The document discusses the challenges of using drones in emergency response operations in the Valencian Community of Spain. It outlines the current rescue model which involves different agencies coordinating under a single command. The organization aims to integrate drones to support manned aircraft operations for search and rescue, forest fire monitoring, and disaster assessment. Key challenges include obtaining proper equipment, coordinating flights in restricted airspaces, developing coordinated procedures between agencies, and transforming drone data into actionable information for emergency commanders. Case studies demonstrate the potential for drones to locate missing persons faster than traditional methods. Recommendations include taking a decision to develop own drone resources versus outsourcing, and ensuring specialized technical support for skilled pilots.
EENA 2018 - Airborne rescue: Drones and Helicopters
1. Airborne rescue: Drones and Helicopters
CHALLENGES OF USING DRONES IN AN
EMERGENCY SERVICE
EENA Conference 2018,
Ljubljana, 26 th April, 2018
2. 1. Our organization: Valencian Agency of Security and
Emergency Response
2. Reasons to use DRONES in rescue operations
3. Current model of rescue in Valencian Community
4. Evolution of our model
5. Integrating drones in emergency operations: challenges
6. Case Use and learned lessons
7. Recommendations for emergency & rescue services
3. EMERGENCY
COORDINATION
CENTER
Valencian Community
1st level
• TOWN COUNCIL
2nd level
• AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITIES
3rd level
• STATE
PARTICIPATIONOFCITIZENSASVOLUNTEERS
(PREFEREBLYTHROUGHVOLUNTEERING
ASSOCIATIONS,NGOs)
ORGANIZATION
FOR THE
RESPONSE IN
EMERGENCIES
IN SPAIN
4. • Difficulty to obtain location exactly
• Problems to deploy terrestrial
resources, because of the state of
tracks
• No possibility to activate manned
resources by night
• Resources dispatched at sunrise:
– 2 helicopters, visibility problems
because of the low level clouds.
– Terrestrial resources: Rescue, sanitary,
search
• One of them was found at 15:18
• The other two hikers were found
dead
28th February 2016
3 hikers are lost in the
mountain, since the morning
In the middle of a snow storm
They call 1·1·2 asking for help
at 0 h 10’ 22’’
REASONS TO USE DRONES IN RESCUE OPERATIONS
Could something else have been done for them?
5. 1 HLC medicalized
1 HLC medicalized
1 (+1) HLC, search and rescue operations
1 HLC search and rescue operations
1 HLC maritim rescue
1 HLC, search and rescue operations
CURRENT MODEL OF RESCUE IN VALENCIAN COMMUNITY
ResourcesbelongingtodifferentAgencies
Integrated in an only structure of response when a civil proteccion plan is activated
UNDER A UNIQUE COMMAND
6. EVOLUTION OF OUR MODEL
CURRENT MODEL: based on manned aircrafts
WHERE WE GO: A mix model, with drones supporting
manned aircraft operations
In all types of emergencies:
- Search and Rescue
- Forest fires, Industrial fires
- Characterization of affected areas after a forest fire, an earthquake, floods …
- Technological emergencies: Chemical and radiological risk
7. OUR MODEL AS RPAS OPERATOR
• Based on our own resources (experts in emergencies)
• Authorised by Spainsh Regulation Organism (AESA) in July 2017
• Previous work of training pilots, preparation of procedures and
purchase equipment
PROS:
• The know-how belongs and remains
in your organization
• The power of being an authority
when you have to agree exemptions
from airports, nuclear plants or other
critical facility
CONS:
• A slower process
• If extra resources aren’t hired, the
own:
• Not experts in drones technology
• Detracted of your emergency taskforce
8. INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (I)
TO BUY THE PROPER EQUIPMENT:
• Specify the characteristics of the equipment
• The administrative process to buy them
2 DJI INSPIRE 1
PRO - v2.0, with a
Zenmuse X3 camera
Thermal camera compatible with
INSPIRE 1 for search and rescue
operations and hot point detection in
forest fire
Hexacopter with RGB and Thermal
cameras
Fix wing with RGB and Thermal
cameras
NOW IN THE PROCESS OF A TENDER
9. INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (II)
AREAS WITH FLIGHT RESTRICTIONS:
• 3 airports (15 km from the axes of the tracks )
• 1 nuclear plant
• Protected natural spaces
Spanish laws let overfly them or reduce
the restricted area:
• Only in case of emergency (not for training
or preparedness)
• With the previous authorisation
• Establishing coordination mechanisms with
them
NOW Defining procedures
10. INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (III)
COORDINATION WITH OTHER AGENCIES
In emergency:
• Several Agencies working under an
structure with a unique command
• Operations in the frame of a civil
protection plan
APPROVAL OF AN OPERATION PROCEDURE OF AIRCRAFT PILOTED BY
REMOTE CONTROL IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS UNDER THE DIRECTION
OF THE GENERALITAT
DOGV 16.6.2017
http://www.dogv.gva.es/datos/2017/06/16/pdf/2017_5348.pdf
OPERATIONAL
COMMAND
DIRECTOR OF
THE EMERGENCY
UNITS WHERE
RESOURCES ARE
INTEGRATED
(depending of functions)
11. PROCEDURE OF AIRCRAFT PILOTED BY REMOTE CONTROL IN EMERGENCY
SITUATIONS UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE GENERALITAT: BASIC PRINCIPLES
• A previous register of the of RPAS belonging to public agencies and
companies is needed
• Operations only authorised by the operational command of emergency
• The area where restrictions apply, is protected by the Unit of Security
• A unit to coordinate RPAS operations is created and integrated in civil
protection plans
• Operations coordinated by the responsible of the RPAS Unit
• All the information obtained during the emergency is available for the
operational command of the emergency
• Spreading images of the emergency must be authorized by the director of
the emergency DIRECTOR CIVIL
PROTECCION
PLAN
COMMUNICATION
CABINET
OPERATIONAL
COMMAND
UNITS OF THE CIVIL PROTECTION PLAN:
INTERVENTION, SANITARY, SECURITY,
LOGISTIC …
RPAS OPERATION COORDINATION
UNIT
13. For flights:
– Night flights
– Over inhabitated areas
– In urban enviroments
– In controlled air space
– EVLOS flights
INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (IV)
OPERATIONAL SECURITY STUDIES
Exceptions in case of emergency
But safety must be guaranteed
Employing SORA Method
NOW: Beginning the work with the support of
the Valencian Politechnical University
14. INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (V)
COORDINATED OPERATIONS BETWEEN MANNED AND UNMANNED AIRCRAFTS
NOW Forbidden by our own procedure of aircraft piloted by remote control in
emergency situations under the direction of the Generalitat
FUTURE ACTIONS to analyse the way to make complatible the work of manned
and unmanned aircrafts in emergencies
AN HOMOGENEOUS RESPONSE 24x7
Ready to be dispatched automatically, with the basic structure that
has been defined in our Agency
15. INTEGRATING DRONES IN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS: CHALLENGES (VI)
TRANSFORM VIDEOS AND IMAGES IN INFORMATION TO MAKE DECISIONS DURING THE EMERGENCY
NOW
•Thermal images NEXT FUTURE
Video transmission to Operational Command
Processing information in nearly real time
16. • A wide area to track
• A big impact in the press:
Agencies and Volunteers
offers their servicies to
collaborate with drones
19th August 2017
A child dispears
swimming in a river
A witness phones 1·1·2
at 18:39:52
USE CASE
The need to organize the intervention with several agencies or volunteers’ drones
• In the border of two Autonomous Communities
Different communications systems
• Resources Deployed: (both AACC)
•Resources of terrestrial search
•Diving resources
•HLC
• Procedure of aircraft piloted by remote control
in emergency situations under the direction of
the Generalitat is activated
• The child’s body is found when the intervention
with drones is beeing prepared
17. PRACTICES WITH OTHER AGENCIES IN RURAL SEARCH
AIMS:
- Zoning of work areas with different agencies
operating together
- Defining searching patterns
- Develop working procedures for the the RPAS
unit coordinator
- EVLOS flights
18. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR EMERGENCY & RESCUE
SERVICES
MY VIEW
- For emergency & rescue services is ‘a must’ introduce
new technologies in order to improve our work: HELPING
PEOPLE
- A decision must be taken: OWN RESOURCES vs.
OUTSOURCED SERVICE
- It is not an easy task: specialized resources and technical
support is needed. SKILLED PILOTS IS NOT ENOUGH
- Essential: SUPPORT OF THE ORGANIZATION DIRECTORATE