diffractograms of samples originating from sites near
the mineralized areas, fluorite peaks were not identified,
possible due to the experimental conditions of the diffraction analysis, where phases with a concentration lower
than 1-2% in weight are not detected. For this reason these
samples were also observed by the MEV, in which fluorite
was confirmed through the elements mapping by dispersed electrons images. Other identified mineral phases
were apatite (probably fluorapatite), baryta, biotite, zircon,
rutile, ilmenite, quartz, feldspar and iron oxides.
CONCLUSIONS
With regards to surface water quality in the Cerro
Azul region, this study revealed a risk area, situated
near the Mato Preto deposits, where the water was not
fit for human consumption because of the high fluoride
concentrations. On the other hand, it was confirmed the
F- contents in the distributed water for consumption in
Analysis of the Stream
Sediments
The sediment samples had F contents between 330 and 1,300
mg/g. In general, the F
concentrations in the fraction <63mm were higher
than those in the fraction
<177mm, except for those
samples close to the Mato
Figure 3 – Areal distribution of the fluoride contents in the surface water.
– 119 –
Fluorine geochemistry in luvial waters and sediments of the Cerro Azul Region, Paraná State: deinition of risk areas for human consumption
Figure 4 – Fluorine contents in both granulometric fractions from
fluvial sediments.
Cerro Azul and the Mato Preto community were inferior
to those established by law.
In the case of the stream sediments, the <63 mm
fraction presented, in general, higher F contents than
the <177 mm. This is due to the fluorine retention in clay
minerals (especially illite and smectite) also present in
this granulometric fraction, as well as fluorite, which due
to its fragility, is more concentrated in the smaller fraction. Based on the region’s mineralogical composition of
the fluvial sediments and rocks, the possible F sources
in the sediments may be: i) fluorite and apatite (probably
fluorapatite) from the mineralized areas; ii) hornblende
and biotite (and accessory minerals such as apatite and
titanite) from granitic rocks, and iii) illite and smectite resulting from the alteration of the different minerals and from
the siltic clayed metasediments of the Açungui Group.
Although the results show that the population’s
exposure risk to fluoride from surface water is low, it is
estimated that the fluoride contents in groundwater are
higher, given the longer interaction period of this water
with the surrounding rocks. The well water sample (23),
situated on a granitic area, presented contents close to
Figure 5 – Areal distribution map of the fluorine contents in stream sediments (fraction <177mm)
– 120 –
Maria Jimena Andreazzini
1 mg/L F-. Water from those aquifers situated in carbonate and alkaline-carbonatite conditions deserve special
attention as the highest F- contents were registered here.
Therefore it is recommended, groundwater intended for
consumption from private wells, is previously analyzed
for F- in addition to an exposure risk evaluation. It would
also be interesting to determine the fluorine content in
the region’s soil and crops, which may pose as another
fluorine source (via food) increasing the risk of fluorosis
among these populations.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
To the National Research Council and Foundation
for Research Support of the São Paulo State (Conselho
Nacional de Pesquisa, CNPq and Fapesp) for financing
this research. To the directors of the Mining Company
Mineração Nossa Sra. do Carmo Ltda, to MINEROPAR,
to geologist Ídio Lopes Jr (CPRM-SP) and co-workers, to
the Laboratory of Mineral Analysis (LAMIN), to the X-Ray
Laboratory of the Federal University of Pará, to the Water
Company of the State of Paraná (Companhia de Saneamento do Paraná -SANEPAR), to the technicians Dailto
Silva and Aparecida Vendemiatto of the IG of UNICAMP.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ALALLMANN, R.; KORITNING, S. Fluorine. In: WEDEPOHL, K.H. (Ed.). Handbook of Geochemistry. Berlin:
Springer- Verlag, 1972. Cap 9, 66 pp.
APAMBIRE, W.B.; BOYLE, D.R.; MICHEL, F.A. Geochemistry, genesis, and health implications of fluoriferous
groundwaters in the upper regions of Ghana. Environmental Geology, Berlin, v. 33, n. 1, p. 13-24, 1997.
AGENCY FOR TOXIC SUBSTANCES AND DISEASE REGISTRY. Toxicológical profil for fluorides, hydrogen
fluoride and fluorine. Disponível em:<http://www.
Atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts11.html>. Acesso: mar. 2005.
BELL, F.G. Environmental geology: principles and practice. [Oxford]: Blackwell Science, 1998. 594 p.
BLARASÍN, M.; CABRERA, A.; PARIS, M.; MATTEODA,
E. Aplicación del análisis factorial y cluster al
tratamiento de datos hidrogeoquímicos en la hoja
Río Cuarto, Córdoba: memorias del III Congreso
Argentino de Hidrogeologia y I Seminario Hispano-Latinoamericano sobre temas actuales de la
hidrología subterránea. Rosario, Argentina: [s.n.],
2003. V.2, p. 309-318.
BIONDI, J.C.; FELIPE, R.S.; FUZIKAWA, K. Jazida de
fluorita da Volta Grande, Cerro Azul, Paraná (BR):
relatório interno. [Curitiba]: MINEROPAR; NUCLEBRÁS, 1985. 16 p.
BONORINO, A.G.; ALBOUY, R.; BUNDSCHUH, J.
Geoquímica y origen del flúor en el acuífero de la
vertiente suroccidental de las Sierras Australes. In:
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HYDROGEOLOGISTS CONGRESS: ground water and human
development, 32.; ALHSUD CONGRESS, 6., 2002,
Mar del Plata, Argentina. [Trabajos expuestos]. [S.l.:
s.n.], 2002. p. 126.
BRASIL. Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária. Portaria N_ 518, de 25 de março de 2004. Controle
e vigilância da qualidade da água para consumo
humano e seu padrão de potabilidade. Ministério
da Saúde, Brasília, 2004. 15 p.
BRASIL. Conselho Nacional do Meio Ambiente. Resolução CONAMA N_ 020/86. Disponível em: <http://
www.lei.adv.br/020-86.htm>. Acesso: abril/ 2005.
CANGUSSU, M.C.T.; NARVAI, P.C.; FERNANDEZ, R.C.;
DJEHIZIAN, V. A fluorose dentária no Brasil: uma
revisão crítica. Cadernos de Saúde Pública, Rio de
Janeiro, v. 18, n. 1, p. 7-15, 2002.
CARDOSO, L.; MORITA, M.C.; ALVES, J.C.; LICHT, O.A.B.
Anomalia hidrogeoquímica e ocorrência de fluorose dentária em Itambaracá-Pr. In: CONGRESSO
BRASILEIRO DE GEOQUÍMICA, 8., 2001, Curitiba.
Resumos... Curitiba: SBGq, 2001. 1 CD-ROM.
COMPANHIA DE SANEAMENTO BÁSICO DO ESTADO
DE SÂO PAULO SABESP. Resolução SS 293/96 –
Qualidade da água. Disponível em:<www.sabesp.
com.br/legislacao/PDF/RSS29396.PDF>. Acesso:01
abr. 2005.
DARDENNE, M. A.; RONCHI, L. H.; BASTOSNETO, A. C.;
TOURAY, J.C. Geologia da fluorita. In: SCHOBBENHAUS, C.; QUEIROZ, E. Texeira de; COELHO, C.E.
Silva (Ed.). Principais Depósitos Minerais do Brasil.
[S.l.]: DNPM; CPRM, 1997. v. 4, parte B, p. 479-506.
FINKELMAN, R.B.; BELKIN, H.E.; ZHENG, B. Health
impacts of domestic coal use in China. Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. USA Washington, DC, v. 96, n. 7, p. 34273431, mar. 1999.
GOLDSCHMIDT, V.T. 1970. Fluorine. In: MUIR, A. (Ed.).
Geochemistry. Oxford: [Clarendon Press], 1970. p:
568-583.
GUPTA, S.K.; DESHPANDE, R.D. Depleting Groundwater levels and increasing fluoride concentration in
villages of Mehsana District, Gujarat, India: cost
to economy and health. Disponível em: <www.globenet.org/preceup/pages/ang/chapie/capitali/cas/
indmehs.htm>. Acesso: 01 mar. 2005.
HOPKINS, D.M. An improved ion-selective electrode
method for the rapid determination of fluorine in
rocks and soils. Journal Research U.S. Geol. Survey,
v. 5, n. 5, p. 589-593, 1977.
JENKINS, R.E. Geology of the Clugger-Fluorite Deposit,
Mato Preto, Parana, Brazil. Revista Brasileira de Geociências, São Paulo, v. 17, n. 3, p. 288-294, 1987.
LICHT, O.A.B. A geoquímica multielementar na gestão
ambiental: identificação e caracterização de províncias geoquímicas naturais, alterações antrópicas da
– 121 –
Fluorine geochemistry in luvial waters and sediments of the Cerro Azul Region, Paraná State: deinition of risk areas for human consumption
paisagem, áreas favoráveis à prospecção mineral e
regiões de risco para a saúde no estado do Paraná,
Brasil. 2001. 236 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geologia
Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia, Universidade
Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
LICHT, O.A.B.; MORITA, M.C.; TARVAINEN, T. A utilização
de dados de prospecção geoquímica de fluorita
no primeiro planalto paranaense, na identificação
de áreas de interesse para a saúde pública: uma
abordagem preliminar. Geochimica Brasiliensis, Rio
de Janeiro, v. 10, p. 57-69, 1996.
LICHT, O.A.B.; ARIOLI, E.E.; PIERKARZ, G.F. The multilevel geochemical survey in Paraná State, Brazil. In:
INTERNATIONAL GEOLOGICAL CONGRESS, 30.,
Beijing. Documents. Beijing: [s.n.], 1996 1 CD-ROM.
LICHT, O.A.B.; PIEKARZ, G.F.; SILVA, J.C.C.DA; LOPES
JUNIOR, I. Levantamento geoquímico multielementar de baixa densidade no Estado do Paraná
(hidrogeoquímica – resultados preliminares). A terra
em revista, Belo Horizonte, v. 3, n. 3, p. 34-46, 1997.
LOUREIRO, F.E.L.; TAVARES, J.R. Duas novas ocorrências de carbonatitos: Mato Preto e Barra do Rio
Itapirapuã. Revista Brasileira de Geociências, São
Paulo, v. 13, n. 1, p. 7-11, 1983.
MARTINI, S.L. Fluorita de Volta Grande: retrospecto
e nova programação: relatório interno. Curitiba:
MINEROPAR, 1985. 12 p.
MATOS, L.H. Jazidas de fluorita no Vale do Ribeira. Curitiba: DNPM, 1989.
MENEASSE, LN.; FANTINEL, L.M.; KNAUER, L.G.; HORN,
A.H.; DUPONT, H.S.J.B.; CASTRO, R.E.L.; FREIRA,
A.P.S.; EFIGÊNIA, F.; PAIXÃO, H.H.; CASTILHO,
L.; BAZZOLI, N.; SANTOS, C.V.N.; SOUZA, C.A.S.;
LÚCIO, P.S. Flúor na água subterrânea e fluorose
dental no município de São Francisco, Minas Gerais.
In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA,
41., 2002, João Pessoa. Anais. João Pessoa: SBG
Núcleo Nordeste, 2002, p. 554.
ORTIZ, Ruiz P. Efectos deletéreos de la administración
oral de flúor. Revista de Medicina Interna Concepción. Concepción, Chile, v. 1, n. 2, 1997.
RONCHI, L.H.; FELIPE, R.S.; DARDENNE, M.A. O depósito de fluorita de Volta Grande: tipos de minério e
sucessão mineral. In: SIMPÓSIO SUL-BRASILEIRO
DE GEOLOGIA, 3., 1987, Curitiba. Atas...Curitiba:
[s.n.], 1987. v.2, p. 615-622.
RONCHI, L.H; TOURAY, J.C.; DARDENNE, M.A. 1995.
Complex hydrothermal history of a roof pendanthosted fluorite deposit at Volta Grande, Paraná
(Southern Brazil). Economic Geology, Montpellier,
VT, v. 90, p. 948-955, 1995.
SANTOS, R.V.; DARDENNE, M.A. Fluorita de Mato Preto:
um caso particular de mineralização de fluorita
associada a complexo alcalino carbonatítico. In:
CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 35.,
1988, Belém. Anais... Belém: SBG, 1988. v. 3, p.
1251-1261.
UNICEF. UNICEF´s position on water fluoridation. Disponível em: <www.nofluoride.com/Unicef_fluor.
htm>. Acesso: 01 mar. 2005.
WARREN, C.; BURGESS, W.; GARCIA, M.G. Arsenic and
fluoride in quaternary loess and alluvial aquifers at
Los Pereyra, Tucumán, Argentina.: aguas subterráneas y desarrollo humano. In: IAH, 32. & ALHSUD,
6. CONGRESS: groundwater and human development. 2002, Mar del Plata. [Trabajos expuestos]. Mar
del Plata: [s.n.], 2002. p.91.
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. Fluoride in drinkingwater: background document for development of
WHO guidelines for drinking-water quality. Disponível em: <http://www.who. int/water_sanitation_helth/
dwq/chemicals/fluoride. pdf>. Acesso: 01 abr. 2005.
– 122 –
HYDROGEOCHEM ICAL
STUDY OF FLUORINE IN
GROUNDWATER
OF THE CASSERIBÚ,
M ACACÚ AND SÃO JOÃO
RIVER BASINS, RIO DE
JANEIRO STATE BRAZIL
¹Theodoros I. Panagoulias, geotheo@uol.com.br
¹Emmanoel V. da Silva Filho, geoemma@vm.uff.br
¹Fluminense Federal University - UFF
INTRODUCTION
The studied region (Figure 1) is experiencing rapid
demographic growth, which generates an increasing
demand for water resources. Because of the lack and/
or costs of a public supply (a water distribution network
has been recently initiated by CEDAE), groundwater is
being increasingly explored through wells, both shallow
and deep, to meet the local commercial activities and
population’s demands.
This area has fluorite vein occurrences (a mineral
composed of calcium and fluorine), of hydrothermal origin and embedded in normal and directional faults, 1 to
2 meters thick and tens of meters long. As a result, the
groundwater in this region may present concentrations
anomalies for certain chemical elements, fluorine among
them.
Fluorine is a chemical element principally ingested
by humans in drinking water (more than 70%) (Bowell et
al., 1997 and Plant et al., 2001). In low concentrations
(1mg/L), fluorite prevents the occurrences of dental caries, but excessive intake of the element (>4mg/L) can
– 123 –
Figure 1 – Map of the State of Rio de Janeiro and location of the
studied area
Hydrogeochemical study of luorine in groundwater of the Casseribú, Macacú and São João river basins, Rio de Janeiro State Brazil
result in public health problems (ranging from dental
fluorosis to skeleton deformation) (Moller, 1982), as well
as problems when the water is used for other purposes
(such as irrigation and animal demands). The relationship between fluorine and public health problems is well
registered in areas of alkaline volcanic lithologies, as in
parts of India, Sri Lanka, China and Eastern Africa (Dissanayake, 1996), but little is known of areas where fluorine
originates from hydrothermal occurrences (Ferrari et al.,
1982; Maddock and Dias, 1989).
Therefore, this region, due to its geological characteristics, its pattern of soil occupation and the incidence
of human and animal fluorosis, merits a study on the occurrence, spatial distribution and geochemical behavior
of this element to better manage the use of groundwater.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Groundwater is water that infiltrates rocks and soil,
percolating until the hydrostatic level. Given that surface
catchments (with an acceptable quality level) are becoming increasingly more distant (e.g. the Imunana CEDAE
center, in Magé, to supply the populations of São Gonçalo
and Niterói) and the treatment of excessively degraded
water, or its reuse is restricted by technical and economical limitations, the use of groundwater is the most promising technical-economical alternative (Da Silva, 1984).
Groundwater is a natural renewable resource, therefore its long term exploration must be balanced and based
on the available natural recharge.
Groundwater is considered polluted when the concentration of total dissolved ions or suspended solids,
caused directly or indirectly by man, is higher than the
maximum national (such as the CONAMA Resolutions)
and international (WHO) permitted standard concentrations for potable water or for use in certain commercial
activities.
In the case of groundwater unaffected by man with
elements in concentrations exceeding such limits, the
contamination can be defined by values in excess of
global natural mean values for the contents in a given
water source (Matthes, 1982).
Therefore it is essential to know the quality of a region’s aquifers to define the naturally enriched element’s
variation, the geochemical mobilization mechanisms of
these elements in the water, the cost/benefit for consumption and its viability for use in specific commercial
activities.
There are countless factors considered responsible
for groundwater contamination (Geraghty & Miller, 1972).
In the studied region, possible contamination sources
could be: i) fluorine rich mineral vein occurrences (Fluorite); ii) atmospheric emission from brick factories and
mining companies and; iii) domestic and/or industrial
sewage.
In recent studies (Maddock & Dias, 1988 and Maddock & Dias, 1989) of this region, anomalies in surface
water fluoride concentrations of 12.5 mg/L were detected.
If ingested in low concentrations (1 to 3 mg/day),
fluorine is recommended as a dental prophylactic and
the appropriate development of bones. To be effective,
almost all fluorine (>90%) must be dissolved in water in
its most abundant form: fluoride. The intake of elevated
doses (>40 mg/day) can cause the loss of the teeth
glossiness and, in some cases, it can reach the stage
of skeletal deficiency, causing rheumatic pains and/or
arthritis (OMS/WHO, 1970).
Natural fluorine concentrations can vary from traceconcentrations to 2.800 mg/L, as in East Africa (Gaciri &
Davies, 1993). Fluorine concentrations in natural water
depend on several factors such as: temperature, pH,
the presence or not of mineral complexes, precipitated
ions and colloids, a mineral’s solubility, its ionic exchange
capacity, granulometry and the type of lithology and the
waters’ time of residence (Apambire et al., 1997).
Minerals that influence the fluoride hydrogeochemical concentration variation are: fluorite, apatite, mica,
amphibole, certain types of clay and vermiculite. Fluorite
is the main mineral controlling the fluoride concentration
in water. The total fluoride released in water with weak
ionic potential for fluorite dissolution is about 8 to 10 mg/L
(Boyle, 1976). However, the concentrations of Ca, Na,
hydroxyls and certain ionic complexes can change this
dissolution rate. Studies have indicated a high negative
correlation between Ca and F concentrations in water with
Ca concentrations above that for the F solubility (Boyle
1976, 1992). Voroshelov (1966) demonstrated that water
with high Ca contents influence the fluorine dissolution.
Sodium usually presents a positive correlation with
fluoride in different types of groundwater, especially those
with low Ca concentrations. High Na concentrations increase the fluoride solubility in water (Apambire, 1997).
This process results in high fluoride concentrations in
water (>30 mg/L), but in the presence of clay this is not
the case as the process involves base exchanges (Ca
and Mg for Na) that progressively shift the pH to more
alkaline water, typical of sedimentary basins (Boyle, 1992).
Recent studies have demonstrated that fluorine
forms mono and difluor complexes with REE and that
this mechanism of fluorine mobility into water is not fully
understood (Sallet et al., 2000 and Schijf & Birne, 1999).
Fluorite is a mineral that commonly presents REE and Y
concentrations. Certain occurrences with elevated concentrations (above 13% of the total Y weight and 14.1%
of the total Ce weight) have already been mentioned in
specialized literature. The REE tend to replace the Ca in
the mineral structure, indicating that an enrichment of the
concentrations of both heavy and light REE can occur.
Rocks in hydrothermal deposits exhibit concentrations of
the whole REE series and studies have demonstrated that
– 124 –
Theodoras I. Panagoulias
REE rates, such as Tb/Ca X Tb/La, can indicate whether
the fluorite deposit is from hydrothermal origins or from
sedimentation processes, due to the REE fractionation
in fluorite (Henderson, 1984). In the case of apatites,
secondary minerals in the region’s lithologies, some
group members have relative ERR concentration, but the
fluorapatites, generally have low, but significant, concentrations, which vary between 0.01% and 12% (alkaline
rocks). The REE replace the Ca in the apatites structure,
forming Ce and Y complexes (Henderson, 1984). In addition, the ERR behavior and complexation in water, related
to the water’s acidity or alkalinity, mainly for minerals like
apatite (Johannesson et al., 1996 and Fleet & Pan, 1997)
and/or phosphate minerals with fluorine content, is not
well explained.
As a consequence, it is important to carry out ERR
hydrogeochemical analyses in the region to define the
hydrogeochemical mechanisms that make fluorine available in the environment.
PARTIAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results were plotted on a map showing the F- concentration contour curves (Figure 2). The map indicates
the highest concentrations (>6 mg.L-1) were obtained
between the towns of Tanguá and Rio Bonito, a region
with fluorite vein occurrences, especially affecting deep
wells. Shallow wells presented low concentrations of
the element, suggesting that the water is diluted by rain
and/or that these wells receive infiltration from surface
water. The highest concentrations obtained are within
the maximum potability standards established by the
WHO and the Ministry of Health. Analyzing the correlations between elements, a close to negative correlation is
confirmed between the Ca and F concentrations in water
with Ca concentrations above that for F solubility (Boyle,
Figure 2 – Distribution of Fluorine in the studied area groundwater.
1976, 1992). Voroshelov (1966) demonstrated that water
with high Ca contents condition the fluorine dissolution.
Analyzing the correlations between F and Na, an element
that normally has a positive correlation with fluoride in
several kinds of groundwater, especially those with low Ca
concentrations; the Na concentrations increase fluoride
solubility in water (Ampabire, 1997). This process is not
well understood when it involves several lithologies, since
the process involves base exchanges (Ca and Mg for
Na) that progressively shift the pH to the field of alkaline
water. Based on the results of the concentrations’ spatial
distribution, it is confirmed that the region’s groundwater
is inadequate for consumption due to the high fluorine
concentrations.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
AMPABIRE, W.B. et al. Geochemistry, genesis, and health
implications of fluoriferous groundwaters in the upper
regions of Ghana. Environmental Geology, Berlin, v.
33, n. 1, p. 13-24, 1997.
BOWELL, R.J. et al. Improving water quality assessment
and supply. In: WEDC CONFERENCE: “Water and
Sanitation for All”, 23., 1997, Durban. [Proceedings].
Durban: [s.n.], 1997. p. 146-149.
BOYLE, D.R. Effects of base exchange softening on
fluoride uptake in groundwaters of the Moncton
Sub-Basin, New Brunkswick, Canada. In: KHARAKA,
Y.K.; MAEST, A.S. (Ed.). INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON WATER ROCK INTERACTION, 7., 1992,
Rotterdam Proceedings...Rotterdam: [s.n.], 1992.
p. 771-774.
BOYLE, D.R. The geochemistry of fluorine and its application in mineral exploration. 1976. 370 p. Tese
(Doutorado PhD)-Imperial College of Science and
Technology, University of London, London, 1976.
CHERNET, T. et al. Mechanism of degradation of the
quality of natural water in the lakes region of the
Ethiopian Rift Valley. Wat. Res., [S.l], v. 35, n. 12, p.
2819-2832, 2001.
DISSANAYAKE, C.B. Water quality and dental health in the
dry zone of Sri Lanka. In: APPLETON, J.D.; FUGE, R.;
MCCALL, G.J.H. (Ed.). Environmental geochemistry
and health. London: The Geological Society, 1996.
p. 131-140. ( GSL Special Publications, 113).
FERRARI, A.L. et al. O pré-cambriano das folhas Itaboraí,
Maricá, Saquarema e Baía de Guanabara. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 32., 1982,
Salvador. Anais. Salvador: SBG Núcleo Bahia, 1982.
v. 1, p. 103-114.
FLEET, M.E.; PAN, Y. Rare Earth elements in apatite:
uptake from H20-bearing phosphate-fluoride melts
and the role of volatile components. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta, Oxford, v. 61, n. 22, p. 47454760, nov. 1997.
– 125 –
Hydrogeochemical study of luorine in groundwater of the Casseribú, Macacú and São João river basins, Rio de Janeiro State Brazil
FLUORIDES and human health. Geneva: World Health
Organization, 1970. (WHO Monograph Series, n.
59).
GACIRI S.J.; DAVIES, T.C. The occurrence and geochemistry of fluoride in some natural waters of Kenya. J.
Hydrol. Amsterdam, v. 143, n. 3-4, p. 395-412, mar.
1993..
GERAGHTY, J.J.; MILLER, D.W. Groundwater contamination: an explanation of its causes and effects:
a special report. New York: Gerghty & Miller Inc.,
1972. 15 p.
HENDERSON, P (Ed.). Rare Earth geochemistry. Oxford:
Elsevier, 1984.
JOHANNESSON, K.H. et al. Rare earth element complexation behavior in circumneutral pH groundwaters:
assessing the role of carbonate and phosphate ions.
Earth and Planet Science Letters, Amsterdam, v. 139,
n. 1-2, p. 305-319, mar. 1996.
MADDOCK, J.E.L.; DIAS, R.B. Hydrogeochemical prospecting for fluorite in the Serra do Mar, Brazil.In:
CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOQUÍMICA, 2.,
1989, Rio de Janeiro. Anais . Rio de Janeiro: SBGq;
CPRM; DNPM, 1989. p. 61-68. .
MADDOCK, J.E.L.; DIAS, R.B. Prospecção hidrogeoquímica para fluorita, no Estado do Rio de Janeiro.
In: SIMPÓSIO BRASILEIRO DE GEOQUÍMICA, 3.,
1985, Ouro Preto. Anais...Ouro Preto: Revista da
Escola de Minas, ano LII, v. XLI, n. 1-4, p. 174-188,
1989.
MAGALHÃES, M. Levantamento de poluição com Flúor
em pastagens de gado nas vizinhanças de olaria –
Município de Itaboraí- RJ. 1982. 60 p. Dissertação
(Mestrado em Geoquímica)-Universidade Federal
Fluminense, Niterói, 1982.
MATTHES, G. The Properties of groundwater. New York:
John Wiley & Sons, 1982. 406p.
MOLLER, I. Fluoride and fluorosis. International Dental
Journal, London, v. 32, p. 135-147, 1982.
PLANT, J. et al. Environmental geochemistry at the global
scale. Applied Geochemistry, Oxford, v. 16, n. 11-12,
p. 1291-1308, Sep. 2001.
RIO DE JANEIRO (Estado). Departamento de Recursos
Minerais. Fluorita de Tanguà. Boletim Técnico nº 01.
Niterói, 1982.
SALLET, R. et al. Fluorite 87Sr/86 Sr and REE constraints
on fluid-melt relations, crystallization time span and
bulk DSr of evolved high-silica granites: Tabuleiro
granites, Santa Catarina, Brazil. Chemical geology,
Amsterdam, v. 164, n. 1-2, p. 81-92, mar. 2000.
SCHIJF, J.; BYRNE, R.H. Determination of stability constants for the mono- and difluoro-complexes of Y
and the REE, using a cation-exchange resin and
ICP-MS. Polyhedron, Oxford, v. 18, n. 22, p. 28392844, Sep. 1999.
SERRANO, M.J.G. et al. REE speciation in low-temperature acidic waters and the competitive effects on
aluminum. Chemical Geology, Amsterdam, v. 165,
n. 3-4, p. 167-180, Apr. 2000.
SILVA, A.B. da. Evolução Química das Águas Subterrâneas. Revista Águas Subterrâneas, São Paulo, v.
8, p. 5-12, 1985.
STANDARD methods for the examination of water and
wastewater. 16 ed. Washington: American Public
Health Association; American Water Works Association; Water Pollution Control Federation, 1985. 1134 p.
VOROSHELOV, Y.V. Geochemical behaviour of fluorine in
the groundwaters of the Moscow Region. Geochem.
Int., Silver Spring, MD, v. 2, p. 261, 1966.
– 126 –
M ERCURY NATURAL
OCCURRENCES
IN PARANÁ STATE
BRAZIL
¹’²Rafael A. B. Plawiak, rafaelbp@geologist.com
¹Otávio A. B. Licht, otavio@pr.gov.br
²Eleonora M. G. Vasconcellos, eleonora@ufpr.br
³Bernardino R. Figueiredo, berna@ige.unicamp.br
¹Minerals of Paraná AS - MINEROPAR
²Federal University of Paraná - UFPR
³University of Campinas - UNICAMP
INTRODUCTION
OBJECTIVES
The regional geochemical surveys carried out in
Paraná State, North Brazil, indicated extensive positive
mercury anomalies. One, identified in a geochemical
survey of active stream sediments (ASS), showed a geographical correlation with some deep tectonic structures
that cut across the Paraná Basin igneous rocks (São
Bento Group – Mesozoic) that has many thermal artesian
water springs. Whereas, the geochemical survey on the B
soil-horizon (SOLO) showed a regional anomaly coinciding with the carbon rich sedimentary sequences of the
Paraná Basin (Paraná, Itararé and Passa Dois Groups
– Paleozoic). In another geological context related to
the Proterozoic, both surveys, but especially the SOLO,
showed that the known Ribeira Valley Pb-Zn deposits and
mineralizations may be responsible for this geochemical
anomaly.
These geologic-geochemical correlations enabled
the authors to build the following study hypotheses: a)
existing metal mobilization within some of the sedimentary
sequences of the Paraná Basin through thermal water
percolation along deep faults, followed by the metal deposition on the surface and b) association with the Ribeira
Valley Pb-Zn-Ba ore processes.
This study sought at this stage to compile the available data on the presence of mercury in Paraná State
(Figure 1), related to different geological settings. These
support the genetic hypotheses for the geochemical
anomalies on the surface and on the regional scale
(geochemical survey of active stream sediments, and
geochemical survey of soils-horizon B – SOLO) as well
as on a detail scale (Salto do Itararé region – SOLO
and Palmeira region – SAD), Figure 2 and Figure 3
respectively.
– 127 –
Figure 1 – Geographical location of Paraná State.
Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State, Brazil
mineral can be collected with ease. The Baron of Tibagy
asserts that a naturalist, who visited the place, had told
him that the mine was very rich and on another occasion he had already obtained, with ease, half a pound of
quicksilver/mercury on his request.” The same author later
refers: “It is impossible that the least doubt still remains
today about the existence of quicksilver /mercury mines
in the Province. Samples of the famous liquid metal had
already been sent to various expositions. The Kellers,
German father and son engineers, had examined the
mine situated 13 kilometers from Palmeira.” Finally, the
author makes the following reference “Manoel de Assis
Drumond and Bernardo Pinto de Oliveira – Decree n°
6246 of July 12th 1876 – They are granted permission
to explore quicksilver/mercury in Villa da Palmeira. This
grant was extended (sic) by Decree nº 6876 of July 20th
1878, and later by Decree nº 7392 of July 31st 1879.”
The Collection of Laws of the Brazilian Empire – 1876,
Acts of the Executive Power confirms - Decree nº6246 of
July 12th 1876 where the Regent Imperial Princess grants
Manoel de Assis Drumond and Bernardo Pinto de Oliveira
the authorization to explore quicksilver/mercury mines in
the Province of Paraná. Decree nº 6976 of July 20th 1878,
extends the concession for another year (Figure 5).
HgS) grains were found in the marmites excavated
by the water on the river bed made of sandstones of the
Itararé Group (Paleozoic). The transcription states: “The
presence of mercury was signaled in the Castelhanos
Figures 2 – Geographical location of the Salto do Itararé area in
Paraná State.
Figure 3 – Geographical location of the Palmeira area in
Paraná State.
HISTORY
The study revealed that since the early 19th century,
there have been many references to mercury in several
Paraná State communities.
Ferreira (1885) refers to a “mercury mine” discovered
in 1842 in the Palmeira region, near the Castelhanos
River, an Iguaçu River tributary (Figure 4). Located 13
kilometers from the “Palmeira community”, Ponta Grossa
municipality, there is a quicksilver /mercury mine which
was later examined by the Kellers - father and son engineers, who found it to be important. Furthermore, Dr. Paulo
José d’Oliveira informs in his memories (sic) published
elsewhere: - “The creek on whose bed the quicksilver/
mercury was found, originates in a swamp formed by a
water spring. Further below there are some loose stones
to be found among which, in drought times, the aforesaid
Figure 4 – Front page of the Geographical Lexicon of Mines in Brazil
- “Diccionario Geographico das Minas do Brazil” (Ferreira, 1885).
– 128 –
Plawiak, R.A.B
Figure 5 – The Imperial Decree nº 6246 of July 12th 1876, for the
exploration of the mercury mine in Villa de Palmeira (National
archives).
creek, a tributary of the the Iguassú River, in the town of
Palmeira. The first notice appeared in the report of the
engineers Keller on the exploration of Ivahy River. Lead
by wrong observations, they made the description of the
deposit. Drops of the metal were found in potholes open
in sandstone of the Itararé Series. In 1902, Drs. F. de
Paula Oliveira and Eugenio Elmo made the very detailed
examination of this region, having studied almost all the
creeks, from Restinga Secca to Porto Amazonas on the
Iguassu. The investigations were negative, but Dr. Elmo
assured me that he had found some grains of a mineral
that, after having been analyzed, revealed sulphide of
cinnabar mercury. As for native mercury nothing was
found.”
The National Department of Mineral Production
(Departamento Nacional de Produção Mineral – DNPM)
granted, in 1935, the mining license nº 3127 for mercury
in the region of Salto do Itararé. The original document
has not been found in the DNPM archives.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Seeking to confirm these historical references to the
occurrence of mercury in Paraná State, some periodic
geochemical surveys were carried out by MINEROPAR.
In 1984, on the Paranapanema River right margin,
near Salto do Itararé, in a regular grid with a base line
orientation N75E, 110m wide transects with sampling
sites every 45m, 75 soil (horizon B) samples were collected (MINEROPAR, unpublished, apud Plawiak et al.,
2004). The fraction <0.177mm (<80#) of the soil samples
was analyzed in a commercial laboratory through Atomic
Absorption Spectrophotometry with cold steam.
In 2003, in Palmeira, 70km west of Curitiba, 17
samples of active stream sediments were collected in the
Tibagi and Iguaçu River basin head areas (MINEROPAR
and Evandro Chagas Institute – ECI, unpublished, apud
Plawiak et al., 2004). The basin areas varied between 10
and 60km². The samples were analyzed by the Toxicology
Laboratory, Environment Section of the ECI, in two granulometric fractions: <0.104mm (<150#) and <0.062mm
(<230#), through Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry
with cold steam.
The mercury distribution on a regional scale was
identified by two ultra low density surveys that followed
the standards established by the Global Geochemical
Reference Network – GGRN. The first Low Density Multielemental Geochemical Survey (Licht, 2001), was based
on 696 samples of active stream sediments representing
practically all hydrographic basins in Paraná State, from
which 39 composite samples were produced, representing the GGRN cells (Figure 6). The second Low Density
Multielemental Geochemical Survey was based on 307
samples of the soils’ horizon B (Licht & Plawiak, 2005)
representative for the whole Paraná State territory, from
which 43 samples were built representing the 43 GGRN
cells, (Figure 7).
The Hg geochemical data of both regional surveys
were obtained through Atomic Fluorescence Spectrophotometry with cold steam in the Institute of Geophysical and
Geochemical Exploration – IGGE Laboratory, Langfang,
Hebei, China.
The geochemical maps were combined with the digital terrain model (DTM) for the entire Paraná State, built
with 900,000 altitude points extracted from topographic
maps on the scale of 1:250.000 published by the Brazilian
Institute for Geography and Statistics – IBGE. The DTM
was projected with an azimuth of 345°, inclination of 45°,
light source of a horizontal angle of 135° and a vertical
angle of 45°. The coordinate system used was the UTM
with SAD 69 horizontal datum and central meridian of 51°.
To explain the mercury distribution on the surface
allowing correlations with geological settings (having the
Figure 8 geological map as a layer – MINEROPAR, 1986),
the main tectonic features(Figure 9) (such as that identified by Zalán et al., 1987) and the data obtained by the
regional and detailed surveys, a Geographical Information
System - GIS was developed. The geological cross-section
NW-SE of the Paraná Basin was used as a secondary
background information, (Figure 10) (Bizzi et al., 2001).
– 129 –
Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State, Brazil
Figure 6 – The GGRN cells, the 696 sediment samples and their watersheds (modif. Licht,2001).
Figure 7 – The GGRN cells and the 307 soil samples – B horizon (Licht and Plawiak, 2005).
– 130 –
Plawiak, R.A.B
Figure 8 – Simplified Geological Map of Paraná State (modif. MINEROPAR, 1986).
Figure 9 – The main fault zones of Paraná State (modif. Zalán et al., 1987).
– 131 –
Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State, Brazil
seems to play an important role since they coincide with
the Guaxupê and Jacutinga Fault directions (N60E).
CONCLUSIONS
Figure 10 – Schematic cross section NW-SE of the Paraná
Sedimentary Basin (Bizzi et al., 2001).
RESULTS
Several mercury anomalies are shown in the geochemical maps (regional or detail) within the Paraná
State territory.
Relatively elevated mercury contents occur in both
granulometric fractions of the samples collected in the
Palmeira region (N=17) of the Tibagi River head. The
mean content in the fraction <150# is 30 mg/kg Hg with
the highest values between 41 and 62 mg/kg Hg (Figure
11). In the fraction <230#, the mean content is 27 mg/kg
Hg, with the highest values between 29 and 67 mg/kg
Hg (Figure 12).
The mean of the significant values (higher than the
detection limit) (N=10) of the soil samples from Salto Itararé is 56 mg/kg Hg with the highest value of 80 mg/kg
Hg in the center-West portion of the sampling grid (Figure
13). The other samples (N=65) showed Hg contents lower
than the detection limit of 5 mg/kg Hg.
The mean content of the GGRN-ASS samples is 33.34
mg/kg Hg. The highest contents, between 49.47 and
53.08 mg/kg Hg, are situated in the South-East region of
Paraná State in the direction N53W, practically restricted
to the Iguaçu River valley coinciding with the Caçador
fault zone (Figure 14).
The mean mercury content in the GGRN-SOIL samples is 60.90 mg/kg Hg. The large geochemical anomaly
along the Caçador Fault zone, identified on the map after
the active stream sediments, is no longer evident due to
the overall higher background values (between 80.91
and 167.5 mg/kg Hg) (Figure 15). This regional mean
increase of Hg content is largely caused by the effect of
the mineralizing processes (Pb-Zn-Ba) that occurred in
Ribeira River valley, as identified by Daitx (pers. com. Elias
C. Daitx, 2004). High mercury values were found in the
ore of Pb-Zn (14,000 mg/kg Hg) and in the barite gangue.
In the regional geochemical surveys, the mean mercury content of the Paraná Basin igneous rocks (Serra
Geral Formation) are between 42.73 and 49.47 mg/kg
Hg in the GGRN-ASS samples and between 69.04 and
80.91 mg/kg Hg in the GGRN-SOIL. A tectonic control
The great regional geochemical structures may be
understood as the surface expression, of the interaction
of several geological and geochemical factors. Some
hypotheses must be investigated to establish the veracity
of cause-effect relationships between the geology and
the tectonic structures.
An important research field deals with the mobilization of Hg within the carbon rich horizons of the Paraná
Basin sedimentary sequence. The lithostratigraphic units
containing rocks favorable to Hg accumulation are: a)
Ponta Grossa Formation, Paraná Group; b) Siderópolis
Member, Rio Bonito Formation, Guatá Group; c) Irati
Formation, Passa Dois Group. The mercury mobilization
at relatively low temperatures (about 40°C) may occur
through remaining and residual hydrothermal activity,
along the fault zones of Caçador (NW), Guaxupé (NE)
and Jacutinga (NE), which cut deeply across these
sedimentary units.
Many thermal water springs and artesian springs
are known in the South-West of Paraná, which reinforces
the possibility of fluids migration from the Paraná Basin
deep regions, with temperatures capable of mobilizing
and transporting Hg to the surface, where the metal
would be precipitated by the sudden fall in temperature.
Bingqiu & Hui (1995) came to similar conclusions about
the presence of Hg in thermal water springs.
In the Salto do Itararé region, the Guaxupé and Jacutinga faults may be the structures responsible for the
Hg mobilization. In the Palmeira region, the geochemical
anomaly on the surface must be related to the Cândido
de Abreu/Campo Mourão fault zones intersection with the
Lancinha/Cubatão fault zones.
In the case this hypothesis is confirmed, remobilization of Hg by thermal waters from the Paraná Basin
Paleozoic sedimentary sequences along the Fault zones
are likely to occur, particularly in carbon rich horizons,
black shale deposits and coal deposits.
Finally, the cause-effect relationships between the
large anomalous areas of the Ribeira River valley and
the mineralizing processes of Pb-Zn-Ba deserves special attention, particularly considering the risk to the
population’s health in the area adjacent to the former ore
processing plant and concentrate melting process site
in Adrianópolis.
ACKNOWLEGMENTS
To the President Dr. Eduardo Salamuni and Technical
Director Rogério da Silva Felipe for the authorization to
publish data from the MINEROPAR collection.
– 132 –
Plawiak, R.A.B
Figure 11 – Geochemistry Map of the Hg in the fraction < 150# from active stream sediments of the Palmeira region
Figure 12 – Geochemistry Map of Hg in the fraction < 230 # from active stream sediments in the Palmeira region.
– 133 –
Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State, Brazil
Figure 13 – Geochemistry Map of Hg in the fraction < 150 # from soils in the Salto do Itararé region.
Figure 14 – Geochemistry map of Hg (mg/kg) in GGRN – ASS cells.
– 134 –
Plawiak, R.A.B
Figure 15 – Geochemistry map of Hg (mg/kg) in GGRN – SOIL (B horizon).
To Dr. Edilson da Silva Brabo, from the Evandro
Chagas Institute, for the mercury contents made on the
active stream sediment samples from the Palmeira region.
To Mrs. Kátia Borges and M. Antonio Carlos G. Valério
from the National Archives for the research and identification of the 19th century documents.
To Dr. Paulo Roberto Amorim dos Santos Lima for
his kindness of sending me a copy of the Diccionario
Geographico das Minas do Brazil (Ferreira, 1885) from
his private library.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BINGQIU, Z.; HUI, Y. The use of geochemical indicator
elements in the exploration for hot water sources
within geothermal fields. Journal of Geochemical
Exploration, Amsterdam, v. 55, n. 1-3, p. 125-136,
1995.
BIZZI, L.A.; SCHOBBENHAUS, C.; GONÇALVES, J.H.;
BAARS F.J.; DELGADO, I.M.; ABRAM, M.B.; LEÃO
NETO, R.; MATOS, G.M.M.; SANTOS, J.O.S. Geologia, tectônica e recursos minerais do Brasil: sistema
de informações geográficas - SIG e mapas na escala
1:2.500.000. Brasília: CPRM, 2001. 4 CD-ROMs.
FERREIRA F.I. Diccionario Geographico das Minas
do Brazil. Rio de Janeiro: Imprensa Nacional,
1885.450 p.
GOLDEN SOFTWARE, INC. Surfer - Surface Mapping
System. Golden, CO, 2002. v.. 8.
LICHT O. A. B. A Geoquímica multielementar na gestão
ambiental: identificação e caracterização de províncias geoquímicas naturais, alterações antrópicas da
paisagem, áreas favoráveis à prospecção mineral e
regiões de risco para a saúde no Estado do Paraná,
Brasil. 2001. 236 p. Tese (Doutorado em Geologia
Ambiental)-Faculdade de Geologia, Universidade
Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 2001.
LICHT O.A.B.; PLAWIAK R.A.B. Projeto Geoquímica
de Solos, Horizonte B: levantamento geoquímico
multielementar do Estado do Paraná: relatório final.
Curitiba: MINEROPAR, 2005. 2 v.
MINERAIS DO PARANÁ S.A. - MINEROPAR. Mapa
Geológico do Estado do Paraná. Curitiba, 1986. 1
mapa. Escala 1:1.400.000.
– 135 –
Mercury natural occurrences in Paraná State, Brazil
OLIVEIRA, E.P. Geologia e Recursos Mineraes do Estado
do Paraná. Rio de Janeiro: Ministério da Agricultura,
Indústria e Comércio. Serviço Geológico e Mineralógico do Brasil, 1927. 172 p.
PLAWIAK, R.A.B.; LICHT,O.A.B.; VASCONCELLOS,
E.M.G. Indícios da ocorrência natural de mercúrio
no Estado do Paraná. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO
DE GEOLOGIA, 42., 2004, Araxá, MG. Anais...
Araxá,MG: SBG. Núcleo Minas Gerais, 2004. 1 CDROM, S18:69.
ZALÁN, P.V.; WOLFF, S.; CONCEIÇÃO, J.C.J.; ASTOLFI,
M.A.M.; VIEIRA, I.S.; APPI, V.T.; ZANOTTO, O.A.
Tectônica e Sedimentação da Bacia do Paraná. In:
SIMPÓSIO SULBRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA, 3.,
1987. Atas. Curitiba : SBG. Núcleo Paraná/Santa
Catarina e Rio Grande do Sul, 1987. v.1, p. 441-477.
– 136 –
CONTAM INATION
BY ANTHROPOGENIC
M ERCURY IN SOIL AND
STREAM SEDIM ENTS
IN LAVRAS DO SUL
M UNICIPALITY – RS BRAZIL
¹Carlos Antonio Grazia, carlos.grazia@cprm.gov.br
²Maria Heloisa Degrazia Pestana, mariahdp@fepam.rs.gov.br
¹Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/PA
²State Environmental Protection Foundation - FEPAM
,
INTRODUCTION
This study is part of the Project “Anthropogenic Mercury in Streams Associated with the Auriferous Mining
in Lavras do Sul”, which is being made in partnership
with the Brazilian Geological Service – CPRM (Serviço
Geológico do Brazil) and the State Foundation for Environmental Protection – FEPAM, Rio Grande do Sul State.
This Project integrates the National Research Program
in Environmental Geochemistry and Medical Geology
(Programa Nacional de Pesquisa em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia Médica – PGAGEM), coordinated by
the CPRM.
Gold mining in the Lavras do Sul – RS auriferous
region (Figure 1) officially dates from the late 19th century. The mineralization originated through hydrothermal
processes occurs as E-W auriferous quartz veins with
Fe, Cu and/or Pb sulphides. They are surrounded by
andesites and associated volcaniclastic rocks from the
Hilário Formation and by some granite from the Lavras
do Sul intrusive complex, as described by Gastal, 1997.
The gold content in the mineralization was low, on
average 5g/t (Calógeras, 1938). Most of the ore extracted
from several region mines was processed by one of three
grinder plants in Chiapetta, Paredão and Cerro Rico,
that functioned in different periods until the early 20th
– 137 –
Figure 1 – Location of the research area.
Contamination by anthropogenic mercury in soil and stream sediments in Lavras do Sul Municipality RS – Brazil
century. Mercury was used as amalgam in the grinders,
and also by the gold diggers and, in the late 1980s, by
the Mining Company of Rio Grande do Sul (Companhia
Riograndense de Mineração -CRM). The resulting residual
Hg contamination in the neighborhood of some of these
processing units was confirmed by Pestana & Formoso
(2003) in soil samples from the CRM and Chiapetta
Grinder areas and by Pestana et al. (2000) in sediment
samples from the Cerro Rico Grinder treatment pool.
OBJECTIVES
To confirm the presence of Hg contamination in soil
near the processing units in comparison to soil from more
distant sites;
To check the dispersion degree of Hg contaminated
soil through the analyses of stream sediments;
To establish the thresholds and background mean
values for Au, Fe, Mn and other elements of environmental
interest, such as As, Cd, Cu, Hg, Pb and Zn in soils and
stream sediments over the granites and andesites;
To compare the obtained thresholds with current
Brazilian guidelines (CONAMA and CETESB).
METHODOLOGY
Eight soil samples over andesitic rocks were collected: one adjacent to the CRM processing area, another
near the Cerro Rico processing unit and six samples from
sites far from the processing plants. In the granite areas,
three samples were collected from: i) inside the Chiapetta
Grinder processing area; ii) outside the same location
and iii) a reference non-contaminated soil, far from the
processing area. 24 stream sediments were collected
in streams draining granite rocks and 19 over andesitic
drainage areas.
The soil samples belong to the A horizon. They were
sieved with PVC sieves and nylon grid by wet process for
the fraction <230 mesh, and subsequently dried at ambient temperature. The stream sediments were also dried
at ambient temperature before being disaggregated by a
quartz mortar and separated in the fractions <120 mesh
with PVC sieves and nylon grid. The granulometric fractions <230 mesh and <120 mesh of the soil and stream
sediment samples, respectively, were treated with an
aqueous solution (6ml / 1g of sample), at 95°C during
one hour to test for 51 elements by ICP-MS at the ACME
Laboratories (Canada). The As, Au, Cd, Cu, Fe, Hg, Mn,
Pb and Zn concentrations were evaluated in this study.
Within the sample collection, a blank sample previously
certified for Hg (NIST-8407) was included, the result of
which showed an analytical error < 7%.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Soils
The element concentration values in analyzed soil
samples from sites distant from the gold processing areas
were extracted from Grazia & Pestana (2005a) as shown
in Table 1. The 5 soil samples’ mean concentration values
(VM) in andesitic terrains and the values referring to a
sample taken over granite rocks were used as a reference to calculate the sample contamination rates from
the processing areas.
The comparison of the andesitic terrains soil VM
(mean values) with the reference soil values, according
to CETESB (2001), described below Table 1, showed
naturally elevated backgrounds for As, Cu and Pb in
Table 1 - Element concentration in non-contaminated soil from andesitic and granite areas (fraction < 230 mesh)
Sample
Rocha
As (µg/g)
Au (ng/g) Cd (µg/g)
Cu (µg/g)
Fe (%)
Hg (ng/g)
Mn (µg/g)
Pb (µg/g)
Zn (µg/g)
2
Andesito
23.10
35.7
0.03
57
1.91
39
384
29.40
44.6
3
Andesito
13.70
40.9
0.03
108.2
4.16
44
901
26.30
74.7
4
Vulcanoclástica
10.20
11.3
0.04
11
2.62
57
334
24.10
60.5
5
Andesito
6.10
6.1
0.06
62.70
3.23
25
369
13.20
46
6
Andesito
8.50
3.9
0.04
33.90
2.09
16
410
12.10
48.9
11
Andesito
8.70
26.5
0.09
60.90
2.71
58
350
32.70
57.2
8
Granito
8.20
6
0.03
10.30
1.84
54
131
18.90
38.7
Andesito
12.30
19.6
0.04
54.60
2.8
36.2
480
21,00
54.9
Reference Value
3.50
nr
<0.5
35
nr
50
nr
17
60
Alert Value
15
nr
3
60
nr
500
nr
100
300
VM
> or = the alert value
> or = the reference value
The VM was calculated with samples 2 and 6. Sample 11 was excluded from the calculation, since it was taken from a sulfide quartz vein.
1
nr= element without reference according to CETESB (2001).
Reference soil values in total samples from CETESB (2001)
– 138 –
Carlos Antonio Grazia
Table 2 - Element concentration in soil located next to the gold processing plant and their respective contamination rates
(fraction < 230 mesh)
Sample
Geologic background
As (µg/g)
Au (ng/g)
Cd (µg/g)
Cu (µg/g)
Fe (%)
Hg (ng/g)
Mn (µg/g)
Pb
(µg/g)
Zn
(µg/g)
7
Andesite CRM
24.5
(2)
688
(35)
0.20
(6.8)
270
(4.9)
3.03
(1.1)
18508
(511)
626
(1.3)
79
(3.8)
113
(2.0)
Granite within Chiapetta
127
(15)
13173
(2195)
1.34
(44)
270
(26)
4.86
(2.7)
43497
(805)
418
(3.2)
1465
(77)
661
(17)
Granite outside Chiapetta
59.3
(7.23)
2870
(478)
1.63
(54)
124
(12)
2.84
(1.5)
11021
(219)
566
(4.3)
1100
(58)
500
(13)
Andesite Cerro Rico
163
(13.2)
1533
(78)
0.29
(7.2)
1469
(27)
5.68
(2)
10379
(287)
1029
(2.1)
719
(13)
250
(4.5)
Reference Value
3.5
nr
<0.5
35
nr
50
nr
17
60
9
10
12
1
Alert Value
15
nr
3
60
nr
500
nr
100
300
1
Agricultural Intervention Value
25
nr
10
100
nr
2500
nr
200
500
1Residential Intervention Value
50
nr
15
500
nr
5000
nr
350
1000
1
or = the reference value
1
> or = the alert value
> or = the agricultural intervention value
Reference soil values in total samples from CETESB (2001 – contamination rates ( ); nr= element without reference according to CETESB (2001)
this volcanic areas. The reference values also exceeded
those for As, Hg and Pb in the sample 08 (taken over
granite areas).
The soil sample element concentrations obtained
in the ore processing areas, as well as their respective
contamination rates are found in Table 2. These rates were
calculated as the quotient between the sample concentration and the respective mean value (VM) from Table 1,
which, for granites, refer to the sample 08 value. In Table
2 the reference values were also included, according to
CETESB (2001), except for those of industrial intervention.
Considering the soil’s multi-functionality in environmental management, the use of intervention values as
an agricultural use reference in this evaluation is more
suitable, as these are more restrictive than those for residential use. Furthermore, the sampled sites are situated
in a predominantly rural area.
Hg showed the highest contamination rates, followed
by Pb, Cu and As. The most Hg and Au contaminated
soils were sampled inside the Chiapetta ore processing
plant and in the CRM area, showing a clear association
with losses in the amalgam processes. The most As, Cd,
Pb and Zn contaminated samples were those from the
Chiapetta ore processing plant (inside and outside) and
the most Cu contaminated samples, from the Cerro Rico
ore processing plant. The elements Fe and Mn, with weak
or no association with the sulfide mineralization presented
the lowest contamination rates.
The comparison of contaminated soil data with the
reference values adopted by CETESB (2001) showed
the Hg and Cu concentrations exceeded the respective
intervention values for agricultural use soil in 100% of the
samples and 75% of the As and Pb indicating a potential risk to human health. Zn exceeded the agricultural
intervention value in 50% of the samples from the ore
processing areas, more specifically in both samples collected in the Chiapetta ore processing plant. However, it
must be noted the element concentrations analyzed for
the Lavras do Sul soil were determined in the silt-clay
fraction, whereas the CETESB (2001) report does not
specify the granulometric fraction, which suggests these
were total samples.
Recently CETESB published on November 23rd 2005
in the internet, new guidelines Nº 195-2005, which reviews
the reference values of 2001. According to the new values, the Chiapetta ore processing plant contaminated
soil would be also exceeding the prevention value for Cd
(1.3 g/g), which is more restrictive than the previous alert
value (3.0 g/g). However, regarding Hg, the new decision
is much more permissive, as the residential intervention
values passed from 5,000 g/g in 2001 to 36,000 g/g in
2005, and the agricultural intervention values, from 2,500
g/g to 12,000 g/g respectively. Therefore, only the samples
collected inside the Chiapetta and CRM ore processing
plant areas would remain in the same category. The others, in respect of Hg concentrations, would be classified
as above the prevention value, which in this case, coincides with the former alert value. For the other analyzed
elements there would be no alterations to the evaluation
in Tables 1 and 2. In this study we will continue to adopt
the orienting values of 2001 since we have no knowledge
of the technical basis that lead to the 2005 alterations.
– 139 –
Contamination by anthropogenic mercury in soil and stream sediments in Lavras do Sul Municipality RS – Brazil
STREAM SEDMENTS
The analytical data interpretation of the stream sediments consisted of basic statistical treatment (software
NCSS Statistical System for Windows) that established
statistical parameters for each element, such as the
mean background values, its standard deviations and
the thresholds values (upper limit of the background
boundary).
Considering the limitations of the methodology used
to prepare and extract the samples, the environmental
evaluation was made based on the recently implemented
CONAMA Resolution Nº 344/2004 (abbreviate to RC)
that establishes two quality levels for material dredged in
Brazilian territorial water. These are: level 1, below which a
low probability of adverse effects to the biota is expected;
level 2, above which a probable adverse effect to the biota
is expected. However, the subaqueous sediments with
As, Cd, Hg or Pb concentrations above level 1, must be
submitted to ecotoxicological tests (Art. 7 of the same RC).
The analyzed element concentrations, the background zone mean values and its thresholds were calculated for the stream sediment samples from the granite
and andesitic areas. They are shown in Tables 3 and 4,
respectively, together with the RC level 1 and 2 values.
Thresholds above level 1 were found for As in the granite
area sediments, and for As, Cu and Pb, in the andesitic
area. These observations are in agreement with the naturally elevated background values, confirmed for the three
elements, in the volcanic lithology soil. In the latter, the
threshold of 31 g/g As for stream sediments exceeded
even the RC level 2.
In isolated samples, the RC level 2 is exceeded for
Cu in the andesitic area sample 27 and for As and Cu in
Table 3 - Element concentration in stream sediments over granite areas Fraction < 120 mesh
Sample
UTM N
UTM L
As (µg/g)
Au (ng/g)
Cd (µg/g)
Cu (µg/g)
Fe (%)
Hg (ng/g)
Mn (µg/g)
OC-01
6594158
225352
7.8
7
0.04
25.11
1.84
20
404
Pb (µg/g) Zn (µg/g)
20.47
32
OC-02
6592775
225263
7.2
8.8
0.03
23.06
1.67
19
321
12.53
35.4
OC-03
6594516
224244
16.2
40.7
0.04
56.18
2.09
195
331
68.59
39.2
OC-04
6585911
225975
4.9
85.3
0.04
7.67
1.39
38
270
21.07
30
OC-05
6585591
226953
5.4
4.7
0.05
5.59
1.11
40
151
22.44
32.2
OC-06
6585477
227337
3.7
36.2
0.03
5.16
0.78
39
169
14.06
22.2
OC-07
6596230
221950
3.7
7.2
0.04
11.85
1.94
13
563
17.57
39.3
OC-10
6584020
228044
48.1
5518.2
0.16
306.27
2.33
112
455
57.39
62
OC-15
6585317
224966
5.8
6
0.02
8.47
1.44
25
229
15.3
32.2
OC-18
6585720
224663
2.2
17.4
0.01
3.16
0.65
13
105
7.94
12.9
OC-19
6584948
219677
3.3
107.8
0.02
5.99
1.5
21
191
16.18
38.4
OC-20
6586709
224088
9.9
47.9
0.12
16.71
1.89
145
807
32.69
65.7
OC-21
6584989
222577
3.1
13.8
0.02
2.85
0.85
17
189
9.67
18.4
OC-32
6592436
228758
12.7
77.3
0.05
27.34
1.94
31
415
21.55
36.5
OC-34
6590920
228193
13.7
18.8
0.06
37.03
2.27
31
483
28.7
47
OC-35
6587961
223424
9.4
92.3
0.03
3.56
1.03
72
318
19.27
20.9
OC-36
6587482
220938
4.3
140.8
0.03
6.64
0.92
42
202
30.78
32
OC-37
6586794
220119
4
63.4
0.03
3.51
1.03
24
235
17.28
25.6
OC-38
6586622
220269
3.2
51.7
0.04
9.84
1.45
19
737
13.23
33.1
OC-39
6588862
218307
3
34.7
0.03
4.26
0.89
20
250
15.13
20.9
OC-40
6589096
218428
2.7
14
0.04
4.89
0.85
22
103
15.7
42
OC-41
6588172
222058
3.5
6.5
0.02
2.12
0.66
19
124
8.26
11.6
OC-42
6587523
224320
6.1
15.3
0.02
4.89
1.11
48
222
12.79
23.5
OC-43
6584672
217343
Mean background value1
5.3
6
0.03
3.77
1.2
27
581
14.1
18.3
6.13
28.1
0.03
10
1.3
28
286
17.5
30.6
Threshold1
12
35
0.05
24
2
56
572
31
56
CONAMA2 Level 1
5.9
nr
0.6
35.7
nr
170
nr
35
123
CONAMA2 Level 2
17
nr
3.5
197
nr
486
nr
91.3
315
1
This Study - Resolution Nº 344/04 – The resolution CONAMA Nº 344/04 refers only to the elements As, Cd, Cu, Hg, Ni (not assessed in this study)
Pb and Zn nr = not referenced by CONAMA
– 140 –
Carlos Antonio Grazia
Table 4 - Element Concentration in stream sediments over andesitic areas. Fraction < 120 mesh
Sample
UTM N
UTM L
Cu (µg/g)
Fe (%)
OC-08
6584931
229021
As (µg/g) Au (ng/g) Cd (µg/g)
5
28.5
0.03
8.75
1.04
Hg (ng/g) Mn (µg/g) Pb (µg/g)
63
322
16.13
Zn (µg/g)
27
OC-09
6584504
228739
19.8
6.4
0.06
40.24
2.59
18
444
25.13
64.8
OC-11
6585068
232706
8.1
30.3
0.07
17.08
1.85
62
614
22.89
49.5
OC-12
6584941
232789
14.8
11
0.08
26.84
3.83
24
1119
16.6
64.6
OC-13
6585932
234374
21.1
13.5
0.1
19.46
3.25
27
731
20.73
70.3
OC-14
6586710
236173
24.6
7.5
0.13
20.5
2.84
92
951
27.62
79
OC-16
6586455
232551
24
22.9
0.22
28.09
2.55
64
845
134.14
104.8
OC-17
6589066
234283
22.4
1.4
0.07
18.66
3.16
89
929
36.92
80.9
OC-22
6585425
231162
17.4
37.5
0.07
65.53
3.32
46
1039
28.58
71.7
OC-23
6585169
231050
7
12.5
0.04
19.05
1.64
55
465
18.45
42.2
OC-24
6586142
230366
16.9
5.9
0.07
59.72
3.72
50
1012
29.94
80.3
OC-25
6585819
230231
23.3
11
0.05
119.11
4.6
41
1152
29.86
73.6
OC-26
6589451
231218
73.9
1.6
0.08
41.53
3.24
82
914
44.54
66.5
OC-27
6589303
230534
50.6
2760.9
0.09
238.23
3.96
958
1165
94.52
76.3
OC-28
6589482
230360
29.4
9
0.06
49.76
2.72
61
723
30.62
54.6
OC-29
6593372
231887
21.8
10.6
0.08
33.08
2.52
77
1393
22.56
47.7
OC-30
6592326
231879
12.5
1.4
0.04
32.23
2.59
37
634
18.59
51.7
OC-31
6593355
230599
12.4
320.6
0.05
35.63
2.29
34
695
25.02
55.1
OC-33
6592090
228972
17.9
4.5
0.09
37.28
3.13
38
876
27.71
55.5
Mean background value1
6.13
28.1
0.03
10
1.3
28
286
17.5
30.6
Threshold1
12
35
0.05
24
2
56
572
31
56
CONAMA2 Level 1
5.9
nr
0.6
35.7
nr
170
nr
35
123
CONAMA2 Level 2
17
nr
3.5
197
nr
486
nr
91.3
315
This Study - Resolution Nº 344/04 – The resolution CONAMA Nº 344/04 refers only to the elements As, Cd, Cu, Hg, Ni (not assessed in this study)
Pb and Zn nr = not referenced by CONAMA.
1
the granite area sample 10. In the former, the As, Hg and
Pb concentrations also exceeded the respective level 2
values. In this sample, the Hg concentration (958 g/g) is of
anthropogenic origin, due to the Cerro Rico ore processing plant proximity, situated upstream. This explains its
elevated value, the only one higher than the RC level 2 for
Hg. However, a natural Hg contribution is also possible, as
the sediment sample speciation analysis from the water
reservoir used by the Cerro Rico ore processing plant
(Pestana et al., 2000) showed a higher percentage Hg
sulfide than metallic Hg. In addition, Toniolo et al. (2005)
mention the occurrence of cinnabar (Figure 2) sampled
East of sample 27, in the same geological context.
In sample 10, the elevated As, Au, Cu and Pb
concentrations, the latter superior to the RC level 1 are
explained by the Valdo Teixeira mine proximity. Also the
concentrations higher than the thresholds for Cd, Fe, Hg
and Zn suggest stream sediment contamination by wastes
from the same mine.
The 195 g/g Hg concentration of sample 03 (granite
area), superior to the threshold and to the RC level 1 for
this element, is probably related to the area mineralizations, since not only Hg but also the Au, Fe, As, Cu and
Pb concentrations in that sample exceeded the respective
thresholds. The concentrations of the last three elements
also being higher than the RC level 1. This sample, however, seems not to have contributions from mining wastes
because it is far from the mined areas to the South and
because the Au content is not as high as areas with known
mining wastes.
Finally, granitic area sample 20 with 145 g/g Hg
and values superior to the thresholds for Cd, Pb and Zn,
represents a mixture of anthropogenic contaminations,
both by mining processing and urban wastes, due to its
situation downstream from the Chiapetta ore processing
plant and the Lavras do Sul urban area.
The Hg concentrations in soil and stream sediments
found in Lavras do Sul are summarized on the Mercury
Distribution Map (Figure 3). Mercury was chosen because
this is a high potential toxicity element for human health
and its concentrations showed major anthropogenic enrichment in soil samples.
– 141 –
Contamination by anthropogenic mercury in soil and stream sediments in Lavras do Sul Municipality RS – Brazil
Figure 2 – Electronic Microscope detail of a Cinnabar grain.
Figure 3 exhibits the connection between granites
and andesites (Porcher & Lopes, 2000) and the obtained
results correlation when the old gold mines and processing plant locations are added. Furthermore Figure 3
highlights the Hg concentration values, according to this
study’s criteria and these infer high concentration dispersion levels in contaminated soil relative to the nearby
stream sediments. These results, the data evaluation
compared to the orienting values (alert and agricultural
intervention) for soil (CETESB, 2001) as well as the nearby
stream dispersion degrees are summarized in Table 5.
Table 5 - Classification of soil contamination according to
CETESB 2001 reference values and Hg dispersion degree in
nearby drainages.
Location
Alert
Intervention
Hg Diapersion in drainages
CRM
As
Hg
No dispersion
Chiapetta
Cu e Zn
As, Hg e Pb
Discret dispersion
Chiapetta
Cu e Zn
As, Hg e Pb
Discret dispersion
Cerro Rico
none
As, Cu, Hg e Pb
Notable dispersion
CONCLUSION
Soils
Background values naturally elevated for As (12.3
µg/g), Cu (54.6 µg/g) and Pb (21.0 µg/g) were found in
soil samples over andesitic terrains
The highest enrichment factors relate to Hg in the
Chiapetta ore processing plant internal area and the
CRM area.
Soil close to the three processing sites CRM, Chiapetta and Cerro Rico, are anthropogenically contaminated
by As, Cu, Hg, Pb and Zn.
According to CETESB (2001) the contamination
impacted: i) Cu and Hg agricultural intervention values
in the three processing sites, As and Pb in the Chia-
petta and Cerro Rico ore processing plants and Zn in
the Chiapetta area; ii) Residential intervention values
for Hg in the three processing sites, As and Pb in the
Chiapetta and Cerro Rico ore processing plant and Cu
only inside the Chiapetta area; iii) Alert value for As in
the CRM area.
Stream sediments
The andesitic stream sediments presented elevated
thresholds for As (31 µg/g), Cu (66 µg/g) and Pb (40 µg/g)
and compared to the RC, exceeded level 1 for Cu and
Pb, and even level 2 for As;
The Hg thresholds inferior to the RC level 1in granite
(50 g/g) and andesitic (88 g/g) stream sediments, highlight the Hg concentration of 958 g/g, superior to the RC
level 2 found in stream sediment downstream from the
Cerro Rico ore processing plant;
Three types of anthropogenic contamination were
indicated: a) ore processing, downstream from the Cerro
Rico ore processing plant; b) ore front, downstream from
the Valdo Teixeira mine; and c) a mixture of mine processing and urban effluents, downstream from Chiapetta plant
and the Lavras do Sul urban area;
Natural contamination associated with probable
mineralization was identified with 195 g/g Hg, in the NorthEastern part of the granite area;
High dispersion of Hg contamination from the soil to
stream sediments became evident for the Cerro Rico ore
processing plant only
RECOMMENDATIONS
1) Soil remediation for areas close to the processing
sites, due to contamination levels exceeding those of
intervention for Hg and/or As, Pb and Cu, representing a
potential risk to human health;
2) Detailed evaluation of the confirmed contamination
levels, including risk analyses and surveys within those
– 142 –
– 143 –
Carlos Antonio Grazia
Figure 3 – Hg Content Distribution Map.
Contamination by anthropogenic mercury in soil and stream sediments in Lavras do Sul Municipality RS – Brazil
populations potentially more exposed to contamination
by these elements.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
To the mining technician Odilon Corrêa, to the prospector Floro de Menezes Filho and to the Cartographic
Engineering student Álvaro Belotto Perini, for their collaboration in the field and office work.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BRASIL. Ministério do Meio Ambiente. Resolução CONAMA nº 344/2004. Brasília, 2004
CALOGERAS, P. As minas do Brasil e sua legislação:
geologia econômica do Brasil. 2.ed. São Paulo:
Companhia Editora Nacional, 1938. Tomo 3. 507 p.
(Biblioteca Pedagógica Brasileira, v. 134).
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA DE SANEAMENTO AMBIENTAL - CETESB. Relatório de Estabelecimento
de Valores Orientadores para Solos e Águas Subterrâneas . São Paulo, 2001. 245 p.
COMPANHIA DE TECNOLOGIA DE SANEAMENTO AMBIENYAL - CETESB. Decisão de Diretoria No 1952005. Disponível em: <http://www.cetesb.sp.gov.
br.> Acesso em: agosto 2006.
GRAZIA, C. A.; PESTANA, M. H. D. Mercury contaminated
soils in gold mining areas of Lavras do Sul, RS, Brazil. In: INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF HEAVY
METALS IN THE ENVIRONMENT, 13., 2005, Rio de
Janeiro. Abstracts. Rio de Janeiro : CETEM, 2005. 1
CD-ROM, p. 504-507 Contaminated Sites.
GRAZIA, C.A.; PESTANA, M.H.D. Contaminações por
mercúrio antrópico em solos e sedimentos de corrente de Lavras do Sul, RS, Brasil. In: WORKSHOP
INTERNACIONAL DE GEOLOGIA MÉDICA, 2., 2005,
Rio de Janeiro. Relação de painéis, palestras e minicurso internacional... Rio de Janeiro : CPRM, 2005.
1 CD-ROM, painel 7/7.
PESTANA, M.H.D.; LECHLER, P.; FORMOSO, M.L.L.;
MILLER, J. Mercury in sediments from gold and
copper exploitation areas in the Camaquã River
Basin, southern Brazil. Journal of South American
Earth Sciences, n. 13, p. 537-547, 2000.
PESTANA, M.H.D.; FORMOSO, M.L.L. Mercury contamination in Lavras do Sul, south Brazil: a legacy from
past and recent gold mining. The Science of the Total
Environment, n. 305, p.125-140, 2003.
PORCHER, C.A.; LOPES, R. da C. Folha SH.22-Y-A –
Cachoeira do Sul, Estado do Rio Grande do Sul,
escala 1: 250.000 : Programa de Levantamentos
Geológicos Básicos do Brasil. Rio de Janeiro :
CPRM, 2000. 1 CD-ROM.
TONIOLO, J.A.; GIL, C.A.A.; SANDER, A.; DIAS, A.
de A.; REMUS, M.V.D. Modelos exploratórios
de metais-base e preciosos na Bacia do Camaquã: síntese e avanços no conhecimento :
parte I Histórico. In: SIMPÓSIO BRASILEIRO DE
METALOGENIA, 1., 2005, Gramado. Resumos
expandidos. Gramado: CPGq-IG/ UFRGS, 2005.
1 CD-Rom.
– 144 –
RADIOELEM ENTS IM PACT
ON THE ENVIRONM ENT,
AGRICULTURE AND PUBLIC
HEALTH IN LAGOA REAL,
BAHIA STATE BRAZIL
José Erasmo de Oliveira; erasmo@sa.cprm.gov.br
Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/SA
IINTRODUCTION
This study integrates the National
Research Program of Environmental Geochemistry and Medical Geology (Programa
Nacional de Pesquisa em Geoquímica
Ambiental e Geologia Médica – PGAGEM),
developed by CPRM in partnership with
universities and other governmental institutions. The studied area is situated in the
center-South region of Bahia State, between latitudes 13°45’30” and 14°07’30”S
and longitudes 42°07’30” and 42°22’30”W.
Gr, in Lagoa Real and covers 1,126km²
(Figure 1).
The region is known as the Lagoa
Real Uraniferous Province. Mining exploration carried out by the Brazilian Nuclear
Industry - INB (Indústrias Nucleares do
Brasil S.A.) started in 2000 as a miningindustrial business, initiated to promote
the exploration and production of U3O8 in
reserves estimated as 100 thousand tons.
The extracted uranium ore is first
crushed and then subjected to a lixiviation
process in piles (static), where the material is irrigated with a sulfuric acid solution
Figure 1 – Location of the Lagoa Real Project area.
– 145 –
Radioelements impact on the environment, agriculture and public health in Lagoa Real, Bahia State Brazil
to remove the uranium. The uranium concentration is
made by an organic solvents extraction process, followed by separation through precipitation, drying and
conditioning to produce the concentrate (yellow cake).
This is stored in special drums made to the specifications established by the National Commission for Nuclear
Energy (Comissão Nacional de Energia Nuclear – CNEN
– www.inb.gov.br). The yellow cake (ammonium diuranate) is transported to Salvador (Bahia State – BA) by
road. This material needs to be transformed into uranium
hexafluoride gas and enriched in Germany, Netherlands
or England, to be used in Brazil as a nuclear fuel in the
Angra I and II Power Plants.
INB seeks to guarantee the implementation of control operations and remediation of eventual environmental impacts. In the case of the workers, each one receives
a badge with a dosimeter that measures the radiation
dose he is receiving. With regard to the environment,
air, soil, rain and ground water, animals and plants are
monitored. INB maintains frequent contact with CNEN,
IBAMA and the Environmental Resources Center (CRA)
of the Bahia State Government.
This study aims to identify environmental problems
that may be correlated with public health, especially
those related to uranium exposure, as well as to small
watersheds management and, with geochemical data
and parameters, to monitor Lagoa Real Uraniferous
Province programs.
GEOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT
The Lagoa Real Uraniferous Province is situated in
the center-South portion of the São Francisco Craton
in the orthogneisses belonging to an intrusive suite
along the Paramirim shear belt. These Mesoproterozoic
gneisses present cataclastic zones which were metasomatized to albite-oligoclase and sometimes to uranium.
The mineralization control is mainly due to tectonics with
a preferential distribution along the lineation. Uranite is
the principal ore, followed by pitchblende dispersed
in the mafic layers.
The mineralized extensions vary between a couple
to hundreds of meters long, whereas the thickness varies between a few centimeters and tens of meters; a
depth continuity reaching almost 700m was confirmed
with soundings
The secondary uranium minerals (Uranophane and
autunite) are restricted to the weathered zones, conditioned mainly by the fracture system. In the region there
is a predominance of morphogenetic processes associated with chemical weathering and fluvial erosion.
The widespread uranium abundance in mineralized
zones and this element’s increased dispersion in the
environment activities like mining can lead to toxicity
problems. In these cases, knowledge of geochemical
processes is important to understand the migration
paths and uranium exposure routes regarding plants,
animals and human populations.
Even outside the mining area, natural uranium
contents in water and soil can be toxic and cause
adverse effects to human health. Over the last five
years, INB has built wells to meet the demands of the
mining activities and the local population and to avoid
the consumption of surface water. Unfortunately the
geochemical characteristics of these aquifers have not
been considered and, though the soil and aquifer sediments are not mineralized, the concentrations of this
element are elevated enough to cause serious health
problems, as is the case at the Fazenda Juazeiro.
Radon 222 is a natural gas formed during the radioactive transformation of uranium in lead. Although
it has a very short mean life, of only 3.8 days, being a
gas it is very mobile and thus, easily inhaled in closed
environments and likely to provoke lung cancer. 222Ra
limits are part of the INB environmental impact control
and remediation operations.
AGRICULTURE AND GEOCHEMISTRY
The region’s water use is mainly for domestic
animal consumption and irrigation. The United States
Salinity Laboratory – U.S.S.L. (1954) established 16
classifications of water for agriculture uses based on
the RAS index and electrical conductivity. 5 classes
were identified for this region (Figure 2 and Table 1).
The area’s agricultural production is restricted to
pineapple, sugar-cane, beans, castor bean and sorghum crops. Banana, persimmon, orange and mango
are cultivated as permanent crops.
In the region’s podzolic soil, plant roots usually
have a certain difficulty to breach the horizon A. This
phenomenon naturally makes the cultures very sensitive
to droughts and the phreatic water becomes useless.
This could partly explain the relative enrichment of
some ions in the A horizon (Figure 2). Regarding uranium there is the possibility of toxicity but the effects
related to phytotoxicity have not been studied yet.
The lack of water in the region restrains the systematic application of surface water geochemistry.
GEOCHEMISTRY AND PUBLIC HEALTH
Geochemistry in its strict sense is the study of the
chemical composition of the Earth and, on a first approach, there seems to be little connection between the
material composition and human health. However, there
are 92 of the different types of geological chemical elements naturally found on the earth’s surface. About 25
of these elements are either essential or toxic to animal
and vegetable life. For human beings Ca, Cl, Mg, P, K,
– 146 –
José Erasmo de Oliveira
Source: Figure adapted from the United States Department for Agriculture, manual 60 1954.
Figure 2 – Classification scheme for irrigation waters.
Table 1 - Classification for irrigation water in the area of the PGAGEM Lagoa Real
Class
Frequency
Salinity
Na content
Irrigation
C1-S1
1
low
low
Suitable for most of the soul types and
crops
Within potabilty limits
C2-S1
17
medium
low
Suitable only at well drainned soils and salt
tolerant crops
Some contents above potability standards
(chloride, total dissolved soil, etc)
C3-S1
8
high
low
C3-S2
4
high
medium
Not suitable
– 147 –
Potability
Radioelements impact on the environment, agriculture and public health in Lagoa Real, Bahia State Brazil
Na, S and H are essential as macro-nutrients and Co,
Cr, Cu, F, I, Fe, Mn, Mo, Se, V and Zn as micro-nutrients.
Some elements have no or limited biological function
and are generally toxic: As, Cd, Pb, Hg and Al. These
include also the radioactive element uranium.
Uranium is carcinogenic and lethal. Water contamination can be considered the most serious impact
associated with the mineral extraction and uranium ore
processing. The effluent quality parameters can be altered in many ways, especially by chemical substances
added during the ore processing.
In Lagoa Real, between April 20th and 23rd 2000,
there was a 5,000m³ leak of an uraniferous effluent into
the treatment basin from the acid lixiviation of the ore pile
by sulfuric acid. The leak neither reached the aquifer, nor
the rivers and no company employee was contaminated.
However it is difficult to estimate the extent of the leakage
and how much soil was contaminated.
Drinking water contamination by uranium mining
sites has occurred at other sites around the world. The
most recent occurred in March 2001 when the Ranger
uranium mine (Australia) was closed down due to water contamination. Ranger workers drank and bathed
in water contaminated with uranium ore, with levels
exceeding 400 times the country’s maximum security
standard. As a result 28 workers became sick. The
Australian Energy Resources Company (ERA) temporarily suspended its operations to make improvements
to the mine’s security. The mine has had a troubled
history with 120 leakages, spillages and operational
errors since opening in 1981. The workers suffered
from headaches, nauseas, sickness and skin irritations as a result of the incident. Those affected by the
contamination needed to submit to blood checks to
control the exposure.
In Lagoa Real the studies do not show a clear
relationship between uranium radiation and cancer.
Between 1999 (uranium mineralization pre-operational
stage) and 2002 (Cachoeira uranium mine operating),
the DATASUS Information System for mortality through
neoplasias (tumors) registers only eight cases (www.
datasus.gov.br).
ter samples were collected from tubular wells, 32 soil
samples, 30 rock outcrop samples from the tubular
wells proximity and 42 stream sediment samples in the
granulometric fractions < 230 mesh (silt and clay), seeking to quantify the geochemical baselines, focused on
environmental monitoring.
The soil samples, important for monitoring radioactive elements, were stored in 50ml graduated polyethylene tubes, after being filtered in 0.45mm microporous
filter, for the cations analysis. To preserve the soluble
cations in the samples, 1ml of HNO3 1:1 was added,
maintaining the pH<2. For the physical-chemical parameters analyses, two liters of the water sample remained
refrigerated until analyzed.
The stream sediment, soil and rock samples chemical analyses by ICP-MS were made at the Acme Analytical Laboratories, in Canada, for a protocol of 51 elements
(Ag, Al, As, Au, B, Ba, Be, Bi, Ca, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs,
Cu, Fe, Ga, Ge, Hf, Hg, In, K, La, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na,
Nd, Ni, P, Pb, Rb, Re, S, Sb, Sc, Se, Sn, Sr, Ta, Te, Th,
Ti, Tl, U, V, W, Y, Zn and Zr).
To determine the 72 elements in the tubular well
water samples, 21 elements were added to the above
mentioned package (Br, Cl, Dy, Er, Eu, Gd, Ho, Ir, Lu, Nd,
Os, Pd, Pr, Pt, Rb, Ru, Si, Sm, Tb, Tm and Yb). These
chemical analyses were also made at the Acme laboratory by ICP-MS. The physical-chemical parameters
were defined by the National Department for Drought
Relief Work (Departamento Nacional de Obras Contra
as Secas – DNOCS).
The individual and mean analytical data on the soil,
rock and sediment samples were standardized according to Clarke’s values, an important parameter to define
the geochemical and environment signatures.
For the water chemical analyses, values published
by Levinson (1980) for natural water (ppb) were used.
The levels considered dangerous for living beings,
the class II river limits were used, from Resolution nº
357/2005 of the National Environmental Council ( Conselho Nacional do Meio Ambiente) – CONAMA,.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Based on the concentrations and dispersions in the
studied area of the 51 chemical elements analyzed at
the rock-soil-water and stream sediment interface, it was
hypothetically estimated that about 10% of the elements,
on average, remain in the primary environment (rock). Of
the 90% of the elements from the primary to secondary
environments, approximately 54% remain in the soil matrix
and 36% are dispersed in the drainage network (stream
sediment). Less than 0.1% of the chemical elements are
solubilized. This panorama will probably be modified
after the inclusion of the vegetable-animal-man cycle in
the system.
This study carried out a low density multi-elemental
geochemical survey, allowing the results to be used
for several purposes. This model is based on the standardizations of the International Geochemical Mapping
– IGCP (Danrley et al., 1995) and Foregs Geochemical
Mapping (Salminen et al., 1998).
To establish the geochemical model base, different
migration paths were assumed together with the chemical element concentrations at the soil-water-rock-stream
sediment interface (Figure 3). A total of 32 groundwa-
RESULTS
– 148 –
José Erasmo de Oliveira
Figure 3 – Schematical representation of a podzolic soil profile, showing the main horizons and the sampling points.
Uranium arose as one of the ten enriched elements
when comparing the mean content on the earth’s crust
(xi/c>1) with the stream sediments, soil and rock. In this
aspect 10 elements stand out: Se (13.78x), Bi (5.50x),
Ce (4.61x), La (4.48x), Th (2.84x), Y (2.42x), Mo (1.82x),
U (1.43x), Pb (1.28x) and Sn (1.14x). The remaining 41
analyzed elements were considered impoverished (xi/
c<1) or depleted (Figure 4).
In the rock samples the outliers to the mineralized
zone were avoided. The lithotype enrichment is geographically restricted, with a mean equal to 1.920ppm
U, slightly depleted (0.83x).
The predominance of morphogenetic processes in
the region associated with the chemical weathering and
with the fluvial erosion, favors the high mean contents of
4.480ppm U and 3.480ppm U, equivalent to an enrichment of 1.94x and 1.51x in soil and stream sediment,
respectively.
For uranium, a distribution pattern associated with
the Th and ETRL (La and Ce) was registered, with a geochemical behavior characterized by the abundance of the
HFS (High Field Strength), according to Oliveira (2004).
Eight groundwater wells stand out due to radioactive
element pollution (uranium). All the other 71 analyzed
elements do not present, a priori, significant importance
to the radioactive pollution of the aquifers. The water
contamination risk by radiation was defined by the
probability of the well’s contamination level exceeding
the CONAMA (2005) quality standards for human consumption water supplies after conventional treatment
(0.02 mg/L U).
The conversion from risk into threat of soil and rock
contamination (dust) was 3.0 ppmU. Based on the obtained results, target-areas were selected for later studies,
in a detail scale.
Selected target-areas
Three target-areas were selected for detailed study
projects with human and environmental monitoring, in
partnership with health professionals (Figure 5).
The first, the INB mining-industrial complex of Lagoa
Real situated in area nº1 (12 km²). The Cachoeira mining
company, operating since 2000, has reserves superior to
20,400 t U3O8 and an annual production estimated in 300t
of yellow cake. The permanent control/monitoring of the
environment and employees are recommended.
For the two other selected study areas, environmental monitoring and programs related to public health, if
– 149 –
Radioelements impact on the environment, agriculture and public health in Lagoa Real, Bahia State Brazil
Figure 4 – Geochemical signatures in stream sediments, soil and rock.
necessary are recommended. Area nº2 was delimited
within the region of Fazenda Juazeiro, which has elevated uranium contents in the groundwater (85ppb
U and 93ppb U) and includes the Engenho deposit,
sampling site of the soil sample with 8.3ppm U and with
a total reserve estimated in 27,600 t of U3O8. Area nº3
was delimited from geochemical baselines (≥5.0ppm
U), reached in stream sediment samples in the region
of the Monsenhor Bastos deposit with a total reserve
estimated in 2,200t U3O8.
The groundwater wells situated in São Timóteo, Fazenda Muquila and Lagoa Grande are also recommended
for complementary studies in environmental geochemistry
and medical geology (Figure 5 and Table 2).
CONCLUSIONS
Over the last 50 years, scientists worldwide have been
investigating the correlations between geochemistry and
health. But, in Brazil this theme has only acquired more importance in the last 5 years. Work groups of geoscientists,
doctors, biologists, geographers, chemists and experts from
other scientific areas, several governmental institutions and
universities, have been developing this new science of medical geology in Brazil. The National Program for Environmental
Geochemistry and Medical Geology Research (Programa
Nacional de Pesquisa em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia
Médica) – PGAGEM unites these researchers through an
internet network (regagem@ige.unicamp.br).
From the methodological application, evaluation,
interpretation and integration of data from the Lagoa Real
region study, the following conclusions were made:
The method used identified the geochemical and
hydro-geochemical signatures compatible with the standards obtained through the analyses of rocks and soils
sampled from the same sites and indicated eight groundwater wells as polluted or, particularly contaminated by
radioactive pollutant (uranium).
– 150 –
José Erasmo de Oliveira
Figure 5 – Sampling sites and area selected for complementary research within PGAGEM Lagoa Real.
– 151 –
Radioelements impact on the environment, agriculture and public health in Lagoa Real, Bahia State Brazil
Table 2 -Target areas and selected samples for complementary research within Lagoa Real
Sampling sites
Target area (Nº)
Individual sample (*)
Analized material
(Uranium content)
LONGITUDE UTMmE
LATITUDE UTMmE
EF-S-035
(1)
S (5.2ppm)
796,109
8,469,380
EF-S-041
(1)
S (14.9ppm)
793,170
8,470,054
EF-S-042
(1)
S (6.3ppm)
791,503
8,468,748
EST-043
(1)
A (29.89ppb)
R (9.9ppm). S (8.7ppm)
R (9.9ppm). S (8.7ppm)
92,554
8,469,283
EST-045
(1)
L (13.1ppm)
792,554
8,469,283
EST-047
(1)
A (158.79ppb)
796,258
8,468,982
EST-048
(1)
A (41.39ppb)
796,349
8,468,982
EST-058
(1)
A (42.11ppb)
795,749
8,469,438
EF-S-030
(2)
S (5.0ppm)
797,341
8,465,425
EST-072
(2)
A (566.85ppb)
799,705
8,465,694
EST-073
(2)
A (105.93ppb)
799,993
8,465,635
EST-074
(2)
L (8.2ppm)
793,075
8,463,199
EF-S-001
(3)
S (5.2ppm)
807,105
8,439,738
EF-S-002
(3)
S (5.2ppm)
805,444
8,438,631
EF-S-005
(3)
S (5.8ppm)
799,481
8,439,462
EF-S-009
(3)
S (5.0ppm)
794,461
8,439,563
EF-S-015
(3)
S (6.3ppm)
791,835
8,440,462
EST-062
(*)
L (10.7ppm)
788,513
8,457,279
EST-065
(*)
A (21.03ppb)
809,690
8,451,388
EST-067
(*)
A (98.48ppb)
806,517
8,467,984
Sampled material: A (water), L (soil) R (roch) and S (stream sediment), (1) target area at the INB mineral-industrial complex,
(2) target area at Fazenda Juazeiro, (3) Target area Monsenhor Bastos, (*) Tubular wells selected for monitoring campaigns
In Lagoa Real, more recently greater importance has
been given to human health risk related to groundwater
contamination than to the intrinsic problems related to
the Cachoeira uranium mine exploration. This is due
to the aquifer’s slow, predominantly fractured, water
renovation, making it difficult to measure its qualitative
characteristics.
Most uranium polluted wells are aquifers with average to high salinity and also with expressive selenium
contents, which means the water is neither suitable for
human consumption nor other activities such as irrigation
and cattle.
Since this is a rural zone, agricultural soil samples
must be studied considering that some of them are likely
to be irrigated with polluted or contaminated water.
The exclusive dependence of both the local population and the INB mining company on a groundwater supply leads to possible use conflicts. This may also make
it impossible to sustain the hydric resource, mainly in the
case of the aquifer/groundwater contamination.
Although the mining company’s present water production/demand situation can be considered satisfactory,
this condition may be short lived as several regional wells
are drying up.
With respect to uranium, in spite of technological
progress, it is nevertheless a radioactive and lethal substance with high contamination risks. Therefore, constant
human and environmental monitoring is vital. The Lagoa
Real yellow cake industry is the first processing stage of
the nuclear fuel cycle, and the technique of lixiviation in
– 152 –
José Erasmo de Oliveira
piles eliminates many process stages, which means lower
risk to the environment, agriculture and public health.
Though the number of deaths caused by cancer in
recent years in Lagoa Real is statistically very small, the results of this study emphasize the need for complementary
research on the correlation between uranium and cancer
in the Lagoa Real Uraniferous Province area.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author wants to thank the biologist José Jorge
de Souza de Carvalho, chief of the Laboratório de Solos
e Água de Salvador (DNOCS) and the geologist Evandro
Carele de Matos, Coordinator of Development of Deposits,
CDEJA, of INB, for their encouragement and support to
produce this study.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BRASIL. Ministério do Meio Ambiente. Resolução CONAMA nºo 357/ 17 de março/ 2005. Disponível em:
<http://www.mma.gov.br/port/conama/res/res05/
res35705.pdf>. Acesso em janeiro 2006.
DARNLEY, A.G et al. A global geochemical database: for
environmental and resource management. Canadá:
UNESCO, 1995. 122p. il. (Earth Sciences, 19).
LEVINSON, A.A. Introduction to exploration geochemistry. 2.ed. Wilmette, USA : Applied Publishing,
1980. p. 615-924. Suplemento.
OLIVEIRA, J.E. Correlação geológica-geoquímicageofísica de Lagoa Real-BA para aplicação em
geologia médica. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE
GEOLOGIA, 42., 2004, Araxá, MG. Anais... Araxá,
MG : SBG. Núcleo Minas Gerais, 2004. 1 CD ROM.
Simultaneamnte EXPOGEO 2004.
RICHARDS, L.A. (Ed.). Diagnosis and improvement of
saline and alkalis soils. Washington : U.S. Government Printing Office, 1954. (USDA Handbook,
n.60).
SALMINEM, R. et al. Foregs geochemical mapping field
manual. Espoo: Geological Survey of Finland, 1998.
39 p.il.
– 153 –
Asbestos: what is important to consider
ASBESTOS: WHAT IS
IM PORTANT TO
CONSIDER
Wilson Scarpelli, wiscar@attglobal.6net
INTRODUCTION
To the layman, asbestos is a mineral to be avoided
at all costs, because of its carcinogenic properties. As
there are many cancer cases due to asbestos it warrants
a closer study to propose possible measures to ban or
control its use when noxious. However, it should bourn
in mind there are a great number of minerals that present the same physical characteristics as asbestos which
could be used as a substitute. As these minerals have
both different chemical compositions as well as physical
behavior from each other, they have different potential
levels of being carcinogenic.
DEFINITION OF ASBESTOS
The American Geological Institute (1980), Glossary of Geology presents a clear definition of asbestos:
“Asbestos – a commercial term used for a group of
silicates minerals which breakdown into fine strong
fibers, flexible, heat and chemical attack resistant,
used mainly for paper, paints, brake systems, ceramics, cement, fillings and filters where it is necessary
to use non combustible material, of low electric conductibility. These exceptional physical and chemical
characteristics make it an advantageous material for
industrial use.”
MINERALS USED AS ASBESTOS
Asbestine minerals, of acicular habit and usable as
asbestos, are found in two mineral groups, serpentines
and amphiboles. Among serpentines there is only one
mineral, chrysotile a hydrated silicate of magnesium.
Among amphiboles there are five minerals, all containing
iron: actinolite, anthophyllite, crocidolite, cummingtonite
and tremolite. In addition to containing iron, an element
that does not occur in chrysotile, the fibers of the amphiboles are less flexible and more rigid than the chrysotile
fibers. Figure 1 presents details of these minerals usable
as asbestos.
ASBESTOS AND HEALTH
The human body has, in the nostrils, ways of detaining and removing small fragments inhaled when breathing preventing them from reaching the lungs. However,
many fragments, usually smaller than 10 microns, can
enter the lungs. There, these fragments are enveloped by
macrophagic cells, forming little masses that are expelled
through short coughs.
Asbestosis
Asbestosis and other forms of lung cancer occur
when of these mineral fibers, breathed in together with
other everyday dust particles, do not get expired and
remain in the lungs, eventually causing inflammations
and abnormal cell growths. This process is not efficient
with long, rigid prismatic particles that are more difficult
to be enveloped especially if containing iron. Details and
photos are presented in Figure 2.
Influence of smoking on the incidence of asbestosis
A very important factor to be considered is the incidence of asbestosis is expressively greater in smokers
than non-smokers. The vast majority of people suffering
from asbestosis are smokers. Although tobacco has its
own numerous carcinogenic components, considering
the heated air breathed into the lungs by smokers can be
a chemical reaction accelerating agent this leads to the
– 154 –
Wilson Scarpelli
oxidization of the fibers with iron. In this case there are
similarities with what occurs with rock weathering, where
heat is an important factor in the intensity of the chemical
reactions that alter them.
Asbestosis in soapstone workers
Cancer due to amphiboles present in soapstone
have been described in the literature, occurring mainly
in regions where the soapstone is cut and polished for
the production of ornamental pieces, construction and
architecture. Bezerra et al. (2003), researching the situation of soapstone workers in Ouro Preto, Minas Gerais,
conclude that “the study of the dust’s composition revealed the presence of breathable asbestos fibers of the
amphibole group (tremolite-actinolite). These results suggest the occurrence of talc-asbestosis among soapstone
handicraftsmen.” To call such cancer forms “talcosis”
does not seem to be correct, since the causing minerals
are asbestine amphiboles.
Asbestosis in other deposits with
asbestine amphiboles
One of the most representative cases of asbestosis
due to amphiboles resulted from the mineral extraction
front of a vermiculite deposit in Libby, Montana, United
States. The ore contains small amounts of asbestine
tremolite and its mineral extraction and grinding led to a
large number of cancer cases due to asbestos, not only
in Libby but also in other communities where the tremolite
containing vermiculite was sent for use in constructions
and additions to soil.
GEOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS ON THE
CAUSE OF ASBESTOSIS
When they involve the iron containing fibers, the
macrophagic cells may react with them oxidizing the
bivalent iron to trivalent, causing iron hydroxide to be
formed, such as goethite or limonite. These can adhere
to the lung walls and prevent the removal of the mineral.
This alteration does not occur with chrysotile, a mineral
that does not contain iron. In the case macrophagic cells
should chemically react with chrysotile, the fibers will be
destroyed because there is no formation of a magnesium
secondary mineral.
This alteration process is very similar to what occurs
during rock weathering with these minerals. There are
few rock outcrops with amphiboles that present these
minerals without alteration on the surface. In comparison,
the chrysotile serpentine is very resistant to weathering,
normally outcropping without weathering in serpentinite
ultramafic rocks.
Serpentinite Mineral Group
Anphibolite Mineral Group
Micaceous and fibrous minerals,
weathering products from olivines and
pyroxenes.
Fibrous minerals, primary constituents of metamorphic and igneous rocks.
In serpentinites and serpentinized
ultramafic rocks.
In acid, intermediary , basic and alkaline igneous rocks and in metamorphic rocks (gneiss,
amphibolite and schist)
Crysotile - Mg3Si2O5(OH)4
Asbestiform Chrysotile
Anthophyllite
- (Mg,Fe)7Si8O22(OH)2
Actinolite
- Ca2(Mg,Fe)5Si8O22(OH)2
Crocidolite (reibeckite)
- Na2(Fe23,Fe32)Si8O22(OH)
Cummingtonite (amosite)
- (Fe,Mg)7Si8O22(OH)2
Tremolite
- Ca2(Mg,Fe)5Si8O22(OH)2
Asbestiform Anthophyllite
Asbestiform Tremolite
Figure 1 – Relation and chemical composition of the minerals used as asbest
– 155 –
Asbestos: what is important to consider
“Asbestos fibers in the lungs. Most
of the fibers are expelled, but some
may cause inflammation. Infection
by asbestos occurs when there is
a long lasting and strong exposure.
Long durable fibers, such as in
amphibole are the worst. Smoking
habits increase the lung cancer
risks.” ASTDR (2005)
“Asbestos fibers in alveolar
bronchiolitis fluids, retrieved from the
lungs of a man with strong exposure
to asbestos. Macrophagic cells
stick to a larger fiber. Below, on the
right, a small fiber is enveloped by a
group of macrophagic cells.” (Agius,
2005)
“Asbestos fibers, in larger scale,
enveloped by macrophagic cells.
The fibers are covered with iron
hydroxide and proteins. There are
small dark inclusions in many cells,
probably as result of smoking.”
(Agius, 2005)
Figure 2 – Asbestos fibers in the lungs.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
AGIUS, R. “Asbestos and Disease”. Disponível em:<http://
www.agius.com/hew/resource/asbestos.htm>.
Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
BEZERRA, O.M.P.A.; DIAS, E.C.; GALVÃO, M.A.M.;
CARNEIRO, A.P.S. Talcose entre artesãos em
pedra-sabão em uma localidade rual do Município
de Ouro Preto, Minas Gerais, Brasil. Cadernos
Saúde Pública, Rio de Janeiro, v.19, n.6, p. 17511759, 2003.
CAPELOZZI, V.L. Asbesto, asbestose e câncer: critérios
diagnósticos. Jornal de Pneumologia, v. 27, n. 4, p.
206-218, 2001.
U.S. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry
- ASTDR. Asbestos, Asbestos Exposure and Your
Health. Disponível em: <http://www.atsdr.cdc. Gov./
asbestos/index.html>. Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency - EPA. Pollution
Report Libby Asbestos; Ref. 8EPR-ER. Disponível
em: <http://www.epa.gov/region8/superfund/pdfs/
LibbyPol2.pdf> Acesso em: 07 ago. 2006.
– 156 –
THE CRENOTHERAPY OF
RIO DE JANEIRO STATE
BRAZIL M INERAL WATER
¹Aderson Marques Martins, admarques@drm.rj.gov.br
¹Kátia Leite Mansur, kmansur@drm.rj.gov.br
¹Thaís Salgado Pimenta, thais@drm.rj.gov.br
²Lucio Carramillo Caetano, carramillo@gmail.com
¹Department for Mineral Resources - DRM-RJ
²National Department for Mineral Production - DNPM
INTRODUCTION
Drinking mineral water is one of the most ancient
means of health treatment used by man. Through millenary clinical proof it has been shown by its widespread
and efficient use to heal a wide range of illnesses in different periods around the world.
In ancient times the virtues of hydromineral springs
were considered supernatural manifestations and religious phenomena. Gods, nymphs and other symbols
were the first protectors of springs and the first hydrotherapists were priests and healers. In Ancient Greece,
Aristotle proclaimed the virtue of the vapors emanated
from thermal springs, whereas Plato discussed the origin
of mineral water. Herodotus, one of the greatest Roman
thinkers, outlined the principles of crenotherapy (from the
Greek Crenos=spring).
Facts related to mineral water use are frequent
found in historical documents. The Bible mentions
crowds of sick people gathered around the spring of
Bethsaida, in Jerusalem, seeking a cure. In Europe,
before the Roman occupation, the Gauls already used
some of its numerous thermal springs. However organized resorts were started by Julius Caesar. During
the Middle Ages the pagan divinities were replaced by
the Catholic Church saints in the springs under their
responsibility.
Scientific documentation on the subject only appeared in 1604, when the first mineral water legislation
was passed in France, by Henry IV. In the 18th century,
Hydrology was consolidated with the results of a study
with more than 2,000 observations made in Barèges,
by Theophile de Bordeu and several publications of the
French Royal Society of Medicine (Duhot & Fontain, 1963).
The period between the two world wars saw the rise of
the modern industry of bottled water.
In Brazil, Emperor D. Pedro II created in 1848 the
hydromineral station of Caldas da Imperatriz, in Santa
Catarina State, which initiated the country´s use of
mineral water in health resorts. The first studies of Brazilian mineral water appeared in the early 20th century,
especially after 1930 with the creation of the National
Department for Mineral Production (Departamento Nacional da Produção Mineral) – DNPM. Since then the
mineral water industries of health resorts and bottled
water became established. This was largely due to
the discovery of springs in the South of the country
and Minas Gerais (São Lourenço, Caxambu, Lambari,
Araxá, Poços de Caldas, Cambuquira, etc.) and São
Paulo (Lindóia, etc.). In 1945, the Mineral Water Code
(Decree- nº7841, Official Diary August 20th 1945) that
defined and classified mineral water came into effect,
regulating its research, exploration, industrialization and
commercialization.
Rio de Janeiro State had its first hydromineral spring
discovered in 1887, in Paraíba do Sul. This spring’s
water, today inactive, was classified as alkaline-sodic
bicarbonated, and was known as salutary, which origi-
– 157 –
The crenotherapy of Rio de Janeiro State Brazil mineral water
nated the trademark “Salutaris”. The water has been
bottled since 1898 under this name. In 1941 a hotel and
leisure area were built – the buildings still remain – and
the area was called “ Salutáris Water Park - Parque de
Águas Salutáris”, being the first Hydromineral Resort of
Rio de Janeiro State.
One year later, the Santa Cruz Mineral Water was
discovered by the former slave Domingo Camões, known
as “Beiçola”. In 1909, he established a home-bottling plant
called Saint Water (Água Santa), producing 5 liter wine
bottles delivered from door to door on donkey back. The
company Águas Santa Cruz Ltda was founded in 1914,
which still exists in the Água Santa district, perpetuating
the spring’s name.
Currently there are 34 mineral water bottling companies in Rio de Janeiro State.
CONCEPTUALIZATION
Mineral water is the name given to “water from natural springs or artificially extracted, that have a chemical
composition or physical or physical-chemical proprieties
distinct from common water, with characteristics that
confer on them a medicinal action” (DNPM, 1966). This
concept, from the National Mineral Water Code, is the
most accepted, though there are other definitions based
on types of mineral water that do not completely fit the
above criterion.
For the French, for instance, mineral water is any
natural spring water endowed with therapeutic proprieties,
even if it does not have the mentioned physical, chemical
or physical-chemical content distinct from other water, a
phenomenon often observed and confirmed with clinical
proof. This characteristic is attributed to infinitesimal concentrations (ppb) of elements or chemical substances,
generically denominated as oligoelements, responsible
for its medicinal properties. This water is denominated
oligomineral or oligometallic. In Brazil, these waters are
classified as oligomineral.
In 1972, in Vienna, FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization and WHO – World Health Organization, both
United Nations entities, organized a meeting of several
countries seeking a World Mineral Water Code. The most
controversial topic was precisely the concept of “health
enhancement properties” for which no agreement was
reached.
Based on the Brazilian Code, water can be considered mineral (Caetano & Yoshinaga, 2003; Caetano 2005)
according to:
a) Its chemical composition (Table 1) – when the presence of a given element or substance is predominant;
b) When it has proved medicinal action confirmed and
approved by the Permanent Commission for Crenotherapy (Comissão Permanente de Crenologia), linked
to DNPM (oligominerals); and;
c) Its physical-chemical characteristics at the spring:
· when there is a gaseous radon yield between 5 and
50 Mache units (radioactive);
· when there is a gaseous thorium yield equal to 2 Mache
units (thorium-actives);
· when it has a clear release of sulfuric gas (sulfurous)
and;
· cold, hypothermal, mesothermal, isothermal and hyperthermal: when the temperature is, respectively, inferior
to 25°C, between 25 and 33°C, between 33 and 36°C,
between 36 and 38°C and above 38°C.
Today, the WHO, through the Codex Alimentarius
defines natural mineral water as only that which is characterized by the concentration of certain mineral salts,
by the presence of oligoelements or other constituents.
In the United States, the agency responsible for this sec-
Table 1 - Mineral water characteristics (modified by Caetano & Yoshinaga, 2003; Caetano, 2005)
Classification
Characteristics
Radiferous
Permanent radioactivity potential
Alkaline Bicarbonate
Sodium bicarbonate = or > 200mg/L
Alkaline Terrous
Calcium Carbonate = or > 120mg/L
Alkaline Calcic Terrous
Calcium = or > 48mg/L as calcium bicarbonate
Alkaline Magnesian Terrous
Mg = or > 30mg/L as magnesium bicarbonate
Sulfated
Na, K and/or Mg Sulfate = or > 100 mg/L
Nitrated
Nitrates of mineral origin = or > 100 mg/L
Chlorinated
Sodium Chloride = or > 500mg/L
Ferruginous
Iron = or > 5mg/L (Ex.: Salutaris - RJ)
Carbo-Gaseous
Dissolved carbonic gas = or > 200 mg/L
Predominant Element0.01mg/l)
Iodinated; Lithinated; Fluorinated; Brominated; Vanadic, etc.
– 158 –
Anderson Marques Martins
tor, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), requires a
minimum of 250mg/L of dissolved total solids to classify
the water as mineral.
According to the Economic European Community
– EEC (Directive 80/777/CEE/1980), mineral water is distinguished from other water for its nature and is characterized by the concentration of minerals, oligoelements
or other constituents and, if not, by certain effects and
by its original purity, with one or the other characteristic
kept intact, due to its underground origin, protected from
any risk of pollution.
Before the EEC legislation, the presentation of a minimum dissolved total solids equal or superior to 1,000mg/L
or 250mg/L free CO2 was required for its classification as
natural mineral water. The present classification of natural
mineral water in the European Community follows the
standards reported in Table 2.
In France, the establishment of a mineral water bottling industry depends on the Service of Mines (Ministry of
Industry, General Directions of the Industry, of Research
and of the Environment) and on the Ministry of Health,
after obtaining a certification from the Medicine Academy
regarding the therapeutic properties of the water.
There us a growing concern surrounding the criteria
for mineral water classification and also a tendency to
adopt minimum limits for mineral salt content. The National Mineral Water Code reform is a requirement of the
professional and scientific community.
Two attempts to alter the Code were made respectively by the Republic Presidency, in 2002 and by the DNPM,
in 2003, which issued a text for public consultation. The
text had proposed that any groundwater, since potable
and tapped in a way avoiding contamination, could be
considered as mineral water bearing low, medium and
high mineralization. Based on those generic criteria,
the Brazilian law would contrast with the European and
American mineral water framework. After receiving many
contributions however, the initiative did not succeed and
the reform did not take place.
Besides mineral water, the Brazilian Code defines
table potable water as water bearing normal composition
from natural springs or artificially extracted which fulfills
the potability requirements for a given region. This water
is called natural water by the National Sanitary Vigilance
– ANVISA, linked to the Health Ministry. ANVISA also
gives permission to produce bottled purified water, with
the addition of salt, as water with diverse origin, artificially
mineralized or ozonized.
MINERAL WATERS CONSUMPTION IN PRESENT DAYS
There are justifications which explain the growing
consumption of mineral water. The human rift with nature
produced by technological progress, has generated a
resistance by humanity’s collective unconscious. The
search for an alternative between artificially treated, public
supply water and the contaminated water from increasingly polluted sources, found an outlet in mineral water
which, in addition, is good to health. Thus, a continuously
expanding mineral water market arose used as a drink or
food complementation.
In addition to the dissemination of bottled water consumption, hydromineral resorts are enjoyable. In some
European countries, France for example, the tradition
of famous resorts such as Vichy and Aix-les-Bains are
maintained and their tourist potential generates substantial revenues.
In Brazil famous resorts such as Caxambu, São
Lourenço and Poços de Caldas in Minas Gerais and
Lindóia and Serra Negra in São Paulo attract large
numbers of national and international tourists. Nowadays, after a decline in the crenological medicine, there
is a renewed interest in mineral water, supported by
the development of new medicine specialization fields,
such as orthomolecular. This new tendency fulfills the
search for a new way of life, away from the artificiality
predominating industrialized food, pollution and sedentary stagnation. According to orthomolecular medicine,
a large number of toxins and products dangerous to
our health are ingested. These include: synthetic food
additives, agrochemicals, heavy metals and transgenic
foods (the effects of which are not yet clarified) that
have a negative impact in our metabolism, giving rise
to biological and energetic weaknesses leading to
diseases. Within this context, mineral water appears
as a means not only to the combat these symptoms,
but also to act in a more integrated way. Therefore,
mineral water is seen as a source to replenish the
body’s depleted mineral salts and micronutrients
(Bontempo, 2002).
Table 2 - Mineral water classification by CEE (modified by Caetano & Yoshinaga, 2003; Caetano, 2005)
Classification
Requirement
Very low mineralization
<ou = 50mg/L of TDS
Low mineralization (oligominerals)
between 50mg/L and 500mg/L of TDS
High mineralization
> 1,500mg/L of TDS
– 159 –
The crenotherapy of Rio de Janeiro State Brazil mineral water
GEOLOGICAL ASPECTS
Based on today’s knowledge of the Earth’s water
cycle and distribution, mineral water has its origin, like
groundwater, in pluviometric precipitation flowed by
percolation towards underground reservoirs. So, mineral water is a special type of groundwater with springs
that depend on the vertical movement across faults and
fractures under very low velocities. Being affected by
the weight of the water column above, and sometimes
by gas and vapor, this water tends to rise to the surface
(Figure 1). The mineral water formation begins in the
atmosphere, where, as rain drops, it absorbs elements
from the air. As it percolates through the soil, it becomes
affected by the non-saturated zone until it reaches the
water table and rock media, its last mineralization stage.
The time gap between the infiltration and discharge depends on the geographical extension, varying from tens
to thousands of years. The chemical composition reflects
this percolation process through the geological media,
where, moving downwards under rising temperature and
pressure, it dissolves rocks and minerals (Martins et al.
2002). This theory is based on the geothermal gradient,
which foresees an increase of 1°C for every 30 meters
of depth.
The magmatic theory argument is supported by the
thermal and gaseous sources and the spring’s richness
in elements, which rarely occur in the upper layers of
the earth’s crust. Although, this theory is considered
old-fashioned, it is still possible to conceive a double
source, initially the meteoric water becoming saturated
with the salt content while percolating in the geological
media and the other related to volcanism and plutonic
events (Figure 2).
Andrade Júnior (1937), a pioneer researcher of mineral water origins in Brazil, based on the geographical
distribution of the main springs, has confirmed they are
situated in NE-SW shear belts from North to South coinciding with the nation’s mountain ranges. This geological
interpretation led to the conclusion these hydromineral
springs are related to alkaline magmatism and to a deep
fracture system. This opinion is also shared by Frangipani (1995), who correlates those springs with shear
and folding belts near Cratonic areas and sedimentary
basins, and also, near areas where the basement was
affected by tectonics. Those regions have structures that
allow deep water circulation until it reaches the surface
as a spring.
The Rio de Janeiro State mineral water occurs, in
general, in natural springs, which were discovered by local inhabitants and used empirically for medical purposes
before they had been formally analyzed. This was the case
of the Iodine rich water from Pádua and Raposo Mineral
Water. The simplified State geological map in Figure 3,
shows the known mineral water distribution according to
their predominant composition.
Figure 1 – Origin of the Mineral Waters
– 160 –
Anderson Marques Martins
Figure 2 – Composed origin for the mineral waters.
RIO DE JANEIRO STATE MINERAL WATER
THERAPEUTIC INDICATIONS
Crenotherapy treatment must be conducted by a
professional who will be responsible for the important
periodic examinations. Furthermore it must be done
on-site, as the water only has its full potential within the
spring areas. There are two types of treatment: internal
(water ingested as medication) and external. The internal
treatment, besides simple oral ingestion, there are subcutaneous, intramuscular and intravenous injections, which
may be done with isotonic water. The external techniques
are based on showers and pools, saunas, aerosols, even
through local application with a compress etc. Despite the
innumerous proprieties shown in Table 3 (only by ingestion), the mineral water consumption must be oriented by
a professional. There are contra-indications according
to the water type and each person’s metabolism. This is
the case for water with high salt contents that can not be
ingested by people with hypertension. In the same way,
water with a high calcium concentration is not suitable
for people with a potential high tendency of renal and
vesicular problems.
Regarding radioactive water, there are divergences
as to their health benefits. The allopathic medicine praxis
manifests some concern about the radiation effects. According to Mourão (1992), a famous crenologist doctor,
in his book “Hydrological Medicine”, Rio de Janeiro State
presents three main categories of hydromineral springs:
Radioactive;
Alkaline-terrous bicarbonate;
Carbo-gaseous.
A special mention is made of the Pádua iodine-rich
water, considered rare due to its iodine concentration,
used therapeutically in circulation diseases, such as
arteriosclerosis and hypothyroidism.
– 161 –
The crenotherapy of Rio de Janeiro State Brazil mineral water
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ANDRADE JUNIOR, J. F. Águas minerais brasileiras. Mineração Metalurgia, Rio de Janeiro, v. 2, n. 9, 1937.
ASSOCIAÇÃO BRASILEIRA DA INDÚSTRIA DE ÁGUAS
MINERAIS - ABINAM. Tipos e características de
águas minerais. INFORME ABINAM, v. 2, no 18,
1996. Manchete Saúde.
BONTEMPO, M. Guia das águas: manual prático para o
uso correto das águas minerais medicinais do sul
de Minas Gerais. São Lourenço,MG: Arco Íris, 2002.
CAETANO, L. C.; YOSHINAGA, S. Águas Minerais e Águas
Subterrâneas: conceitos e Legislação Brasileira
(Estudo de Caso no Estado do Rio de Janeiro). In:
SIMPÓSIO DE HIDROGEOLOGIA DO SUDESTE, 1.,
2003, Petrópolis. Anais... Rio de Janeiro: ABAS, 2003.
CAETANO, L.C. A Política de Água Mineral: uma proposta de integração para o Estado do Rio de Janeiro.
2005. 329 p. Tese (Doutorado em Ciências) – Instituto de Geociências, Universidade Estadual de
Campinas, Campinas, 2005.
DEPARTAMENTO NACIONAL DE PRODUÇÃO MINERAL
- DNPM. Código de Águas Minerais: Decreto- Lei
nº 1.985, de 29-1-1940. 3.ed. Rio de Janeiro, 1966.
DUHOT, E.; FONTAN, M. Le Thermalisme. Paris : Presses
Universitaires de France, 1963. 126 p.
FALCÃO, H., 1978. Perfil analítico de Águas Minerais. Rio
de Janeiro : DNPM, 1978. v. 2 (Boletim DNPM, 49).
FRANGIPANI, A. Origem das Águas Minero-Medicinais.
In: TERMALISMO no Brasil. [S.l.]:Sociedade Brasileira de Termalismo- Minas Gerais, 1995.
HIDROMINAS. As estâncias hidrominerais do Estado de
Minas Gerais: divisão e considerações gerais. Belo
Horizonte, 1969.
LOPES, R. S. Águas minerais do Brasil: composição, valor
e indicações terapêuticas. 2.ed. Rio de Janeiro :
Serviço de Informação Agrícola, 1956. 148 p.
MARTINS, A. M.; MANSUR, K. L.; ERTHAL, F.; MAURÍCIO,
R. C.; PEREIRA FILHO, J. C.; CAETANO, L. C. Águas
Minerais do Estado do Rio de Janeiro. Niterói: DRM-RJ, 2002. 121 p.
MOURÃO, B. M. Medicina hidrológica: moderna terapêutica das águas minerais e estações de cura. Poços
de Caldas : Prefeitura Municipal, 1992. 732 p.
ROCHE, M. Effets théraupeutiques des eaux minérales.
Ann. Mines, Paris, 1975. p.39-46.
UNTURA FILHO, M. Uso Terapêutico das Águas Minerais. In: TERMALISMO no Brasil. [S.l.] : Sociedade
Brasileira de Termalismo - Minas Gerais, 1995. p.
75-83.
– 162 –
Anderson Marques Martins
Figure 3 – Simplified geological map for the State of Rio de Janeiro and the location of the most important mineral springs.
– 163 –
The crenotherapy of Rio de Janeiro State Brazil mineral water
Table 3 – Therapeutically properties of some mineral water (Lopes, 1956; Untura Filho, 1995; ABINAM, 1996).
Therapeutical functions
Mineral Waters
Branch
Classification
Aqua Fresh
Fluorinated
X
X
Acqua Natura
Fluorinated and low radioactivity at spring
Águas Claras/Vale do
Amanhecer
Very low radioactivity at spring
Águas do Porto
Fluorinated and low radioactivity at spring
Avahy
Carbo-gaseous
Gastric
Hepatic
Dermatologic
Metabolic
Intestinal
Nervous
Teeth’s and Bones
Renal
X
X
X
X
X
Belieny
Alkaline Bicarbonate
X
Calita
Alkaline-calcic fluorinated terrous
X
Cascataí
Very low radioactivity at spring
Claris
Litinated and Fluorinated
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Corcovado
Very low radioactivity at spring
Costa Dágua
Fluorinated
X
X
Costa Verde
Fluorinated and Very low radioactivity at spring
X
Cristalina
Alkaline-fluorinated terrous
Cristina
Fluorinated
X
Da Montanha
Fluorinated and Very low radioactivity at spring
X
X
Dedo de Deus
Fluorinated and Very low radioactivity at spring
X
X
Farol
Hypothermal at spring
X
X
X
X
Federal
Oligomineral
Fênix/Donna Natureza
Fluorinated and Very low radioactivity at spring
X
X
Fontana
Radioactivity at spring
X
X
Hidratta
Fluorinated and radioactivity at spring
Ibitira
Potable bottled water
Imbaíba
Very low radioactivity at spring
X
Indaiá
Fluorinated and radioactivity at spring
X
Ingá
Potable bottled water
Iodetada de Pádua
Lodinated, Litinated, Brominated, Alkaline,
Bicarbonate and Fluorinated
L’Aqua
Fluorinated
Las Vegas
Carbo-gasous
Leve Sul
Fluorinated and radioactivity at spring
Milneral/Soft
Fluorinated and lithinated
Nazareth
Fluorinated and hypothermal
Nova Friburgo/Lumiar
Fluorinated and low radioactivity at spring
Ouro Branco
Alkaline – Fluorinated Lithinated terrous
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Pagé
Lithinated
Passa Três
Radioactive at spring
X
X
Pedra Bonita
Very low radioactivity at spring
X
Pedra Branca
Fluorinated and radioactivy at spring
Petrópolis/Levíssima
Radioactivity at spring
Pindó
Fluorinated and radioactivity at spring
Raposo/Raposo Levíssima
Carbo-gasous Fluorinated
Recanto das Águas/
Millenium
Fluorinated and radioactivity at spring
X
X
Rica
Nitrated
Rio Bonito
Radioactivity at spring
Sagrada
Fluorinated and hypothermal at spring
Salutaris
Alkaline-ferruginous terrous
Santa Cruz
Fluorinated and hypothermal at spring
São Gonçalo
Alkaline-carbonate terrous
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
– 164 –
X
X
ASSESSM ENT OF
GROUNDWATER
CONTAM INATION LEVELS
IN PARINTINS CITY,
AM AZONAS STATE BRAZIL
José Luiz Marmos, jose.marmos@cprm.gov.br
Carlos José Bezerra de Aguiar, carlos.aguiar@cprm.gov.br
Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/MA
INTRODUCTION
Parintins municipality, with an area of 6,100 km², is
situated in the East of Amazonas State, on the border with
Pará State. Parintins Island, is located on the right bank of
the River Amazon, has about 70,000 inhabitants, an area
of 45 km² and is the seat of the municipality. It is about
350 km from Manaus and stands out as the State’s main
tourist center due to the traditional Boi-Bumbá festival.
The island has a rather flat relief, with the lowest altitudes, around 15 m near Lake Francesa and the Paraiba
Pumping Station (extreme NE), and the highest, about
30 m, in the central area, neighboring the Bosque da
Seringueira. The internal drainage is reduced to Lake
Francesa and several small tributaries that flow into Lake
Macurany.
Geologically, it is seated on Cretaceous sandy
sedimentary rocks of the Alter do Chão Formation, which
do not outcrop in the studied zone due to the intense
degree of weathering. The local decomposition of these
sediments gave origin to the predominantly thick yellow
clayish-sandy latosoils, and secondarily sand rich soils
probable fluvial neosoils. The native vegetal covering has
been almost entirely removed to give place to dwellings
and farms. Only some patches of campinarana (shrubby
vegetation) can still be observed on the sandy soils and
restricted riparian that grow along branches/inlets of Lake
Macurany (Figure 1).
All the public water supply for human consumption
comes from underground catchments, through tubular
wells, distributed by three supply stations (Paraíba, SHAM
and Itaúna), under the responsibility of SAAE, Autonomous Municipal Water and Sewerage System (Sistema
Autônomo de Água e Esgoto Municipal).
Residents’ reports and local chemical analyses, promoted by the SAAE laboratory, indicate that this water’s
quality is jeopardized, with chemical contamination probably linked to the precarious basic sanitation. Chemical
analyses of water collected in public supply wells, in the
ambit of PGAGEM – National Program for Environmental
Geochemistry and Medical Geology (Programa Nacional
de Geoquímica Ambiental e Geologia Médica), coordinated by CPRM – Brazilian Geological Service, confirmed
the problem, registering nitrate and aluminum contents
well above the maximum values allowed by law (BRASIL,
2004).
Recent studies suggest that high aluminum concentrations in water may unleash, after longer consumption
periods, renal and motorial coordination troubles, as well
as deficiencies in the immune system (Centeno, personal
communication). The nitrate ion, though not very toxic, can
be reduced to nitrite ions in the human organism. These
– 165 –
Assessment of groundwater contamination levels in Parintins City, Amazonas State Brazil
Figure 1 – Satellite Images showing Paritins island location, the registered wells and the water sampled.
– 166 –
José Luiz Marmos
are noxious to health because they induce methemoglobinemia, a disease that leads to the hypoxygenation of
the blood in children and can be fatal. Moreover, nitrites
can react, in the human body, with amines, producing
nitrosamines in the stomach, substances recognized
as potential carcinogenic agents by laboratory studies
(Cortecci, 2003; Freitas et al., 2001).
Through the study of the physical characteristics of
several public and private wells, associated with chemical
analyses and instantaneous measurements of physicalchemical parameters (pH and electric conductance/
conductivity) of surface and groundwater samples, the
intensity of the contamination was evaluated and solutions
for the problem’s mitigation proposed.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
· The field and laboratory work, developed between April
and May 2005, involved the following activities:
· fluvial recognition around the whole island perimeter,
assessing the natural and anthropogenic features of
the entire island, such as: geology, declivity, soil type,
vegetation, urban occupation, etc.
· Tubular well and hand dug well inventory covering
urban and rural areas, registering data such as: well
head altitude, depth, static level, dynamic level, yield,
filter position, lithological profile, etc.
· Groundwater and surface water sampling for laboratorial analysis at the Laboratories of the Catholic
University of Brasilia for the following ions:
- As, Al, Ba, Bi, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn,
Na, Ni, Pb, Sb, Se, Sn, V and Zn.
- Chloride, ammonium, nitrate, nitrite, sulfate and silica
were analyzed at the Laboratory of the National Institute for Amazonian Research-INPA.
· On-site analysis through digital sensors to measure pH,
electrical conductivity and temperature.
· Mechanical soundings in public land, next to water
wells to determine the water static level.
DISCUSSION AND RESULTS
Distributed in the interior part f the island, six samples
from streaSix stream water samples were collected from
around and in the central part of the island. The results
indicated a good homogeneity in the physical chemical
characteristics of these water samples: pH around 6,1
and 6,5; electrical conductivity between 41 and 50 µS/
cm; nitrate content and Al below the 0,1mg/L: ammonium
around 0,3mg/L and chloride 1,2 mg/L. This homogeneity
was due to the season in which the sampling was conducted. This was the River Amazon flood period, when the
river invades the whole low lands and get mixed with other
water bodies, such as lakes, boreholes and the island’s
backwaters and surroundings, diluting eventual surface
and localized contamination. Regarding the groundwater, 33 tubular wells, 28 in urban areas and 5 rural zones
were sampled (Figure 1). The results reveals that among
the 18 wells from the public supply system, only two presented contents of Al (<0,2mg/L), nitrate (<10mg/L) and
ammonium (1,5mg/L) obeying the levels established by
the national legislation (Brasil, 2004). The others showed
nitrate concentrations varying from 11 to 49mg/L, Al from
0,3 to 2,0 mg/L and ammonium up to 2,9 mg/L. They also
show high levels of nitrate and Al in three public and two
private supply wells. The urban area wells can be separated in two categories, according to their depths: deeper
and shallower than 65 meters; the former showing nitrate
levels and/or Al according to the legislation, whereas in
the others the situation was reversed. This contamination
is strongly associated with the well depths. Also the water
from the shallow wells is always more acidic than from
the deep wells (Figure 2), suggesting an inverse correlation between the pH values and the nitrate contents,
especially when considering only the contaminated wells
(Figure 3). The correlation between the water acidity with
the nitrate is explained by the ion’s origin, representing
the final stage of organic matter oxidation. Effluents are
rich in nitrogen and degrade into nitrates in the presence of oxygen, according to the organic nitrogen cycle
>ammonium>nitrite>nitrate:
NH4+ + 3/2 O2 ? + NO2- + H2O + 2H+ and
NO2- + 1/2 O2 ? NO3-; or, simply:
NH4+ + 3/2 O2 ? NO3- + 4H+ (the production of nitrate
increases the acidity)
The origin of the high nitrate levels in the shallow
wells in the Parintins urban fringe is related to the lack of
an adequate catchment system and sewage treatment in
the city. This leads to liquid sewage wastes, dumped into
septic tanks or open cesspits, infiltrating until contaminating the upper levels of the aquifer. An example is the
Paraiba pumping station in whose terrain all the wells are
situated besides being in a very low area flanked by urban
occupation. This is a system of homes on stilts, where
the residents dump all their waste directly into a surface
channel that connects with Lake Francesa (Figure 4). The
general lack of sanitation within the city is the main nitrate
contamination source. The Parintins nitrate distribution
map developed from the results, shows a clear tendency
of higher concentrations along the island’s main urban
occupation. The Al distribution is similar, suggesting a
strong correlation between these two elements (Figure
5). The high acidity in the nitrate contaminated water is
also responsible for the process that triggers the Al contamination. This metal is an element known to have very
low mobility within a pH in the range 4,0 to 8,0, typical for
natural environments. Therefore, it is not easily liberated,
as a ionic specie in the aqueous media, being fixed in
the solid phase, as a clay mineral. However, under low
pH, below 4,0, as found in many wells, together with the
– 167 –
Assessment of groundwater contamination levels in Parintins City, Amazonas State Brazil
Figure 2 – Comparison between the mean pH values, conductivity and nitrate content for two different depth levels defined for urban wells.
and aluminum. The high nitrate concentrations are due
to deficiencies in the urban waste system. The Parintins
island aquifer has water, which is naturally acidic (pH
4,0 to 4,5), representing a natural constraint to the public
health. This acidity increases in the wells with high nitrate
contents providing conditions for the aluminum in soil
particles to mobilize into the aqueous media, generating
a composite of natural and anthropogenic contamination.
As an immediate action, it is recommended pumping in
six public wells with the highest contamination levels
should be ceased (PT-6, PT-17, PT-22, PT-11, PT-20 and
PT-19). Initiate the operation of two 80 m deep wells with
good yields, in the Itaúna Station, which will replace the
well closures. The actual Parintins demand considering
the system losses (30%), is about 17.000 m3/day. The 12
remaining public system wells according to actual daily
discharge data can produce more than 18.000 m3. In
the short term, it is suggested a gradually deactivation
Figure 3. Strong inverse correlation between pH values and the
nitrate concentration in Parintins well water.
high organic acids concentration, the Al may be soluble
in the aqueous media, due to complexation, followed by
a migration to solid phase building complex ions (Carvalho, 1995). The strong correlation between the nitrate
contents with Al contents corroborates the suggested
hypothesis (Figure 5). Among the metals analyzed in the
groundwater samples, none registered a concentration
above the permitted maximum values. In the rural areas,
despite the shallow well depths, there is no evidence of
organic contamination.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMENDATIONS
The majority of Parintins public water wells produce
water with a chemical composition that does not obey the
pertinent legislation, with emphasis on nitrate, ammonium
Figure 4 – Open sewage channel near the public water wells at the
Paraiba pumping station.
– 168 –
José Luiz Marmos
100 meters deep with an initial 50 meter cement liner.
The 10 wells could produce about 14.000 m3/day of
water. In order to supply 100.000 inhabitants, it’s crucial
to lower the groundwater natural acidity. The alternative
would be to install a catchment and treatment plant, with
intake from the River Amazon, with a capacity of at least
15.000 m3/day of treated water, with a pH around 6,0 to
6,5 to be mixed with the acidic groundwater. Above all,
resources must be allocated to build a waste water system connected to a treatment plant covering the whole
Parintins urban zone.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
Figure 5 – Strong correlation between the nitrate and aluminum content in Parintins groundwater.
of the Paraiba Station wells, due to its precarious location (lowlands submitted to flooding and surrounded by
open sewage channels) and the shallow wells (PT-10,
PT-14 e PT-16) in the SHAM Station. At the same time,
foreseeing 100.000 inhabitants in the city (daily water
demand of 26.000 m3), 5 new wells should be drilled (2
at the SHAN station and 3 at Itaúna), each more than
BRASIL. Ministério da Saúde. Portaria no 518, de 25 mar.
2004. Brasília: 2004.
CARVALHO, I. G. Fundamentos da Geoquímica dos
Processos Exógenos. Salvador : Bureau Gráfica e
Editora , 1995.
CORTECCI, G. Geologia e Salute. Disponível em:<http://
www.dst.unipi.it/fist/salute/salute.htm.>. Acesso em:
10 de outubro de 2003.
FREITAS, M. B.; BRILHANTE, O. M.; ALMEIDA, L. M. Importância da análise de água para a saúde pública
em duas regiões do Estado do Rio de Janeiro:
enfoque para coliformes fecais, nitrato e alumínio.
Cadernos Saúde Pública, Rio de Janeiro, v. 17, n.
3, p. 651-660, 2001.
– 169 –
GEOCHEM ICAL
CHARACTERIZATION OF
THE EASTERN AM AZONAS
PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY
SYSTEM
Edesio M. Buenano Macambira, edesio.macambira@cprm.gov.br
Eduardo Paim Viglio, eduardo.eviglio@cprm.gov.br
Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/BE
ABSTRACT
This study is part of the National Program for Environmental Geochemistry and Medical Geology Research
(Programa Nacional de Pesquisa em Geoquímica Ambiental e Geológica Médica) – PGAGEM and it was made
by the Brazilian Geological Survey through their Belém
Office, in the States of Pará and Amapá, and part of
Maranhão, Piauí, Tocantins, Mato Grosso and Amazonas.
During the field work, 77 public water supply samples
were collected in some cities covered by the study.
The samples were analyzed for 6 anions (F, Cl, NO2, Br,
SO4 and PO4) through ion chromatography and for 25
cations (Al, As, B, Ba, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Li,
Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Pb, Se, Sr, Ti, V and Zn) through
ICP-AES. The result interpretations were based on statistical calculations and the maximum values permitted
for human consumption, according to the CONAMA
357/2005 Standards and Resolution MS 518/2004. The
elements Be, Ca, Co, Cr, Li, Mg, Mo, Na, Ni, Sr, Cl and
F presented concentrations below the limits established
by the legislations in all samples. However, the elements
Pb, Al, Cu, Fe, B, Ba, As, Se, Br, Cd, K, Mn, Zn and PO4
showed values improper for human consumption in the
water samples of some communities. Although there
are no studies showing a direct relationship between
the elevated concentrations of these elements and diseases among the population, the confirmed Al and Pb
contents (18 and 145 times higher than the maximum
permitted values) are particularly worrying because
they are elements considered toxic, which may cause
adverse effects to human health.
INTRODUCTION
The studied area covers about 2,000,000 km2 comprised of the whole States of Pará and Amapá and part
of the States of Maranhão, Piauí, Tocantins, Mato Grosso
and Amazonas. To optimize the operational activities and
follow its physiographic and logistic characteristics, the
area was divided in 10 work blocks: I – Northeastern Pará,
II – Pará-Maranhão, III Tocantins-Piauí, IV – Southern Pará,
V – Altamira, VI – Marajó, VII – Macapá, VIII – Trombetas,
IX – Santarém and X – Tapajós (Figure 1).
77 public water supply samples were collected
during four field work stages. The largest work volume
was carried out in Block I (47 samples in Pará and 14 in
Maranhão). Another stage was carried out in Blocks II
– 170 –
Edesio M. Buenano Macambira
Figure 1 – Location map of the PEGAGEM-Belém executed studies.
and III in partnership with the Zeolitas Project in the Paranaíba Basin (10 samples). The third stage was carried
out in Block IX in partnership with the Amazonian Basin
Hydrology and Geochemistry Project (Projeto Hidrologia
e Geoquímica da Bacia Amazônica) – HIBAM, product
of a partnership between the National Water Agency
(Agência Nacional de Águas) – ANA, the National
Research Council (Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa)
– CNPq and the Institut de Recherche pour le Dévelopement – IRD, of France (4 samples). The last field
work stage was carried out in Block V together with the
Hydrometeorological National Network Program (Projeto
Instalação e Operação da Rede Hidrometeorológica
Nacional) (2 samples).
In each municipality one water supply sample was
collected, the chosen site being always the station or
well with the largest distribution system. During sampling,
forms were filled out with the descriptive parameters of
the sampling site and the pH measurement. The samples
were collected directly from the well, spring or drainage, before any treatment was made. They were kept
in polyethylene graduated tubes, with a 50ml capacity,
after being filtered in a micropore 0.45 m for cations and
anions analysis. To preserve the soluble cations in the
samples, 1ml HNO3 1:1 was added to keep the pH <
2. The samples were kept refrigerated until analysis. 24
cations were analyzed (Al, As, B, Ba, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr,
Cu, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Pb, Se, Sr, Ti, V and
Zn) through ICP-AES and 6 anions (F, Cl, NO2, Br, SO4
and PO4) through ion chromatography, in the Laboratory
for Mineral Analysis (Laboratório de Análises Minerais) –
LAMIM, of CPRM, in Rio de Janeiro.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC, PHYSIOGRAPHIC AND
GEOLOGICAL ASPECT
The Amazon Craton is main geotectonic unit in the
area, a complex tectonic-stratigraphic array of ArcheanProterozoic age, made up of a diversity of geological
environments, such as greenstone belts (Rio Maria,
Tacumã, Vila Nova, etc) shear belts (Itacaíunas, Jarí,
Araguaia, etc) orogenic provinces (Tapajós), transcurrent basins (Carajás, Aquiri, São Félix, etc), old terrains
(Cupixi) and high metamorphic degree terrains (Bacajá)
– 171 –
Geochemical characterization of the Eastern Amazonas public water supply system
among others. In the extreme Eastern part of the region,
the São Luis Craton and the Gurupi belt deserve special
attention. Surrounding the Cratonic areas, are Paleozoic
sedimentary basins, such as the Amazon and Parnaíba
Basins. A large area is covered by Quaternary sedimentary
layers related to the main water bodies and the coastal
zone (Faraco et al. 2004).
The River Amazon and its largest tributaries constitute the studied region’s main hydrographic system. In
Amapá State, the Oiapoque and Araguari rivers are the
most important, as in the States of Maranhão-Piauí, the
Gurupi/Parnaíba system.
The highest population density levels are situated in
the Eastern portion of the studied region with an emphasis
on the Southern border too, and along certain stretches
of the main waterways and highways. In the remaining
regions a great demographic emptiness predominates,
particularly on the left margin of the River Amazon. As a
consequence, in those regions where the human concentrations are higher, the main economic activities are also
established: mining, metallurgy, timber industry, farming
and cattle breeding, fishing and trade.
The studied area has a precarious basic sanitation
system, even in the large cities. Malaria, leprosy and leish-
maniasis are endemic to the region and several water born
diseases and/or alimentary propagation (vermin, hepatitis,
diarrhea, etc.) reach high incidence rates (DATASUS).
OBTAINED RESULTS
The program Statistic was used for the statistical
calculations and the software ArcView 3.2 for the maps.
For result interpretations the standards used (chemical
elements maximum concentrations in water for human
consumption) were those established by the National
Environmental Council (CONAMA Resolution 357, March
17, 2005) and the Ministry of Health (Resolution 518,
March 29, 2004) and the values recommended by the
WHO (World Health Organization – WHO, 2004).
Block I – Northeast of the state of Pará
This block covers approximately 50,000 km², about
80% forming the Northeastern region of Pará and the
remainder the Northwestern portion of Maranhão State
(Figure 2). This is the most densely inhabited Pará
State region, served by a good logistic infra-structure
and with an economy based on farming and fishing
activities.
Figure 2 – Simplified geological map of Block I Northeast Pará State (CPRM/Projeto GIS do Brasil, Faraco et al. 2004).
– 172 –
Edesio M. Buenano Macambira
From a geological point of view, the greatest portion of
Block I is occupied by the Barreiras Group (sandstone, siltites
and claystones). The São Luis Craton is found in the Gurupi
region (granites and a metavolcanic sedimentary sequence).,
There are sedimentary units distributed in the region, such
as the Guamá Sandstone, Itapeçuru Formation and intrusive
granites (Tracuateua, Nei-Peixoto, Cantão, Japiim, Oca, etc).
Along the main water courses and in the coastal zone, there
is the Quaternary sedimentary cover (Figure 2).
The sampling sites are shown in Figure 2. Of the
31 analyzed elements and chemical compounds, As
(<0.01 mg/L), Mo (<0.005 mg/L), Se (<0.02 mg/L), V
(<0.02 mg/L), Be (<0.001 mg/L) and NO2 (=0.1 mg/L)
had results below the analytical method’s detection
limit and therefore were not submitted to statistical calculations. The elements Cd (<0.001 mg/L), Co (<0.002
mg/L), Cr (0.02 mg/L), Ni (0.004 mg/L), Ti (0.05 mg/L)
and PO4 (0.2 mg/L) also had more than 90% of their
results below the analytical method’s detection limit,
being interpreted only visually. The other elements
were submitted to statistical calculations and the main
parameters are shown in Table 1.
Table 1 - Statistical parameters – Block I – Northeast Pará / Northwest Maranhão
Element
Population
Minimum Value
Maximum Value
Mean
Standard
deviation
Max. Value permitted for Class I fresh water
- Resolution CONAMA 357
Al
59
0.005
1.8
0.2043
0.3033
0.1 mg/L
As
59
0.005
0.005
0.005
0
0.01 mg/L
B5
9
0.001
2
0.1331
0.3118
0.5 mg/L
Ba
59
0.001
0.163
0.0228
0.0372
0.7 mg/L
Be
59
0.0005
0.0005
0.0005
0
0.04 mg/L
Ca
59
0.1
60.05
77.517
125.985
10 a 100 mg/L **
Cd
59
0.0005
0.002
0.0006
0.0004
0.001 mg/L
Co
59
0.001
0.004
0.0011
0.0004
0.05 mg/L
Cr
59
0.01
0.03
0.0108
0.0034
0.05 mg/L
Cu
59
0.001
0.05
0.009
0.0088
0.009 mg/L
Fe
59
0.002
6.66
0.3614
10.445
0.3 mg/L
K
59
0.1
101
41.441
134.763
12 mg/L **
Li
59
0.001
0.02
0.0027
0.0036
2.5 mg/L
Mg
59
0.09
15.27
22.615
29.889
1 a 40 mg/L **
Mn
59
0.001
0.223
0.038
0.0608
0.1 mg/L
Mo
59
0.0025
0.0025
0.0025
0
0.07 mg/L **
Na
57
0.1
42
9.456
10.512
200 mg/L *
Ni
59
0.002
0.015
0.003
0.0026
0.025 mg/L
Pb
59
0.0025
1.45
0.17
0.3146
0.01 mg/L
Se
59
0.01
0.01
0.01
0
0.01 mg/L
Sr
59
0.001
0.652
0.0545
0.1105
1 mg/L **
Ti
59
0.025
0.06
0.0256
0.0046
***
V
59
0.01
0.01
0.01
0
0.1 mg/L
Zn
59
0.001
0.274
0.044
0.0681
0.18 mg/L
Br*
58
0.025
0.81
0.0626
0.1059
0.025 mg/L *
Cl
57
1.58
61.63
11.41
12.296
250 mg/L
F
58
0.005
0.75
0.0594
0.1035
1.4 mg/L
58
0.05
0.05
0.05
0
1.0 mg/L
PO4
58
0.1
1.4
0.1466
0.2121
0.1 mg/L
SO4-
58
0.4
38.4
47.638
67.064
250 mg/L
PH
59
4
7.5
52.136
0.8653
de 6 a 9
NO
2
-3
* set by the Ministry of Health, Resolution nº 518, de 25/03/04 ; ** World Health Organization (WHO, 2004). Values in mg/L or ppm; *** The max.
Values for Ti were not obtained.
– 173 –
Geochemical characterization of the Eastern Amazonas public water supply system
The following considerations are presented based
on the above information:
· The sedimentary units represented by the Barreiras
Group, Itapecuru Formation, Guamá sandstone and
Quaternary alluvial deposits form the largest aquifers
in the region, due to the great territorial extension,
thickness and permo-porosity index. In the other units
(granite zone, Gurupi belt and São Luís Craton) the
possibility of aquifers is limited, being restricted to
fracture zones (Figure 2).
· Among the analyzed elements, the As, Ba, Be, Ca,
Co, Cr, Li, Mg, Mo, Na, Ni, Se, Sr, Ti, V, Cl and F and
the compounds NO2 and SO4 had results in the range
considered fit for human consumption according to the
CONAMA, MS and OMS standards mentioned earlier.
· The Al, B, Cd, Cu, Fe, K, Mn, Pb, Zn and PO4 presented
results higher than the above referred standards indicating them as unsuitable for human consumption.
· In about 80% of the study area, the Al and the Pb
presented inadequate values for human consumption
(Al=0.1 mg/L; Pb=0.01 mg/L). The highest Al content
was of 1.8 mg/L, equal to 18 times the maximum permitted limit, and for Pb, the highest value was of 1.45
which is 145 times the tolerated limit. There is no perfect
correlation with the geographical distribution of the two
elements (Figure 3).
· The Cu values inadequate for human consumption
(>0.009 mg/L) occupy about 60% of the studied area,
particularly the Eastern portion (Figure 3).
· The water for the Western portion public supply (Figure
3) is characterized by Fe values exceeding the permitted limit for human consumption (0.3 mg/L).
· Zn, B, Mn and K presented small areas with inadequate
contents for human consumption. These areas are
spread throughout the study area and apparently there
is no correlation with the mentioned elements.
· Cd and PO4 presented point values distributed over
the whole studied region in this Block. For Cd, 3
samples were detected that presented values of 0.002
mg/L, which is higher than those permitted for human
consumption (0.001 mg/L). Contents of 0.7 mg/L and
0.9 mg/L PO4 were also observed. These values are
higher than those permitted for human consumption
(0.1 mg/L).
· With regards to the pH, 90% of the values lay between
4 and 6, characterizing acidic to slightly acidic water.
In only 8 samples the confirmed values lay between 6
and 7.5, which is within the acceptable pH range according to CONAMA (6 to 9).
· Fitting the anomalous values in the geological context
the geochemical anomalies are found in the 4 mapped
domains. The Sedimentary Domain encompasses the
largest number of anomalous samples, possibly as a
consequence of its larger geographical occurrence.
In regional terms the background trends for Al and
Pb coincide with the NNW orientation, parallel to the
Gurupi belt.
Block II – Pará-Maranhão / Block III – Tocantins-Piauí
The research area occupies approximately 9,300
km2, about 2/3 of which is in Maranhão State and the rest
in Tocantins (Figure 1). It is a relatively inhabited area (25
to 100 inhabitants/km2), served by a good logistical infrastructure and with an economy based on agricultural and
cattle breeding activities.
It is situated in the North-West portion of the Parnaíba
Basin (Figure 4). The oldest stratigraphic unit is the Mosquito Formation (Jurassic), made up of basalt sheets, covered
by the Corda Formation, considered to have the greatest
territorial extension and represented by sandstones, and
red shales. Above them are the Grajaú and Codó Formations, both Cretaceous and interbedded. The Grajaú
Formation is composed of sandstones while the Codó by
shales, limestones and sandstones. The Itapecuru follows,
also of Cretaceous age, made up mainly by sandstones
and claystones. In the Northeastern portion of the studied
area, the detritic and/or lateritic cover predominate whereas
alluvial deposits are found along the river bodies.
10 public water supply samples were collected
(Figure 4).
The field work and the analytical results lead to the
following considerations:
· About 80% of the studied region is made up of sedimentary units, the formations Corda, Itapecuru and
Grajaú highlighted as excellent aquifers.
· The elements B, Be, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo,
Na, Ni, Pb, Sr, SO, Zn, F and Cl presented results below
the maximum permitted value for human consumption
according to current Brazilian environmental laws.
· Ba presented the most samples with inadequate contents for human consumption.
· Al presented all results equal to the lowest limit of the
analytical method (0.1 mg/L), which coincides with the
maximum permitted content for human consumption,
except for one sample collected in Imperatriz that had
0.2 mg/L. A similar coincidence was confirmed for As,
Cd, Cu, Se, V, Br and PO.
· Of the samples collected in the municipal seats, only
those from Ribamar Freire were found concentrations
low enough for human consumption.
· Plotting the sampled sites on a geological basis, with
their respective results – those with values inadequate
for human consumption – there is no correlation between the elements with the various stratigraphic units.
· Although below the maximum permitted values by environmental laws, the Itaguatins water supply precipitates
a white powder on the bottom of the aluminum pan
when it is boiled. This material was analyzed at UFPA
with the following results: Aragonite (69%), Magnesian
Calcite (9%) and Cesarolite (8%).
– 174 –
Edesio M. Buenano Macambira
Figure 3 – Variation on the content of Pb, Al, Fe, Cu, Zn, Mn, B and K in in the water supply system in the Block I – Northeast of the Pará State.
– 175 –
Geochemical characterization of the Eastern Amazonas public water supply system
Figure 4 – Geological Map of the Southern region of Tocantins State and the Western part of Maranhão State
(CPRM/Projeto GIS do Brasil, Faraco et al . 2004).
Block V – Altamira
In this block only two water supply samples were
collected. The studied area is situated in the Lower Amazonas Basin, mainly in the Altér do Chão Formation region
(Cretaceous-Tertiary). Lithologically it is similar to the Barreiras Group and is represented by layers of sandstones,
siltites and claystones. It presents a high permo-porosity
which is why it constitutes an excellent aquifer. The studied region is situated on the River Tocantins right bank
presenting good logistic facilities with its economy based
on agricultural and cattle breeding activities. It has a low
population density (2 to 5 inhabitants/km²).
Based on the studies, the following considerations
were established:
· The contents of the elements B, Ba, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe,
K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Pb, Sr, V, Zn, Be, F, Cl and
SO4 presented results below the limits established for
human consumption.
· In all samples, the results of Al, As and Cd presented
contents that coincide with the analytical inferior limit
and with the maximum content permitted by CONAMA
Resolution 357/2005 and the Ministry of Health Ordinance 518/2004.
· The contents of Cu, Se, Br and PO4 exceeded those
permitted for human consumption.
· Generally speaking, the water sample contents in both
municipalities are similar, principally for the elements
whose values are above the allowed standards.
Block IX – Santarém
The sampling studies (4 samples) were made in
partnership with the HIBAM Project. The studied region is
situated in the States of Pará and Amazonas border zone.
The sample collection sites are situated in the Middle
Amazonas Basin, predominantly in the Quaternary alluvial
deposit regions related to the Amazon and Tapajós Rivers. These are sandy and clayish sediments, with high
permo-porosity and constitute excellent aquifers. Among
the sampled towns, Santarém stands out for its greater
population and economic development. However, all
towns present good logistic facilities, the economy based
on agricultural and cattle breeding activities and they all
have a low population density.
Based on the results the following considerations
are made:
· The contents of elements B, Ba, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe, K, Li,
Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Sr, V, Zn, Be, F, Cl and SO4 were
below the limits established for human consumption.
· For As and Cd, the contents found are coincident
with the limits established by the environmental legislation for human consumption and the analytical
inferior limit.
· In most samples, the elements Al, Cu, Pb, Se, Br and
PO4 presented contents that exceeded those permitted
for human consumption.
· It was confirmed that all samples presented excessive
contents for human consumption for the elements Se,
– 176 –
Edesio M. Buenano Macambira
PO4 and Br. However the sample collected in Santarém
presented the greatest number of elements harmful to
health, because in addition to those already mentioned,
Al and Pb were also confirmed. In Curuá the Cu content was higher than the maximum permitted value for
human consumption.
CONSIDERATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
The 4 studied areas are good representations of the
Amazon region environmental and hydrogeologic systems
as its 4 main aquifers were targeted: Corda, Grajaú, Codó
and Itapecuru Formations, in the Parnaíba Basin; Altér
do Chão Formation in the Amazon Basin; and Barreiras
Group, Itapecuru Formation, Guamá Sandstone and
Quaternary fluvial and marine deposits.
The economy of these regions is mainly based on
agricultural activities, cattle breeding, fishing and the
forest products extraction. The population density is less
than 100 inhabitants/km². In this region, endemic diseases
transmitted through water and food, such as vermin, digestive system diseases and dental caries predominate.
Frequent cases of anemia, hepatitis, malaria and malnutrition are also observed.
The supply systems are usually shallow tubular
wells (<100m). In some cases the water consumded by
the population is canalized directly from rivers. In most
towns the supplied water receives no kind of treatment
and chlorination is made in just a few towns.
These conclusions are based on the results obtained:
1. Block I
The results showed that the elements As, Ba, Be,
Ca, Co, Cr, Li, Mg, Mo, Na, Ni, Se, Sr, Ti, V, Cl and F, and
the NO2 and SO4 compounds had concentrations below
the maximum values for human consumption (CONAMA
Resolution 357/2005, Ordinance MS 518/2004 and/or
WHO/1993). The elements Al, B, Cd, Cu, Fe, K, Mn, Pb,
Zn and PO4 had contents exceeding the standards mentioned above, indicating it unfit for human consumption.
Regarding the toxicity, the elements Al and Pb presented respectively, contents of up to 18 times and 145
times the maximum permitted value by environmental
laws. In the literature no quotations with such high values
of Pb in a potable water supply were found. These elements occur in about 80% of the studied region, however
there is not a good geochemical correlation among them/
with each other. The elements Fe and Cu also showed
concentrations exceeding that permitted for human
consumption.
The region’s enormous area, allied to the magnitude of the results for Al, Pb, Fe and Cu, substantiate
the supposition that there is a natural origin for these
contents. The other elements (Zn, B, Mn, K, Cd and
PO4) are distributed in small areas or present point val-
ues, which may also suggest possible anthropogenic
contamination.
The pH presented values from 4 to 6 indicating an
acidic nature in 90% of the studied area. These values
are considered inappropriate for human consumption and
may be related to the intense decomposition of organic
substances and high regional rainfall, evapotranspiration
and lixiviation.
Augusto Correa town presented the largest number
of elements noxious to health (Al, Pb, Cu, Fe, Zn, B and
Cd). In second place are the towns of Cachoeira do Piriá
(Pb, Cu, Zn) and Boa Vista do Gurupi (PO4 and Mn).
2. Block II and III
The results of Block II and III confirmed the contents
of B, Be, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Pb,
Sr, SO4, Zn, F and Cl were adequate for consumption.
The elements Al, As, Ba, Cd, Cu, Se, V, Br and PO4 had
concentrations unfit for human consumption, The element
Ba was present in the largest number of samples with
contents exceeding the permitted level by environmental
legislation. Among the town water supplies sampled, only
Ribamar Freire had no contents inadequate for human
consumption.
3. Block V
The samples from Block V presented contents of
B, Ba, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Pb, Sr,
V, Zn, Be, F, Cl and SO4 below the maximum permitted
limits for human consumption. The elements Al, As and
Cd had levels equal to the maximum values determined
by CONAMA and MS. The concentrations of Cu, Se, Br
and PO4 exceeded the maximum permitted value for human consumption.
4. Block IX
In Block IX, the elements B, Ba, Ca, Co, Cr, Fe, K, Li,
Mg, Mn, Mo, Na, Ni, Sr, V, Zn, Be, F, Cl and SO4 presented
values appropriate for consumption. For As and Cd, the
contents were coincident with the limits established by
legislation and with the analytical inferior limit. For Al,
Cu, Pb, Se, Br and PO4, however, the concentrations
exceeded the standards established for consumption.
The town of Santarém presented the largest number of
elements with inappropriate concentrations for human
consumption: Al, Pb, Se, PO4 and Br.
At this stage of the study it is difficult to determine the
source of cations, particularly those which presented contents above the maximum permitted value by CONAMA
and the Ministry of Health. Due to the erratic nature of the
results of the elements and anomalous values, the possibility of a systematic sampling error can be eliminated.
One of the Pb anomalies of Block I was analyzed by another method (Atomic Absorption) confirming the value
obtained with ICP/AES; as a consequence, the possibility
– 177 –
Geochemical characterization of the Eastern Amazonas public water supply system
of analytical errors are rejected. In the sampled sites there
were no landfills, industries, sewage or other contamination sources, which reduces the possibility of a localized
environmental contamination. In the face of the results the
elevated contents of several elements found in the public
supply systems are related to natural aspects, especially
to hydrogeologic factors.
In Block I, where the greatest volume of work was
done, the main aquifer is the Barreiras Group, lithologically
made up of sandstones, siltites and claystones with interbedded lenses rich in organic matter. According to recent
studies by Miranda (2004) the source areas of these sediments would be located in the Tocantins-Araguaia zone,
the Borborema province with its gneissic and migmatitic
complexes, the Gurupi Group (neoproterozoic granites
and greenstone terrains) and the Carajás province, mainly
composed of granitoids.
All the elements (Al, B, Cd, Cu, Fe, K, Mn, Pb, Zn and
P) that presented content levels above those permitted
by legislation may well proceed from the source areas
mentioned. Therefore these elements, according to their
geochemical properties, could be associated with the different geochemical-stratigraphic conditions present in the
Barreiras Aquifer, for example: the rich levels of organic
matter, adsorbed in the clay, forming compounds with the
oxides and hydroxides, making a coating on the different
minerals. The acidic pH would facilitate the solubilization
of compounds with the metals. In this way the elements
would be easily incorporated in the groundwater caught
by the public supply systems and may be causing several
health problems, such as the large number of digestive
system cancer cases that occur in Pará State (the largest
in Brazil) made public by the Public Health Secretary of
Pará State - Secretaria de Saúde Pública do Pará.
One of the contributions of this study is to warn governmental authorities about the occurrence of elements
harmful to human health, in potable water supplied to
the populations of various cities. These contents exceed
those levels permitted by CONAMA (2005) and the Ministry of Health (2004). Complementary and multidisciplinary
studies in partnership with specialists from the medical
field are necessary, to confirm any influence of these
anomalous contents on public health, to adopt preventive
measures to avoid future endemic diseases.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BRASIL. Ministério da Saúde. Portaria no 518 de 25 de
março de 2004. Diário Oficial [da] República Federativa do Brasil, Poder Executivo, Brasília, DF, 26
mar. 2004. Seção I, p.266.
BRASIL. Ministério do Meio Ambiente. CONAMA.
Resolução No 357 de 17 mar. 2005. Disponível
em:<http://www.mma.gov.br/port/conama/res/res05/
res35705.pdf>. Acesso em: janeiro 2006.
FARACO M.T.L.; MARINHO P.A.C.; VALE A.G. Folha SC.22
– Tocantins. In: SCHOBBENHAUS C., GONÇALVES,
J.H.; SANTOS, J.O.S.; ABRAM, M.B.; LEÃO NETO,
R.; MATOS, G.M.M.; VIDOTTI, R.M. (Eds.). Carta
Geológica do Brasil ao Milionésimo. Programa Levantamentos Geológicos Básicos do Brasil. Brasília
: CPRM-SGB, 2004. 41 CD-ROM, CD-ROM 22/41.
MIRANDA, L. da C.P. Proveniência de arenitos da Formação
Barreiras (Mioceno), região de Ipixuna, com base em
análise de minerais pesados e datação de grãos de
zircão por evaporação de chumbo. 2004. 1 CD-ROM.
Trabalho de Conclusão de Curso - Centro de Geociências, Universidade Federal do Pará, Belém, 2004.
WHO-WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. 2004. Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality. 3ed., v.1. Disponível
em:<http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/
dwq/>. Acesso em: abril 2005.
– 178 –
CHEM ICAL ELEM ENTS
IN THE PUBLIC WATER
SUPPLY IN CEARÁ
STATE BRAZIL
Sergio João Frizzo; frizzo@fo.cprm.gov.br
Brazilian Geological Survey of Brazil - CPRM/FO
INTRODUCTION
Regarding human and animal health, water carries many Regarding human and animal health, water
carries many chemical components that are easily
absorbed by their body cells. Many are beneficial and
essential to life (Ca, K, Mg, Fe, etc.). Others (F, Se,
Mo, Cr, etc.) can bring benefit or toxicity depending
on their respective concentrations in drinking water.
As, Pb, Hg and Cd, however, do not play any known
physiological roles, being toxic especially for the renal
and nervous systems.
The intoxication usually happens through a prolonged intake of toxic substances (chronic exposure),
or indirectly, through the consumption of organisms that
absorbed such substances from water and concentrated
them. For instance, there are cases of intoxication with
arsenic in the water consumed by populations in China,
India, Mexico, Chile and Argentina, affecting thousands
of people (Scarpelli, 2003); the poisoning of a population through the consumption of fish contaminated with
mercury from industrial effluents dumped into Minamata
Bay, in Japan (Kudo et al., 1998) and the frequent intoxi-
cation cases among the inhabitants of Fungang, Japan,
due to rice consumption from paddy fields irrigated with
cadmium rich waters from the River Shentong, that passes
through zinc mining areas (Yama, 1987, apud Nian-Feng
et al., 2004).
The real dimension of the salubrity of consumption
water, that tends to worsen on a global level, is best assessed following the almost daily information about the
subject in the press.
In Ceará, only 470 of the territory’s 760 districts (forming 184 municipalities) have a water supply system and
in 154 of them there is no treatment at all. The remaining
290 districts have alternative supplies, such as tubular
wells, hand-dug wells, fountains, water bowsers , etc
(IBGE, 2005). The state public agencies and distribution companies are only concerned about the quality of
consumption water regarding the presence of pathogenic
microorganisms and salinity. The concentration of known
toxic chemical elements, that may be imperceptibly corroding the population’s health, is neither identified in a
systematic nor even on a sporadic basis.
This article presents a summary of the study developed by Frizzo (2006). There are also some observations
– 179 –
Chemical elements in the public water supply in Ceará State Brazil
on the results of chemical element analyses in water
samples from dams, springs, rivers and wells that are the
main public sources of cities in Ceará State. This study
seeks to confirm the water quality on-site before treatment
and distribution. It is part of the National Program for Environmental Geochemistry and Medical Geology Research
(PGAGEM) being developed by the Brazilian Geological Survey - Serviço Geológico do Brasil – CPRM. This
program had the support of the National Water Agency
(ANA), through the partnership between ANA/CPRM.
PGAGEM aims to study the relationships between the
chemistry of geological occurrences and their influence
on the environment and public health.
THE WATER IN CEARÁ
According to IBGE and SUDENE (1966), Ceará State
has a great abundance and wide distribution of surface
water. It is a mixed type of Bicarbonate and Sodium Bicarbonate, occurring respectively in the North and South
of the State and in the region close to Fortaleza (capital
of Ceará); mixed chlorinated which occurs in the State
territory center, in a zone extending to the North coast
and another almost until the Northeast coast; Sodium
chlorinated and mixed sodium in the West-centre of the
State. The potability (based on the main cations concentrations and hardness) is good, except for a small basin
in the Alto River Banabuiú and with restrictions in the area
close the mouth of the River Jaguaribe of higher salinity.
For irrigation, the water is inadequate in the State central
region, in the Quixeramobim and Alto Banabuiú Rivers
and near the mouth of the River Jaguaribe, due to the
high content of dissolved salts (Figure 1a).
As for the groundwater, there is primary classification between fresh, brackish and salt, based on the
concentration of total dissolved solids (TDS). This is
calculated from the electric conductivity measured in
7,092 wells, among the more than 13,000 wells registered by the Ceará State Well Inventory Program carried out by CPRM in 1999 (CPRM, 1999). These results
delineate the known hydrogeologic provinces of the
State: Cenozoic, Mesozoic and Paleozoic sedimentary
coverings to the North (coast), to the South (Araripe
Plateau) and to the East (Ibiapaba Plateau – on the
border with Piauí State), respectively, where there is
predominance of fresh water wells, and the crystalline
basement, in the wide central region covering almost
the whole State, where brackish and salt groundwater
predominate (Figure 1b).
In spite of the great geologic diversity in the State
and the irregular territorial catchment sites distribution,
conditioned by economic, social or politic conveniences,
there is a logical relationship between the lithologies and
the water catchment types adopted as public supply
sources for the municipality seats.
The tubular and Amazon type wells are dominant
in land covered with unconsolidated sediments, sands,
clays and gravel from the Quaternary. Several tubular type
wells that supply the municipalities are also registered
in the sandstones and siltites of the Neogenic Barreiras
Group; in sandstones, siltites and shales from the many
Mesozoic geological formations and also in sandstones
and conglomerates of Silurian age.
A minority of wells, less than 60 m deep, occur in the
Proterozoic and Archean crystalline rock domain; these
domains have a varied mineral composition and, generally
do not favor groundwater circulation that happens through
fracture systems, with a high content of dissolved salts.
In surface water streams the water composition has
the contribution of solubilized material from the whole
hydrographic basin upstream from the sampling site,
and has a more important seasonal variation (due to differences of flow, variable rain fall in the area of influence,
etc.) than that found in the groundwater. Regarding the
river catchment samples, the highest number occur in
belts of sand, gravel and the Quaternary unconsolidated
clay, perennial river alluvial deposits.
Dams and lakes are the State’s main public water
sources; the waster should also reflect the river basin’s
composition that originates them, with intermediary variations due to seasonality. They are established preferably
on crystalline terrains made up of ancient igneous and
sedimentary rocks affected by metamorphic processes:
granites, granodiorites, ortho and paragneisses, metabasic rocks, quartzites, micaschists, limestones, Phyllites
etc that compose several stratigraphic units positioned
in the Proterozoic and Archean.
WORK METHODOLOGY
Most of the 184 municipalities and 46 districts that
were visited (area exceeding 1,000 km²) have their water
supply from dams (130) and tubular wells of different
depths and yields (51), wells of the amazon type (28) and
direct intake from rivers (20) and springs (4) have also
been registered (Figure 2). In some towns, the catchment
system is mixed, composed of tubular + amazon wells
or amazon wells + direct stream intake. At the time the
sampling was made, Ibaretama was being supplied by
water bowser and in Sucatinga, a Beberibe district, the
wells are individual domestic. When the catchment unit
installation was common for several towns and districts,
the corresponding number of samples were taken from
that common site.
The samples were collected in plastic containers, at
the sites (wells and springs) or near the suction pumps
(in dams and rivers), always situated before the treatment stations, pre-distribution. From that container 50ml
volumes were separated in two appropriate containers,
using a disposable syringe connected to a 0.45mm “Mil-
– 180 –
Sergio João Frizzo
Figure 1 – Characteristics of water in Ceará.
– 181 –
Chemical elements in the public water supply in Ceará State Brazil
lipore” membrane filter. One volume was acidulated with
10 drops of superpure HNO3 for the cations analyses.
During the field stage the samples were kept refrigerated.
The cations analyses were made through Atomic
Emission Spectrometry with plasma source (ICP-AES)
in the CPRM and EMBRAPA laboratories and the anions
analyses, through Ionic Chromatograph in the Chemistry
Institute of UFRJ (Federal University of Rio de Janeiro) and
in the Water Laboratory of PUC-RJ (Catholic University
of Rio de Janeiro). The concentrations of cations Al, As,
B, Ba, Be, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Li, Mg, Mn, Mo, Na,
Ni, Pb, Se, Sr, Ti, V and Z and anions Br, Cl, F, NO2, NO3,
PO4 and SO4 were evaluated.
Maps of the geographical distribution of those elements’ concentration that presented sufficient results
amplitude were generated. In Figures 3 and 4 are the
results for some selected elements, whose higher values
are likely to be originated from pollution or contamination
and from the substrate’s lithology, respectively.
RESULTS
Tdoes not reach the reference values of CONAMA
(2005). The elements V, Cr, Ti, Mo and Be were not studied because they had less than 3% of defined results
and all were inferior to the respective CONAMA (2005)
references.
Figure 2 – Water sampling sites in Ceará.
– 182 –
Sergio João Frizzo
Figure 3 – Results of the element distribution in Ceará public water supply.
– 183 –
Chemical elements in the public water supply in Ceará State Brazil
Figure 4 – Result of the element distribution in Ceará public water supply.
– 184 –
Sergio João Frizzo
A small set of samples were collected at the same
sites before and after the annual rain period. This permitted the assessment that the temporal variation has little
effect and reflects the processes of rain water flowing into
the streams. This results in the dilution of components in
the dams and rivers and increases the contents in groundwater due to the dissolution of salts during infiltration and
percolation to the aquifers.
The downstream-upstream and lateral compositional
differences and similarities that express the represented
environment homogeneity were estimated with samples
from the same water bodies, sampled at short distances
from each other. It was confirmed the content variation
is almost inexistent for the elements that are solubilized
and somewhat divergent for those transported preferably
as colloids. In the rivers the variations are greater than in
dams. These small variations seem to be episodic and
from sources of little expression as to their origin or they
are situated far away, which may weaken an expressive
geological origin. Such variations are, nonetheless, the
essence for local environmental studies.
Among the elements most noxious to human health
that may not be retained during the conventional treatment
(Angino, apud Thornton, 1983, p.171), highlighted are the
high values for Cd and Pb (0.02 and 0.465 mg/L, respectively) found in the Gavião dam water that supplies several
towns of the Metropolitan Region of Fortaleza (capital of
Ceará State) (Figure 3). In the 4 samples from this dam,
one contained a Pb content above the CONAMA (2005)
reference value and in the other 3, Cd occurred within the
limit determined by the legislation. These concentrations
probably proceed from atmospheric pollution, as the
Gavião dam is close to several towns with important and
diversified industrial areas (Fortaleza, Eusébio, Itaitinga,
Maracanaú and Horizonte).
The higher results for Br and Cl (7.67 and 4,012 mg/L,
respectively) were found in the Buenos Aires dam sample,
the water catchment for Catarina the State center-South
region and the anions F and PO4 values both exceed
the CONAMA maximum levels. Anthropogenic pollution
is the most likely source for this contamination. Brome
merits being highlighted because almost 88% of the
Ceará State public water supply samples had elevated
concentrations, considered a risk to human health, with
values between 0.03 and the maximum of 7.67 mg/L,
already mentioned.
The water from the Salitre deep tubular well (far
South-West of the State) contains 2.56 mg/L Brome from
a natural lithological source, influenced by the Santana
Formation evaporite saline deposits. On the other hand,
in the other samples this anion must come from secondary pollution sources (anthropogenic), due to the brome
derivatives found in fuel, herbicides, insecticides, paints
and pharmaceutical preparations. The purification treatment itself for potable water can introduce or increase this
element in the consumption chain, since there is evidence
that commercial products such as sodium hypochlorite
solutions contain brome as a contaminant (Thompson &
Megonnell, 2003).
For nitrates (NO3), the highest result was 599 mg/L,
recorded for the tubular well water sample that supplies
the Marrecas community, Tauá district, South-West of
the State. There is another record of 59 mg/L NO3 for
the amazon type water well also used by the population.
Both have high associated Br, Cd and PO4 values. Of
course, there is no relationship with the region’s lithologies, paragneisses with Proterozoic granitoids. Nitrogen
compounds are commonly used in fertilizers, which are
the main regional sources of surface and groundwater
pollution. In the mentioned places, however, the likely
contamination of the aquifer comes from inadequate
sewage systems.
In Cococi, Parambu, in the far South=West of Ceará,
a tubular well sample had the highest result for zinc –
0.768 mg/L. There are occurrences of shales, claystones
and calciferous siltites of the Cococi Formation, Rio Jucá
Group, attributed to the Cambro-Ordovician period. With
a somewhat lower content, the sample collected from
the Lagoa dos Monteiros well, that supplies Jijoca de
Jericoacoara on the North coast region, registered 0.736
mg/L for the metal, together with several other elements
with values above the respective reference levels; the
local ground is composed of clay sandstones with conglomeratic lenses and lateritic nodules of the Neogen
Barreiras Group. Though this is a common element in
rock accessories, in these cases, the high Zn concentrations are probably due to contamination through the very
material used for building the wells, as this metal is used
in the galvanization of steel pipes and ducts.
Of the elements related mainly to the lithological
composition (Figure 4), aluminum presented the smallest detection, having an irregular distribution in the State
territory; the results that stand out occur mainly in dams
and rivers. The highest content (0.8 mg/L) was found
in the River Patu, that supplies Mineirolândia, district of
Pedra Branca, associated with a high iron content. This
stream cuts across Archean rocks of the Cruzeta Complex, gneisses and migmatites, quartzites, limestones,
ferriferous formations and calcissilicates. The weathering
of these rocks may result in these high detected values,
with the release of clays and fluvial colloids.
Water containing barium in concentrations of 5.588
(highest value) and 1.727 mg/L come from tubular wells
that supply the towns of Jijoca de Jericoacoara and Cruz,
about 20 km to the East, respectively. The local land is
composed of clay sandstones of the Barreiras Group,
which suggests a possible relationship with local facies
of this lithological unit.
The most elevated result for iron (12.19 mg/L) was
found in the amazon well sample that supplies Pacoti,
– 185 –
Chemical elements in the public water supply in Ceará State Brazil
about 100 km South-West of the capital. The highest
value for manganese (1.204 mg/L) was obtained in a
tubular well sample in Santana do Acaraú, North of the
State. The association Fe-Mn confirmed in the elements
distribution maps, is typical of colloidal oxides-hydroxides
that may contain other adsorbed ions, from oxidization in
the aquifer fluctuation level zone.
Magnesium, as well as K and Ca, with which it is
strongly related, is essential to life and has no content
restriction in water. The highest result (65.5 mg/L) was
found in the a tubular well sample in Cipó dos Anjos,
Quixadá district; it indicates the Eastern limit of a magnesium enriched stripe that extends 100 km towards the
North-West. Here 42.14 mg/L was measured in Choró
(Choró Limão dam), 45.16 mg/L in Madalena (amazon
well) and 51.76 mg/L in a tubular well sample in Itatira.
Although the rocks that occur in these sites are varied,
it suggests a lithogenic origin, as this element is a
product of the weathering of a wide range of rock forming minerals (amphiboles, piroxenes, biotites, clorites,
dolomites, etc).
For fluorine, the highest registered content was 6.29
mg/L in a tubular well sample part of the Santana do
Acaraú supply system, North Ceará. The likelihood is a
lithogenic origin, either through enrichment in alkaline facies of the Parapuí volcanic rocks or through circulating
hydrothermal fluids in faults and fractures. This is due to a
confirmed fluorite occurrence 120km to the SW, following
the wide fault system that cuts across the area. Fluorine
being an essential element, the World Health Organization
recommends it be added during the potability treatment,
when the contents are inferior to 0.4 mg/L in the water
supplies. The fluorine distribution map shows this is the
case for almost all (about 90%) of the supply sources of
the Ceará State municipalities.
In short and considering all the evaluated elements,
the public water supply of 211 communities out of the
230 visited, (91%) contained at least 1 element in a level
exceeding that recommended, and in 49 (21%), there are
3 or more elements in the same situation.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
This study sought to determine the existence or not
of heavy metals in the Ceará State public water supply.
The results convincingly portray a serious situation, not
only because of the elevated levels of known toxic elements but also due to the quantity and amplitude of the
samples’ distribution that contains them throughout the
State territory.
However it is too soon at present to claim these water
supply sources inadequate for human consumption. In
addition to factors such as concentration, local variations
in the same water body and the persistence of the high
values over prolonged periods, the individual chemical
speciation also has to be taken into account (state of
oxidization /valence). This affects the respective mobility
and bioavailability and impacts their risk evaluation (Centeno, oral communication, International Medical Geology
Workshop, 2005).
These results, though consistent, must be considered as clues. They indicate the water is inadequate for
human consumption but more studies are necessary to
confirm this data and characterize the Ceará State water
supply throughout the whole territory. It is important to
carry out detailed work and systematic monitoring at
those sites with result tendencies that negatively influence
the inhabitants’ health. The aim would be to identify the
original contamination source (natural or anthropogenic)
and confirm if these factors persist in the local environment so as to remediate it. If the evidence is confirmed,
the public health authorities must be immediately warned
to carry out epidemiological studies as well as appropriate toxicological examinations of the population in risk
situations.
The governmental agencies should also control
mineral water quality. This is mostly from groundwater prone to enrichment by toxic elements and sold
in 20-liter bottles that usually have no treatment or
purification prior to distribution. Official data (DNPM,
2005) indicates a production of 115,609,000 liters of
mineral water in Ceará in 2004. This represents about
5.7 million 20-liter water bottles; in current compulsory
characterization analyses, the identification of heavy
metals is not required.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
CPRM - Serviço Geológico do Brasil. Atlas dos recursos hídricos subterrâneos do Ceará: programa
recenseamento de fontes de abastecimento por
água subterrânea no estado do Ceará. Fortaleza:
CPRM – Residência de Fortaleza, 1999. 1 CDROM.
DEPARTAMENTO NACIONAL DE PRODUÇÃO MINERAL- DNPM. Anuário mineral brasileiro – parte
II: estatística estadual. [S.n.:s.l.], 2005. Disponível
em: <http://www.dnpm.gov.br/portal>. Acesso em:
1 dez. 2005.
FRIZZO, S. J. Elementos químicos (metais pesados)
em águas de abastecimento público no estado do
Ceará. Fortaleza: CPRM – Residência de Fortaleza,
2006. 67p.
IBGE. Superintendência de Desenvolvimento do Nordeste. Hidroquímica dos mananciais de superfície:
região Nordeste. [S.l.: s.n.], 1996. 1 mapa, color.
Com nota explicativa. Escala 1:2.500.000.
IBGE. Pesquisa nacional de saneamento básico. [S.l.:
s.n.], 2000. Disponível em: <http:// www,ibge.gov.br/
home/estatistica/populacao/condicaodevida/pnsb/
– 186 –
Sergio João Frizzo
abastecimento_de_agua/abagua12.shtm>. Acesso
em: 04 out. 2005.
KUDO, A. et al. Lessons from minamata mercury pollution,
Japan – after a continuous 22 years of observation.
Water Science and Technology, v.38, n.7, p. 187193, 1998.
NIAN-FENG LIN; JIE TANG; JIAN-MIN BIAN. Geochemical
environment and health problems in China. Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2004.
SCARPELLI, W. Introdução à geologia médica. São Paulo:
Universidade de São Paulo - Instituto de Geociências, 2003. Curso proferido na I FENAFEG.
THOMPSON, K.; MEGONNELL, N. Casebook: activated carbon – a media for bromate reduction?
Disponível em: http://www.pollutionengineering.com/
CDA/ArticleInformation/features/BNP__Features__
Item/0,6649,108123,00.html. Acesso em: 14 abr. 2005.
THORNTON, I. (Ed.). Applied environmental geochemistry. [S.l.]: Academic Press Inc., 1983.
– 187 –
CONTAM INATION
ASSESSM ENT OF POTABLE
WATER IN THE UFRN
(FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF
RIO GRANDE DO NORTE)
CAM PUS REGARDING
NITRATES FROM SEPTIC
TANKS
Reinaldo A. Petta, petta@geologia.ufrn.br
Ludmagna P. de Araújo, ludmagna@rn.gov.br
Raquel F. S. Lima, raquel@geologia.ufrn.br
Cynthia R. Duarte, cynthia@geologia.ufrn.br
Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte - UFRN
ABSTRACT
This study seeks to analyze the potable water quality
in the UFRN (Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte)
campus in Natal (capital of Rio Grande do Norte State).
60 water sampling sites were selected: the supply source
outlet of the Campus internal network and various drinking
fountains around the sector classrooms. The sampling
was made in May and June 2003, within the school
term. The water samples were chemically analyzed and
a databank built with information of the sampled sites, to
allow future monitoring and water quality management.
A Geographic Information System (GIS) was used to
visualize and integrate the results of nitrate concentrations
in the drinking water fountains. The contaminants were
identified and quantified together with their influence on
the water quality and visualize their spatial distribution.
This system is based on CAD cartographical plans of the
whole campus and a databank of existing contamination
contents. The study aims to provide a bases to discuss
the issues related to water quality vigilance and control.
The approach of this study is based on diverse
variables to characterize the critical points for possible
decision making. In the GIS, the inter-related information
plans included spatial data inherent to the water quality on
a map of permanent control sites. The monitoring program
standard values used were taken from environmental
control agencies based on the standards established by
– 188 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
the World Health Organization (WHO) and the National
Environmental Council - Conselho Nacional do Meio Ambiente (CONAMA).
To assess the water quality, the samples were submitted to nitrates and nitrites analyses, as well as total fecal
coliforms with the membrane filter technique; general
counting of heterotrophic mesophyll bacteria through
the Pour Plate technique, according to the Standards
Methods. In some locations, rests of organic matter in
suspension were visually identified, and based on the
evaluation of the 60 analyses, it was confirmed that the
nitrate contents of some sections are altered, for example,
in the Geology Laboratory, where contents above the
maximum permitted limit were found. The project also
implemented a digital cartographic map of the Campus
showing the permanent control sites, by academic block
and geo-referenced by GPS. This database contained
comprehensive information to allow a continuous and
systematic monitoring to take remedial precautions and
establish policies to control water potability and quality
standards in the UFRN Campus.
INTRODUCTION AND CONTEXT
Water pollution may be generated by (i) domestic effluents (biodegradable organic pollutants, nutrients and
bacteria), (ii) industrial effluents (organic and inorganic
pollutants, depending on the industrial activity) and (iii)
urban and rural diffuse discharges (pollutants drained
from fertilizers, pesticides and animal excrements).
There are contaminants that only affect the water’s
appearance, whereas others are not that obvious but
may cause serious health problems, for example, toxic
pesticides and coliform bacteria, in addition to nitrate
and nitrite ions.
In the spatial analysis of water contamination related
problems, the modern geo-processing technologies,
Global Positioning System (GPS) and Geographical
Information Systems came to the fore in recent years as
being very effective in potential risk identification of hydric
resources. They also facilitate long term monitoring of
pollution problems and the relationship between life and
health quality and the consumed water quality. GIS has
often been used to consolidate and analyze large health
and environmental data bases to bring new planning
subsidies and help administrative activities based on the
analysis and spatial distribution of the events, accurately
locating the environmental risks.
Geo-processing is, thus, a very useful organizational
tool for health and environmental strategic planning,
where continuous decision taking must prioritize actions
according to a given reality (Barcellos, 1998). Together,
the GIS and the created models, managed by a graphic
and friendly interface, form the most modern decision
support systems, which are being used evermore fre-
quently to plan and manage hydric and environmental
resources.
This study considered the GIS a suitable project
platform due to its interrelated information plans. These
included: a) an integrated spatial information database;
b) the university campus private water supply network;
c) its main springs and dams; d) the data of the Water
and Sewage Company - Companhia de Águas e Esgotos
do Rio Grande do Norte – CAERN; e) the water quality
standards; (provided by the state environmental control
agencies’ monitoring program, namely: 1) Institute for
Economical Development and the Environment (Instituto
de Desenvolvimento Econômico e Meio Ambiente do Rio
Grande do Norte) – IDEMA/RN, 2) the State Secretary for
Water Resources (Secretaria de Recursos Hídricos do
Rio Grande do Norte) – SERHID) and 3) the Municipal
Secretary for Urbanism and Environment (Secretaria
Especial do Meio Ambiente e Urbanismo) – SEMURB).
These were all represented in thematic maps through
permanent geo-referenced control sites/points.
The studied area geological context (the Federal
University of Rio Grande do Norte Campus) consists of
Quaternary sediments, typical of dunes, and sediments
from the Barreiras Group that, in turn, are covered by
Cretaceous sediments (Superior Mesozoic) detected
in some profiles. These are highly porous sediments,
composed of well selected grains giving the region high
permeability. The sand dunes/Barreiras aquifer structure
(which supplies the town of Natal) is varied, with high
permeability of the soil made up of eolic sands that present high infiltration rates.
Contamination due to inadequate, unplanned urban
occupation regarding soil, rivers and lacustrine ecosystems in the area surrounding the capital city of Natal, has
become a serious environmental problem. There is a distinct lack of a sewage system in much of Natal town, which
allows domestic effluents (disposed in septic tanks and
unprotected drains) to reach aquifer levels. This increases
the chances of groundwater contamination and the affected area has substantially increased in recent years,
impacting important supply sources for the population.
Currently, the Central Campus academic community
consists of 15,338 students, 3,605 employees and 1,523
professors concentrated in a 123 ha area, surrounded
by vast walls of coastal dunes on one side, and by the
access roads to downtown Natal, on the other (Figure 1).
The university campus is somewhat far from downtown, where the water should, theoretically, be less
polluted. However, this study will show all five supply
stations are already contaminated – inappropriate for
human consumption. The water from these wells is confirmed as inadequate for human consumption and shall
be used, from now on, only for washing laboratory glass
ware, cleaning physical space, irrigating gardens and
similar activities.
– 189 –
Contamination assessment of potable water in the UFRN (Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte) campus regarding nitrates from septic tanks
Figure 1 – Location of the studied area.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The water samples from the selected sites were
chemically analyzed and a data bank established with the
relevant information of the sites to allow future monitoring
and water quality management (Figure 2). This study was
based on different variables using the systemic, exact or
heuristic approach, among others, to characterize the
points considered critical for decision making.
The study followed these stages: (i) Cartographic
Survey and Field work: in this stage wells, ponds and
drinking fountains were localized by means of GPS. Simultaneously, water samples were taken and all the relevant
site information registered. The software Excel was used
for that purpose. (ii) Chemical Analysis of the samples: the
samples were analyzed in the CEFET/RN laboratory, with
geochemical kits. These analyses identified those sites
with nitrate contamination (Table 1). (iii) Elaboration of the
GIS: with this data and the geo-referenced maps, the GIS
was calibrated, seeking to understand the quantity and
quality spatial distribution of the UFRN campus water..
(iv) GIS Visualization and analysis of the UFRN Campus
using the different information plans, identifying the main
drinking fountains and the water quality (Figure 3). Some
of the information sets were structured as Themes, which
are information levels structured in the ArcView itself and
may be summarized as follows:
· Census and cartographic sectors: the census sector
boundaries – SC of Natal town. These were digitally
transcribed, from the cartographic base of IBGE to
plans in the scale 1:2,000 obtained from IDEMA/RN,
CAERN together with the Campus from the University
Campus city hall - UFRN. These sectors were divided
in two information plans, one of Natal – a larger area –
the other the Campus-UFRN.
· Private water supply system: this information plan
includes the identification and localization of private
wells, treatment and pumping stations and their respective information, located with GPS;
· Drinking fountains: this information plan covers the
active, deactivated and closed drinking fountains. The
sites were obtained in the field with GPS, together with
the material sampling and the respective data;
· Water quality: identification of the sites and their affected degree by the ion nitrate.
ASSESSMENT OF THE SYSTEM: SIG-CAMPUS
This system is composed of information plans on
the CAD cartographic base of the whole campus and a
– 190 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
Table1 - NO3 (mg/L) content in drinking water sources at the University Campus
Water source
Sector II - Classroom
NO3 mg/L
Water source
NO3 mg/L
18
Sector IV – Classroom
68
CCHLA – Sector Library
22.05
Chemistry Lab.
68.4
Sector I - Classroom
24.75
Sector III - Classroom
70.65
Sector V - Classroom
32.4
Garage
71.95
CT
32.8
School of Music
72.39
CCHLA – Geography Secretary
32.85
University Lodgings
73.23
University Restaurant
73.71
Sector I - Classroom
35.1
Sector IV – Classroom
73.8
CCSA – Social Services
38.25
University Restaurant
74.08
TVU
40.5
40.5
University Lodgings
University Lodgings
74.08
Sector I - Classroom
74.08
74.08
41
University Lodgings
DIMAP Lab.
41.4
Sector IV – Classroom
75.6
Geology Lab.
42.4
Sector III - Classroom
76.05
CCHLA – Lunch room
43.2
Sector III - Classroom
76.63
CCSA – Law
43.65
IT Lab.
77.85
Chemistry Lab.
46.35
Sector III - Classroom
77.85
BCZM
46.8
Sector IV – Classroom
78.3
TVU
51.3
Convenience Center
81.45
Sector I - Classroom
51.3
Garage
84.74
BCZM
Sector III - Classroom
55.8
Multisports Court
87.3
Sector III - Classroom
56.25
Sector IV – Classroom
88.65
Amphitheater
56.7
63
Biosciences Center
Biosciences Center
116.46
63.42
Biosciences Center
116.46
Chemical Engineering Lab.
65.25
Biosciences Center
116.73
Human Resources Dept.
65.55
Biosciences Center
116.73
67.5
Biosciences Center
122.05
Sector IV - Classroom
School of Music
Chemical Engineering Lab.
data bank of the existing contamination contents. This
data was the basis for the discussion on water vigilance
and quality control related issues. The “SIG” elaboration
enabled the identification and quantification of the nitrate
contaminant (NO3) in the potable water from the Campus
drinking fountains and the visualization of the spatial distribution (Figures 2 and 3).
From the evaluation of a duplicated set of the 60
water sample analyses from drinking fountains distributed
in the UFRN Campus, it was confirmed that the nitrate
concentrations, mostly from the water fountains, were
above the maximum limit of 45 mg l-1 NO3 - established
by the World Health Organization (WHO) and CONAMA.
As examples of sites where the NO3 concentration was
well above the mean value (Table 1), these are highlighted: Classroom Sector III (56 to 78 mg/L) and IV (63
114.5
to 78 mg/L), Chemical Engineering Laboratories (65 to 78
mg/L), Amphitheatre – CCET (57 mg/L), Soil Laboratories
(76 mg/L), Music School and University Restaurant (63
to 72 mg/L), Arts – former Engineering School (83 mg/L),
Recreational Center (81 mg/L), restaurant and university
dorms (74 mg/L) and other sectors where contents very
much above the maximum permitted limit were found,
such as the Biosciences Center (114 to 122 mg/L), garage
(72 to 85 mg/L) and the gym (87 mg/L).
Other analyzed sectors show the presence of NO3 in
concentrations below or very close to the permitted limit
as, for example: CCSA – Social Service (44 mg/L), ADURN
(42 mg/L), Central Library (47 mg/L), Geology Laboratory
(42 mg/L), Classroom sector I – Block F (51 mg/L) and
CCHLA (43 mg/L). On the other hand, some sectors, such
as Sectors I and II presented values compatible with the
– 191 –
Contamination assessment of potable water in the UFRN (Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte) campus regarding nitrates from septic tanks
Figure 2 – Visualization and integration of all data types.
Figure 3 – Spatial distribution of the results for nitrate content in the UFRN Campus water supply.
– 192 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
OMS standard, registering even lower values (18 mg/L).
It is also confirmed this is neither a punctual problem nor
is it restricted to the Campus.
The NO3 concentrations exceeding 45 mg/L are
mainly a result of the lack of basic sanitation in Natal,
especially in the dense habitation complexes around the
campus. The NO3 - concentration contents found in areas
adjacent to the campus, such as “Mirassol” and “Conjunto
dos Professores”, had lower values because the potable
water there is from a mixture of water from public system
wells (CAERN) and water from the Jiqui Lake. However, if
only the well water is analyzed in this area, similar values
to those detected in the Campus will be found.
Figure 4 illustrates the characteristics of the NO3
concentrations in the campus water fountains. The highest
values occur in the SW portion of the area and the lowest
values are distributed in the NE. The intermediary NO3
concentrations should be given attention because of their
rates exceed the WHO recommended value. Thus, the
spatial patterns of the concentrations of these contents
facilitate positive actions to be adopted.
CONSIDERATIONS
The values detected in the Campus are well above or
close to the permitted limit. They are worrying and show
that the UFRN potable water monitoring initiative must be
continued. The high nitrate values in the UFRN Campus
is mainly due to the water being extracted directly from
the ground and so it has the contents identified in the
aquifer itself. These are regional distribution values and,
as mentioned before, are linked to the lack of sanitation
in the city. The nitrate concentration values are higher in
the campus because the well water does not undergo any
dilution, as in the case of the water obtained from wells
neighboring the campus.
The contamination mainly reaches the most inhabited
areas due to the edification process (sinkholes) and pavement (waterproofing) and areas, such as the university
campus that concentrate areas favorable to infiltration,
are affected by the groundwater flux dynamics.
The Bioscience Center was confirmed as having the
samples with the highest concentrations and, in view of
this measures were taken to find the problem source. It
was proved that the supply origin, a well situated in that
Center was inadequate for human consumption. The
well was closed down and the network connected to another well with lower values. The supply to these drinking
fountains continues with water from another better quality
source. As for the remaining fountains, measures were
taken to reduce the contamination rates.
The university campus data base with the hydrochemical control sites map of the nitrate parameters,
through the systematic monitoring implemented by this
study, will make it possible to have a continuous and
systematic monitoring. This will enable precautions to be
Figure 4 – Spatial distribution of the results for nitrate content in the UFRN Campus water supply
showing the contamination hot spots.
– 193 –
Contamination assessment of potable water in the UFRN (Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte) campus regarding nitrates from septic tanks
taken and policies made to control the water potability and
quality standards in the area of the campus.
The campus is indeed facing a dilemma that requires
a reorientation of practices and emergency measures
must be taken, with the participation of the whole community, to find solutions to improve the quality of these
hydric resources. This will, in turn, benefit the campus and
the life standard of the population using it. Otherwise, the
degradation of the sand dunes and barriers type aquifer
through the observed propagation of contamination is
eminent. The preservation of this reservoir is important
and measures must be taken to maintain the physicalchemical and bacteriologic integrity of its water.
CONCLUSIONS
Considering these results it can be concluded that:
1 – The study’s aims were attained: i) to generate and use
the System SIG - Campus - UFRN; ii) to identify and
characterize the nitrate concentrations; iii) to control
the potability standard of the campus water supply.
These were achieved through a different approach,
which enabled a topic analysis and the future water
quality management and monitoring in the university
campus.
2 – The data capture steps, treatment and conversion
of maps and alphanumeric data from an analogical
to a digital format, when associated with the system,
supplied satisfactory results.
3 – It is necessary to evaluated the contamination impacts on the current potable water sources and
their relationship with the health of the consumers.
Left unchecked, the ingestion of chemical contents
can occur, such as nitrogenous compounds that in
high concentrations provoke hypertension, methemoglobin, certain types of cancer and lymphoma.
Therefore the condition of the water consumed must
be addressed in appropriate future planning.
4 – The methodologies used in the arrangement of the
geographical entities permitted the digital environment representation of the phenomena present in the
real world, and met expectations.
5 – The software used demonstrated a good capacity in
the sampling and treatment, conversion and integration of data. This generated diversified information
levels in the form of maps and attributes giving a wide
view of the studied geographic space.
6 – The elaborated SIG creates scenarios that allow a
better focalization of the most diverse groups of thematic maps and the planning of actions in sanitation
and health vigilance in the area. The developed SIG
can also be used as a didactic and debate instrument with students, teachers and the neighboring
population about the conditions and occupation of
the urban space.
7 – The aggregated value resulting from this study,
will allow public and private municipal institutions,
especially administrative authorities related to
hydric resources and public health, a wide vision
of the problems related to the subject, within their
geographical limit. The interactivity of the different
subjects that integrate the administrative unit will
allow public policies in the area to be guided in the
best practices concerning the different thematic
compositions.
8 – It must be emphasized that some information concerning the urban zone collected for the whole town
of Natal, were not specifically processed in this study
as they did not have a direct relationship with this
process. However the criteria used in this study are
the same applied to the town as a whole and may
be applied in the future to better identify other areas
and other risk groups.
9 – This being a pioneering study at a local, municipal
and state level, the impact of the GIS technology will
bring a new conscience: that it is necessary to any
decision maker to master the geographical knowledge and its components.
RECOMMENDATIONS
After the first results of this study were published,
some emergency measures were taken, including the
hiring of a firm specialized in deep wells, that could drill
beyond the limestone level, just below the sand dunesBarriers Aquifer System, reaching deeper water from, as
yet uncontaminated levels. Originally that water is more
acidic and a much lower discharge rate, but, being uncontaminated, it was the best solution found.
The other recommendations in this case address, first
of all, the need to adopt simple, reasonable measures and
procedures to minimize nitrate originated contamination
problems. These could include: the cleaning of water tanks;
the changing of drinking fountains; the installation of filters
and, especially, the catchment of uncontaminated surface
water (distributed by CAERN) to be mixed with the campus
well water and lower their contamination levels. However,
emergency governmental measures on a regional level
should be adopted as soon as possible, with the participation of the whole community to seek solutions to improve
the quality of these hydric resources and consequently the
living standard of the population. Otherwise the degradation of the Dunas/Barreiras Aquifer through the spreading
of the still punctual contamination is imminent.
The reservoirs preservation in the Greater Natal area
is important and measures have to be taken to maintain
the physical-chemical and bacteriological integrity of
its water, thus minimizing the cost of public health. It is
also necessary to urgently implement policies to protect
the public with an efficient sewage system, as problems
– 194 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
occur due to illegal connections that contaminate the
environment.
Finally, it is convenient to mention that the tool used
to generate the SIG-Campus/UFRN is not, the only one
available for this kind of work. There are several market
options, with different ways of processing the subjects
inherent to the inventory, some of them with more resources than others.
This system was used due to its ease of operation,
the ability to integrate the various information plans
(chemical and cartographical data, databank) and its
wide use by the technical-academic community. However, the technological evolution allows the migration to
open data that can be read in different software, permitting wider access to the information.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
ARAUJO, L. P.; PETTA, R. A.; DUARTE, C. R. Sistema
de informações geográficas aplicado à análise
das relações da qualidade da água e risco em
saúde pública no município de Natal (RN) . Geociências,2004. (Submetido)
ARAÚJO L. P. Análise das relações de risco em saúde
pública e qualidade da água na região de Natal
(RN) com base em sistema de informação geográfica (SIG). 2002. 150 p. Dissertação ( Mestrado em
Geociências) - Universidade Federal do Rio Grande
do Norte,Natal, 2002.
BARCELLOS, C. ; PINA, M. de F. Análise de risco em
saúde utilizando GIS: o caso do abastecimento
de água no Rio de Janeiro. Revista FatorGis, São
Paulo, 1998.
CÂMARA, G.; CASANOVA, M.A.; HERMERLY, A.S.;
MAGALHÃES, G.C.; MEDEIROS, C.M.B. Anatomia
de sistemas de informação geográfica. Campinas:
Instituto de Computação UNICAMP,1996. 197 p.
Disponível em: <http://www.dpi.inpe. Br/geopro/
livros/anatomia.pdf> Acesso em: 08 ago. 2006.
PETTA, R.A.; ARAUJO, L. P. de. Avaliação da contaminação do Aquífero em NO3 e incidência de casos
mortalidade no município de Natal (RN) com base
em um SIG. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE GEOLOGIA,42.,2004, Araxá. Anais. Araxá: Sociedade
Brasileira de Geologia. NúcleoMinas Gerais, 2004.
1 CD-ROM, v. S-20, p. 946-946.
– 195 –
DISSOLVED ALUM INUM
IN THE WATER OF SAND
EXTRACTION PITS –
A STUDY OF POSSIBLE
TOXICITY IM PLICATIONS
– SEROPÉDICA
M UNICIPALITY – RJ
¹Eduardo Duarte Marques, eduirmaodageo@yahoo.com.br
¹Emmanoel Vieira Silva Filho, geoemma@vm.uff.br
²Décio Tubbs, tubbs@ufrrj.br
¹Ricardo Erthal Santelli, santelli@geoq.uff.br
¹Sílvia Maria Sella, qgasela@vm.uff.br
¹Fluminense Federal University - UFF
²Rural Federal University of Rio de Janeiro - UFRRJ
INTRODUCTION
Sepetiba Basin occupies an area of about 4.4% of
Rio de Janeiro State. It is bounded by the Serra do Mar
mountain crest line, where the rivers that flow into the
Sepetiba Basin initiate, forming the hydrographic basin
of Guandu river (SEMA, 1996 apud Berbert, 2003). This
hydrographic basin occupies an area of about 2,000
km², 90% being an alluvial plain, where the studied area
is situated (Figure 1), inserted between the horizontal
(7,470,000 and 7,478,000 North) and vertical (630,000
and 638,000 East) UTM coordinates.
Unconsolidated Quaternary deposits form the local geology, made up of alluvial environment sediments
(fluvial, fluviomarine and fluvio-lacustrine), superimposed
on a Precambrian basement. The sediments integrate the
Piranema Formation (aquifer) (Góes, 1994 apud Barbosa
et al., 2002) represented by two units. The lower unit has
Pleistocene sandy facies, with medium to coarse size
sands of quartz and feldspar with gravel, normally at the
basal strata. The upper unity, an alluvial cover, is formed
by silt-clay Holocene facies. Area drillings indicate thicknesses vary between 10 and 25 meters. Geophysical
soundings register basement depths of about 35 to 40
meters in the Piranema area. However, there are literature
registrations indicating a thickness of 75 meters (CEDAE,
1986 apud Barbosa et al., 2002).
Regarding the local hydrogeology, preliminary observations suggest multiple or superimposed aquifers,
usually of free occurrence, locally confined, made of a
coarse arkosic matrix, possibly separated by clays of
variable occurrence and thickness. The level of ground
– 196 –
Eduardo Duarte Marques
Figure 2 – Aerial Image showing the extraction sites.
Figure 1 – Location map of the studied area (Berbert, 2003).
water varies between 3 and 7.5 meters, according to
season. The ground water is little mineralized, presenting low values of electrical conductivity and pH (Tubbs,
1999).
The region’s main socioeconomic activity, considering the local geology, is sand mining. The Sand
District of Itaguaí – Seropédica is the main sand supplier for the Rio de Janeiro State building industry
(90% for Rio de Janeiro city), with about 80 mining
businesses, 71 of which are legally entitled to explore
mineral sand (Figures 2 and 3). However, the mining
activity causes environmental conflicts not only by
exposing the phreatic aquifer but also lowering it.
Furthermore, the aquifers are subject to fuel oil spills
from the suction pumps installed on floating drags as
well as waste dumping from the processing activities
(Berbert, 2003) (Figures 4 and 5).
Governmental authorities, pushed by society, have
been urging the sand firms to find solutions to lessen the
several environmental impacts caused by this activity. This
study seeks to characterize the water hydro-geochemistry
in the sand extraction pits and considers the recuperation
proposals for the area of providing subsidies to introduce
Figure 3 – Distribution of the studied sand pits (blue dots)
(BERBERT, 2003).
pisciculture in the extraction pits as an alternative business.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In four active sand pits 10 samplings were carried out
between January 2004 and February 2005, to determine
the behavior of some physical-chemical parameters. Electrical conductivity, pH, temperature and total dissolved
solids were measured in the field with portable WTW-LF
330 equipment. Samples were filtered with 22µm pellicles and separated in sub-samples to determine metal
contents, acidified to pH2 with concentrated nitric acid,
and to identify anions, frozen until analyzed.
– 197 –
Dissolved aluminum in the water of sand extraction pits – a study of possible toxicity implications – Seropédica Municipality – RJ
Figure 4 – Sand extraction operations.
Figure 5 – Sand pit irmãos Unidos.
The anions identifications (F-, SO42-) were made
through ionic chromatography, SHIMADZU CDD-6A
equipment; to determine the cations (Ca 2+, Mg 2+),
atomic absorption spectrometry was used with VARIAN
equipment; to detect aluminum, the optical emission
spectrometry in inductively coupled plasma (ICP-OES),
JOBIN YVON – HORIBA (model ULTIMA 2) equipment
with an aluminum detection limit of 0.015 mg/L ; the silica
presence was made by the colorimetric method through
the formation of silicomolybdic acid, spectrophotometer
HITASHI (model U-1100).
showed low pH (3.11 – 4.95) (Figure 6), variable sulfate
(2 – 65 mgL-1) and aluminum (0.015 – 14 mgL-1) concentrations (Table 1). The anomalous aluminum values occur
between May and August. This may probably be associated with the low regional rain fall in this period (annual
mean for this period is 50 mm). This would impact the
water’s pH zones making the aluminum to be presented
as Al3+ and as the pH increases, Al(OH)2+ and Al(OH)2+.
Such substances are considered toxic because of their
greater reactivity with the cell membrane’s surface of
aquatic organisms. They can, for example, react with
fish gills, which have higher pH values than the water,
causing aluminum hydroxide to precipitate in the form
of gel. This gel prevents the water oxygen assimilation
by the gills, suffocating the fish, causing ionoregulatory
and respiratory effects (Baird, 2002). Because of the high
sulfate and aluminum values, there will probably be the
formation of AlSO4+ and Al(SO4)2- (Yariv & Cross, 1979).
Thus, according to the pH zones, there is a predominance of these sulfates. However, with the pH elevation,
aluminum hydrolysis occurs, turning the hydroxides into
the predominant element species. The hydroxides are
responsible for the adsorption of suspension particles
in the water, making them coagulate and then decant.
This process gives the water a clean aspect.
Aluminum organic species are not expected in large
amounts in this water, since these are artificial pits and
so there is vegetation removal due to the mining activity.
Thus, the addition of organic matter, highly reactive with
aluminum, into the pits should be minimal. However, the
Rio de Janeiro State Departamento de Recursos Minerais
(DRM-RJ) points out occurrences of peat deposits in the
sand mining region, which could support the hypotheses
origin of the pit water low pH values and would confirm
the presence of aluminum organic species.
Aluminum toxicity can be reduced by the presence of
silica in the water, an experimentally proved fact, though
it does not occur in practice, since aluminum tends to
be more reactive with the organic matter or with other
complexing agents present in higher amounts in the
water (Camilleri et al., 2003). In the case of sand pits,
the concentration of silica in the water is relatively high
(Table 1) and it probably occurs, according to the found
pH zones, in the colloidal fraction in the form of silicon
acid (H4SiO4). On the other hand, because of the greater
Table 1 - Mean cations and anions concentration
in the water
Sand pit
SO4
Al
Ca
Mg
F
SiO2
1
61.54
2.54
6.93
2.68
0.196
26.3
2
29.78
2.84
2.86
1.54
0.193
27
3
3.31
1.53
1.92
0.54
0.198
21.07
4
60.9
2.95
5.71
3.63
0.212
25.5
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The water monitoring preliminary results of four selected sand pits between January 2004 and April 2005
– 198 –
Eduardo Duarte Marques
BIBLIOGRAPHIC
REFERENCES
BAIRD, C. Environmental
chemistry. 2.ed. [S.l.] : University of Western Ontario ;
Bookman, 2002. 622 p.
BARBOSA ,C. F.; GUEDES,
F. S. P. ; TUBBS FILHO, D.
Contaminação por nitrato
das águas subterrâneas
no bairro de Piranema, limítrofe aos municípios de
Seropédica e Itaguaí, RJ.
In: JORNADA CIENTÍFICA
[da] UFRRJ, 12., 2002, Rio
de Janeiro, [Anais]. Rio de
Janeiro: UFRRJ, 2002.
BERBERT, M. C. .A mineração de areia no distrito areeiro de Itaguaí-Seropédica/
RJ: geologia dos depósitos
e caracterização das atividades de lavra e dos impactos
ambientais. 2003. Dissertação (Mestrado em Geologia)- Universidade Federal
Figure 6 – Aluminum concentration variations versus pH in four pits.
do Rio de Janeiro, 2003.
CAMILLERI,
C.;
affinity and high sulfate concentrations in the pits, it is
MARKICH,S.J.; NOLLER, B.N.; TURLEY, C.J.; PAmore probable that the aluminum will form complexes
RKER, G.; VAN DAM, R.A. Silica reduces the toxity
with this anion rather than silica. Small concentrations of
of aluminium to a tropical freshwater fish (Mogurnda
fluorine and low water hardness favor the bioavailability
mogurnda). Chemosphere magazine, n. 50, p. 355of aluminum (Table 1).
364, 2003.
TUBBS, D. Ocorrência das águas subterrâneas :“AqüíCONCLUSION
fero Piranema” no município de Seropédica, área
da Universidade Rural e arredores, estado do Rio
The preliminary results presented indicate that the
de Janeiro. [S.l.] : Fundação de Amparo a Pesquisa
alternative of introducing pisciculture to the sand extracdo E. Rio Janeiro, 1999. 123 p. Relatório Final de
Pesquisa.
tion pits of the Itaguaí-Seropédica mining district must
consider the bioavailability and toxicity of aluminum on YARIV, S.; CROSS, H. Geochemistry of colloids systems
for earth scientists. Berlin : [s.n.], 1979. 450 p.
aquatic organisms.
– 199 –
THE INFLUENCE OF THE
SPECIFIC SURFACE AREA
OF PARTICLES ON TRACEELEM ENTS ADSORPTION
BY BOTTOM SEDIM ENTS:
A CASE STUDY IN THE
SURROUNDINGS OF
M ACAÍBA CITY, RIO
GRANDE DO NORTE STATE
BRAZIL
¹Raquel F. S. Lima, raquel@geologia.ufrn.br
¹Josiel A. Guedes, josielquedes@yahoo.com.br
²Paulo R.G. Brandão, pbrandao@demin.ufmg.br
¹Laécio C. de Souza, laecio@geologia.ufrn.br
¹Reinaldo A. Petta, petta@geologia.ufrn.br
¹Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte - UFRN
²Federal University of Minas Gerais - UFMG
ABSTRACT
This study evaluates the influence of the particles’
specific surface area characteristics on the retention of
trace-elements by bottom sediments. The fine fraction
(<0.063 mm) of the River Jundiaí bottom sediments,
sampled upstream and downstream of the Macaíba city
urban center Rio Grande do Norte State, was analyzed
for trace elements through inductively coupled plasma
– atomic emission spectrometry (ICP-AES) for Pb and
Zn, and atomic absorption spectrometry – cold vapor
generation (AAS-CV) for Hg, after strong acid digestion
with aqua regia. The chemical element contents varied
within the following ranges (unit mg/kg): Pb (12-91), Zn
(24-141) and Hg (0.005-0.355). The enrichment degree
was obtained by comparing these sampled contents with
– 200 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
the average concentration found in samples from sites in
the same catchment basin, deemed free of anthropogenic
influence. The results show higher values for the elements
analyzed in the urban center. X-ray diffraction data and
stereomicroscope observations indicate that quartz and
feldspar are the samples’ main constituents. The identified
clay mineral is kaolinite. The specific surface area (unit
m²/g) was used to calculate each element’s adsorption
density (unit µm/m²) on the particles surface. This includes
all the inaccessible internal surface portions (especially
the pore wall surfaces). Considering both internal and
external surfaces are accessible to strong acid lixiviation,
the relationship between trace-element concentration,
organic matter total content and specific surface area,
is discussed. It is suggested that, in the case of partial
digestion of the bottom sediment fine fractions used for
environmental studies, with either simple or sequential
extraction, occasional anomalies may be adjusted to the
correct results through the adsorption density calculation
(the ratio between a given lixiviated element concentration and the sample specific surface area). The use of the
adsorption density to measure bottom sediment traceelements retention may present important implications
in environmental risk analysis.
INTRODUCTION
The cumulative and rearrangement properties of a
species in sediments qualify them as being extremely
important in environmental impact studies, registering
more permanently the contamination effects (Förstner &
Wittmann, 1981; Bevilacqua, 1996).
To correctly assess the amount of chemical species in sediments, it is necessary to distinguish natural
origin processes from anthropogenic action origins. A
sediment is usually formed of solid phases, composed
of different chemical elements, which may originally be
in high concentrations or have been added to the environment from anthropogenic sources. In natural water,
the sediments consist predominantly of organic waste,
colloidal matter, living cells (bacteria and algae) and inorganic solids, such as Fe and Mn oxides and hydroxides,
carbonates, sulfides and clay minerals. Many factors
influence the adsorption and retention of contaminants
on the particles surface. Size is one of the main factors.
The observed tendency is the smaller the particles, the
higher the concentrations of adsorbed nutrients and
chemical contaminants. This primary tendency is due
to the small particles having elevated specific surface
areas, that favor the adsorption and occasional fixation
of what is available in the aqueous environment. The
drainage channel bottom sediments of rivers play an
important role in the evaluation of their pollution, since
they reflect part of the phenomena occurring in the water
and particulate matter compartments.
Several researchers prefer the fine fractions of siltclayish particles (<0.063 mm) for sampling and analyses,
using these fractions to determine the presence of contaminants in surface water (Lacerda et al., 1990; Davidson
et al., 1994; Droppo & Jaskot, 1995; Truckenbrodt & Einax,
1995; Gatti, 1997; Liu et al., 1999; Soares, 1999). As for
the chemical treatment used to quantify the chemical element’s availability in the aqueous environment, there are
authors who choose the so-called simple extraction, with
a strong or weak acid (Novozamsky et al., 1993; Bevilacqua, 1996; Gatti, 1997); or the sequential extraction with
different acids of varied concentrations (Davidson et al.,
1994; Daus et al., 1995; Gonzales et al., 1994; Krause et
al., 1995; Urasa & Macha, 1996).
The studied area is in the town of Macaíba, 22 km
from Natal city, Rio Grande do Norte State. The River Jundiaí crosses Macaíba, which is in the upper fluvial portion
of the River Potengi estuary. This area is characterized
by both the addition of fresh water and the direct daily
tide action. Considerably high levels of Pb, Zn and Hg
in the water and bottom sediments of the River Jundiaí
have been reported before (Guedes, 2003; Guedes et al.,
2003a; Guedes et al., 2003b). The River Jundiaí course,
from the upper to the middle part, is characterized as an
intermittent river. The environmental problems in these
sections are typically of natural origin, even when crossing
urbanized areas. However, as it approaches Macaíba, a
medium sized town, the problems get worse due to the
occupational and horizontal growth. The basic sanitation
issue is one of the greatest problems this town faces, since
only 3% of the town has a sewage system. It has a surface
aquifer, the domestic septic tanks are very shallow and the
town council undertakes removal for the poorer population. However, most of the waste goes clandestinely to
the pluvial drains, which consequently ends up becoming
perpetual, taking the “in natura” sewage into the River
Jundiaí. Solid waste disposal is another environmental
problem with which the Macaíba population cohabits,
as the town does not have a specific landfill area. As a
result, part of the domestic waste is dumped directly into
the river or near it. Moreover, in the three downstream
sampling sites from the studied area, where the river
depth and width are greater, the influence of the saline
environment is clearly suggested by the high values found
for the electrical conductivity, salinity, calcium, potassium,
magnesium, sodium, sulfate, chloride, total solids and
dissolved solids parameters (Guedes, 2003).
The previous studies carried out on the River Jundiaí
bottom sediments were based on the chemical analyses
results of the bottom sediment’s fine fraction (<0.063 mm),
without considering the specific surface area parameter.
This is defined as the ratio A/m (unit m²/g) between the
absolute surface area of a solid and its mass. The specific
surface area includes the external surfaces of the solid
particles and all the inaccessible internal surface portions
– 201 –
The inluence of the speciic surface area of particles on trace-elements adsorption by bottom sediments:
a case study in the surroundings of Macaíba city, Rio Grande do Norte State Brazil
(mainly the internal pore wall surfaces). The ratio between
the specific surface area (unit m²/g) and the adsorbed
chemical element concentration on the samples (unit mg/
kg) was used to calculate the adsorption density (unit µg/
m²) of that element on the particles surface. This study
evaluates the influence of the particles’ specific surface
area on the retention of trace-elements by bottom sediments.
METHODOLOGY
The samplings were made in January and February
2001, during the dry period, when the fresh water contribution to the River Jundiaí is basically represented by the
“in natura” sewage. This enters the stream through the
pluvial drains that clandestinely receive the discharged
urban waste. Samples were collected in 10 sites (Figure
1). The sites P3 to P9 are distributed 01 km apart; of these, the sites P4 to P9 are in an urban area which is also
influenced by the tide. The samples P13 and P14 were collected in the same catchment, in places deemed free from
anthropogenic influence, 50 and 27 km from Macaíba,
respectively. Upstream from the town, the sampling sites
are distributed in a tide and possibly urban influence free
area of the River Jundiaí. The bottom sediment samples
were collected to accurately obtain the material from the
superior interval (0 to 5 cm) of the active stream channel.
In the laboratory, the samples were dried at 60°C for
24 hours, disaggregated and sieved. The sediments’ fine
fraction (<0.063 mm) sampled upstream and downstream
from the Macaíba urban center was analyzed for Pb and
Zn through inductively coupled plasma – atomic emission
spectrometry (ICP-AES), and for Hg by atomic absorption
spectrometry – cold vapor generation (AAS-CV), after
strong acid digestion with aqua regia.
The total organic matter content analysis was carried out in two stages. In the first, humidity was removed
from the sediment for 12 hours in a tray dryer at 105°C.
In the second stage, about 2 grams of this material was
maintained at 600°C for 4 hours in a muffle furnace. The
organic matter content calculation was based on the
mass difference between the humidity free sample and
the mass after heating at 600°C.
The specific surface area was determined using the
Brunauer, Emmett and Teller method (BET). The analyzed
samples went through a degassing step at 110°C for 4
hours in a nitrogen atmosphere. The precise specific surface area measurement of solids through gas adsorption,
according to Brunauer, Emmett and Teller, is to determine
the adsorbate amount (or gas that adsorbs) necessary
to cover the external and internal surfaces of the pores
of a solid, with a monolayer of adsorbate. That monolayer
capacity can be calculated from the adsorption isotherm
by using the BET equation.
Mineralogical data was obtained by observing the
samples in the stereomicroscope and X-ray diffraction.
For the clay fraction X-ray diffraction analyses, oriented
sections were prepared, mounted from a clay-water
suspension with a concentration of 60 mg clay for 1 ml
distilled water, carefully placed on a glass plate, and then
dried on a hot plate at 60°C. The scanning was conducted
from 2 to 32º (scale 2), with a velocity of 1º/minute.
Figure 1 – Location map of the studied area and sampling sites.
– 202 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
RESULTS
The chemical element content varied within the following ranges (unit mg/Kg): Pb (12-91), Zn (24-141) and
Hg (0.005-0.355). The results show elevated values for
the analyzed elements in the urban center, as shown in
Figure 2. The 3 graphs present, on the horizontal axis, the
sampling sites distribution and, on the vertical axis, the
chemical elements concentrations of Pb, Zn and Hg, in mg/
kg (represented by diamonds), and the adsorption density
in g/m² (represented by squares). The vertical axis scale is
logarithmic to facilitate the visualization and comparison,
on the same graph, between the two different approaches
used (concentration and adsorption density). Upstream
and downstream directions, as well as the sampling sites
in urban area are indicated. The urban area and Macaíba
town sites are placed about 1 km apart. The two left-hand
sites on the graphs (P13 and P14) are located upstream in
the same catchment area, in a position considered free of
anthropogenic contribution, 50 and 27 km from Macaíba
respectively. The horizontal lines on each graph represent
the arithmetic mean of the P13 and P14 site results. These
values, in this study, are called threshold. The ellipses highlight zones of remarkable contrast between the chemical
elements concentrations and the adsorption density of the
chemical elements adsorbed in the bottom sediment fine
fractions collected in the River Jundiaí.
In the urban area and downstream from Macaíba, the
values for Pb, Zn and Hg concentrations are all above the
threshold, with the maximum contents always in the urban
area (Pb: maximum in P4, Zn and Hg: maximum in P10).
In this same zone, the adsorption density follows the same
variation tendencies observed for the three chemical
elements concentrations with the maximum adsorption
density of Pb in site P4 and Zn and Hg in site 10.
The three sampling sites upstream and near Macaíba (P3, P2 and P1) highlighted with ellipses in the three
graphs, represent the zone where the chemical elements
concentrations and adsorption densities present considerable differences from each other. It is important to
emphasize this is the studied section of the river where
lower concentrations in relationship to the urban area were
expected. The Pb concentration values are above the
threshold with the maximum in P3 and the minimum in P2;
the Pb adsorption density values are below the threshold
adsorption density with a maximum in P3 and a minimum
in P1. In the case of Zn, 2 of the 3 concentration values
are above the threshold (P3 and P1), with the maximum in
P3 and minimum in P2; the Zn adsorption density values
are all below the threshold, with a maximum in P2 and
minimum in P3. The chemical element Hg has one of the
3 concentration values above the threshold (P1), with a
maximum in P1 and minimum in P2; the adsorption density
values for Hg are all below the threshold, with a maximum
in P1 and minimum in P3.
X-ray diffraction data and stereomicroscope observations indicate that quartz and feldspar are the samples’
main constituents. The clay mineral identified is kaolinite.
The horizontal axis in Figure 3 shows the bottom sediments sampling sites distribution on the River Jundiaí,
in the urban area and around Macaíba. On the vertical
axis are shown data on specific surface area in m²/g
(diamonds) and organic matter content in % (squares).
The specific surface area (diamonds) varies between
4.5 and 42.2 m²/g, with the highest values found in the 3
sites sampled upstream of Macaíba. The organic matter
content varies from about 10% in the upstream sites,
taken as the threshold, to about 20% in the sites further
downstream, with a growing content in the sediments from
within and after the urban zone (squares). Apparently
there is no significant correlation between the organic
matter content and the specific surface area.
DISCUSSION
Guedes (2003) reports results of analyses carried
out in water samples collected in the same period and in
the same bottom sediments sampling sites in the River
Jundiaí, near Macaíba. These results show elevated Pb,
Zn and Hg concentrations in the River Jundiaí urban zone.
The Pb, Zn and Hg contents in water varied between
0.04 and 0.19 ppm, 0.02 and 0.05 ppm and 0.0002 and
0.0003 ppm, respectively. According to this data, the
elements Pb, Zn and Hg added to this environment have
an anthropogenic origin.
Among the factors that influence the contaminants
adsorption and its retention on the surface of particles in
natural water, highlighted is the particle’s size. Usually,
the smaller the particles are the higher the concentrations
of adsorbed nutrients and chemical contaminants. This
primary tendency is due to the small particles having elevated specific surface areas, which favor the adsorption
and occasional fixation of what is available in the aqueous
environment.
This study used the fine fractions of silt-clayish
particles (<0.063 mm) for the analyses, being the usual
practice in many studies (Lacerda et al., 1990; Davidson
et al., 1994; Droppo & Jaskot, 1995; Truckenbrodt &
Einax, 1995; Gatti, 1997; Liu et al., 1999; Soares, 1999).
These study results serve as support for environmental
risk diagnosis, monitoring and analysis.
As shown in Figure 2, in the urban area and downstream from Macaíba (sites P4, P5, P10, P6, P7, P8 and P9),
the Pb, Zn and Hg concentration values in the bottom sediments fine fractions and the adsorption densities, follow
the same variation tendencies, with even the same sites
with the maximum concentration and adsorption density:
Pb in site P4, and Zn and Hg in site P10. However, in the 3
sampling sites situated upstream but near Macaíba town
(P3, P2 and P1), emphasized by ellipses in the 3 graphs
– 203 –
The inluence of the speciic surface area of particles on trace-elements adsorption by bottom sediments:
a case study in the surroundings of Macaíba city, Rio Grande do Norte State Brazil
Figure 2 – Horizontal axis: sampling points distribution of the River Jundiaí bottom sediments, in urban areas and the vicinity of
Macaíba City. Vertical Axis: concentration in mg/kg (diamonds) and adsorption density in mg/m2(squares) of the chemical elements
Pb, Zn and Hg. Sampling sites to the left in the graph (P13 and P14): threshold values. Ellipses: sections where concentration and
adsorption density in the bottom sediments fine fractions present controversial tendencies and smaller values related to the threshold values.
– 204 –
Reinaldo A. Petta
Figure 3 – Horizontal axis: of the sampling points distribution of the River Jundiaí bottom sediments, in urban areas and the vicinity of Macaíba
City. Vertical Axis: specific surface area in m2/g (diamonds) and organic matter content in % (squares). Sampling sites to the left in the graph
(P13 and P14): threshold values.
of Figure 2, the concentrations and adsorption densities
present remarkable differences compared to the threshold
values, and display even opposed tendencies, as is the
case of Zn. It is important to emphasize this is the studied
section where the results of the investigated element
concentrations were expected to be lower, compared to
the urban area.
The high Pb, Zn and Hg concentrations in water in
the River Jundiaí urban zone reported by Guedes (2003),
confirm the hypothesis of anthropogenic contribution for
the Pb, Zn and Hg in the bottom sediments. Among the
possible alternatives to justify these chemical elements in
the bottom sediments upstream of Macaíba, the first is that
in the absence of an anthropogenic source, Pb, Zn and Hg
are present in high concentrations in the rock substratum
of that area. This alternative does not seem acceptable,
since the average contents registered in the sediments
fine fractions sampled 27 and 50 km from Macaíba do not
present high values. A second alternative, which a more
quantitative approach, suggests that the use of the chemical element adsorption density, rather than the element’s
net concentration value leached from the surface of the
particles, should be used in environmental risk analyses.
CONCLUSIONS
The data from this study, mainly that obtained in the
sites upstream from the Macaíba urban area (ellipses),
suggest that, in the case of the partial digestion of the
bottom sediment fine fractions used for environmental
studies, be it simple or sequential extraction, occasional
anomalies can be adjusted to the correct result through
the adsorption density calculation (the ratio between
the concentration of a given leached element and the
sample’s specific surface area). The use of adsorption
density as a measure of trace-elements retention by bottom sediments may represent important implications in
environmental risk analyses.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors wish to thank the Institute for Economical Development and Environment of Rio Grande do
Norte - Instituto de Desenvolvimento Econômico e Meio
Ambiente do Rio Grande do Norte (IDEMA/RN) and the
Postgraduate Program in Geosciences of the Federal
University of Rio Grande do Norte – PPGEO/UFRN for
financing this research; Renato Souza da Silva who made
the X-ray diffraction and organic matter content analyses
during his activities as research assistant CNPq/PIBIC;
CAPES for the concession of the masters scholarship to
the second author.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BEVILACQUA, J. E. Estudos sobre a caracterização e estabilidade de amostras de sedimento do rio Tiete, SP.
1996. 171 p. Tese (Doutoramento) - Instituto de Química, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 1996.
DAUS, B. ; ZWANZIGER, H. W. Heavy metals in river
sediments: a chemometrical evaluation. Fresenius
– 205 –
The inluence of the speciic surface area of particles on trace-elements adsorption by bottom sediments:
a case study in the surroundings of Macaíba city, Rio Grande do Norte State Brazil
Journal of Analytical Chemistry, v. 352, p. 444-450,
1995.
DAVIDSON, C.; THOMAS, R.P.; McVEY, S.E.; PERALA ,
R.; LITTLEJOHN, D.; URE, A.M. Evaluation of a sequential extraction procedure for the speciation of
heavy metals in sediments. Analytica Chimica Acta,
v. 291, p. 277-286, 1994.
DROPPO, I.G.; JASKOT, C. Impact of river transport characteristics on contaminant sampling error and design. Environ. Sci. Technol., v. 29, p. 161-170, 1995.
FÖRSTNER, U.; WITTMANN, G. T. W. Metal pollution in the
aquatic environment. 2.ed. Berlin: Springer- Verlag,
1981.
GATTI, L.V. Distribuição de metais em testemunhos de
sedimentos de duas lagoas marginais do rio Moji-Guaçu (E.E. de Jataí, Luiz Antônio, SP). 1997. 146
p. Tese (Doutorado) - Departamento de Química,
Universidade Federal de São Carlos, São Carlos,
1997.
GONZALEZ, M.J.; RAMOS, L.; HERNÁNDEZ, L.M.
Distribution of trace metals in sediments and the
relationship with their accumulation in Earthworms.
International Journal of Environmental Analytical
Chemistry, v. 57, n. 2, p. 135-150, 1994.
GUEDES, J.A. Diagnóstico geoquímico-ambiental do Rio
Jundiaí, nas imediações da cidade de Macaíba/RN.
2003. Dissertação (Mestrado em Geociências) Centro de Ciências Exatas e da Terra, Universidade
Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Natal, 2003.
GUEDES, J.A.; LIMA, R.F.S.; SOUZA, L.C. Distribuição
de metais pesados em sedimentos de fundo no
Rio Jundiaí em área de Mangue-Macaíba /RN. In:
MANGROVE 2003: Connecting Research and Participative Management of Estuaries and Mangroves,
2003, Salvador. Livro de resumos. Salvador : UFBA;
UFRPE, 2003. 1 v., p.251.
GUEDES, J.A.; LIMA, R.F.S.; SOUZA, L.C. Variação sazonal da geoquímica de água e sedimentos de fundo
em um trecho do Rio Jundiaí, cruzando a cidade
de Macaíba, RN. In: CONGRESSO BRASILEIRO DE
GEOQUÍMICA, 9., 2003, Belém. Livro de resumos
expandidos. Belém: Sociedade Brasileira de Geoquímica, 2003. 1 v., p. 301-303.
KRAUSE, P.; ERBSLÖH, R.; NIEDERGESÄß, R.; PEPELNIK, E.; PRANGE, A. Comparative study of different
digestion procedures using supplementary analytical methods for multielement-screening of more than
50 elements in sediments of the River Elbe. Fresenius
Journal of Analytical Chemistry, v. 353, p. 3-11, 1995.
LACERDA, L.D.; PAUL, F.C.F.; OVALLE, A.R.C.; PFEIFFER,
W.C.; MALN, O. Trace metals in fluvial sediments of
the Madeira River watershed, Amazon, Brazil. The
Science of the Total Environment, v. 97/98, p. 525530, 1990.
LIU, W.; WANG, W.; WEN, X.; TANG, H. The application of
preliminary sediment quality criteria to Metal contamination in the Le An River. Environmental Pollution,
v. 105, p. 355-366, 1999.
NOVOZAMSKY, I.; LEXMOND, T.M.; HOUBA, V.J.G. A
single extraction procedure of soil for evaluation of
uptake if some heavy metals by plants. International
Journal of Environmental Analytical Chemistry, v. 51,
p. 47-58, 1993.
SOARES, H.M.V.M.; BOAVENTURA, R.A.R.; MACHADO,
A.A.S.C.; SILVA, J.C.G.E. Sediments as monitors of
heavy metal contamination in the Ave River Basin
(Portugal): multivariate analysis of data. Experimental Pollution, v. 105, p. 311-323, 1999.
TRUCKENBRODT, D.; EINAX, J. Sampling representatively and homogeneity of river sediments. Fresenius
Journal of Analytical Chemistry, v. 352, p. 437-443,
1995.
URASA, I.T.; MACHA, S.F. Speciation of heavy metals in
soils, sediments, and sludges using D.C. plasma
atomic emission spectrometry coupled with ion chromatography. International Journal of Environmental
Analytical Chemistry, v. 64, p. 83-95, 1996.
– 206 –
www.cprm.gov.br/pgagem
seus@cprm.gov.br
Tel.: (55)(21) 2295-5997
Fax.: (55)(21) 2295-5897